ipl-logo

Miguel Leo Portilla The Broken Spears Summary

1410 Words6 Pages

The Broken Spears, book written by Miguel Leon-Portilla, honorable Mexican anthropologist and historian that studied in the National Autonomous University of Mexico in 1956. The book The Broken Spears or Vision de Los Vencidos (original Spanish book name) has been translated to six different languages; English, German, French, Polish, Catalan, and Otomi. The book was originally published in Spanish in 1959, and presented the Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire from the point of view of the natives. Mr. Miguel Leon Portilla, with the help of Angel Maria Garibay K. (in the version of the texts), and Alberto Beltran (in illustrations), known to us in his book " The Vision of the Defeated " a little better about the conquest of the whole area of Mexico between the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, long after the arrival of Hernan Cortés and his men to the territories of Mexico - Tenochtitlan. In his introduction Mr. Leon Portilla mentioned briefly what was added to the new edition (twenty-eighth edition to be exact), its new chapter entitled “What …show more content…

This chapter tells us the reaction of Motecuhzoma, if receive in peace or war. After discussing with his brother and his son he decided to receive them peacefully. The next chapter tells how the Spaniards and their allies come to the city of Mexico-Tenochtitlan by the course of Iztapalapa, as major local people come to meet and dialogue between Moctezuma and Cortes, with the help in translating the Malintzin. Further comments, the attitude taken by both the Spaniards and indigenous lords. At the end of chapter tells how the Spaniards, after being installed, interrogating Motecuhzoma about gold stocks and how to seize

Show More
Related

Bernal Del Castillo Research Paper

1593 Words | 7 Pages

A faithful edition of Diaz' Guatemala manuscript became available only at the turn of the 20th century, when Mexican historian Genaro García published it in two volumes appearing a year apart, in 1904 and 1905. In 1908, the Hakluyt Society published The Discovery and the Conquest of Mexico 1517-1521, Alfred P. Maudslay’s English translation of the major part of the Genaro García

Read More

Summary Of Violence Over The Land By Rand Blackhawk

940 Words | 4 Pages

As the book continues and the rise and fall of the Spanish nation happened the Americans come into the equation and this is generally where the “Violence over the Land” starts to take place. The first major sign of Violence in this land was one of the largest and most powerful alliances between the Utes and Comanches. Eventually this violence was a part of their society and it states in the text that the Comanches “always traveled in militarized bands, constantly prepared to defend themselves as well as to attack weaker neighbors.” Violence with these groups was eventually a part of who they are not only representing social status but honor. Over the years as time progress the spanish empire eventually fall and then the American Explores came

Read More

Florentin Paragrax And The Hopi Summary

953 Words | 4 Pages

He justifies his submission to the Spanish on the evil omens that foretold the arrival of the Spanish conquest of the Aztec empire. The Spanish plundered the Aztec nation and easily assume they have privilege and superiority over Montezuma’s

Read More

Why The Diaz Account Is Sugar Coated And Biased?

1660 Words | 7 Pages

Why the Diaz account is sugar coated and biased Throughout history, many events that have occurred had either been inevitable or contingent. Contingency is an important concept to allow historians to understand and investigate why these events occur. A major issue that occurs with this, is bias and sugar coating the truth. In historical context, many of the conquered are not given as much as representation as the victor, as proven with the Broken Spears account which is the point of view of the Aztecs. Between the two accounts that are being analyzed, the conquest of “New Spain” (Mexico) which is the Diaz account had been sugar coated, biased and unreliable, in the point of view of the Spaniards.

Read More

How Did Montezuma Contribute To The Downfall Of The Aztecs?

1778 Words | 8 Pages

(Portilla, 160) Montezuma II, also known as Motecuhzoma Xocoyotizin in the Nahuatl Language, lived 1466-1520 CE (Cottril). He was the 9th and final leader of the Aztecs. He met the famous conquistador of Spain, Hernando Cortes. Montezuma II was a very dynamic, militaristic, and theological leader of the Aztecs, his legacy led to the downfall of the Aztecs, as a reminder for developing civilizations. Montezuma II was a very militaristic leader, whom was feared by his enemies.

Read More

Broken Spears: Summary

123 Words | 1 Pages

Conclusively, Broken Spears is an eloquent testimony that Miguel León-Portilla, so passionately dedicated hard-work and effort to have this book be published. For he is determined to have the Nahuatl passages publicized and have their voices heard, which is something that Gustavo Verdesio would have wanted. As Verdesio argued that passages that have been written by marginalized people are disregard by many historians and authors, and so when a book like Broken Spears is published, it helps bring awareness the argument that Verdesio has been claiming. Proving, that although it may be hard to give into account the stories of those who are marginalized, it is possible to bring those historical anecdotes to light, paving a path for future historical

Read More

Compare And Contrast Pizarro And Cornes Fight The Aztecs

243 Words | 1 Pages

As Moctezuma welcomed Cortés to his capital, they remained to stay in the city and saw more of the Aztec treasure. They decided to imprison Moctezuma so they could gain control of the Aztecs and their riches. Cortés and his Indians allies captured and demolished Tenochtitlán. Cortés success inspired Pizarro. Pizarro

Read More

Aztecs Dbq

930 Words | 4 Pages

Document C poses a map in which shows the spread of the Aztecs and demonstrate how their conquests allowed them to gain more control of land. Also, it states that how the “Aztec warriors had the reputation of being fierce fighters, and most territories shown on the map were acquired by force.” Document C mainly shows their military power of the Aztecs. Similarly, on document I, it represents how there were thousands of prisoners are killed as a sacrifice. The thousands of prisoners described how their military was advanced in which they were so powerful and highly that they were able to capture many prisoners.

Read More

How Effective Was The Spanish Conquest Of The Maya Indians?

467 Words | 2 Pages

The Spanish conquest on the Mayans was a significant event during the 1500’s. The Spanish conquest brought their military equipment’s that was no match for the Mayan Indians. As the conquest continued to expand throughout Central America there was little unity among other tribes beside the Mayan empire. The reason for this is because they believe that the Spanish were much inferior to their own beliefs and ancestry.

Read More

Aztlan Colonial New Mexico Analysis

504 Words | 3 Pages

Menchaca speaks about how unfairly the and about Onate his journey and how his colony was racially mixed. Also how when he passed through villages he greeted the Indian and told them that they have become vassals. She also goes over the colonist’s rebel and the growth of the Spanish colonies. ” Race and Honor in Colonial New Mexico” is

Read More

Cortez And Mctezuma

307 Words | 2 Pages

When Moctezuma met Cortez he believed that Cortes was a god in which he had immediately treated him with praise and respect or so it assumed to be. Initially, Moctezuma had sent lots of gifts, especially gold. As getting more gold was the main important thing on his mind, he had marched the capital of the Aztecs. Oddly enough, when he had arrived Moctezuma had greeted him, but Cortez took him prisoner. There had been quite confusing though, did Cortez let this get to his head?

Read More

The Broken Spears Summary

573 Words | 3 Pages

The Broken Spears, by Miguel Leon-Portilla, is an all-inclusive and compelling account of the Spanish conquest, told by the Aztecs also known as the conquered. Leon Portilla’s choice of events depicted in this book collides together giving the reader a broad view of the Spanish conquest. This book gives a history of emotional and spiritual human experiences, allowing the readers to comprehend, and relate to the Aztecs as they went through terror and faced their fears. This book provides an extensive amount of details concerning lack of leadership, bias and technological hardship that led to the Aztec defeat. After reading this book the reader will start to understand how and why the Aztecs suffered .

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Interaction Between The Spaniards And The Native American Civilizations

490 Words | 2 Pages

At first encounter between the spaniards and the Native American population, the colonizers had embodied their new “discovery” as heroic and selfless. Though the interaction between the Aztecs and the Incas and the European settlers bared some systemic disadvantages and resulted in things like mercantilism and mass genocide, as well as the vast spread of disease, the actual development of the New World had benefited greatly to the countries around them. People had interpreted the situation through use of the factors: what their religion was, what aspirations they wished to obtain in the new world and the part of Europe that they confided in. The development of the New World and gradual extinguishment of the original Native American Population had resulted in advantages for everyone around them.

Read More

Fall Of The Aztec Empire Essay

1135 Words | 5 Pages

The Spanish retreated from Tenochtitlan, by fighting their way out, away from the angry mobs. The Spaniards took shelter with the Tlaxacan where they devised a plan to finally to conquer the Aztecs once and for all. The Spaniards, Tlaxacan, and other allied tribes all returned to Tenochtitlan with reinforcements and a siege. After eighty days of bloody battles Cuauhtémoc surrendered to the Spaniards, and that was the end of the Aztec

Read More

Hernan Cortes Hero

975 Words | 4 Pages

Using war equipment that the Aztec had never seen before and different battle techniques, Cortes and his men were able to quickly and effectively conquer Tenochtitlan. During battle against the Aztecs, animals from Spain that served in many battles called horses (about twelve), as well as swords and crossbows (a much more advanced version of the Aztec war club and spear-thrower) were labelled as advanced technology as they were quicker, deadlier, and consequently more efficient. These many advantages against the Aztecs and their traditional weapons; and therefore the Spaniards won many battles alongside their allies, and succeeded greatly by using guns that were far more powerful than the Aztecs' weapons. Unfair as it is, this gave the Spanish explorer a supremacy in conquering one of the most elaborate European cities at the time. “The Aztecs were unable to rebel against the Spaniards because most of them were sick or dead from smallpox.

Read More

More about Miguel Leo Portilla The Broken Spears Summary

Related Topics

Open Document