ipl-logo

Malcom Alexander Case Summary

1479 Words6 Pages

This is the story of Malcom Alexander, a 20 year old who, at the time, was found to be the culprit of an aggravated rape although he was a completely innocent man. Alexander served 38 years in prison based on unreliable and coercive police tactics that included multiple rounds of faulty eyewitness identification procedures and a lawyer who was later disbarred for complaints of neglect and abandonment by multiple clients. Ethically speaking, the police were faced with a dilemma: Although police are constantly looking to close the case as quickly as possible with the right suspect, should they close it on someone they aren’t 100% sure committed the crime with the evidence they have, or should they continue their search efforts until they are …show more content…

Then, I would identify the concepts and values within Alexander’s case. The value of justice is important in this case, not only because police are obligated to bring the right person to justice, but also because it would be morally wrong for someone innocent to serve the time of a guilty individual. The value of lawfulness is at hand, because all the proper rules and regulations must be kept in place to ensure that police are being fair and upholding “innocence until proven guilty” for each suspect. Furthermore, the value of freedom is important because if convicted of a crime one didn’t commit, time would have to be served, and that is freedom taken away from the individual. A number of dilemmas are at play in Malcom Alexander’s case, from whether or not police should have incorporated Alexander as part of their case to whether or not police should have conducted multiple identification procedures with the witness. The most immediate dilemma, however, is in regards to the police’s actions in closing the case: Should the police close the case on someone they aren’t 100% certain is the guilty party with the evidence they have, or should the police continue their search efforts to become sure of who the culprit …show more content…

I think that Ethical Formalism is the best analytical framework to apply in this scenario because it is suggested that what is right in one scenario will always be right and that what is wrong in one scenario will always be wrong in every scenario. Similarly to the law, everyone is to be treated equally and fairly, being given the exact same treatment regardless of race, ethnicity, cultural background or any other difference we may have. Ethical Formalism also consists of the concept of A.N.A., which teaches that we ought to act in a way we wish to see others act, not use people, and always allow the autonomy of others. Instead of using coercive tactics through witness identification, a direct violation of allowing autonomy, I would try to branch out more from just the victim’s identification. Rather than assuming she was the only witness to the crime, I would look to any potential security cameras in the area as well as canvass the area to find anyone who might have been in the area at the time who may know anything about what

Show More
Related
892 Words | 4 Pages

During the year 1993, Maurice Turner, a police officer in Cobb County, Georgia, listed Julia Lynn Womack as the inheritor on his life insurance policies and retirement account. The two got married three months later and not even six months later, she started an affair with Randy Thompson. Supposdly she led him to believe that she was divorced. In March of 1995, Mr. Turner began to experience flu-like symptoms and as a result he made his way to the emergency room where he would be treated then sent home.

Read More
549 Words | 3 Pages

In the State of Texas v. Cameron Todd Willingham case, smalltown Todd Willingham was convicted and put on death row after being unjustly convicted of setting his house with arson and murder. The police’s preconceived opinions of him played its role in this case. However, when clouded judgment is involved mistakes are made. In this case, the results may have been an innocent man's life was destroyed and he ultimately died because of it. Police took his lack of injuries and the fact that he never tried to re-enter the house to save his kids as evidence in their case against him.

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

October 2nd, 2002 was the start of a long and horrific three weeks in the Washington DC Metropolitan Area. People were terrified to be in the area and everyone was on edge. What appeared to be random killings, turned out to be a well-organized series of senseless shootings that took the lives of ten innocent people. After days of people being scared to death and much confusion, investigators discovered that there were two suspects in the shootings; John Allen Muhammad and his teenage partner Lee Boyd Malvo and they were in a blue 1990 Chevrolet Caprice sedan designed to terrorize people. This break in the case came when one of the suspects called the tip hotline and told them to look into a murder in Alabama, which lead to the case being

Read More
637 Words | 3 Pages

There was a case study in Houston, Texas regarding Gary Graham. The state accused Gary of murder, and no one had sufficient evidence that he shot another person. After sustaining evidence, they started to realize that they prosecuted an innocent man. The witnesses who testified could not identify who killed the woman. The only evidence that the Law Enforcement officers had was a picture of Gary and a line up which pointed out Graham.

Read More
1125 Words | 5 Pages

In January, 2015, Adam Robinson was convicted by a jury on three charges of force sexual assault. The victim was an elementary school girl that lived in the apartment building that he worked in. The prosecutor committed several things that caused the case to overturn the conviction because of misconduct. The rulings of the case then were reversed, and a new trial was requested. The prosecutor’s misconduct in this case poorly affected Robinson’s right to a fair trial.

Read More
232 Words | 1 Pages

First, I want to examine a particularly critical review of Alexander’s text by Joseph D. Osel. According to Joseph D. Osel’s, “while Alexander’s book claims to be concerned with exposing and describing the history and mechanisms of mass incarceration of the American ‘caste system,’ which affect the poor and people of color systematically and disproportionately, her work systematically, strangely, and empathically excludes these voices” (OSEL Whitewash). Osel goes on to contend that Alexander’s work provides the history of criminal justice and imprisonment with a “vast rhetorical and historical facelift where the most relevant and affected voices on the topic at hand are safely expunged from the discussion, from relevance, from history” (OSEL

Read More
1118 Words | 5 Pages

The case highlights the problems associated with flawed eyewitness identification, prosecutorial misconduct, and inadequate legal representation. By addressing these issues through comprehensive reforms, such as improving eyewitness identification procedures, increasing accountability for prosecutors, and providing adequate resources for public defenders, we can work towards a more just and equitable system. The case of Lamar Johnson not only underscores the importance of rectifying individual wrongful convictions but also emphasizes the broader implications for our society and the urgent need for criminal justice

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

As with any criminal case, there are always a number of issues pertaining the stages of the crime and also the media and the general public’s opinion of the case. Many of the issues and explicit actions of certain individuals that had happened during the Corryn Rayney case had affected the interpretation of the case in someway for both government workers and the general public. By analysing the issues of the case, it allows a much more detailed view on the case and how most of the issues are linked in one way or another. One of the issues regarding this case was where a police officer had been found attempting to pressure forensic pathologists to alter their case reports to align with their best interests.

Read More
901 Words | 4 Pages

This essay provides the idea of justice for the charged and freedom for the innocent who are falsely convicted. Stevenson argues that the criminal and juvenile justice systems need reform

Read More
409 Words | 2 Pages

I am 21 and for as long as I can remember I have heard many stories about innocent people being accused of and being punished for crimes they did not commit. On Monday, March 20th of this year, I met Anthony Ray Hinton and learned about his story. Arrested on suspicion of two capital murders at age 29. He was convicted and sentenced to death despite having a reliable alibi and passing a polygraph test. It was only after repeated efforts by the Equal Justice Initiative (EJI) team that the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously overturned his conviction based on his attorney’s deficient representation and he was eventually exonerated after 30 years in solitary confinement on Friday, April 3rd, 2015.

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

Instead of just looking at their actions and looks, they should have a better proof or evidence ready. Anyone can commit a crime. What if the thought that person committed a crime, but later the police finds out that person did not commit a crime. Telling the person or arresting the person because of their race is mean. They can be innocent, but you are arresting them because of their race.

Read More
983 Words | 4 Pages

Alexander explains how discretion is granted at almost every stage of the legal system, especially regarding the discretion that prosecutors have, jury selection and policing. Also, many of those arrested either get no legal representation or are given public defenders who are too overworked to truly dedicate their time, and rarely go to trial due to the pressures of guilty plea bargains. To add to the misfortune, arrestees are not told how a guilty plea will negatively damage the rest of their life, due to debt, denial of public assistance, loss of voting rights, and the social label of being a felon. Innocent family members are punished sometimes too, for if they are caught housing a criminal they can face losing their home, food stamps, and welfare. Alexander makes it clear that convicted criminals aren’t the only ones being affected by the vicious consequences of the legal system, but that their families are

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

Every day forensic investigators use tactics just like the ones that were discussed throughout the paper. It’s more than just looking for an admission of guilt, and interrogating potential suspects until they

Read More
1298 Words | 6 Pages

It is a long held truth in society that it is always better to be the bigger person. There is something to be said for those who will not do unto others as those others have done to them. It takes a large amount of strength to overcome the thirst for justice, especially when there is no equitable justice to be had. However, whatever wrong has been done in the past, there is a future and in order to prevent history repeating, perhaps society should look at the example it is setting. Stephen Nathanson asks us to truly delve deeper into the principle of lex talionis and examine if getting what is given is the right path to take when it comes to punishing criminals.

Read More
1567 Words | 7 Pages

For the Application of the Criminal Justice System project of the Criminal Justice course, I chose the arrest of John Burke. This case is about the arrest and sentencing of John Burke who had shot and killed Joseph Ronan. Twenty-five year old John Burke agreed to meet with 22 year old Joseph Ronan at Ronans home, in Reading, Massachusetts on Monday, August 15, 2011 around 1pm, with the intent of purchasing Percocet pills. (Boston.com, 2013) However, shortly after entering Ronans home, Burke opened fire (News, 2011), and after shooting Joseph Ronan several times, with the belief that Ronan was involved in a robbery at Burkes apartment in April 2011 (Boston.com, 2013), fled the home.

Read More

More about Malcom Alexander Case Summary

Open Document