My Brother: A Brief Summary And Analysis

1701 Words7 Pages

"Time heals all wounds" is a notorious saying. But what if time itself is not enough for the pain of loss? Under different circumstances, people grieve conventionally. However, in some cases, mourning can become more complicated and challenging than expected, as evidenced in Kincaid's autobiography, My Brother, which is a powerful exploration of the complexities of mourning and our experiences of loss. The autobiography evokes the intricacy of Kincaid's relationship with her younger brother, Devon Drew, who died of AIDS at age 33—following the impact of Devon's illness and the difficulty of coping with loss through a series of memories. While mourning is a natural and necessary process for dealing with loss, difficult conditions such as unresolved …show more content…

I will first focus on Kincaid's relationship with her mother and unresolved issues referencing excerpts from Robert O. Stolorow's "Trauma and Human Existence" to support my analysis. In the second part, I will go over Kincaid's experience with her brother's death and her mourning process. Again, I will reference excerpts from Freud's "Mourning and Melancholia" to demonstrate this. Finally, I will examine "Kagwahiv Mourning II: Ghosts, Grief, and Reminiscences" by Waud H. Kracke's cultural mourning practices and how we deal with a loss under challenging conditions. By incorporating these various perspectives, I aim to demonstrate Kincaid's grief's complexity and depth and how it is linked to …show more content…

It explores the dynamic relationship between her and her mother; their unsettled issues and her mother's lack of support have led her to melancholia. While the memoir pivots on Kincaid's experience with her brother's death, it is often overshadowed by the attachment to her past and her ongoing struggles with her mother. For instance, her mother's caring nature only seems to arise in the face of tragedy, making her mother nurturing when her children are ill. Kincaid suggests that her mother's love is unique and valid but not necessarily what she desires. "My mother loves her children, I want to say, in her way! And that is very true, she loves us in her way. It has never occurred to her that her way of loving us might not be the best thing for us. It has never occurred to her that her way of loving us might have served her better than it served us." This statement conveys her elaborate feelings toward her mother's love, and the complexity is demonstrated in the following passage illuminating the nature of their relationship. "She loves and understands us when we are weak and helpless and need her" ( Kincaid 16). This denotes that her mother's love is limited and communicates that form of loss for