ipl-logo

Is Orientalism? Outline And Evaluating Edward Said's Argument

2749 Words11 Pages

IR 4027 Middle East Politics

Name: Marek Madle
The Course Co-ordinator’s name: Dr Andrea Teti
Essay topic:
What is ‘Orientalism’? Outline and evaluate Edward Said’s argument. What implications does his line of argument have? (Discuss with reference to EITHER media coverage of Middle East issues, government policies towards a Middle Eastern state, OR to the application of IR theories to the region.)

I. The Summary

This paper examines the definition of Orientalism, it outlines and evaluates Edward Said’s argument and what implications his line of argument has with reference to the media’s coverage of issues in the Middle East. This paper is also includes a case study of Osama Bin Laden based on implications of Said’s line …show more content…

That is what happened to Osama. The article by Kate Zernike and Michael T. Kaufman (2011) in New York Times described the life of Osama and how his role in the Wold order had changed. This happened in 1989 when the Soviet army was defeated in Afghanistan. This all could not have been done without US support of weapons and capital. The turning point came in 1998 when he declared that he was “confident that Muslims will be able to end the legend of the so-called superpower that is America.” But this article clashes with the previous article in that it states Osama ran his training camps from 1986 …show more content…

Unfortunately, Said also gave us an idea how easy may be to judge and misunderstand one part of the world by using wrong picture of Orient by Western writers and media but also brainwashing people’s brains by Western governments. The example I gave in this paper was story of Osama Bin Laden. Therefore it is still uncertain whether Osama Bin Laden was a freedom fighter or terrorist. On one hand, media gave us clear picture of Bin Laden as a terrorist with no mercy. On the other hand, Michael Scheuer’s book offers completely different view on him. Therefore it is important to follow Said’s aspects of contemporary reality to make sure that we fully understand what we read and do not paint everyone with the same brush as Aslan

Show More
Related
828 Words | 4 Pages

Coming of age is the prolonged transitioning process of individuals to adulthood confronted with various challenges that requires human all endeavors to reach maturity. These universal ideas are demonstrated through ‘Raw’ written by Scott Monk and ‘Napoleon in Exile’ directed by Michael Lukk Litwak. In both text, the protagonists are challenged with various obstacles ultimately gaining maturity during the process. In ‘Raw’, one of the many ideas that is mentioned in the text is the understanding of independence and responsibilities.

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

“Doran explained that Bin Laden’s followers “consider themselves an island of true believers surrounded by a sea of iniquity and think that the future of religion itself, and therefore the world depends on them and their battle.” Based on Doran’s quote, he believes that the Middle East idolize themselves and think they are chosen to make the world better. By brining in this expert opinion, it solidifies the idea on “God’s will.” Bergen also believes in this idea because he describes the idea as “brilliantly articulated.”

Read More
1301 Words | 6 Pages

He states, “For an empathetic understanding of the present generation of Muslims one has to recognize that most of them do not accept Western critics’ radical reinterpretations of some parts of Muslim history” (Shepard, 5). Wilson had begun to understand this after countless times of her husband denying the Western depictions of Islam. He states “I can’t believe you’re going to teach American history…. This is exactly the kind of Western cultural takeover Egypt is turning a blind eye on” (Wilson, 40).

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

BOOK REVIEW Book Review Submitted to Professor Daene Liberty University Online Lisa Barton HIUS 222: Survey of American History II INTRODUCTION Escape from Bataan: Memoir of a U.S. Navy Ensign in the Philippines, October 1941 to May 1942 is a memoir about Ensign Ross Hofmann who joined the Navy as a young man during World War II. From his own eyes, he paints us a picture of what it was like to be in the Navy during the harrowing World War II. David Snead, his editor, says the book “provides a very unique look at the experiences of a junior naval officer who survived the harrowing defense of the Philippines.” In reading the book, I agree with David Snead’s comments.

Read More
1516 Words | 7 Pages

Osama was a fly in a crowded room. Coll recounts when bin-Laden’s name had popped up on numerous occasions in CIA reports or in conversation between ISI officials, but due to the lack of relevance it had on their mission, he was overlooked and swatted away. As the theory of organization represents a theory X method of governing, POSDCORD, Osama had proven to be a theory Y. He led his men with bravado, but was not authoritarian in his ways. Close confidents regarded him as calming, brilliant, and adept figure, who had a way with his words.

Read More
1158 Words | 5 Pages

Many held stereotypes against the Middle-Eastern because of the September attacks. Lots of these stereotypes were held up by ignorance of the misinformed. Many weren’t familiar with the culture and customs of the Middle East, and this raised the question: What is the Middle East really like? All calls were answered on October 31, 2005, George Saunders, a graduate from Syracuse and former GQ magazine writer, traveled to Dubai and experienced what the other side of the world is like.

Read More
992 Words | 4 Pages

Title: Surveillance and the Killing of Osama Bin Laden Thesis: Despite all efforts to live off the grid and leave no electronic trace behind, Osama Bin Laden, the most wanted terrorist on the planet, was located and assassinated at the hands of U.S. Navy Seals. Controversial Technologies played a crucial role in bringing justice to the most wanted terrorist in U.S. history. I. Osama Bin Laden was the founder of Al-Qaeda, the organization that is responsible for the September 11 attacks on the United States, along with other terrorist attacks against civilian and military targets directed to send a message to the U.S. and anyone else that disagreed with Al-Qaeda through any means necessary. A. Osama Bin Laden was born in 1957 to a wealthy

Read More
492 Words | 2 Pages

Mahatma Gandhi and Osama Bin Laden were both influential twentieth century figures that inspired millions of people through religion, unity, and nationalism. These men wanted to fight against colonialism and oppression which was thriving in their regions at the time. Despite the extreme differences in each of their modus operandi, these two separately radical men lived quite parallel lives. Both of these icons had a grand vision for change in the regions that they lived in, along with eventual global change. The global powers of their lifetimes where the main oppressors of their visions, with the British empire during Gandhi’s time, and the United states during Bin Laden’s.

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

With this divided view on the situation Lila Abu-lughob describes it as being an idea of East versus

Read More
2010 Words | 9 Pages

Inevitably, these resulting stereotypes and biases now influence the way that many Muslims typically act and feel about themselves in the 21st century. Moreover, in the literary works of Persepolis and Disgraced, Marji, an Iranian Muslim, and Amir, a Pakistani Muslim, both initially attempt

Read More
1449 Words | 6 Pages

The book deals with the history of Islam and provides arguments over the liberal interpretation of the religion. The book puts the blame on the Western imperialism and the self-serving misinterpretations of Islamic law by the past scholars for the controversies which are taking place within Islam. The work by Reza Aslan challenges the clash of civilizations. The book

Read More
1260 Words | 6 Pages

His background in the field establishes him as a near expert on Middle Eastern representation in the press as shown by the depth of his insight about the inner workings of the press. An example of this is an incident he describes in which a “distinguished” news official who requested that he cover a story in Turkey, assuming that his fluency in Arabic would enable him to be passably understood as he travelled through the country (41). Luyendijk explains his shock at the man’s assumption, and highlights the significant ignorance about the Arab World that exists even among journalism professionals, who are in fact responsible for representing the region to the Western world. This kind of “behind the scenes” insight establishes Luyendijk as a credible source and compels the reader to suspend their own beliefs about the Middle East in exchange for obtaining perhaps lesser known knowledge about an area of the world that plays a leading role on the world stage. Another example of this insight can be found in Luyendijk’s description of a typical protest in the Middle East that might be shown in the Western news, where “it might look like there was a crowd; but on the spot you saw that there was just a few angry men who only held up their lighters when the cameras were turning, and that they all went home for tea afterwards” (34).

Read More
573 Words | 3 Pages

The Middle East: a region rich in oil, beauty, and potential wealth. Yet, this beautiful area is being torn apart by a conflict so old, bloody, and vicious that many Westerners wonder, ‘will it ever stop?’ But other Westerners believe that if the Jews and Muslims just realized the other side’s goals, they would resolve their problems. In order to better understand this deep tension, we need to understand the background of the Muslims, the background of the Jews, and current causes of conflict. By doing this, we will paint a comprehensive picture of why such profound hate exists in one of the world’s most sought-after regions.

Read More
968 Words | 4 Pages

Our academic disciplines, journals, movies, and our whole cultural system is highly affected by the inevitability of the conflict between 'Islam ' and 'West ' (Adib-Moghaddam, 2011). This " clash regime" is a cultural artifact which is positioned in different strata of society because it is made up by a system of interdependent discourses that disperse into society and form a powerful 'clash mentality (Adib-Moghadam, 2011, p.5). This clash regime has constituted a main part of today 's national and international political culture (Adiv-Moghaddam, 2011, p.5). Therefore, European culture gained its own strength and identity by setting itself off against the Orient (Said, 1978). According to Macfie (2002), one of the convictions that is widely held in orientalism is the belief that Islam unlike other religions, is inherently violent its followers believe in the doctrine of Holy War or Jihad.

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

Ameen Rihani:Bridging East and West: a pioneering call for Arab-American. New York. University Press of America.

Read More

More about Is Orientalism? Outline And Evaluating Edward Said's Argument

Related Topics

Open Document