ipl-logo

The Gift Marcel Mauss Analysis

1528 Words7 Pages

Why do we give each other Gifts? Sociologist Marcel Mauss wrote “The Gift” in 1925 to analyze this question. He argued that the ritual of gift giving fulfills several key social obligations. Mauss believed that gift giving is an organising principle of social cohesion and act as social glue. For him gift giving is usually used to establish or strengthen an alliance or to achieve reconciliation. It is therefore a moral transaction connected to the individual or group relationships rather than an economic one. Mauss looked in detail at the structure of gift giving, outlining three inherent obligations. Firstly Mauss outlined the obligation to give gifts. He argued that we are obliged to give gifts in order to demonstrate our generosity and appear …show more content…

The anthropologist Raymond Firth, an expert on indigenous New Zealand culture, however, questioned the originality of the analysis and disputed Mauss’s interpretation of Maori customs and concepts. After the author’s death and the book’s publication in English in 1954, The Gift was criticized by a generation of anthropologists who were wary of the search for general laws, the progressive logic of evolutionism, and the method of comparative analysis. They argued that Mauss overemphasized similarities in institutions across cultures and ignored or downplayed differences, possibly as a result of his lack of fieldwork experience. More, they criticized Mauss for disapproving of the English anthropologist J. G. Frazer for presuming the universality of totemism (the practice of infusing a neutral object with sacredness as the symbol for a group of people) without evidence, while extending terms such as potlatch and mana (a spiritual force potentially attached to objects) to the institutions of societies where parallel, local concepts were lacking. Potlatch was a ceremonial feast practiced by Native American populations in Northwest North America that includes gifts to the guests; it was a means for the competitive display of wealth and prestige that even included the destruction of objects.Even though Mauss discussed self-aggrandizement and the desire to belittle rivals, critics argued that he underplayed negative elements because they complicated the larger message that reciprocity is necessary for social cohesion. Walter Goldschmidt noted that his own studies of societies in Mauss’s middle-range category revealed very clearly the greed, unscrupulousness, and “cold reasoning” involved in reciprocal exchange relationships. Finally, the knowledge that the institutions of simple societies are not just precursors to those of complex societies

Show More
Related
901 Words | 4 Pages

It's a gift" (Golding,1962). The boys do this when they hunt down a pig and put its head in a stick. They believe that by giving an offering it will not try to kill them. The same actions were done in the Lewis and Clark expedition when they offered the Indians clothing, pipe tomahawks, beads, jewelry, flannel, and many different types of knives (UV, 2007). In return for all the gifts, the Indians offered the Americans food, medication, and shelter from the harsh

Read More
743 Words | 3 Pages

In the article ‘Body Ritual Among the Nacirema’ written by Horace Miner he goes on to describe the culture and rituals of the Nacirema. A group of North Americans that are found “between the Canadian Cree, the Yaqui and Tarahumare of Mexico, and the Carib and Arawak of the Antilles.” Throughout the article he describes American rituals from an outsiders point

Read More
769 Words | 4 Pages

A person’s culture is their way of life. From a young age, we learn to act within the norms of our culture and to be truly ethnocentric. What if one day someone came into your life and told you everything you were doing your entire life was wrong and stupid? Brian Moore’s Black Robe, tells the story of Laforgue, a Jesuit priest from 17th Century Québec who travels to an unfamiliar land called New France. Laforgue’s goal is to convert Algonquin Native Americans into God fearing Christians. Laforgue faces many cultural misunderstandings with the Natives along his journey; he finds the most difficulties understanding the native’s concept of death, why they value dreams, and overcoming ethnocentrism.

Read More
1419 Words | 6 Pages

Horace Miner, a American Anthropologist wrote an academic essay titled “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema.” In this article Miner described some of the bizarre rituals and practices of the “Nacirema” which the reader comes to find out that he is talking about North Americans. The way Miner goes into detail about how these people live makes them seem foreign. Thus making the norm for an American lifestyle seem odd because the certain type of lingo Miner uses to make this “tribe” more exotic then the actually are. His point in doing this is to show the reader how obnoxious anthropologist can be when they are explain a different culture.

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

The Northwestern Coast tribes became a thriving society using materials, religion and art, and their way of living to their advantage. They became known as one of the richest tribes in North America, due to their vast supply of resources. The tribe’s material usage was so efficient, allowing them to advance quickly. Religion was encouraged through art, stories, and ceremonies. Every person living here was placed onto the social ladder which was very laidback, but very important to the Northwest Coast.

Read More
1013 Words | 5 Pages

Contradicting the grandmother’s ability to preserve and display her cultural heirloom, preservation was not an option considered for the museum’s totem pole in King’s short story. Rather than viewing the totem pole as a piece of art and allowing it to remain in the place it was built, the workers of the museum deem it necessary to “get a chainsaw and cut it close to the floor”. It may be that the Chinese grandmother was able to preserve a relic on her own, among her family, her own “isolated island”, King’s short story teaches how it is vital for all cultures to be respectful and understanding of others cultural practices and teaching. Although indigenous teachings may be their most well established among certain regions of Canada, the display of indigenous relics across the country is an example of its multiculturalism and its delight to display varying arts and cultures. King demonstrates how preservation of culture must be a collective effort, so that traditions do not remain exclusive to “isolated

Read More
1140 Words | 5 Pages

Native American culture is full of rich traditions and values that many, myself included, have never taken the time to understand or even consider. Some of those traditions are strange to many outsiders today, and to the European settlers who took over their land hundreds of years ago. However, other aspects of Native American culture are rather similar to modern culture. There was, and still is, an emphasis placed on community within the tribe. This included stressing the importance of the individual, but also the family and the tribe itself.

Read More
1264 Words | 6 Pages

The Role of Women in Seneca (Iroquois) Society Full Circle Anthropologic studies of culture are about observation through a lens that is defined by the observer. In order for it to be free of bias, the observer needs to remove any and all preconceived notions and their own ’world’ references while functioning ‘emically’(Kottak 2013). Part of the observer’s job is to look into the past and present, reconciling roles within that culture (Kottak 2013). Gender roles are an important area of study (Kottak 2013).

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

Although Native Americans are characterized as both civilized and uncivilized in module one readings, their lifestyles and culture are observed to be civilized more often than not. The separate and distinct duties of men and women (Sigard, 1632) reveal a society that has defined roles and expectations based on gender. There are customs related to courtship (Le Clercq, 1691) that are similar to European cultures. Marriage was a recognized union amongst Native Americans, although not necessarily viewed as a serious, lifelong commitment like the Europeans (Heckewelder, 1819). Related to gender roles in Native American culture, Sigard writes of the Huron people that “Just as the men have their special occupation and understand wherein a man’s duty consists, so also the women and girls keep their place and perform quietly their little tasks and functions of service”.

Read More
550 Words | 3 Pages

At the core of this tradition is the food, including the turkey. This celebratory turkey feast, according to Siskind, is a symbol for the conquering of Native American tribes. The turkey is noted for its both wild and domesticated likenesses, similar to the Native Americans (179). The Europeans first began eating turkey upon their arrival in North America, as the turkey was traditional only to this region. Therefore, “as a true ‘native of America’ the turkey, wild and domesticated, could easily become a symbol for those other natives” (ibid).

Read More
517 Words | 3 Pages

The most important assignment in the community. He must receive memories from the current receiver. The chief elder made the decision to make only one person bear the burden of the memories. Everyone thinks the community is perfect, a utopia, but Jonas sees all the flaws .Jonas changes throughout The Giver and as a result, tries to change the community.

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

One of the main themes in “The Giver” is the importance of individuality. The people in the community are not given any freedom to be individuals. They are not allowed to be different, and this creates less understanding of the world. This is why the community needs a receiver to understand these things for them.

Read More
459 Words | 2 Pages

“We gained control of many things. But we had to let go of others” (Lowry). In other words, this means that to get what you want, you have to get rid of other things you have. Although there are many similarities between The Giver and our society, there are a lot more differences like families, rules, and personal freedoms. For starters there are many differences with families between their society and our society.

Read More
850 Words | 4 Pages

The ability to give enhances autonomy since it requires an enhanced level of autonomy. It reinforces a feeling of competence within the environment because if one is threatened by it, it would be unlikely one would focus on giving. Relatedness is also affected by the need for positive relationships with the individuals, It is positive being able to give to others. In summary, wellbeing is enhanced by focusing on giving rather than

Read More
1306 Words | 6 Pages

“The Devil” by Guy De Maupassant The short story is about Honore, the farmer, who is forced by the doctor to hire a washerwoman, La Rapet, to look after his ninety- two years old dying mother, Bontemps, while he reaps his corn. After the washerwoman examines the old lady, she predicts to stay with her for 2-3 days till she utters her last breath. She stipulates to get six francs from the farmer for her services and after moments of hesitation and arguing about the price, he grudgingly acquiesces.

Read More

More about The Gift Marcel Mauss Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document