ipl-logo

Inaccuracies And Misrepresentation Of Native Americans In Western Film

1882 Words8 Pages

Samantha Padilla
60W Cluster

Instructor Rachel Birke

June 4, 2023

Literature Review: Analysis of stereotype on Native Americans In Western Film

Abstract The role of this paper is to investigate the inaccuracies and misrepresentation of Native American Culture. Through the use of literature and multiple films as the main source of media for the exploration of misrepresentation of Native American culture. The conclusion of this research is that Western Film , backed by many forms of literature, have dominated the misrepresentation of Native American peoples, and these types of film continue to be made and exist today.

Introduction Throughout our History as American society, the evolution of the media has been astounding. Media had …show more content…

The idea for Native Americans to be included in film would regard the Native Americans to be portrayed as violent “savages” whose main goal was to harm the White Mens and impede their journey. The Natives in American western films were seen to be cast as characters that the White American cowboy would have to face as a challenge to get on through their Journey. Through western films, it is a common trope for Native Americnas to be placed in a category that would benefit the plot of the movie. The tropes that can be seen as a common pattern for Native Americas in film, as noted by M. Elise Marubbio in the novel Look at the Heart of The Searchers: The Centrality of Look to John Ford’s Commentary on Racism. are the stereotypes of the “Noble Savage” or the “Ignoble Savage”. The “Noble Savage” was the Native that was considered the “good” and complacent Individual, and the “Ignoble Savage” was the Native American who was violent, the antagonist to the white western cowboy. Not only were these categorizations of the Indigenous individuals detrimental to them, it also created a mass consciousness of these inaccuracies of their culture. Through western film and these stereotypes, it had led American Society to believe that Native Americans were violent, wild, and svaggeious, or they can be calm, spiritual, and wise. Although the latter may have been interpreted in a positive manner, the former was detrimental to the Culture of the Native

Show More
Related
776 Words | 4 Pages

In the documentary, Reel Injun: On the Trail of the Hollywood Indian, directed by Neil Diamond, he investigates the progression of how cinema has portrayed the Native American. They begin with the early classic films that first were made up until recent times. The image of the Indian has been portrayed in several ways and films had typically created misleading depictions of the Indians. What was created in these films are often stereotypical and what many people today believe to be true. Throughout the documentary, we see many themes being presented and these are themes of how the image of Native Americans were viewed as the “bad guys” during some early films and how they evolved to show how they were really just human beings.

Read More
320 Words | 2 Pages

Neil Diamond 's documentary “Reel Injun” depicts the historical portrayal of the treatment of the First Nations in America. It brings awareness to the truth behind not only First Nations, but other stereotyped groups. For example, that many people often mistake all members of the Muslim community as Extremists who commit inhumane acts of terrorism. Small percentages of the population who fit the stereotyped criteria may often unintentionally represent their background negatively and as a whole. These are then misinterpreted by society ultimately having a biased view on groups of people.

Read More
1007 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout history, there have been many literary studies that focused on the culture and traditions of Native Americans. Native writers have worked painstakingly on tribal histories, and their works have made us realize that we have not learned the full story of the Native American tribes. Deborah Miranda has written a collective tribal memoir, “Bad Indians”, drawing on ancestral memory that revealed aspects of an indigenous worldview and contributed to update our understanding of the mission system, settler colonialism and histories of American Indians about how they underwent cruel violence and exploitation. Her memoir successfully addressed past grievances of colonialism and also recognized and honored indigenous knowledge and identity.

Read More
1480 Words | 6 Pages

The film, Reel Injun reveals a distortion of the way Hollywood sees Native American life through comedy and the real way Native Americans live which changes according to the current times. Neil Diamond sets out on a journey across America to figure out where the incorrect image of Natives arose from, all signs pointing towards Hollywood. Dozens of films recreate the way Americans believe Natives live as savages and wear costumes and decorated headpieces with feathers, but Hollywood does not show the true spiritual side and the meaning of why they live the way they do as true to their own culture and assimilated to the American culture as well. US history negatively affects Native American live which lead to the image of Natives to be clouded by imagination through film, changed the way Natives viewed themselves and expect to live, and misshaped the view we now have for Natives.

Read More
1153 Words | 5 Pages

Native Americans who traveled with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show used the press to make social and political statements as well as communicate their opinions of white society. According to memoirs, some Native Americans accepted to travel with a show that portrayed them stereotypically in order to understand “‘the white man’s beliefs about God’s will, and how they act according to it.”’ Although the only way for this goal to be achieved was through the noble savage stereotype, the performance of the stereotype gave Native Americans some control over the ways in which tourism and religion intersect. The tourist gaze is therefore symbiotic because the tourist gains access to the authenticity he or she desires while the Native Americans gather knowledge to better protect their religion and culture against the encroaching white world. Thus, self-commodification can be utilized as a method to adapt but not necessarily resolve a problematic history of colonialism.

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

Even today, movies and cartoons that depict Native Americans in any way are most often being portrayed in the same fashion as they have been for hundreds of years: through the eyes of the earliest white settlers. When Disney’s Pocahontas came out, the brutal song “Savages!” devastated Native American children.

Read More
607 Words | 3 Pages

At this point in the film the audience has not seen Geronimo and the Apache tribe on screen, so it already feels like the Native Americans are the villains. By being described as butchers, the audience can dehumanize Native Americans because they assume that they ride along and kill people. One more issue with the portrayal of Native Americans in Stagecoach is that it perpetuates the idea of Native Americans as stoic and voiceless individuals. An example of this can be seen in a scene where three high ranked officers discuss the whereabouts of the Apache leader, Geronimo. Rather than asking the Native American man in the room, the officer asks his peers for an

Read More
529 Words | 3 Pages

Furthermore, the myth of the vanishing Indian is also demonstrated in Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West advertisement, as it portrayed Native Americans as uncivilized, violent peoples. This advertisement likely facilitated racist views—namely, views that Native Americans were primal warriors

Read More
1494 Words | 6 Pages

Even though America has become quite the diverse place with diverse cultures, the cultural appropriation found within the American society contributes to the loss of multiple minority culture’s identity. Native Americans are one of the minority groups most heavily impacted by cultural appropriation. From offensive sports, many American Indians feel as though their cultural identities are lost in the mass of stereotypes and false representations of them in popular culture. In literature and film, Indians are too often portrayed as some variation of “the Noble or Ignoble Savage” (Gordon, 30), violent and uneducated, and it is easy to imagine how this negative representation inspires resentment in the Native American community, who have no interest in having their cultures and peoples being reduced to mere savages,

Read More
1058 Words | 5 Pages

The media today consists of a huge diversity of different things. This is because the United States is known as the melting pot country and today 's society doesn 't understand the real history of the Native American people. They are easily one of the top most underrepresented cultures and people in the media in today’s world. This is why there are stereotypes of them throughout the media. Native Americans are stereotyped in many ways such as in movies, tv shows, books, etc.

Read More
1106 Words | 5 Pages

They are often labeled as uncivilized barbarians, which is a solely false accusation against them. This paper aims to address the similarities between Native American beliefs and the beliefs of other cultures based on The Iroquois Creation Story in order to defeat the stereotype that Natives are regularly defined by. Native Americans are commonly considered uncivilized, savage, and barbarian. Nevertheless, in reality the Natives are not characterized by any of those negative traits, but rather they inhabit positive characteristics such as being wise, polite, tolerant, civilized, harmonious with nature, etc. They have had a prodigious impact on the Puritans

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

‘Dances with the wolves’ is a 1990 American epic western movie that defied norms in Hollywood, revitalized the western genre in filmmaking, challenged and changed the perception of viewers toward native Americans. The movie significantly impacted social, cultural, historical aspects of society. Native American are rarely screened in Hollywood and when they do, they are demonized as the blood thirsty savages and bad guys. According to Beverly R. Singer, "Despite the fact that a diversity of indigenous peoples had a legal and historical significance in the formation of every new country founded in the western hemisphere, in the United States and Canada the term 'Indians' became a hegemonic designation implying that they were all the same in regard to culture, behavior, language, and social organization. The view of 'Indians' as savage and uncivilized was repeated in early films and crystallized the image of 'Indians' as dangerous and unacceptable to the normative lives of European

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

Science journalist, Charles C. Mann, had successfully achieved his argumentative purpose about the “Coming of Age in the Dawnland.” Mann’s overall purpose of writing this argumentative was to show readers that there’s more to than just being called or being stereotyped as a savage- a cynical being. These beings are stereotyped into being called Indians, or Native Americans (as they are shorthand names), but they would rather be identified by their own tribe name. Charles Mann had talked about only one person in general but others as well without naming them. Mann had talked about an Indian named Tisquantum, but he, himself, does not want to be recognized as one; to be more recognized as the “first and foremost as a citizen of Patuxet,”(Mann 24).

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

Hollywood Cinema is a major contributor to the stereotypes that have plagued the First Peoples all over the world. Over the past three decades, First Peoples Cinema has experienced a rebirth that has reclaimed their identity and also combated the negative “Imaginary Indian” depiction of First Peoples in Hollywood. The Imaginary Indian depiction can be seen in films such as John Ford’s Stagecoach (1939), which portrayed Native Americans as a savage group of humans that were holding back the notion of Manifest Destiny in the United States. Also there are films like James Cameron Avatar (2009) and Kevin Costner’s Dances with Wolves (1990) that portray Native Peoples in a positive manner, but ultimately centralizes their themes around the rebirth

Read More
1055 Words | 5 Pages

Dead Man was a response that shocked the world, as It is an independent that aimed to mock the way Native Americans’ life and cultures are portrayed by the Hollywood movies. Dead Man earned a lot of attention when was first released. Although Dead man might seem a normal movie, the implicit purposes of releasing it are way more complicated than they might appear, for it is a critical film that contained a lot of mocking elements, techniques and strategies. The importance of Dead Man comes not only from the fact that it is the first to mock the Western American films but, as its director states in one of his interviews with Scott Macaulay, a Canadian film producer, “Dead man is a very simple story on the surface, but there are so many things the film is about – history, language, America, indigenous culture, violence, industrialization” (Macaulay, 1), this movie is very comprehensive, for despite the purposes of producing it, it is a thorough

Read More

More about Inaccuracies And Misrepresentation Of Native Americans In Western Film

Related Topics

Open Document