ipl-logo

Pan's Labyrinth And Marjane Essay

606 Words3 Pages

Marjane and Ophelia’s battle of fame
After reading Persepolis and watching Pan’s labyrinth I’ve noticed they both have similarities and differences. Both these stories are very great, one being a fantasy and the other being a biography. In this essay i will compare both stories from their surroundings in both characters, their families and the type of stories they are. In persepolis marjane was growing up. She lived in Iran where their country was going through changes. War was going on where she lived, she even saw one of the buildings that got destroyed as it states in the book “Iraq invades Iran, and bombs them regularly. Marjane's neighbor's building is destroyed” (Satrapi 142). Ophelia was also in a type of war not much similar to Marjane's. She was living in an army camp not being able to have much freedom and liberty to go outside and wonder around …show more content…

Marjane has both her parents and are very nice and love her. Marjane's parents decided to go on a trip to turkey and they let her stay home since she didn’t want to go. “They go to Turkey. Marji doesn't want to go, but she gives them a list of things she wants them to bring back.”(Satrapi 50). Marjane continues her being with her family but later gets to go away in a different country. Meanwhile in Pan’s labyrinth Ophelia lived with her mother and without her father. Her mother was in rough times and meets a Captain of an army and later decides to have a baby. Ophelia doesn’t get along with her stepfather and thinks she is crazy. Close to the end of the movie ophelia’s mom dies due to the birth of the baby and her father kills her and later also gets gets. Marjane had a little more better ending while ophelia had her mom and herself killed. Marjane and ophelia have very different families. Marjane has her real dad with her while ophelia has a stepfather. Both these stories are very good but one is an actual story and one is made

Show More
Related
482 Words | 2 Pages

Marjane parents both choose that Iran was not the place for their daughter. She was headstrong, outspoken, and independent. However, the behavior she has got her expelled so her mom and dad was afraid something worse would happen. They shipped Marjane to Vienna where she ended up in a boarding house that was run by some nuns.

Read More
1226 Words | 5 Pages

While she reaches the country her Mother is severely ill and she is greeted with an immoral black-hearted new father. Ophelia’s life is terrible and it is clearly only going to get worse as her mom dies and she is left with her new father. When Ophelia dies she does not simply go into darkness but instead she is greeted by her parents in a fictitious kingdom. I believe that the writer did this to create a more uplifting ending and to not leave viewers with the sadness of a little girl dying. The writer uses fictitious elements to prevent Ophelia from facing the dark truth of her circumstances.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

It’s written on the first page of our schoolbook’ [said Marjane]” (Satrapi 19). Marjane’s perspective before imperialism is shown in this quote, and here the reader can see how Marjane is not yet ready to speak out against what she is told to believe.

Read More
939 Words | 4 Pages

Ophelia’s character went through quite a large transformation. In the play her father tells her that she is to stay away from Hamlet and she readily agrees. In the movie Ophelia doesn’t disagree with her father but she also doesn’t agree just to please him. This shows that Ophelia isn’t easily persuaded, even by her own father. Despite her father’s warning about Hamlet, Ophelia met with him in secret at her apartment until her father found out.

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

She starts to fuse her views of the revolution to her religious ideology. “ It was funny to see how much Marx and God looked like each other. Though Marx’s hair was a bit curlier”(13). In the quote, Marjane is merging her perspective of her ministerial to her version of a dictative being. She isn’t doing this on purpose, the effect of the war is causing Marji to see people of a bad nature in a good light, she reads books like the Dialectic Materialism which stands in a biased viewpoint.

Read More
932 Words | 4 Pages

Ophelia goes mad throughout the story. She is overwhelmed by the loss of her father and the rejection of Hamlet. Her character is seen spiraling down a dark path that also ends in death. Ophelia is depicted as not having control over her actions; speaking and acting erratically. While Hamlet is speaking erratically and behaving oddly, he still maintains control over his actions and movement throughout the story.

Read More
923 Words | 4 Pages

Her loss of innocence is also contributed to by the government, with them killing Uncle Anoosh, which is a cause of nationalism by the Islamic State to kill the communists. Nationalism also negatively affects Marjane because of the Guardians of the Revolution. They relentlessly torment her, in an attempt to remove the Western influence from her. In summary, nationalism completely and utterly destroys Marjane’s childhood innocence, and is one of the major reasons why Marjane is the way she is today. In essence, this picture conveys social class through showing different styles of hats.

Read More
819 Words | 4 Pages

Ultimately this shows how little Marjane’s father and everyone else thinks that people need to stay in their own social classes and shouldn 't try to leave them, no matter what. This tears apart the maid for she truly loved the boy, but was forced to end the relationship and Marjane sees this as very wrong, and wishes social classes didn’t affect people’s lives. However, Marjane’s young perspective doesn’t allow her to see the full picture of this. Social classes are a big part of the Iranian culture and they believe that people need to stay in them, Marjane can’t understand this and as a result she became so angry. Another theme in the book Persepolis that is talked about is religion.

Read More
1234 Words | 5 Pages

Ophelia was the daughter of polonius, the love interest of hamlet who was brutally torn up mentally throughout the novel. At the beginning of the novel all was well for her as well, her boyfriend was off at college and she was perfectly fine at home with her father. It was until her father took away a note from hamlet to her that things started going downhill. She was a weak person not like hamlet who when faced with injustice takes thing into his own hands to seek justice or revenge. She was a quite simple girl who had a gentler soul.

Read More
1402 Words | 6 Pages

Marjane states, “With this first cigarette, I kissed childhood goodbye. Now I was a grown-up” (Satrapi 117). Marjane, just like the girl in this image, has shown her loss of innocence through her perspective. She can no longer be sheltered from her parents or be ignorant in relation to the world around her. The theme of gender roles has heavily impacted Marjane 's perspective in regard to the events occuring in Iran.

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

Her friends, boyfriends, and surroundings were the causes that altered her in her journey. Marjane came of age through her struggles in both Iran and Vienna by the surroundings and people around her.. Persepolis shows that coming of age can be affected by the historical and cultural events of the character’s childhood. In this novel, Marjane will unrestrainedly do whatever her parents are doing or did even though they command her not to. For example, when Marjane asked if she can go to the demonstration with her parents, she was refused. Then Marjane decided to go with her maid Mehri “Tomorrow we are going to demonstrate” (Satrapi 38).

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

Ophelia is grieving the loss of her father after Hamlet kills him. Ophelia doesn't know that Hamlet killed her father. But Ophelia has gone mad from learning about her father's death. Also, after Hamlet telling Ophelia that she needs to go to a nunnery, Ophelia is a little bit discouraged. She is discouraged because Hamlet had told her before that if Ophelia would sleep with him that they would get married.

Read More
750 Words | 3 Pages

John Locke was an English philosopher and doctor of medicine who lived between the years 1632 and 1704. He is seen as one of the pioneers of Enlightenment. This movement was a consequence of the French Revolution and theirideals included “freedom and equality for all, founded, ostensibly, upon principles of human reason” (Bristow, 2010). Locke was an essential person in the development and field of psychology due to his inquiry as to “the human understanding”(Connolly, 2016). He contributed greatly to the modern emphasis on the self and personal identity, consciousness or self-awareness and free-will.

Read More
1088 Words | 5 Pages

With all things considered, the personal nature of the story is expertly expressed through Marjane’s loss of innocence, her beliefs and opinions on her religion, and her experiences with gender

Read More
1183 Words | 5 Pages

Marjane can be compared to spoiled milk. She starts off her life being good, but then over time becomes sinful and rotten. Satrapi demonstrates this idea of loss of innocence a lot throughout the book. One example is when Satrapi says, “at the age of six I was already sure that I was the last prophet” (6).

Read More

More about Pan's Labyrinth And Marjane Essay

Related Topics

Open Document