ipl-logo

Justice In The Oresteia

1718 Words7 Pages

ustice, fairness, and decency, abstract concepts that are innate in society and human nature. However, despite their near universal status in humanities mid, they often have different meanings for individuals. Aeschylus uses The Oresteia in order to explore these issues as characters in the play try to determine what it means to be just, what ought a just actor do, and what is the best model for achieving justice. The characters discuss ideas such as vengeance, reciprocity, balance, moderation, and finally the end result of the implied debate leads to a jury system. In this paper I will go over two of the several different interpretations of justice used in the Oresteia and compare and contrast them in order to demonstrate which is the best …show more content…

Vengeance is the model used by both the King of Mycene, in order to justify the war after his wife was taken to Troy and by Elextra to justify Orestes duty to kill his mother to avenge the death of his father. In the Libation Bearers, Elektra asks, “‘Repay those that send these honors,’ for they deserve a gift that matches their evil.” (Aeschylus 72) Later on, the chorus asks her the rhetorical question, “How could it not be right to repay your enemy, evil for evil.” (Aeschylus 74) These lines among others in the play demonstrate that the normal thing to do was to exact …show more content…

This is a model that allows people to get what they deserve, however it is lead by restraint. Restraint allows for a delay in order to deliberate and decide on a punishment that fits the crime nicely rather than being over or under sized. By allowing an outside source to view the case, the goal is that both sides points are understood and taken into account. Questions are asked such as what is enough? How far is too far? How can one know what another is deserving of. Important to the success of this model is the impartiality of the one judging. As Athena says in The Furies, “Prejudice is slander to the innocent, and justice should always be impartial.” (Aeschylus 134)
By using moderation and restraint, escalation and an endless loop of retaliation can potentially be avoided. A prominent example of this occurring in the text of the Oresteia is that of the debate and jury between Athena and the Furies. Athena stops and listens to both sides, Orestes and that of the Furies. Realizing that she would be too biased to be impartial, she assembles a Jury in the hopes that bias would be

Show More
Related
462 Words | 2 Pages

When people think of a good judge they typically think of somebody who is fair, not bias and has some sort of experience. However, in today’s society, particularly in the United States, our judicial selection methods are not made to select judges on their ability to reason well and rule impartially (Carter and Burke, 6). On top of that, judges have no actual training before they become part of the judiciary. The only training they receive is in school when they are studying the law. Sometimes when they pursue an apprenticeship with a judge they also get a little bit more experience or insight into a judge’s job.

Read More
1448 Words | 6 Pages

The Oresteia is a trilogy written by the Greek author Aeschylus that comprises of three plays; Agamemnon, the libation bearers, and the Eumenides. The central theme of this book is “justice” which in the case of Orestes has led to exile. This book was written at a time when the star of Athens was in decline. It was a time that marked the establishment of a new socio- political order, a democracy adjudicated by the rule of law. This rule of law meant the institutionalization of justice (i.e. having a justice system), where cases are heard and verdicts are being reached based on evidence.

Read More
1039 Words | 5 Pages

In the Oresteia, Aeschylus explores social patriarchy through the consistent imagery of women throughout the play. Using similar imagery Aeschylus potentially voices his disagreement with this patriarchy. The Oresteia discusses women in instances to imply the possible patriarchy of the Greeks, in the moments before Clytemnestra’s death and in the discussions of Athena the imagery of the woman is of an inferior person. However, the anger of Clytemnestra and the Eumenides themselves are in contrast to this patriarchy, as Aeschylus potentially recognizes the woman in these scenes. Divine law overrules women in many instances in The Oresteia to establish a pattern of patriarchy.

Read More
1886 Words | 8 Pages

Revenge was persuaded on Agamemnon secretly and therefore it was unjustly. In a journal by William Allan he expresses that, “If you didn’t seek revenge on someone who injured or insulted you then you was seen as unmanly and it diminished a man’s honor” (596). Agamemnon’s honor and manliness got stolen from him in the play and he deserved revenge just as much as Clytaemnestra and Aegithus did. William Allen also summarizes that revenge in Athens wasn’t just for maintenance of status but it was also relaxing because it released grief and anger. The worse part of it all is that Clytemnestra’s actions are portrayed as having grief for her daughter but was that all?

Read More
1230 Words | 5 Pages

As has been argued with the aid of many recent studies, all would agree that the final results of the contest expose a complicated current-day debate approximately the connection between poets and their audiences. By way of the cease of the play, the target audience ought to assimilate now not supreme Homer’s surprising selection however additionally its great importance within the context of this debate. Through all of it, a smooth question persists: did Aristophanes surely merely need us to suppose that Aeschylus changed into a “higher” poet than Euripides—extra beneficial to the polis in its precarious modern-day situation. These are better at supplying moral edification for his audience—and that Euripides composed socially dangerous, even immoral

Read More
679 Words | 3 Pages

The Oresteia: The Metaphorical Portrayal of Men and Women The Oresteia is a collection of three tragedies written by Aeschylus for an Athenian tragedy competition in 458 BCE. This trilogy tells the story of a family who is caught up in a whirl of death all caused by the same motivation: revenge. All the dramatic murders end up leading to a civilized justice system being created instead of having people take matters into their own hands. Throughout the plays, Aeschylus portrays women characters as evil and powerful and male characters as weak, which eventually causes their death.

Read More
276 Words | 2 Pages

Aeschylus’ The Oresteia not only ends the life of Agamemnon, Clytemnestra, and Aeghistus but also the deathly curse that afflicts the House of Atreus – the house to which these three belong. This curse, however, has many similarities from generation to generation, such as the killing of children to serve a higher purpose – for Tantalus, this was to feed the gods, while for Atreus this was to taunt Thyestes; The parallels between the three plays of the Oresteia can be examined by focusing on the nature of tragedy with respect to Agamemnon, the Libation Bearers, and the Furies. These plays, as separate dramas and as a trilogy, show repetitive tragedies that are directly connected to the characters from the plays’ titles by unifying the title

Read More
1455 Words | 6 Pages

Revenge is an emotion that has not only consumed many, it has been simplified that in all fairness one turn deserves another. Within the Iliad and its ever-present themes, the theme of revenge is against the Trojans due to Paris taking Meleanus ' wife Helen who was claimed to be the most beautiful woman in the land. Also, Achilles goes against Agamemnon who to take revenge on Achilles takes away his prize that he rightful deserved and

Read More
486 Words | 2 Pages

The Oresteia is a political trilogy touching the topics of patriarchy and sexism. Even though, Agamemnon's death had happened years before, his essence is still evident in the hearts and minds of the people specially his children Orestes and Electra. His murder filled their minds even disregarding the fact that their father instigated the Trojan War and murdered their sister Iphigenia. Women in Ancient Greece were expected to be hung up on revenge and deception but to stay at home and take care of the family household.

Read More
326 Words | 2 Pages

The purpose of this essay is to argue why Orestes’ situation is tragic and how does Apollo affect it. I am going to argue that Orestes’ situation is tragic because is stuck in a cycle of violence whilst being influenced by Apollo’s power. Orestes puts his faith in Apollo declaring that “Apollo will never fail me, no, his tremendous power, his oracle charges me to see this trial through.” It is not necessarily through free will that he decides to trust Apollo but through fear of what will happen to him if he chooses not to. This fear comes from the way the gods continue the cycle of violence on his household because of Zeus’ son Tantalus who was thrown out of Mount Olympus for feeding his children to the gods.

Read More
1126 Words | 5 Pages

Euripides, the writer of Medea and one of the most famous playwrights in ancient Greece, can be considered centuries ahead of many people in his time. His new ideas presented in many of his works were very controversial, and, as a result, unappreciated. However, most of his ideas such as equality for women’s rights and more rights for slaves correspond to our modern-day norms. In one of Euripides 's most renowned plays, Medea, the female protagonist possess characteristics that are generally found in male characters such as power, intelligence, and cunningness. The lower class characters such as the slaves and servants, who culturally are considered to be unimportant, are presented as being intelligent and also play a significant role in the drama.

Read More
478 Words | 2 Pages

Every story that incites emotion from the reader also sparks opinions on how he or she would react in the same situation. This instigation causes the reader to sympathize or criticize the characters. A Greek play, Medea, compels the reader to do both as the main character, Medea, reveals how her grief and vengeance result in her actions seeming understandable and extreme simultaneously – making it difficult to decide whether she is morally right or wrong. The confliction within Medea’s development in the story and the challenging task of judging her actions highlight how strong emotions can make – even definite – morals appear circumstantial, and thus, cause anyone to be engrossed over satisfying their own emotional needs, while sacrificing the lives of others. After Medea’s husband, Jason, betrayed her, desiring justice for his sin is a predictable action because the natural inclination to punish those who violate what is precious, for example, the sanctity of marriage, connects all of humanity – no matter the culture or time period.

Read More
1191 Words | 5 Pages

This violent depiction is the beginning of the revenge cycle the play portrays. The aforementioned event is an act of systemic violence: it is legally permitted by Rome, but the in the aftermath is catastrophic for Tamora and her family. The potential for aggression is intrinsic to Roman law, and a customary penance in the juridical capacity is by all accounts an appropriate reaction; no disagreements are taken note of. However, the caliber of legally-sanctioned violence becomes problematic when Titus executes one of his own sons for defiance.

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

…justice is done upon him… he has paid… with death.” (Aeschylus 47). This shows the magnitude of anguish inflicted by Agamemnon’s betrayals and how that motivated

Read More
1216 Words | 5 Pages

The actions of the play Orestes by Euripides occurred in Argos where the last two plays have been set as well. The play starts off a few of days after Orestes had killed his mother Clytemnestra and her lover Aegisthus with the help of his sister Elektra. Elektra starts off with another one of her long monologs explaining the situation that she and her brother are in along with the fact that their uncle Menelaus has come back with his wife, Helen, who is the cause of all the strife that her family has been going through. The reader then learns that Orestes and Elektra are awaiting whether or not they will be stoned for their actions against their mother and her lover. She goes on to explain that she hopes that Menelaus can help them because

Read More

More about Justice In The Oresteia

Related Topics

Open Document