ipl-logo

Melanie Scheller's On The Meaning Of Plumbing And Poverty

978 Words4 Pages

In the essay On the Meaning of Plumbing and Poverty, author Melanie Scheller touches on the idea of identity in terms of the poor as well as the treatment they receive. Scheller herself grew up living with her widowed mother and six children in whatever broken-down home they could afford (Scheller 320) . She begins this essay by tying her observance of an elderly woman that goes to the bathroom and flushes the toilet routinely to her growing up without an indoor plumbing system, because during her childhood those that did not have these facilities were considered poor. Basically, if you were poor then you were worthless and would not have a future. Throughout her essay, Scheller tells her stories of having to share a small home with many people, being judged by assumptions, and being …show more content…

The way Scheller speaks to a reader is insightful, she gets in your head and makes you take on the persona of a child from this lifestyle. Then, she steps over and has you see the effects that teasing and shaming these children can do. She sets up a real life situation that you follow the journey of and step in the shoes of those struggling. It is easy to read, because you can see yourself on either side of the scenario, rather you are the bully or the victim. Scheller’s argument is logical, because these people should not feel ashamed of something they cannot change overnight. It is wrong to judge others without walking in their shoes first. She makes this argument prevalent when she says that “people whose children think they deserve the conditions in which they live and hold their heads low to hide the shame. But they’re not the ones who should feel ashamed. No, they’re not the ones who should feel ashamed”(Scheller 323). She is saying this to get those that pick on people living in poverty to see that they are the one’s hurting the people and they should not be cruel when they do not know the situations at

Show More
Related
527 Words | 3 Pages

Pathos dominates the article when Ehrenreich allows her nephews mother in law, grandchildren, and daughter to move into her house. The situation focuses on pathos because in Ehrenreich’s personal story she includes that “Peg, was, like several million other Americans, about to lose her home to foreclosure” (338). She is effective in her writing by appealing to the readers’ emotions through visual concepts and personal experiences. When I read the article, I felt emotional because the working poor are not fortunate to know if they will have a house or food the next day. I agree with Ehrenreich in which the poor are as important as the wealthy group who get more recognition.

Read More
353 Words | 2 Pages

Her oldest son doesn’t even believe that he’s poor. He tries to impress his friends with saying that he doesn’t walk with his brother because of the way he dresses he only walks with him when he dresses nice like him. I think the circumstances that she live in is hard to be part of. She lives in the middle of nowhere and the way she and her sons explain how they live is heartbreaking. When she shows the house around and we see her kitchen

Read More
1121 Words | 5 Pages

I viewed Frontline a documentary series, which episode was entitled Poor Kids. The frontline personnel spent time with three children Kailey, Johnny, and Britany along with their families as they all struggle financially. We perceive a glimpse of what it is like to live below the poverty line in America through a child’s eyes. While observing the documentary, I became consciously aware that children who are considered poor or living below the poverty line were more mindful of the responsibilities of life. The children were worrisome of the lack of employment for their parents, bills, and in Britney’s case; how they would accommodate their way of living to support a new addition to the family.

Read More
1318 Words | 6 Pages

Mantsios’ compares the profiles of different Americans lifestyles in his text and develops the idea that an individual’s class standing can affect their livelihood in detrimental ways, “The lower one’s class standing, the more difficult it is to secure appropriate housing, the more time is spent on routine tasks of everyday life, the greater is the percentage of income that goes to pay for food and other basic necessities, and the greater is the likelihood of crime victimization” (293). Mantsios explains that one’s class standing can affect the chances of survival and success. Ehrenreich describes her own housing experiences as a low income worker. To reduce her overall costs and to obtain a second job, Ehrenreich moves closer to Key West. Ehrenreich has just enough money to pay the rent and deposit on a tiny trailer at the Overseas Trailer Park.

Read More
1217 Words | 5 Pages

Instead of using prejudice or stereotypes, where negative thoughts and attitudes are created and shared, she extends it to the level of discrimination and racism. Although instead of calling it racism, she uses “eyeism”, as she is discriminating on the basis of eye color rather than skin color. She calls all white men “boy”, she interrupts them when they are talking and she talks to them like she is superior. She uses the racism, prejudice, stereotypes and discrimination black individuals have experienced for hundreds of years and turns it around on the white

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

The Most Terrible Poverty “Loneliness and the feeling of being unwanted is the most terrible poverty” (Mother Teresa). Sinclair Ross pens such poverty throughout the pages of his award-winning story, “The Painted Door.” In Ross’s story, readers see how the main character Ann is lonely and uncared-for, alienating her from society and the man she once loved. This alienation can be seen in Ann’s relationship with John, the physical distance between her and human contact, and the traditional gender roles forced upon her.

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

Criminal Homeless Imagine yourself without a job and receiving a final note from your bank stating that you only have a week to dislodge. In consequence, you become homeless as a bug of society and if you sleep in any bench or under a bridge, you will end up in jail. Many people have been suffering such cruel reality due to their poverty. Barbara Ehrenreich, a political activist and author in her essay “Is it Now a Crime Being Poor?” discusses the problems of the US correctional system about the treat of homeless people. She explains how they are sent to jails for minor crimes.

Read More
412 Words | 2 Pages

This is just like how someone like Cathy would judge Esperanza, just because she is less fortunate than

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

A suburban life is a paradise full of shopping, colorful gardens, and well-groomed homes. Despite all these benefits, a suburban life is an isolated life. People living in suburbs are rarely exposed to miseries in society. One of these conflicts is homelessness. When living in an environment surrounded by homes, individuals often have difficulty imagining not being able to sleep in a warm bed, eat a proper meal or even receive necessary medical attention.

Read More
570 Words | 3 Pages

In the article “How I Discovered the Truth about Poverty” Barbara Ehrenreich gives her view in poverty and explains why she think Michael Harington’s book “The Other American” gives a wrong view on poverty. She explained that Harrington believes that the poor thought and felt differently and what divides the poor was their different “culture of poverty.” Ehrenreich goes on to explain on how the book that became a best seller caused so many bad stereotypes on the poor that by the Reagan era poverty was seen as “bad attitudes” and “faulty lifestyles” and not by the lack of jobs or low paying jobs. And they also viewed the poor as “Dissolute, promiscuous, prone to addiction and crime, unable to “defer gratification,” or possibly even set an alarm clock.”

Read More
520 Words | 3 Pages

It is hard to imagine life as a homeless family. I hope that I’ll never have to move my family from shelter to shelter as some families must do every day. According to the essay “Homeless” by Anna Quindlen, we should take more time in our lives to see the pain that homelessness creates. I agree with Anna Quindlen’s assertion that a home is everything. A home can provide certainty.

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

The part where she says that her daughter will live like her and her sons will end up in jail sounds like she is content and accepting of her circumstances. While I do understand her plight and how it is perhaps easy to feel hopeless in situations such as these, but she seems to just accept the fact that poverty is inescapable. Let’s be clear, I am not saying that she wants to be in poverty, no one does, trust me, I’ve been there. But I truly believe that character has no need for money. Character is what will set our children up for success.

Read More
1171 Words | 5 Pages

She begins by talking about her college experience of how her own professors and fellow students believed and “always portrayed the poor as shiftless, mindless, lazy, dishonest, and unworthy” (Paragraph 5). This experience shocked her because she never grew up materialistic. She brings up the fact that she is the person with the strong and good values that she has today because she grew up in a poor family. In culture, the poor are always being stereotyped.

Read More
1170 Words | 5 Pages

The Truth About Poverty “Poverty is like punishment for a crime you didn't commit” this quote was said by Mahatma Gandhi and it relates so well with this article “It is Expensive To Be Poor”, answer the question yourself, Is it expensive to be poor? This article is titled like that to get the audience's attention early and have them thinking ahead of reading. The author Barbara Ehrenreich is building a pre thought when she does this which helps support her claim. “It is Expensive To Be Poor” by Barbara Ehrenreich is an article posted on “The atlantic” “which is where you can find your current news and analysis on politics, business, culture, and technology”. Knowing what “The Atlantic” offers for readers this gives Ehrenreich a detailed look at who she is writing to.

Read More
507 Words | 3 Pages

In the passage “What is poverty?”, the author Jo Goodwin Parker, describes a variety of things that she considers to portray the poverty in which she lives in. She seems to do this through her use of first-person point of view to deliver a view of poverty created by a focused use of rhetorical questions, metaphors, imagery, and repetition to fill her audience with a sense of empathy towards the poor. The author’s use of first person point of view creates the effect of knowing exactly what she is feeling. “The baby and I suffered on. I have to decide every day if I can bear to put my cracked hands into the cold water and strong soap.”

Read More

More about Melanie Scheller's On The Meaning Of Plumbing And Poverty

Related Topics

Open Document