ipl-logo

Incompetent Child Analysis

1474 Words6 Pages

There are studies that focus on the competencies of children in health care decisions, yet do not explicitly mention much about the perspectives of incompetent children. Incompetent children and adolescent patients could be infants, young children, or young persons with mental illnesses or disabilities that could affect their mental and decisional capacities to make well informed health care decisions, and are assumed to require the assistance of substitute decision-makers to make decisions in the child's best interests when the incompetent child could express their approval or disapproval of a treatment. This "mature minor" notion recognizes that some children are capable of making their own health care choices despite their age (Harrison, …show more content…

Young children and adolescents who do not have fully developed cognitive abilities are seen as incompetent. To be competent is to have the ability to understand and appreciate the consequences of treatment and non-treatment, and in Canada, patients are presumed competent until shown otherwise. Competence models for adults presume that "patients are autonomous, have a stable sense of self, established values, and mature cognitive skills" (Harrison, 1997, p. 30), all of which are underdeveloped in children. There should be a continual review of a child's competence because children's cognitive abilities are still developing. When investigating the competency of a child, qualitative social research is the better approach than developmental psychological research because it is informed by critiques of the child development theory to investigate how children's competencies are recognized, denied, encouraged or inhibited (Alderson, 2013). Qualitative social researchers establish a friendly rapport and interactions with children to better understand their perspectives and reasoning instead of using study methods that detach themselves from the children which could make them nervous and underperform in the conducted studies. Through this method of assessment, it has been shown that children with chronic illnesses or disabilities …show more content…

However, health care providers and substitute decision-makers must consult and involve incompetent patients in the decision-making process to the greatest extent possible, because it is a moral requirement for child patients. Substitute decision-makers are obliged to make treatment decisions in the child's best interests and if the health care provider suspects otherwise, they can appeal to provincial child welfare authorities (Harrison, 1997, p.31). Involving incompetent children in decision-making is a moral requirement because the child has the right to know what treatment they will be undergoing and its risks and benefits before consenting to the treatment. The use of age-appropriate discussions are helpful to children and adolescents who are seriously ill because it will help them develop an understanding of the issues regarding their health care decisions (Harrison, 1997, p. 32). In the end, the patient is the child, not the parents, and physicians should ensure that the decisions made are in the child's best

Show More
Related
1319 Words | 6 Pages

In some cultures, family members make treatment decisions on behalf of their loved-ones. Provided the patient consents to this arrangement and is assured that any questions about his/her medical care will be answered, the physician may seek consent from a family member in lieu of the patient.”

Read More
1433 Words | 6 Pages

Mr. Z is 86-years-old, Caucasian male that lives with his wife of 56 years. He values his independence, but recently he been struggling to care for himself. He has a long-standing history of diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and chronic kidney disease. His wife was concerned because she noticed her husband can no longer drive, is having difficulty walking, and managing his own care and daily medication. She explained that her husband is lethargic, sleepless, having poor appetite and difficulty maintaining his weight.

Read More
1650 Words | 7 Pages

What they often forget is that their patients may not have the same level of education as they do and that they may not be able to comprehend the information. Low health literacy can hinder the patient's decision making when it comes to understanding their health status and recognizing the health risks associated with medical procedures. Most medical facilities expect patients to understand the risks and benefits that happen to their health when they want treatments/experiments to be performed on them. Before they receive treatments from doctors, the patient is first given an informed consent. It is standard procedure for the patients to sign an informed consent while being supervised by a medical employee.

Read More
842 Words | 4 Pages

A piece of legislation was created in 2005, with the purpose to allow clinicians to make decisions for the patient, when it is deemed that they haven’t got the ability to think clearly or understand information that is being presented to them, whether that is permanently or temporarily. Whilst this is the case, different levels of capacity are required for different decisions, so a patient cannot be “deprived of their liberty” (SCAS, 2010, 5) and all decision made in the best interest of the patient must be the “least restrictive alternative” (SCAS, 2010, 7.1). This means that these decisions cannot cause the patient to feel uncomfortable, embarrassed, or be detrimental to their health. Until proven otherwise, everyone is assumed to have capacity to make a decision. There are a variety of reasons that affect a patient’s capacity; neurological conditions (eg. dementia etc), head/brain trauma (eg. concussion etc) learning disabilities, effects of hypoxia, the effects of alcohol or substance use, amongst others (SCAS, 2010, 7.1).

Read More
814 Words | 4 Pages

The physician is rendering the aid the patient requests and respecting the patient’s autonomous decision to exercise their right to

Read More
834 Words | 4 Pages

DNR Orders in School DNR orders are given out to the school administration and teachers from medical practitioners, upon the request of the child’s parent. These orders raise a lot of debate in various platforms and many people may not fully comprehend what the orders mean or why they are issued. The all handicapped children act, under the public law 94-142 states that each child should be allowed to attend school and be in class as long as it is for the benefit of the child. This act has therefore placed school administrations at a situation, which require them to equip well enough to be able to handle all the children with disabilities.

Read More
1024 Words | 5 Pages

Healthcare professionals must work on the assumption that every patient has the capacity to make decisions about their care, and to decide whether to agree to, or refuse, an examination or treatment. However, in the case that patients are deemed to be lacking capacity the Mental Capacity Act (2005), The Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act (2000) legislations must be followed (General Medical Council, 2008). Gaining consent before providing care or treatment to any patient is very important because patient requires

Read More
1242 Words | 5 Pages

It also suggests that, “within the hospital team nurses have the right to autonomy of judgement and decision and in conflicted situations, such as the one described here” (109). This means if the parents cannot come up with a definite answer, the nurses have the right to decide what is best for the child. Also, this article explains the conflicts when parents and medical staff disagree. Many problems can be caused by this issue such as, “what extent is it possible to scrutinize the way devoted parents should act” (108). Then, in another scholarly article, “The Role of The Pediatric Nurse in Promoting Pediatric Right to Consent,” gives specific characteristics that nurses should look for in children to determine how capable they are.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

Transitioning from the paediatric to adult care involves a holistic multifaceted, active process that encompasses the health requirements of the young person and transcends beyond specific health condition needs to include the broader context of family, relationships, education, work and social care.1 It is defined as a purposeful, planned process that addresses the medical, psychosocial and educational/vocational needs of adolescents and young people with chronic physical and medical conditions as they move from child-centered to adult oriented health care systems.2 The chronicity of the medical conditions implies that the disease conditions occur more or less throughout life. The children would most likely have then developed a psycho-social

Read More
505 Words | 3 Pages

In most, if not all, countries, all adult and mentally-competent patients have the right to make autonomous decisions concerning their medical and health conditions. This right is reserved so long as the patient has the ability or capacity to voluntarily make and comprehend the decision in the presence of full disclosure with regards to the therapy in question. Failure of a healthcare

Read More
903 Words | 4 Pages

Deborah Abbott & Stephen Gottschalk (2002) states, “Again, however, prayer and reasoned judgment amid the exigencies of practical situations—rather than abstract criteria—tend to shape the choice of treatment in emergency cases,” (p. 6-7).Physicians on the other hand see it as the parents being neglectful on what is necessary for the

Read More
484 Words | 2 Pages

I believe the most compelling reasons to give patients maximum autonomy over decisions regarding their care is because patients should have self-ownership over their own body, and the quality of life. may seem dependent on the patient’s interest over the physician’s decision. The definition of patient autonomy is to have personal freedom of one 's decision that is free from both controlling interferences by others and from personal limitations that prevent meaningful choice. While on the other hand, a physician’s duty of “beneficence” is the hippocratic oath in which action that is done for the benefit of others such as help prevent or remove harms or to simply improve the situation of others. I believe patient autonomy over weighs prioritization over the medical professional’s duty due to the fact the main concern overall is over the patient’s health.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Patients have a right to complain about the doctor's refusal to the Management. Provision of Treatment requires patient’s choice and informed consent. Even if a patient has signed a general consent clause, the patient can still refuse medical treatment or procedures. However, in exceptional or emergency situations a doctor may be legally justified in performing surgery or providing treatment without the patient's consent. The patient should be competent and capable of making such a decision to give a consent.

Read More
1007 Words | 5 Pages

Researchers will need to have a close involvement with the participants to understand their perspective and interpretation regarding on a situation or phenomenon to develop an in-depth explanation. Qualitative research is done in a wide-angle lens as subjectivity is critical to examines the breadth and depth of phenomena. It is often designs in open-ended questions in order to analyse and interpret the data. The method for qualitative research includes ethnography, interview, historical research, participant observation and textual analysis. (Brennen, 2013)

Read More
1398 Words | 6 Pages

Qualitative data analysis is a way by the researcher to summarize the collected data in dependable and in accurate manner. As Miles and Huberman (1984) the most serious and central difficulty in the use of qualitative data is that methods of data analysis are not well-formulated. (Nasution,1988) when starting an on going process, in fact, data analysis in qualitative research is an ongoing activity that occurs throughout the investigate process rather than after

Read More

More about Incompetent Child Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document