ipl-logo

What Is Ohn Stuart Mill's View Of The Subjection Of Women

1301 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Analysis of john stuart mill on 'liberty

ohn Stuart Mill ‘The Subjection of Women’ was composed in 1861 but was not published until the year 1869. Using irrefutable logic and true eloquence, Mill (1999) argues that in the legal system of The Great Britain women are dominated and controlled. According to Mill (1999), the involuntary vulnerability of women started ages ago when physical force transformed into authority and law. Furhtremore, he argues that women’s legal condition needs to be reviewed in order for the the nation to remain healthy (Mill,1999).

In the first chapter, Mill seeks to state his primary aim. Essentially, this aim is to challenge the popular idea that, by default, women are not equal to men. Mill’s disapprovals of women’s social status are founded on his social justice analysis eliminating women from decision-making, politics and generally from the public. He argues that this type of social injustice is one of the major obstacles to human development and the moral progress of human kind. Stuart states that such situations have a negative impact on women …show more content…

His gender conception is still one of the philosophically most fascinating formulations of an open-minded feminist thought. This is witnessed from the viewpoint of the present feminist philosophy, which comprises of his thoughts on issues like women subjection source, the dissimilarities between the men and women and the origin and nature of such dissimilarities (Mill, 1999). Although one cannot agree on everything, his ethical point of view is still worthy of consideration. According to his open-minded and thorough knowledge, Stuart emphasizes the comparisons between women and men rather than their dissimilarities, stressing that any of the mental dissimilarities that are thought to be present between men and women are just the natural consequence of the dissimilarities in their educational status and circumstances and does not signal any essential

Show More
Related
942 Words | 4 Pages

Most of the women that worked in the mills where daughters of farmers in the colonies and they would later be known as the “Mill Girls”. Many of the same women that left their homes to go to the factories did not become lifetime factory workers. Most left the factories after a couple years to go out and start their own family. But it wasn’t before the “Mill Girls” showed that women are an important factor in the American family and a driving force in the success of the American

Read More
617 Words | 3 Pages

In the case of the Lowell Mill girls, some young women felt liberated, but some also felt subjugated in the cruel environment. The Lowell girls were young female workers who came to work in industrial corporations in Lowell, Massachusetts during the Industrial Revolution in the United States. While their wages were only half of what men were paid, many were able to attain economic independence for the first time. For many of the mill girls, employment brought a taste of freedom. They escaped parental authority, were able to earn their own bit of money, and several educational opportunities.

Read More
1236 Words | 5 Pages

Words such as ‘unspoken assumption’, ‘insidiously’,‘exaggerating’, and “preoccupation” show suspicion towards the topic of women's rights and movements . In addition, the author also gives emphasis towards the downfall of men’s rights by including details such as “special privileges and protection to women” and “men’s supposed mistreatment of women”, thus showing how the author is directly opressed by the fight for equal rights. The author sees men's rights and their struggle with oppression as them being expected to have traditional cordial manners and fall into the traditional role of the patriarchy of the family, and decides to ‘debunk’ feminism by using these few points against a legacy of hatred, oppression, and misogyny that created

Read More
1023 Words | 5 Pages

Mill said, “the legal subordination of one sex to the other is wrong in itself, and one of the chief hindrances to human improvement”(CH 1). Mill wanted to build a way for woman rights. Mills also talked about marriage is not fair on the woman side. If she was going to be separated with her husband she would have no rights to take anything. Not even her children.

Read More
1224 Words | 5 Pages

Whether it is at the dinner table or in my family’s group text message, the conversation about my brother’s custody battle with my mother’s side of the family seems to remain a bitter topic, especially when discussing my role in it. When my father physically harmed my brother to the extent to which he had to go to the emergency room, the custody trial over my brother and me began. After several sources provided the judge with accusations against my father, I was the final source that needed to assert or deny my father’s abuse; with heavy consideration, I decided to lie to the judge by denying my father’s abuse. Under the principle of utilitarianism, philosophers would infer that lying is permissible if the consequences of doing so are good.

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

On the other hand, some claim that the mills oppressed these women workers by cutting their wages and increasing their work. Reporters of the newspaper The Harbringer visited the Lowell mills in 1836 to observe the practices there (Voices 136). They commented on the cumbersome work load of the operatives: “The girls attended upon an average three looms; many attended four, but this requires a very active person, and the most unremitting care….Attention to two is as much as should be demanded of an operative” (Voices 136). The mill owners reduced the girls’ wages and increased their loom and speed quota to maintain profits during a decrease in cloth prices (“Bagley” 94).

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

Essentially, marriage in the 1700’s was seen merely as a means of birthing heirs and finding a way to financially support yourself, so it resulted in both men and women being devalued. It is universally known that women were often treated as inept and helpless rather than sophisticated people with autonomy and capabilities. In fact, during this time, “married women were consistently compared with minor children and the insane-- both categories of people considered incapable of caring for themselves. To marry a woman was, in one sense, to ‘adopt’ her-- or at least to adopt responsibility for all the circumstances of life with which she entered the marriage” (Teachman 39). Furthermore, when women got married, they would legally cease to exist.

Read More
1463 Words | 6 Pages

According to Mill, there exists a “legal subordination of one sex to the other” (Mill 1) where the oppression of women is a form of a “primitive state of slavery lasting on” (Mill 6). Thus, where on one hand for Marx, oppression of women has nothing to do with law, for Mill, on the other, it exists because of “the law of the strongest” (Mill 6) that enforces that women “shall never in all their lives be allowed to compete for certain things” (Mill 20). Not only this, but for Mill, unlike Marx, the oppression of women in society goes a lot further to include enslavement of the

Read More
1586 Words | 7 Pages

John Stuart Mill wrote The Subjection of Women (1869), arguing in favor of equality between sexes. Mill compares the position of women with slavery in which control by the male sex is based on chivalry and generosity, using bribery and intimidation instead of brutality to secure obedience, deference, and gratitude for protection. Bribery and intimidation effect women economically and morally by having them depend on men, law completes intimidation by discriminatory statues. Much like Wollstonecraft had argued 70 years’ prior, Stuart took cause for women’s education.

Read More
1494 Words | 6 Pages

Women in England during the 1800s faced restrictions to participate in movements and were limited in their political speaking and voting capabilities. Although many women accepted their fate, some fought for a different social role. (“The Women 's Rights Movement”) Women such Mary Wollstonecraft, Jane Austen, and Mary Shelley inspired a new way of radical thinking towards human rights, specifically the rights of women (Surgis). Thanks to these inspiring individuals, there was a change in women’s attitude regarding their options to become part of the work force, gain an education, and have equal rights in marriage (Surgis).

Read More
775 Words | 4 Pages

In the book of vindication of the right of a woman, Wollstonecraft brings out clearly the roles of a woman in her society and how it has led to oppression of women (Wollstonecraft 22). Wollstonecraft believes that men and women are equal given the same environment and empowerment, women can do anything a man can do. In her society, education for women is only aimed at making her look pleasing to men. Women are treated as inferior being and used by men as sex objects. Wollstonecraft believed that the quality of mind of women is the same with that of men, and therefore women should not be denied a chance for formal education that will empower them to be equal with men.

Read More
1750 Words | 7 Pages

This theme relates to the real world because gender inequality is a problem that has been faced throughout history. In many cultures in the past, women were in-charge of domestic work while men took the roles of public life. Be that as it may, both men and women took equally important roles; however, because of the longstanding gender bias in the world, the roles of men in society were glorified more than the roles of women. Today, gender inequality still exists in the world. Specifically, today’s women are faced with sexist comments and attitudes from men that put women down.

Read More
361 Words | 2 Pages

The second topic that has been discussed in class this semester is the views of John Stuart Mill. In class we have discussed Mill’s views on nature verses nurture, women in the Victorian era, representative democracy, tyranny of the majority, the voucher system, middle class and inheritance. Throughout this paper I will be discussing the views of Mill as well as providing you with my opinion on these topics. John Stuart Mill believes that we are who we are because of our upbringing and education, not because of nature. Mill never went to school and became a highly ranked philosopher.

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

In nearly all historical societies, sexism was prevalent. Power struggles between genders mostly ended in men being the dominant force in society, leaving women on a lower rung of the social ladder. However, this does not always mean that women have a harder existence in society. Scott Russell Sanders faces a moral dilemma in “The Men We Carry in Our Minds.” In the beginning, Sanders feels that women have a harder time in society today than men do.

Read More
1104 Words | 5 Pages

I chose to review the fifth chapter of “New Ideas From Dead Economists” titled The Stormy Mind of John Stuart Mill. John Stuart Mill was born in 1806 in London to two strict parents who began to educate their son at a very young age. Mill’s father was James Mill, a famous historian and economist, who began to teach his son Greek at the age of three. The book reports that “by eight, the boy had read Plato, Xenophon, and Diogenes” and by twelve “Mill exhausted well-stocked libraries, reading Aristotle and Aristophanes and mastering calculus and geometry” (Buchholz 93). The vast amount of knowledge that Mill gained at a young age no doubt assisted him in becoming such a well-recognized philosopher and economist.

Read More

More about What Is Ohn Stuart Mill's View Of The Subjection Of Women

Related Topics

Open Document