ipl-logo

Impact Of Franz Boas

1597 Words7 Pages

The Intent and Impact of Franz Boas

Introduction
In his article, “Engineering Internment: Anthropologists and the War Relocation Authority,” Orin Starn (1986) concludes that ethnographers should closely analyze “the circumstances surrounding anthropological participation, the intentions of the ethnographer, and the outcomes of their work” (p. 702). While he is specifically referencing the role of WRA anthropologists, his logic can be applied across the board. Throughout the semester, the class has grappled with, and even avoided on some occasions, the question, does intent or impact matter? What is interesting about intent and impact is how often they are artificially separated, especially when examining the history of anthropology. In their …show more content…

Lewis (2001) both provide different interpretations of the intent and impact of Franz Boas’s ideas on race and culture. While Visweswaran (1998) claims that current anthropologists have failed to take a critical analysis of Boas’s ideas on culture on race, Lewis (2001) claims that critiques made by Visweswaran and others “are often insensitive to historical context, eschew benign but equally reasonable alternative interpretations, and are cavalier about cause and effect” (p. 450). As demonstrated by the arguments provided by Visweswaran (1998) and Lewis (2001), there is an unproductive stand-off between anthropologists. Unfortunately, this will continue to happen until anthropologists realize that the measurement of intent is subjective and that the impact of anthropological work needs to be critically analyzed for what it is. As Lewis (2001) presents, each one of Boas’s critics supports their arguments about why Boas’s intentions were not as moral as one might perceive. However, these arguments, comparable to Lewis’, are supported using their own interpretations, rather than facts. In addition, as Visweswaran (1998) presents, anthropologists should not overlook how Boas’s construction of race and culture has affected anthropological thought, as well as other disciplines outside of anthropology, such as ethnic and cultural studies. In …show more content…

S. (2001). The Passion of Franz Boas. American Anthropologist, 103(2), 447-467.
Price, D. H. (2008). Anthropological Intelligence. The Deployment and Neglect of American Anthropology in the Second World War, 22, 70.
Silverman, S. (2005). The United States. In One Discipline Four Ways: British, German, French, and American Anthropology (pp. 255-347). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Starn, O. (1986). Engineering Internment: Anthropologists and the War Relocation Authority. American Ethnologist, 13(4), 700-720.
Stocking, G. W. (1965). On the Limits of ‘Presentism’ and ‘Historicism’ in the Historiography of the Behavioral Sciences. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 1(3), 211-218.
Visweswaran, K. (1998). Race and the Culture of Anthropology. American Anthropologist, 100(1),

Show More
Related

A History Of World War II Prisoners In The Heartland By Melissa Marsh

638 Words | 3 Pages

World War II is an area of history researched by many scholars and amateurs from all walks of life. Unfortunately, some aspects of this international event have been widely ignored. Thus, many books on unknown aspects of history are forced to balance informing about the event and creating an argument within its history. As such, Melissa Amateis Marsh’s book, Nebraska POW Camps: A History of World War II Prisoners in the Heartland, was a refreshing read on a forgotten event close to home for Nebraskans. Although, Melissa Marsh’s argument of the Nebraska POW camps appeared extremely biased by only discussing positive POW experiences, with few negative experiences mentioned.

Read More

Abuction On The Texas Frontier Sparknotes

1406 Words | 6 Pages

armed forces drove the Indians into reservations, the change was troublesome and difficult. Zesch sees himself both to be a relative of whites and, through the experience of his predecessor Adolph Korn, to be an assenting relative of the Comanche. He recounts to the two sides' accounts with equalization and compassion. He additionally investigates his very own family's conflicted relationship to its ancestors, and strips back the layers of history, so one feels not just the truth of the 1860s and 1870s, yet the resulting manners by which the encounters of officers, Indians, prisoners, and others were later spoken to in the mid-twentieth century, through books, Wild West shows, reunions between previous White and Indian and previous hostages and their previous individual warriors. The author states, “ By the fall of 1872, Adolph Korn, Clinton Smith, Herman Lehmann, Rudolph Fischer, and Temple Friend were living with the Indians as Indians, fighting their battles and taking part in their raids, prepared to die in defense of the tribe if necessary” (Zesch 139).

Read More

On The Run By Alice Goffman Sparknotes

576 Words | 3 Pages

The underlying principle of The Interpretation of Cultures is that anthropology is a descriptive science

Read More

Summary Of Body Ritual Among The Nacirema

588 Words | 3 Pages

Contemporary anthropologists are faced with “the problem of representation,” in other words, they are faced with the problem of deciding who gets to “represent” a group of people. So, who is worthy of “representing” a group? As we learned in the lectures, anthropology is the study of mankind, therefore, based on their extensive studies an anthropologist should be able to “represent” a group of people. Unfortunately, all humans, including anthropologist, are subject to thinking in a bias manner.

Read More

Assess The Difference Between Cultur Culture And Non Human Primate

446 Words | 2 Pages

Primatologists define culture as information that shapes individuals behavior through observations, interactions and teachings from other members of the same species. These social interactions shape individuals whether they are aware of it or not, and ultimately it is what shapes their behavior. These cultural behaviors are not solely learned in human primates but also non-human primates show evidence of culture. According to the University of Cambridge they have evidence that suggest that “monkeys can learn skills from each other, in the same manner as humans”, which demonstrates evidence of non-human primate culture (University of Cambridge, 2007).

Read More

Social And Political Factors In Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

2315 Words | 10 Pages

Thomas Morgan delves into the history of the relationship between Germany and Native Americans in Native Americans in World War II. In the First World War, Native American languages were used as codes for American, French and British troops to send messages, and even by the end of the war, the Germans had not broken the code (Morgan). In the 1930s, it was clear to many that another World War was on the horizon. Hitler sent Nazi agents to the US posing as scientists to try to learn native languages to prevent the same thing from happening again. Americans who supported the Third Reich tried to convince Native Americans to stay out of the war, and many tried to instigate a native revolt (Morgan).

Read More

The Harsh Treatment Of Japanese Soldiers During World War II

814 Words | 4 Pages

In addition to the cultural tradition of Bushido, the Japanese’s harsh treatment of prisoners of war during World War II can also be attributed to the military doctrines and structures that were prevalent in Japan at the

Read More

Impact Of Ww2 On African American Women

502 Words | 3 Pages

The comforting but uneducated conclusion made in "Native Americans in the Military - World War II” is that “many who left the reservation during the war to work in the “white” world found they were accepted into and became a part of the national society.” While it would be grand to claim that oppression on the Native Americans was destroyed after WWII, history and modern times are riddled with the stubborn-narrow mindedness of the “ white” society. Sadly, the ignorant conclusions demonstrated by the author Thomas D. Morgan, the article "The Role of Native American’s During World War II”, and the article “Native Americans in the Military - World War II” poison much of today’s

Read More

A Family Bid: 150K Under The Highest Offer On An Oakville Home

718 Words | 3 Pages

Anthropology, Sociology and Psychology Newspaper Assignment Article: A family bid $150K under the highest offer on an Oakville home and still got the sale. The reason why will leave you heartened Source: Toronto Star Publication Date: Thursday, March 30, 2017 Part A) Anthropology, Sociology and Psychology, the three Social Sciences, are systemic studies of humans, their day-to-day activities and their relationships to others. Anthropology, one of the three social sciences, is the study of the creation, the actions, as well as the physical, social and cultural growth of humans. Sociology, on the other hand, is the study of human social interactions, institutions and organizations that create what we call society.

Read More

Why Do Chimpanzees Use Correct Spelling And Hyphenation?

561 Words | 3 Pages

The word culture has traditionally been used to describe human behavior, but maybe, he says, a new definition is needed. Considering this startlingly new theory of chimpanzee “culture,” some researchers think that humans now have an undeniable obligation to protect the lives of all remaining wild chimpanzees rather than zeroing in on just a few of the threatened animals. The loss of a single group of wild chimpanzees would, they say, destroy something irreplaceable—a unique culture with its own traditions and way of

Read More

Mary Douglass Purity And Danger Summary

1226 Words | 5 Pages

Koume Ono Ritsumeikan University Introduction to Anthropology The most surprising thing to me about reading Mary Douglas anthropology book, Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo, is that I was actually fascinated about everything she argues in the book, many things I had questioned about but did not know the answer or simple facts that make you realized how our society structure works. Which is why in these book review paper I will emphasize more in some chapters rather than the book itself in one big paragraph. Mary Douglas, analyses the ideas of pollutions and taboo in different cultures and also different timing (primitive cultures, modern cultures) focusing in the Gestalt psychology. However, one of the things I liked the most about her writing style is that she avoided limited explanations, explained everything in details and giving examples making it easier for the

Read More

Using The Work Of Anthropologist Constance Classen And Horace Miner

495 Words | 2 Pages

On Senses and the World Using the work of anthropologists Constance Classen and Horace Miner. Three different cultures will be examined in order to answer the question “what is the primary sense through which “we” perceive the world”. To answer this question one first should define “we”, which in this case “we” should be understood as broadly as possible, In terms of concept rather than exclusivity to a group, because the group one person could claim ownership to, and use “we” to describe most likely is very different culturally and in the context of perceiving the world through a sense to one another. Different cultures can place importance and create social constructions based on different senses in order understand the human experience their place in the world (Classen 1). “We” as a part of any society need senses to make since of the abstract and scientific complications present within our world.

Read More

Pitt Rivers And Boas: A Comparative Analysis

1457 Words | 6 Pages

It was under the influence of two men that the fields of anthropology and ethnology began to change and transform into what they are today. Augustus Pitt Rivers and Franz Boas each had very different approaches to material culture; they had different ways of understanding objects, and this guided the ways they organized and displayed them in museums. Pitt Rivers believed material culture could be used to illustrate the evolution of humans and technology, arranging museum displays to show progression of complexity. Boas believed material culture served to inform researchers of the cultures from which they came, arranging his displays by 'tribal groupings.' Nevertheless, both approaches were innovative for their time and established influential

Read More

Anthropology Interview Summary And Analysis

1000 Words | 4 Pages

Surprisingly, all five of the people that I interviewed had heard of the word “anthropology”, regardless of their level of education. However, only one out of all five actually knew the correct definition of the term and what anthropologists really

Read More

Tale From The Jungle Margaret Mead Analysis

825 Words | 4 Pages

“Tale From the Jungle: Margaret Mead”, youtube videos, which was introduced by Professor Ana, humanities professor, are a six long clip video documentaries of the first anthropology’s discoveries ever brought to public, the Samoan civilization. This ‘Samoan civilization’ anthropology discovery was discovered by Mead Margaret, an American female anthropologist, and later by Derek Freeman, an Australian anthologist. According to Mead Margaret, an American female anthropologist, she believes that humans are influenced by nurture. On the other side, Derek Freeman, an Australian anthologist, opposes Mead Margaret’s idea. He believes that humans are influenced by nature.

Read More

More about Impact Of Franz Boas

Related Topics

Open Document