ipl-logo

Mlk Vs Malcolm X Comparison Essay

2324 Words10 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Contrast martin luther king and malcolm x leadership styles

When Worlds Collide: A Comparison between Martin Luther King and Malcolm X’s approaches to the Civil Rights Movement influenced by their childhood years, religious beliefs, and starts as leaders in Civil Rights.

Introduction
Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were two distinguished figures in the Civil Rights Movement in the United States. Despite having devoted their lives to producing prolific advances to the political climate of the Civil Rights Movement, King and Malcolm X had distinct opposing views. King heavily believed in desegregation and integration through the means of non-violence whereas Malcolm X had a more radical perspective, pushing for separation by any means necessary, including violence. The polarising approaches of King …show more content…

Martin Luther King Jr. lived a comfortable childhood in Atlanta Georgia, born on the verge of the Great Depression. As a young boy, he made observations about the differences in socioeconomic states. For instance, at the age of five, King questioned why dozens of people stood in bread lines while his middle-class family strolled past the impoverished (King, 35). King had described himself as having “always been the questioning and precocious type.”, his young curiosity of racial issues had been fostered by dinner table discussions with his family (King, 39). King grew up in a household that strongly upheld religious ideals, his father was a prominent theologian in the National Baptist Church, a prominent African American Church, making Christianity and the African American Community an anchor throughout his familial and personal life (Howard-Pitney, …show more content…

Throughout his career, Martin Luther King Jr. had an unwavering dedication to achieving his goal of an integrated society through non-violent means. His ultimate goal was to achieve a “beloved community” which he believed a truly just society was one that loved all members of the human race (Howard-Pitney, 57). With legal segregation and black suffrage being largely secured by mid-1965, King shifted his focus towards aiding the impoverished as he believed that addressing this issue was interconnected with the need to achieve full equality for African Americans. In this same year, the United States decided to enter the Vietnam war, gaining harsh criticism from King on the government’s capitalism and foreign policies. His growing radicalism caused a downfall in his support from the U.S government and the whites as in his 1967 address at New York City’s Riverside Church where he labelled the government as “the greatest purveyor of violence”(King,

Show More
Related
1450 Words | 6 Pages

Notoriously, Martin Luther King Jr. has been the name of the civil rights movement, the one we all look up to in terms of the end of segregation. But, this respectable man was not the only one to take action in the name of equality, as another infamous speaker, Malcolm X, also drove the civil rights movement in a way of ferociousness and rage. This man, the head of the Black Nationalist movement, gave phenomenal speeches that indirectly propelled the civil rights movement, including Prospects For Freedom, By Any Means Necessary, and Message to the Grassroots. Malcolm X was a man who was an illustrious black nationalist, and was the speaker for the Nation of Islam. He often preached controversial things that regularly contrasted him with Dr.

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

Both Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Jr were civil right leaders who were well respected for their ideas. However, they had differences that would impact the success of their initiatives. Malcolm X had superior solutions for a strong centralized black community and a stable black economy, while King’s ideas made more sense in terms of his nonviolent philosophy and push for an integrated education system. Whiles Martin Luther King, Jr’s idea about blacks and whites together would work in a perfect society,America was far from a perfect society in the 1960s.

Read More
2517 Words | 11 Pages

Julia Schulz O’Brien Honors U.S. History II May 10, 2024 Title (undecided so far) In our current society, the stories of Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X are perceived to be very different from one another. Martin Luther King is often remembered as a forgiving saint, while Malcolm X is villainized as a crazed, bloodthirsty white-hater. This difference reflects the oversimplification of history and the disregard for how the two civil rights leaders evolved throughout their campaigns.

Read More
1047 Words | 5 Pages

In Document 2, Mr. King envisions a nation where individuals are judged not by their skin color but by their character, advocating for unity and brotherhood across racial division. This American dream-esque vision, symbolizes King's commitment to nonviolence as a means to achieve social equality for his community. Moreover, Document 3, narrated by Malcolm X, called for a collaboration between white and black individuals. He emphasizes the importance of working within each other’s respective communities to promote peace, demonstrating a sentimental understanding of achieving social equality without always having to be aggressive to supposedly “opposed’ races. Together, these documents illustrate the transformative power of King’s nonviolent strategy along with sincere collaborations from Malcolm X’s ideologies.

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

This book brings together some of the best primary sources on Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X that relate to what I’ve learned in history class. Through their writings and speeches, I appreciate the roles they played in the freedom crusade of the 1950s and 1960s. It is a good summary of its essential teachings that give me insight into their individual styles and personalities. The book is not one that tries to force ideas or a religion on the reader but instead offers new insight on two of these most important civil rights leaders of the century. It is a valuable effort that helps me both within and beyond the classroom, which focuses on the crucial years in the lives of quintessentially human

Read More
694 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout the 1960s and 70s, the partakers of the Civil Rights Movement changed their views on how to achieve equality, although they faced multiple challenges, but throughout these difficulties I believed that Malcolm

Read More
563 Words | 3 Pages

MLK and Malcolm X both wanted equality but in different ways. Martin Luther King believed in nonviolence to end segregation. However, Malcolm X believed in segregation; where African Americans would govern themselves without bothering the whites. But which idea was better for society? Malcolm X’s philosophy offers a variety of solutions for

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

Martin Luther King Junior and Malcolm X were two leaders of their time that were committed to the struggle for civil rights and equality for black people. Despite their fight for the same struggle, they had different ideas about the best way to achieve these goals. Martin Luther King Junior believed that nonviolent protest methods were crucial in the pursuit of equality for all people in order to build a beloved community. King offers the best solution to the needs and problems of the black community over Malcolm X. Malcolm X advocated for violent protest methods whereas King’s means of non-violent resistance was the more effective way to bring about change all while promoting love and reconciliation against forces of evil. Martin Luther

Read More
1974 Words | 8 Pages

Martin Luther King and Malcolm X were two influential men who served as important figures for the Civil Rights Movement. The two men came from diverse backgrounds and had contrasting views in life about religion and African American’s stance in society. Malcolm X was born in Nebraska and had great amounts of exposure to racism. Martin Luther King was born in an educated family in Atlanta, where he experienced racism, but to a lower extreme than Malcolm X. Although they passed away long time ago, they continue to live on today in a world independent of segregation. Martin Luther King and Malcolm X used opposing principles to achieve equality for blacks; King utilized integration of both races and nonviolence as opposed to Malcolm X who separated the same races and employed non violence so as to achieve the same goal.

Read More
1125 Words | 5 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr said,“We must learn to live together as brothers or perish together as fools”. In the late 1960s, racial tension was high, African Americans were not given the right to vote, the right to a fair education, and the right to a fair judgement. This then led to the separation of schools and the destruction of a normal livelihood. Dr.King and Malcolm X, two men in the face of oppression rose up to challenge the racial barrier, thus changing the world forever. Although Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X seem to have mutual respect and an equal understanding of the inequality, their philosophies were quite different from each other.

Read More
1059 Words | 5 Pages

The Civil Rights movement led to the emergence of two historical African-American figures during the 1960s, being Martin Luther King Jr. and his rival, Malcolm X. While both men shared a common goal of achieving civil rights for their people, their approaches to reaching this goal were vastly different. Malcolm X advocated for a more confrontational and violent approach, while Martin Luther King Jr. believed in peace and nonviolence. Differing factors such as speed, duration, and tactics separated the two methods from one another. Both were effective in their own ways, though it’s clear that Malcolm X had the stronger approach to the matter. To start things off, it’s clear that Malcolm X’s approach would provide quicker results.

Read More
1352 Words | 6 Pages

Nelson Mandela vs. Malcolm X In the 1960’s civil rights activists spoke around the world, Nelson Mandela and Malcolm X were two major spokesmen for the human rights movement. Both men fought for the same cause but used different tactics. The goal was equal rights among blacks and an end to segregation and police brutality towards the blacks. Two tactics were used in the fight for equality one being non violence and the other violence.

Read More
364 Words | 2 Pages

King is still misunderstood even by those who claim to know him, says the Rev. Lewis Baldwin, a historian and authority on King. " Each year we celebrate a man whom we have not come to understand," says Baldwin, a professor emeritus of religious studies at Vanderbilt University in Tennessee and author of the forthcoming book, "Behind the Public Veil: The Humanness of Martin Luther King, Jr." Consider what follows as "mythbusting MLK," a debunking of the five most persistent misperceptions about the civil rights leader. Myth 1: He grew more radical in his last years Here 's the standard take on King 's evolution: He started off focusing on racism, then grew more radical in the last three years of his life as he turned against the Vietnam War and focused on

Read More
1848 Words | 8 Pages

Martin Luther King Jr. was one of the most influential leaders of his time and played a crucial role in the African-American Civil Rights movement. Luther was a charismatic leader who took a firm stand against the oppressive and racist regime of the United States (US), devoting much of his life towards uniting the segregated African-American community of the US. His efforts to consolidate and harmonise the US into one country for all is reflected in many of his writings and speeches spanning his career. As a leader of his people, King took the stand to take radical measures to overcome the false promises of the sovereign government that had been addressing the issues of racial segregation through unimplemented transparent laws that did nothing to change the grim realities of the society. Hence, King’s works always had the recurring theme of the unity and strength of combined willpower.

Read More
392 Words | 2 Pages

Frederick Douglass and Malcolm X were great revolutionary leaders. Their motives inspired others to be against the segregated 20th century. Frederick Douglass is famous for writing “Learning to Read”. The intended audience would have been anyone. Learning to Read was written in 1845 and it is a narrative.

Read More

More about Mlk Vs Malcolm X Comparison Essay

Related Topics

Open Document