ipl-logo

Lord Of The Flies Girls Vs Boys Research Paper

717 Words3 Pages

Would it be different? In the book Lord of the Flies it was based on a group of 11- 12 year old boys that resorted to being savage and their natural savage instincts. But was it because of their environment or was it because they were just boys? Let's imagine it was a group of girls and how different it would be. Would the girls resort to their natural savage instincts like the boys? I think that if the group of kids were all girls instead of boys, it would be a lot different and would have a more civil ending. A study of relationships between genders and leadership roles shows amazing insight into society expectations. While the original story shows a group of boys turning into violence, imagining an all-girl group offers different outcomes. …show more content…

Girls might not be as violent as boys in the story, showing us that people's actions can be influenced by their gender and the world around them. By thinking about these differences, we can learn more about how boys and girls are expected to behave, both in stories and in real life. While the boys at first did try making rules and tried being as civil as they were raised to, a lot changed. They started seeing everything, them being stuck on an island, as a temporary thing and started agreeing with Jack about how they should have fun on the island since there were no adults thus meaning no rules. If they were all girls, they would stay civil and stick with the rules that they collectively made, they would not assent to the things that the boys did. While they might mess around a bit, studies have shown that girls mature earlier than boys do so they would most likely still prioritize making a fire signal, making shelters, and finding food unlike the boys. Later on in the book we were shown how violent they all became and how they essentially became fascinated with killing and hunting, all in all just being violent, chaotic, and acting …show more content…

Yes, it might come to the point where they commit such an act, but they wouldn't be obsessed with it like the boys were. Adding on to that, in the book they managed to kill two people, which is such a violent act to commit. Yes, one of the killings was done as a group with them using an incantation of sorts repeating the phrase, “Kill the beast! Spill the blood of the squid! Cut its throat. ” While the other was done by one person in particular, the other boys still had something to do with it because they watched and let it happen. There is a very low 10-20% chance that a girl will do a violent act like this. Would Lord of the Flies have turned out differently if it had been about girls rather than boys? This question requires us to consider how gender, society, and the environment influence our behavior. The original story reveals boys becoming violent, but putting girls in the same position might result in different results. Based on what we know about girls' behavior, they care more about and value collaboration and following

Show More
Related
673 Words | 3 Pages

If the boys do not stick together they will soon fall into the hands of evil and begin to become savage. The boys need each other and rules to help them ever overcome anything as strong as evil. They need to keep order within them to be able for everything to go as best as it can on the island. If the boys fall apart and do not control themselves or the others everything will soon and easily be destroyed. Order will not be in existence if the boys are all fighting on a little island,

Read More
985 Words | 4 Pages

At the end of William Golding’s Lord of the Flies, the children whose actions were chronicled in the book committed atrocities like murder and torture. Regular children somehow did things worse than anything that they ever could have imagined back at home. This begs the question of what prompted what once were normal children to snap: the circumstances or something that was inside of them all along. The answer in my mind isn’t as simple as one or the other. A winning combination of both spurred average boys into becoming killers, because without something dark being triggered in some of the boys, no one would have even thought about the horrible things that ended up happening.

Read More
639 Words | 3 Pages

When it comes to the novel, Lord of the Flies, some of us will readily agree that the boys’ immoral and savage acts exposed at the end of the novel, demonstrates the evil that lives naturally within humankind. Where this agreement usually ends, however, is on the question of was the cause for the boys’ immoral and savage conducts a biological or an environmental factor. Whereas some are convinced that biological factors are to blame, others maintain that the situation or the environment is to blame for their behavior. In my own view, both factors are to blame for the boys’ immoral and savage behavior, but the environment the boys’ where force to live had the most impact on their actions. Being deserted on an unknown island can cause any individual to experience a variety of emotions all at once; from fear, to anger, and then excitement.

Read More
469 Words | 2 Pages

How would Lord of the Flies be different if girls took part in the storyline? Lord of the Flies is a book about school boys that crashed on an island, and are now stuck. The boys are ruthless and have interesting “manners”. The girls would be more polite, try to less dirty, but be more moody. There is more stuff to say about these girls and their actions.

Read More
841 Words | 4 Pages

In William Golding’s Lord of the Flies, a group of stranded boys survive on an island with no adults, soon their sense of morality falls apart and violence takes place. The loss of morality causes the boys to break the rules and become violent. Eventually, the boys become uncivilized and stop caring about their actions. They get to a point where they disregard logical thought and resort to violence without reason. As the story progresses, the absence of morality causes violence to reign among the boys.

Read More
267 Words | 2 Pages

If the boys are replaced by girls it would have been a different story. Girls are known to be more mature especially in a society where they are supposed to present themselves well. Once all the girls had gathered they would mainly focus on getting saved because they know that they won’t be able to last on the island too long

Read More
885 Words | 4 Pages

They become more savage and even murder some of their fellow schoolmates. There was no physical “beast” that killed anyone, only the war which justified the violent and cruel actions. The boys use war as an excuse to torture and murder; it is the true “beast” in the

Read More
291 Words | 2 Pages

‘‘The Behavior of The Boys’’ In the novel The Lord of The Flies, I think the boys’ savage and immoral behavior should be blamed on biology. The biology of our brain when younger is so complex. This reason is that when we are growing up our brains are growing too.

Read More
632 Words | 3 Pages

Golding uses their behavior to show that mankind is inherently evil and that there's no hope for humanity. The novel talks about Inherent evil of humans and its shown in murder and beatings, but after reading the book a question is brought up; what if it were girls on the island not guys, what would happen. Well Dr. Stephanie van

Read More
979 Words | 4 Pages

Racism, Sexism, and Savagery-- Lord of the Flies? In the midst of a raging unspecified nuclear war, it would be tough to survive with a group of boys ranging from the ages of 6-12 attempt to govern themselves on an uninhabited island after their plane crashes. This is the set-up for disaster that author William Golding lays out for his fiction novel, Lord of the Flies. Minus a few choirboys, the boys seem to have never been in contact with each other before; with parents and responsibilities out of sight and out of mind, at first they enjoy their time on the island with no rules.

Read More
833 Words | 4 Pages

I believe the author wanted to show us that men are not perfect to begin with and even at a young age (like the characters in the novel) the boys struggle with responsibility, maturity, and respect. So, would the story be different if the characters were all female? In this essay I will compare differences on boy and girl characters in the novel and I will replace a character from Lord of the Flies with a female counterpart. Giving details on how she looks, acts, what motivates her to do the things she does, and how would life on the

Read More
1228 Words | 5 Pages

The boys no longer had adults in their lives, and because of this void, they had to become responsible. They attempted to create rules, shelters, and a way off the island. They attempted to provide for one another, and eventually began to act a little like adults. “…The ground was hardened by an accustomed tread and as Jack rose to his full height he heard something moving on it.

Read More
398 Words | 2 Pages

In the book Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the change of adolescence is portrayed in a number of different situations. Their ignorance of what was going on around them made these situations worse, but any other child would do the same things. These children were absolutely clueless about what to do without the help of the adults that they were normally dependent on. Not only did they react to conflicts differently than a more mature person would and did the wrong actions to gain respect and authority, but throughout the book they progressively turned more violent. First, they didn't know what to do without their parent/guardians guidance and order.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

Shakespearean Sonnets William Shakespeare is one of the world’s most famous playwrights. Historians aren’t sure exactly when he was born, but most agree that it was probably April 23, 1564 (Andrews v). He not only was successful writing plays, but also with writing poetry. From 1592 to 1595, the theater Shakespeare presented his plays in had closed, which left him with no means of income (Rowse 198). To compensate, Shakespeare wrote sonnets instead.

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

Lord of the Flies is a story where its representation of childhood and adolescence shape the meaning of the work as a whole. The boys struggle with giving into their evil instincts. Most of them give in. Golding uses this novel to show that children are not naturally good. They are evil and without the constraints of society that savagery shines through.

Read More

More about Lord Of The Flies Girls Vs Boys Research Paper

Open Document