ipl-logo

Middle East Conflict: Contrasting Religion And Not Land

1609 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Conflicts in middle east essay

Question: To what extent was the Middle East Conflict a war based on contrasting religion and not land?
The Middle East Conflict between Israel and Palestine, is a war based on contrasting religions of Judaism and Islam to a greater extent. The spiritual connection to the land outweighs the arguments of the need resources of the conflict caused by the division of land.
The origins of the conflict lie in Biblical times. Moses led the Hebrews out of slavery in Egypt and across the Red Sea, Moses later received the Ten Commandments (placed in The Ark of the Covenant) on Mount Sinai. Moses led the Hebrews to the “Promised Land” which became Israel. Solomon’s Temple was built as a symbol for justice and righteousness. Israel existed up until 70AD …show more content…

The desire for a homeland became evident after World War II and atrocities of the Holocaust became known to the world. The call to return home to the “Holy Land” was actively promoted by the Zionist movements in Britain and the USA (Source E). The importance of spiritual and religious connection to the “promised land”, combined the need to unite all scattered Jews in a country of their own, free from persecution. This is what guided the United Nations decision to divide Palestine in half shared by Arabs and Jews equally.(Source C)The division of Palestine had been proposed by Winston Churchill as early as 1922 (Source G) but this idea never became reality due to the opposition of Arabs of having the Jewish Nation as their neighbors. (Source E) The conflict between the two opposing religions increased to a large extent and resulted in a series of riots, opposing the division of Palestine in 1929(Source G). After the Holocaust and the immediate problem of hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees to deal with arose (Source E), the United Nations formally proposed the Partition Plan (Source C). The Jews were finally going to have their own independent homeland, situated on the very place that had historically and spiritually been deemed as their “Promised …show more content…

Moreover, the city of Jerusalem, the home of Sacred Mosque was placed under United Nation administrations and shared, equal access to both religions needed to be allowed (Source G). This provision of the Partition Plan would result in increasing conflict between the opposing religions due to the fact that Jerusalem lay in the heart of Israeli portion of land (Source C) making it more difficult for Muslim worshippers to enter the Al-Aqsa Mosque. The partition of land between Israel and Palestine resulted in the Declaration of Independence of Israel in 1948. This act of independence escalated the conflict into a full scale war when a united Arab Nation attacked Israel the day after they declared independence. The Arabs suffered a great defeat which they called “Al Naqba”- great disaster- whereas the victory for the Israelis strengthened their resolve to claim that God had promised the Jews land and their victory as an act of divine intervention. In Deuteronomy 7, the fifth book of Moses in the Holy Bible (Source F) it argues for the Jews that God indeed promised them the land as their homeland in which he would drive out all enemies. Both religions are nonetheless, fighting for the right to claim the land as their

Show More
Related
123 Words | 1 Pages

To begin with, there were disputes because Jews were donating money to Jerusalem which then this caused class tensions. Making the rich wealthier and the poor living in greater poverty. Another incident which sparked up the fire of this war was there were also social fights in the Jewish society.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

The Russians were beginning to defeat Germany, starting to take ahold of the war. Many of the Jewish people still believed that the Germans would not come to take them

Read More
515 Words | 3 Pages

Creation of Israel in 1948 Jews had to leave Israel in the first place because they were forced from their homes by the Roman Empire. When the Jews returned to Israel in 1948, Palestinians were still living there. The return of the Jews was a problem because it caused war to break out between the Arabs and Israelis. Wars between the two are still occurring today.

Read More
309 Words | 2 Pages

However, Britain’s support of the Jewish homeland was reaffirmed. Proposal was made to establish a legislative council which Palestinians rejected because the representation was unfair. When the Jewish immigration somewhat increased in 1928, British policy was hesitating under the conflicting pressures of Arabs and Jews. Immigration increased sharply after the Nazi regime in Germany persecuted Jews in 1933.

Read More
404 Words | 2 Pages

Imagine watching your beloved hometown being captured by your worst enemy. All the things that you love, being stripped of you one by one. Forced to wear a gold star just because of your religion, and being beat up and mistreated by your fellow neighbors. Sadly, this was just the beginning. As time continued on ghettos where the Jews’ new home.

Read More
225 Words | 1 Pages

In November of 1917 a resolution calling for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. This resolution caused anger amongst Arab community they believed Palestine would be a free Arab State. This declaration was made for one to influence US Jewish businessmen in supporting war. The Jewish population continued to support Russian involvement,

Read More
1153 Words | 5 Pages

Everyone’s focus was about the war and how to be at peace again. Many Jews looked towards the United States to immigrate for safety, but Roosevelt refused to take them in. A committee for the Jewish Army of Stateless and Palestinian Jews spoke out about their contribution to civilization, and the genocide they experienced to persuade Americans to save the remaining Jews. In June 1945 Roosevelt developed a rescue-through-victory strategy to save the remaining Jews (Takaki

Read More
748 Words | 3 Pages

Up to approximately seven major Crusades, the Muslims and Christians went through bloody days, and many attacks on each other. After many years of victories and misplacements, the Holy Land was claimed by the Muslims. It is perceptible that the Crusades were caused primarily by religious devotion because Jerusalem had a Holy significance, They wanted to signify their loyalty and cause of their God, and to guarantee

Read More
803 Words | 4 Pages

The Jewish Struggle in Ghettos By mid-1941, almost all Jews in occupied Poland had been forced into these overcrowded districts. This meant Jews living in Poland at that time had barely enough food, water, and clothing to survive, as so many people were put into one area to live. The reason for this was that the Nazis wanted to control the Jews and their whereabouts. The Nazis and Germans disliked the Jews, because they believed they were a source of “racial pollution.” Although people across Europe tried to help Jews escape the ghettos, they were unable to do so because the Nazis controlled most of Europe, created policies for Jews in ghettos, and living conditions were terrible for Jews.

Read More
1112 Words | 5 Pages

The Holocaust was a horrific part of Jewish history. With time the Jewish population was able to recover from this devastating event through the creation of Israel. Israel was established with the intention of being able to perform self defense against further attacks. The study of the Holocaust and the study of the state of Israel are directly related because the Holocaust led to the development of present day Israel, Israel is a symbol of the growth of the Jewish people since the Holocaust, Israel is a strong and successful nation only because of the development of its people that took place during the events of the Holocaust. Israel's development into its present state was inspired by the Jews that endured the Holocaust and didn't

Read More
1239 Words | 5 Pages

Jews lost their citizenship, rights, and privileges. They were forbidden to marry or have sexual relationships with non-Jewish Germans and job opportunities became limited to them. These laws forcefully excluded Jews from many aspects of German society and made it easier for the Nazis to group them to deport them to ghettos, extermination camps, and concentration camps during the Holocaust. Nazis separating Jewish families caused chaos and confusion in the country of Europe. During the time of Adolf Hitler, millions of Jews were persecuted and many tried to flee Germany to ally countries but many were not able to make it out of Germany (Anne Frank, 1957).

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

It was after that war when America gained the power that it possesses nowadays. The main Jewish leaders knew what was going on with the people from Europe. Nazis were collecting Jews like if they were cattle. The American Jewish authorities were requesting the United States Military to destroy one of the most relevant concentration camps, Auschwitz. A concentration camp was some type of slaughterhouse.

Read More
861 Words | 4 Pages

Firstly, many of the Jewish people were separated from each other both mentally and physically regardless of their feelings about the separation. An example of this was when the people were loaded into the cattle cars, eighty in each.

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

The causes and effects of the war are mainly political, socio-economic and religious. The main cause and spark of the Lebanese conflict was driven by political issues and complications within the government as well as the bordering countries’ complications. The Arab-Israeli conflict during 1970 to 1973 played a huge role in sparking the Lebanese conflict because the Israelis took control over the land which caused a huge influx of refugees to the surrounding countries, including Lebanon. Lebanon was home to more than 100,000 of the Muslim refugees and is still refuge to many to this day.

Read More
1316 Words | 6 Pages

Ben Gurion states the essential problem in Israel/Palestine: “we and they want the same thing: We both want Palestine. And that is the fundamental conflict.” (Shlaim, 2001, p. 18) For both Israelis and Palestinians it is nationalist conflict, there is a clear reason in the action of both parties, a territorially secure state. Yet, both Israel and Hamas seem to accept that negotiation is the eventual end through which to meet their nationalist ends (Hroub, 2006; Shlaim, 2001).

Read More

More about Middle East Conflict: Contrasting Religion And Not Land

Related Topics

Open Document