ipl-logo

Monsanto Argument Paper

1537 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: “monsanto’s harvest of fear,” essay

Monsanto was founded in 1901 in St. Louis, Missouri, but it did not begin its industrial and chemical research until the 1920s. Monsanto’s pledge states, “We want to make the world a better place for future generations.” (Monsanto) Monsanto is pretty bad in the sense that it harms the environment. However, there have been several claims against Monsanto and its use of harmful GMOs. Vice’s Monsanto article titled: “GMOs Aren’t That Bad But Monsanto Is the Worst;” approaches this claim from a everyday person perspective and breaks down the companies main advertising points. (Vice) The article argues that Monsanto values corporate greed over the health of the society and its practices have been proved to be unethical. So how is Monsanto still …show more content…

Vice has been known to write thought provoking pieces that inform the masses about worldwide situations that they believe need attention. My analysis is strongly based on the “Harvest of Fear” article , written by Barlett and Steele, two investigative journalists that delve strongly into the tactics and words that Monsanto employs.(Barlett and Steele) The Vice article was published on June 6th, 2013, which was around the time that Monsanto has tried to move its businesses into Europe. The expansion failed because of Europe’s strict regulations on food and the use of chemical agents. The biggest sources of protests against Monsanto however have been the people. As soon as Monsanto began considering moving into Europe, citizens began people started protesting on the streets and writing petitions. The article informs the public about the “March Against Monsanto” and several other protests. As written in the Harvest of Fear, the most significant protest against Monsanto is the “March Against Monsanto” and the authors’ inclusion of it …show more content…

Monsanto is a very confusing company because of its conflicting views. The group that is strongly against Monsanto consists mostly of farmers. The farmer group against Monsanto is very strong and the Vice article matches with the investigative journalists analysis of Monsanto being the bully. When read about for the first time, the reader can’t help but feel emotion for the farmers and the use of ethos evokes the human action of helping those in need. Because Monsanto has also been in the news fairly often, the term “Monsanto” is familiar to most, if not all individuals. As mentioned previously, the famous DDT pesticide scandal is still not forgotten. Farmers have been hurt by Monsanto with several law suits and a system that has been compared to the ancient “sharecropping.” The article analyzes both sides, but leans slightly towards the farmers’ point of view. The place where it’s bias is mostly shown is the tie to the chemical agent that was proved to hurt thousands of Vietnamese citizens. There is a picture in the article of a mother and her disfigured child and the caption states, “Some Vietnamese people would argue that Agent Orange was a bad thing.” This caption adds a sarcastic insult towards Monsanto. The picture and several of the controversial headings used in the article have a strong effect

Show More
Related
666 Words | 3 Pages

The direct quote from navy officials proves Monsanto is not trustworthy with its chemicals. Also, the purpose is clearly demonstrated in a direct quote from a trusted national source reviewing Monsanto’s PBC substance. Again a quote from a trusted source is used to show Monsanto’s chemical history. Doctors discuss the lasting effects of the chemical dioxin, which is one of the most deadly chemicals known to date. They say after meeting with the workers who were exposed to this chemical, “‘We believe these men are excreting a foreign chemical through their skins,’the confidential report to Monsanto noted.

Read More
1068 Words | 5 Pages

Sondra Simpson’s article “Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc.: Strategy with a Higher Mission or Farmed and Dangerous?” alludes to portraying a controversy involving the popular Mexican fast food chain Chipotle and the agricultural industry, but it reads more as a testament to the restaurant’s environmental and marketing achievements. The introductory paragraphs lead us right into a brief explanation of the issue at hand, as well as Chipotle’s intentions and opposition. Simpson hooks her readers with inciting blog titles illustrating the overall feelings of Chipotle’s offended adversaries, such as, “Boycott Chipotle: My Farm is Not Dangerous” and “Chipotle Unnecessarily Tears Down Agriculture to Build a Brand” (qtd by Simpson p 38). These blog posts describe the agricultural industry’s reaction to Chipotle’s latest attempt at spreading their corporate message through a series of webisodes titled “Farmed and Dangerous.”

Read More
357 Words | 2 Pages

In 2008 “Monsanto’s Harvest of Fear” was published in Vanity Fair. Penned by Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele, this exposition presents acts by Monsanto that may be considered questionable. Acts such as possessing a “shadowy army of private investigators” and the production of “two of the most toxic substances ever known”. The company was established in 1901 as Monsanto Chemical Works.

Read More
271 Words | 2 Pages

On the off chance that there's anything you read – or offer – let this be it. The substance of this article can possibly drastically move the world in an assortment of positive ways. Furthermore, as Monsanto would love for this article to not become famous online, whatever we can ask is that you share, offer, share the data being exhibited so it can reach however many individuals as could be expected under the circumstances.

Read More
225 Words | 1 Pages

In the article entitled Monsanto's Harvest of Fear, Donald L. Barley and James B. Steele demonstrate that Monsanto already dominates the United States food chain with their genetically modified seeds. They are currently targeting milk production which is just as scary as the corporation's legal battles against the small farmers. This situation leads to a history of toxic infections or diseases. There were many disagreements between Gary Rinehart and a stranger about the innovative seeds. They were under surveillance and an investigator came in the picture.

Read More
845 Words | 4 Pages

The three essays assigned this week had several common threads running through them. The strongest core theme is the rapid change in the food cycle in America and the vast changes that have taken place in the way by which we grow, produce, and process the food that average Americans eat. The food we eat now is drastically different from what our grandparents grew up eating and the three essays each examine that in a different way. Another theme is the loss of knowledge by the average consumer about where their food comes from, what it is composed of, and what, if any, danger it might pose to them. “Monsanto’s Harvest of Fear” by Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele is a harsh look at the realities of food production in a country where large corporations, like Monsanto, have been allowed to exploit laws and loopholes to bend farmers and consumers to their

Read More
640 Words | 3 Pages

Through the article, Platt hopes to inform the reader on what certain environmental groups are doing to farmers and hopes that through this knowledge, the abuse will be stopped.

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

In the essay “Green monster” who do you believe is his intended audience and why? In “The Green Monster,” James McWilliams informs the reader about GMO (Genetically Modified Organisms) and the affects it has on animals, plants, farmers and our food. Through multiple illustrations of the affects of GMO, he contends that GMO has various potential consequences, which may in fact be more positive than detrimental to food sustainability. His intended audience seems to be food consumers but more specifically, those uninterested in or wary of products which are genetically modified.

Read More
799 Words | 4 Pages

A powerful example of pathos is exhibited in the scene in which Seifert takes his sons to a cornfield to run and play among the rows and rows of vegetation like he had when he was a child. Viewers are swept into the nostalgia of older and simpler times only to become horrified to see Seifert take out gas masks, body suits, and duct tape and begin covering his kids from head to toe. Dressed in apparel fit for a nuclear or radiation site, Seifert and the boys run through the genetically modified field, protected from the pesticide and herbicide the plants are saturated in. This scene sends a striking message of the threat GMO’s pose to the memory of natural farming and food

Read More
1731 Words | 7 Pages

New regulations, an enforced code of ethics and striving to be more socially responsible has led Monsanto to enhance their relationships with stakeholders. Monsanto wrote a pledge to inform all of their

Read More
598 Words | 3 Pages

A corporatist markets off what they know would put them in financial ruin if people found out the truth behind what they claim is bettering the world. Once gathering enough positive claims, they proceed anyway. This is the quintessence of GMO marketing. Now, as the newest generation, millennials are likely to have been fed these genetically modified foods growing up, but have the technology to research and make their own intelligent and informed decision on whether these foods should be continued to be produced and distributed throughout the world. It is not being overly suspicious to not believe a corporation such as Monsanto, the leading agrochemical company, when with minimal research they publicize that GMOs are safe to consume.

Read More
573 Words | 3 Pages

According to the World Health Organization, genetically modified organisms (GMO’s) are organisms in which the genetic material (DNA) has been altered in a way that does not occur naturally. The United States is the world leader in genetically engineered crop production, with 165 million acres, or nearly half of global production. Currently in the United States, approximately 85% of all processed foods contain GMOs (www.gmofilm.com). Labeling is about empowering people towards informed decision making, so what 's bad about it? Despite being at the frontiers of cutting edge research & development the United States

Read More
1048 Words | 5 Pages

Genetically modified crops also aim to lower the failure of crops, which can maximize the benefits of farmer through the increase of income from selling crops. Nevertheless, this technology created chances for biotech companies to exploit farmers, even causing farmers to commit suicide. Big companies developed the genetically modified seed, and sell it to farmers. But farmers have little bargaining power only, they can only rely on the biotech companies. These companies do not aim to help farmers to increase their income, but aim to maximize their own profit.

Read More
769 Words | 4 Pages

Monsanto’s low levels of charitable giving and history of ethical lapses do not help the company’s case that it is seeking to improve the lives of the people of the world. However, Monsanto

Read More
1669 Words | 7 Pages

For years, the health and safety of genetically modified foods have been debated and researched by scientists, but the question still stands: should genetically modified foods be allowed for consumption? The process of genetic modification involves inserting a gene from bacteria or a virus into an organism where it would normally not be found. The purpose is to alter the genetic code in plants and animals to make them more productive or resistant to pests or farming techniques. Genetically modified organisms, more commonly known as GMOs, have been a controversial topic of debate for a number of reasons. The ethics behind genetically modified foods come into question due to an abundance of short and long-term effects from the process, many of which are still unknown today.

Read More

More about Monsanto Argument Paper

Related Topics

Open Document