ipl-logo

Opposing Views Of Augustine On Immortality

631 Words3 Pages

Augustine examines closely two opposing opinions on immortality through the lens of philosophical and scientific studies: the survival hypothesis, which asserts that the human personality will continue to exist after the death of the physical body, and the extinction hypothesis, which claims that the human personality will completely vanish after the death of the body (2). Before stating his claim in detail, he first premises that he does not deal with ethical and religious arguments (2). And then, he defines three forms of personal survival as the disembodied mind, the astral body, and resurrection (3). In fact, the difference of two arguments about immortality is derived from conflicting understanding about the interrelation between the body and mind. Although the survival hypothesis is based on dualistic view that insists separation of mind/soul from the body, the extinction hypothesis depends on inseparability. …show more content…

He firstly insists not only that human beings are corporeal but also that the bodily continuity is vital to personal identity rather than memory on the basis of Lament’s and philosophers’ insistences (4-5). He secondly demonstrates the belief of modern science about the dependence of consciousness on the brain (9). He also strongly argues that NDEs, OBEs, and past-life memories can be explained as biological and psychological phenomena. Thus, for him, the extinction hypothesis is generally acknowledged to be true by sufficient experimental evidences of physiological psychology, but the survival hypothesis is only supported by an unintelligible explanation of parapsychology (9,

Show More
Related
1020 Words | 5 Pages

Francis Nosike 09/24/16 AP Literature Mr. Amoroso Death cannot be explained because it’s not a living entity; it’s the transformation from a physical state to dust. In the novel Bless Me Ultima by Rudolfo Anaya; Antonio, the protagonist, witnessed three deaths that fostered his religious ambivalence. Therefore, the three deaths formulated a cycle of inquiries that lead to the constant statement, ‘anyone could die.’ No living soul on this plain could ever explain how death operates. The abstract conception of death itself is challenging, but with time, we slowly begin to comprehend the ‘true’ nature of death and what it brings to us.

Read More
515 Words | 3 Pages

In this two Christian philosophers, Richard Swinburne and Tim O'Connor, discussed the concept of neuroscience and the soul. The first philosopher, Swinburne, believed in the idea of substance dualism while O’Conner supported the argument for emergent individualism. Swinburne starts off by saying one’s physical body is simply the vehicle we interact with the world while the real essence of a person lies within their soul. When it comes to Swinburne’s belief on the soul after death I am reminded of Phaedo and how death will only bring about separation of body and soul.

Read More
270 Words | 2 Pages

In regards to immortality, Todd May argues that it would be an undesirable experience. He argues that immortality would eventually cause everyone to be the same because everyone would have the time to experience the same things. In this paper, I will show that May’s argument is invalid, and that immortality would not cause everyone to become the same person. To begin, May comes to this conclusion after reading “The Immortal” by Jorge Luis Borges.

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

In response to the long-standing philosophical question of immorality, many philosophers have posited the soul criterion, which asserts the soul constitutes personal identity and survives physical death. In The Myth of the Soul, Clarence Darrow rejects the existence of the soul in his case against the notion of immortality and an afterlife. His primary argument against the soul criterion is that no good explanation exists for how a soul enters a body, or when its beginning might occur. (Darrow 43) After first explicating Darrow 's view, I will present what I believe is its greatest shortcoming, an inconsistent use of the term soul, and argue that this weakness impacts the overall strength of his argument.

Read More
257 Words | 2 Pages

A long time ago in Greek Myth there was a story about a Titan named Prometheus. This is how it goes. In Greece there was Titans and their kids the Gods. The Titans ruled over the whole world. The Gods decided they had enough and started a war between the Titans for control over the world.

Read More
1225 Words | 5 Pages

In Plato’s dialogue Phaedo, he explains the soul and comes to the conclusion that the soul is immortal. Through describing the last hours of Socrates life before his execution, he lays out three arguments in support of the idea that while the body may cease to exist the soul cannot perish. In this paper, I will explicate Socrates three arguments for the immortality of the soul and their objections. Then I will argue on the presupposition of the Law of Conservation of Mass, that the universe, entailing the soul, must be cyclical. The Law of Conservation of Mass

Read More
1113 Words | 5 Pages

Kevin Yuan Professor Ananda PHIL 101 16 July 2023 Chapter 3 Paper Who am I? What is the connection between our spirit and our body? What becomes of our souls after we die? These questions are important to human minds because they help people understand themselves better and develop their own meaning in life.

Read More
1423 Words | 6 Pages

The argument of whether or not a human has a soul has been argued throughout centuries. Derek Parfit discusses two separate theories of personal identity, Ego Theory and Bundle Theory. The argument of which present a more accurate account of personhood is very hard to determine. The Ego Theory has some flaws such the soul is separate from the body and is a immaterialist object within us. Bundle Theory is reinforced and proven by the split-brain case, however it can lead to the argument that there is no self.

Read More
581 Words | 3 Pages

Persistence is the view that persons have psychological continuity, thus, a person is the future being that inherits the mental features from that person. A person is also the past being whose mental features they have inherited. Olson refers to this question of persistence as the “traditional problem” of personal identity. The question of persistence asks what is essential and adequate for a person existing at one time to be identical with something present at another time. Therefore, Olson believes that contemporary philosophers think an answer to this question would resolve all there is to know about the metaphysics of personal identity (“An Argument for Animalism”, 613).

Read More
524 Words | 3 Pages

In the Republic, Plato gives an argument saying the soul is immortal. In this paper I will present his argument and show that his argument is invalid. I will show why the conclusion is not true and restate the argument to make it valid to help with Socrates’ claim. Plato’s argument on why the soul is immortal: 1. Something can only be destroyed by the thing that is bad for it.

Read More
1536 Words | 7 Pages

THEMBEKILE TSAOANE BL2015-0178 SSIT311 TAKE HOME TEST INTRODUCTION “Between us and heaven or hell, there is only life, which is the frailest thing in the world" 1.1 Existentialism and death. The problems we face of death seem somewhat natural with the connection it has to existentialism.

Read More
1480 Words | 6 Pages

Much of the work done to support the theory of personal identity has been through thought experiment and illusory scenarios. The psychological approach to personal identity discusses the theory of memory and the importance of our mind and brain in personal identity and creating who we are as an individual. Likewise, the psychological approach to personal identity addresses the role of our brain in creating what we’ve become through our past experiences. John Locke, the key theorist in the theory of memory believed consciousness and personal identity were strongly related. However, this theory fails to acknowledge a person’s beliefs, desires or characteristics through which they express themselves through.

Read More
1970 Words | 8 Pages

(xxvii.¶3) I argue, why should memories be treated any differently? Can it not be said with utmost certainty that a person acquires new memories over time and thus the set of memories we have is constantly undergoing change? How can the memories be the basis for this notion of consciousness and by extension, for personal identity if the set of memories do not remain the same through time? Looking at the

Read More
1129 Words | 5 Pages

He provides criteria of personal identity through time that consist of the necessary and sufficient conditions for the survival of persons. He considered personal identity to be based on consciousness (memory and experience) and not on the physical matter of the body. He argued that many people hastily identify the physical brain with consciousness. The body and the brain are physical objects; therefore, it is subject to change whilst consciousness consistently remains the same. Consequently, personal identity is not located in the brain, but in consciousness.

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

There are other movements, beside physical body movement, allowed by our brain of which individuals are not conscious, or at least not fully conscious; namely, the action of remembering and forgetting. According to Pierre Nora memory “remains in permanent evolution, open to the dialectic of remembering and forgetting” (8) process which he claims to be “unconscious”. It is given to this dialectic, as Jan Assmann mentions in his essay Collective Memory and Cultural Identity that ““the survival of the type” in the sense of a cultural pseudo-species is a function of the cultural memory…” (126), which means: first, that the identity of a place is not inherited through genes; and second, that it depends on individuals’ conscious effort to maintain it. Individual memory or communicative memory as Assmann calls it “does not extent more than eighty to (at the very most) hundred years…”

Read More

More about Opposing Views Of Augustine On Immortality

Related Topics

Open Document