ipl-logo

Zygmunt Bauman Stuart Hall Summary

1443 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The nature of cultural identity stuart hall

How do Zygmunt Bauman and Stuart Hall engage with the problem of

identity as a problem of modernity? How does Bauman extend the

discussion of the identity question in the context of globalization?

ANSHUMAN AGARWAL

201301110

Identity and modernity go hand in hand. To talk about one without involving other can not

complete the discussion. The two main texts to consider here are : Zygmunt Bauman’s “Identity

in the globalizing world” and Stuart Hall’s “The question of cultural identity”. Both the authors

deal with the identity discourse that has taken place with the advent of modernity or what can be

thought of as how identity evolved in the modern times.

Zygmunt Bauman’s article revolves around the thought that “we have moved from a …show more content…

This thought of theoretical antihumanism clearly rejects the basics

of modern philosophy that every human being has an universal essence which is individual.

The next course of dislocation to identity is due to Freud’s discovery of unconscious.Individual

was considered to be a rational subject with a fixed identity but Freud’s theory said that all

desires and identities are due to logic unconscious which is different from logic of reason. Again,

the interpretation of his texts has had a great impact on modern thought of identity. The identity

is considered to be formed out of fantasies of childhood and not to grow naturally. This happens

in the mirror phase of development where, a person sees his image of self in others and does

not has a whole image of self formed. This defines new relation between self and …show more content…

This is in disagreement with Freud’s theory discussed by Hall where logic of

reason is not involved in formation of identity.

The identity that is formed is not something private to individual rather is formed by society and

similarly society is formed depending upon how individual identities are formed. This individual

identity formation is a transformation to actually become what one is. For example, if one wants

to be a king, he has to act like king not just in profession but in culture, traditions and what not.

This new era thus broke the existing divisions of identity and built new divisions based on how

people identified themselves to be. These new divisions which were supposed to be flexible

suddenly became ‘fact of nature’ and every individual’s task remained just to try and fit among

one of them. Slowly, new problems developed as none of the divisions provided complete

satisfaction to someone as they were free to move but were not able to do so.

The problem changed from “how to shift and get recognised” to “where to shift(with risk

analysis) and how to safeguard it” with the continuous flow of changing identities since the

divisions were themselves not fixed. This is in accordance with Foucault’s view that with

Show More
Related
1473 Words | 6 Pages

English 10 Date: _____________ Mango Street—Double Entry Journal (DEJ) Period: ____ Overview: A DEJ is a way to closely read passages from a text, to discover what individual words and sentences reveal about characters, conflicts, themes, etc. In the future, you will be selecting your own “strong lines” and meaningful passages to comment on, but for this first effort three have been chosen for you. Each passage shows something about Esperanza, her relationship to someone else in the neighborhood, and/or her opinion about a particular social issue. Link your passages to the Essential Questions: HOW DOES CHANGE AFFECT THE FUTURE?

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

But identity is where the “self” interacts with social norms and ideas. One then lives a life mediated by these

Read More
792 Words | 4 Pages

Every type of person struggles with a thing we call, identity. Personal identity come from multiple factors from our race to our own personal beliefs. Some people say we have the choice to choose our own identity, but is that always true? No, in fact other people can affect how we look and essentially identity our self’s. In the article called.

Read More
522 Words | 3 Pages

One of Freud’s theories is that the “Id – Ego combination dominates a person’s behavior until social awareness leads to the emergence of the superego, which recognizes that

Read More
759 Words | 4 Pages

In academic article “Who Am I” by Beverly Daniel Tatum; she talks about the complexity of identity, which defined as a person. She describes the multiple identities of different kinds of people and their significance in the community. She illustrate the how person past, historical event, family background, experiences, and thought of person has impact on the personal identification. The concept of past, present, and future, those characterize the person identity. She explains how gander of person is the part of identity, which build identity.

Read More
663 Words | 3 Pages

In his document discussing identity Bauman says that “Identity is a critical projection of what is demanded and/or sought upon what is” (Bauman, 19). In other words, identity is shaped by cultural ideology. Race, gender, socioeconomic status: all will impact the way one moves through the world and will therefore mold their identity. In the cases of Smith and Aciman the lens of gender shows their struggle with what is demanded by society. Yet Bauman also says that “Identity entered modern mind and practice dressed from the start as an individual task” (Bauman, 19).

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

In fact, one of the scholars who believes that identity is never complete but constructed is Stuart Hall, a Jamaican-born sociologist and cultural theorist.

Read More
1092 Words | 5 Pages

Identity is something people tend to think of as consistent, however that is far from the case. The Oxford English dictionary states that the definition of identity is “ The characteristics determining who or what a person or thing is.” The allegorical novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding tackles the issue of identity while following young boys from the ages twelve and down as they struggle with remembering their identities when trapped on a deserted island. Identity is affected by the influence of society and how individuals influence society based on their identities. By looking at Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the Stanford Prison Experiment, and Sigmund Freud 's philosophical ideas, it becomes clear that identity is affected by society through peer pressure and social normalities.

Read More
1586 Words | 7 Pages

William E. Connolly is a political theorist who is a professor of Political Science at John Hopkins University. He is known for his writings on democracy and pluralism. In Identity/Difference: Democratic Negotiations of Political Paradox, Connolly argues that the process of creating identity is inextricably linked to the defining of difference. When the created identity is treated as natural, then those traits that are different from that identity become unnatural. They become other.

Read More
843 Words | 4 Pages

In the article ‘The Complexity of Identity - Who am I?’ , the author Beverly Tatum argues that the definition of identity for a person is laid down by the societal norms and not by one’s own conscious understanding of her or his existence. And these societal norms are the ones that are acceptable to the dominant group of the society. Any aspect of one’s identity that sets her or him apart from others is targeted by the dominants. Tatum has used the terms ‘dominants’ and ‘subordinates’.

Read More
683 Words | 3 Pages

Identity speaks of who we are as individuals but it also comes from two different groups: social and cultural. These groups are connected to power, values and ideology. Social identities are related to how we interact with people and how we present ourselves. Meanwhile cultural identities relate to society in whole such as religion, values, etc. In this paper I will talk about the dominant and subordinate identities.

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

"My identity was a big issue when I was a teenager, and I had a lot of questions, like: 'Who am I? ' 'Who do I belong to? ' But when I was still quite young, I decided that belonging is a tough process in life, and I 'd better say I belonged to myself and the world rather than belonging to one nationality or another". As Hiam Abbas said people belong to themselves, rather than society. We frequently give these questions to ourselves who I am, why I live, what identity is and in every occasion we think deeply , sweat over these but consequently cannot get an authentic and a conscious answer.

Read More
2186 Words | 9 Pages

The Id, Ego and Superego make complete sense to any person who might be interests in learning about the Psyche. Freud’s use of the psychoanalytic theory is relevant when explaining my current behaviour in regards to my past experiences that have occurred throughout my lifetime. Freud’s theory does apply to my own life as he made his theory a way to help understand and focus on the behavioural problems of the human being, and to resolve them in a way that forces me to accept my own destructive

Read More
483 Words | 2 Pages

However, the interesting thing about all of them is that they are one of many divided aspects of identity. While they’re the number one selection on their sites, there are up to 10 more, each dealing with a contrasting realm. These definitions are too narrow, which is the problem behind them, they encompass little of our identities – it’s like shrinking a textbook down to a paragraph. Yet, they do bring up a sort of inquisition into what identity means to you as a person. They spark a sort of philosopher in yourself where you inspect identity down to its roots, forcing in-depth thinking.

Read More
625 Words | 3 Pages

Summary: Charles Taylor addresses the connection between identity and recognition within “The Politics of Recognition”. The need for individuals to understand who they are as an individual is key, society constructs a structure for individuals to abide by in order to create a like-minded society, but within each individual is an individuality that clashes with that oppressive structure. Taylor argues that one cannot be expected to live their life in a manner in which another specific individual would like them to, and therefore the only proper way for an individual to live their life is in a manner consistent with their own individuality Taylor argues for the necessity of language as well as human exchanges.

Read More

More about Zygmunt Bauman Stuart Hall Summary

Related Topics

Open Document