ipl-logo

Person-Centered Therapy Versus Psychoanalytical Therapy

1427 Words6 Pages

This essay is to examine two approaches to counselling, the “Person-Centred Therapy” by Carl Rogers, and “Psychoanalytical Therapy” by Sigmund Freud, both approaches are equally popular. However, these therapies are different; both possess their strengths and weaknesses.
Why is “Person-Centred Therapy” a better therapy than “Psychoanalytical Therapy”?
Firstly, Human beings are complex and unique. According to Maltby, Day, Macaskill (2010) Carl Roger think it was not possible for a therapist to fully understand or enter the perceptual world of a client which is dominated by the client's life experiences. Client know best. In Rogers’ non-directive intervention, the client can find out which problems are important to him and explore these issues, …show more content…

Psychoanalytic therapeutic process, which is lengthy and costly; limiting its application to those in well-off socioeconomic standing (Corey, 2009). Person-centred therapy is an approach that aims to limit the time and cost of psychotherapy while maintaining the focus on the inner psyche and broadening its availability. In treating the psychologically scarred veterans of World War II it was recognised that psychoanalytic therapy was neither cost or time-effective given the lack of available fully-qualified professionals, the length of time a course of treatment, and perhaps crucially the subsequent financial …show more content…

Woody & Viney (2017) pointed out that Freud theory is based on a narrow view of human motivation. According to Ng et al., (2015), in Freud approach, it was assumed that everybody has the same family structure, overemphasized biological determinants of human behaviour and didn’t give sufficient attention to the influences of society, environment and learning in shaping behaviour. His theory was highly focused on pathology. According to Cooper (2010); Shuman (2016), Rogers’ motivation is not narrow like Freud’s central assumption of sexuality and aggression as the sole human primary motivations. Rogerian non-directional humanistic approach values self-fulfilment and personal freedom and flexibility. This focuses more on non-judgmental technique and the warm relationship between the client and the therapist help individuals to be open and

Show More
Related

Trauma-Focused Therapy Paper

156 Words | 1 Pages

The author explains the theoretical approach to the therapy, which incorporates multiple theories such as humanistic, psychodynamic,

Read More

Personal Reflective Essay: Person-Centered Psychotherapy

1598 Words | 7 Pages

ME IN PERSON-CENTERED THERAPY The last couple of months have been a very eye-opening journey for me. I had many realizations about myself and my relationship with people around me. For this, I started to see my self-structure, and this is how I look at it. For me, my self-structure is rigid in specific areas especially, where come my religious beliefs.

Read More

Carl Roger's Theory Of Holistic Analysis

652 Words | 3 Pages

1.1 Explain the historical development of one major therapeutic model, including the people influential in it 's development. Carl. R. Rogers (1902-1987) is the psychologist whose name is synonymous with the person-centred approach to counselling (Hough, 2006, pg.118) Rogers was born in Chicago on the 8th of January in 1902 he was the fourth child of the six children his parents had. Rogers was usually teased by his older siblings which made him become a bit of a recluse and he would turn to reading books which would help him build up his intelligence.

Read More

Person-Centered Nursing Theory

236 Words | 1 Pages

Person-centred nursing is widely practised in clinical areas today, the original concept was developed from the work of psychologists such as Carl Rogers and Tom Kitwood. Rogers (1957.1961) considered empathy and unconditional positive regard to be core features of any therapeutic relationship in counselling. He developed the concept of person-centred therapy in counselling. Stein-Parbury (2009) writes about the use of interpersonal skills in nursing and places a focus on Roger’s model of person-centred therapy. She states that person-centred nursing models have been influenced by the work of Rogers.

Read More

Essay On Carl Rogers Vs Yalom

1536 Words | 7 Pages

Both Carl Rogers and Irvin D. Yalom find that there are healing in therapeutic relationships and agree in this regard. (Duerzen, E. V., 2018) Yalom, however, places his focus in the client’s dealing with issues from a viewpoint that is more philosophical whilst Carl Rogers differs mainly with existentialism. The person-cantered approach deems the client as being authoritative with experiences constructing change with the idea of unconditional positive regard, executed mindfully.

Read More

Disadvantages Of Narrative Therapy

1965 Words | 8 Pages

Putting the client as the expert, understanding her story instead of attempting to judge it, in the therapist’s point of view. The therapist must in any point display with utmost care, interest, respectful curiosity, openness, empathy, and fascination. Once this collaborative relationship has been established, the counsellor and the client can move forward and work on how to improve the outcomes of the

Read More

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Pharmacotherapy

1727 Words | 7 Pages

DISCUSSION From the beginning, the therapist had to deal with own doubts and anxiety. The therapist had heard a lot about the psychodynamic psychotherapy but this was the first time he conduct the sessions by himself. Unlike pharmacotherapy, there is no standard clinical practice guideline or recommendation for the therapist to refer to or follow. The therapist was worried that he was unable to conduct the therapy effectively and his patient would not benefit from the therapy.

Read More

Worldview In Counselling

811 Words | 4 Pages

But in counselling our worldview is define by how we think about everyday matters, cause of behaviour that trigger emotional distress and problems. (Meleod, 2007) state that to be a “good” counsellor we must know our self-awareness, belief values and what our personal feeling and thoughts are, and how it can help us engage with clients in the counselling practice. While Egan state that it important for counsellor to believe in the counselling process and formed a good therapeutic relationship that allow clients to trust them and feel accepted without being judge regardless of their problem or cultures. (Egan.

Read More

Client Interview Reflection

1704 Words | 7 Pages

Additionally, as a counselor, it is important to be genuine with whatever feedbacks one presents to the patient and what one believes regarding the situation of the client. Mrs. Perez believes the more authentic and genuine he is with her patients, the more help he will be able to offer the clients. As a counselor, it is important to have a fine and professional interaction with one 's client but boundaries must be maintained. Through this, a counselor is able to demonstrate their focus on helping the patients by showing the client that they understand their problems. It also through such engagements that counselor is able to use the non-judgmental attention that does not require words for illustration in helping the patient.

Read More

Person Centered Therapy Essay

2624 Words | 11 Pages

Therapists must access their own internal process such as their feelings, attitudes and moods. Therapists’, who are not receptive to the awareness of their flow of thoughts and feelings, will not be able to help clients be aware of theirs (Kahn, 1997, p. 40). Though congruence does not mean that therapists have to share personal issues with clients, a therapist must not conceal their inner process from the client, and not be defensive but transparent (Kahn, 1997, p. 41). By being open sometimes a therapist learns more not only about their client but about themselves

Read More

Compare And Contrast Freud And Jung

1404 Words | 6 Pages

The Comparison between Freud and Jung: Their Contributions, Similarities and Differences Many people have known about psychology because of Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung (Blundell, 2014). In spite of the fact that they have various theories, they have so many contributions to understand the struggle of human mind. Their theories and thoughts have not always differed from each other (Blundell, 2014). Once, they were friends and colleagues.

Read More

Unconditional Positive Regard Case Study

850 Words | 4 Pages

Question #6: How can the coach approach assist in the holding of unconditional positive regard for the client? Unconditional positive regard (UPR) was defined in 1957 by psychologist Carl Rogers and is used in client-centered therapy. Practicing UPR regards accepting and respecting others without judgment or evaluation. This approach to UPR works very well with self-determination theory since practicing unconditional positive regard allows for the enhancing of the autonomy. Within relatedness, the coach is not judgmental and is accepting of all the clients positive and negative feelings.

Read More

Examples Of Congruence In Counselling

1030 Words | 5 Pages

Self actualisation is another strength to this form of therapy as it “helps the client to fully concentrate on themselves and guide in decision making for growth and develop into an honest, selfless and independent person” according to Mearns (1994). This helps the client to have autonomy, gives them self growth and self acceptance and all of which I feel are necessary for Gloria. Rogers strives on having a good relationship between the client and therapist whereas Ellis believes that this is not necessary for effective counselling session or for personality change. However, the negative side to person-centred counselling could be that the client is not challenged by anyone as the therapist does not give opinions or suggestions. There is no structure to the therapy session and therefore it relies on the client to be heavily involved in the counselling session and this maybe too optimistic for some clients as they are not getting answers, so they may find it hard to progress.

Read More

Limitations Of Psychoanalytic Therapy

1590 Words | 7 Pages

Psychoanalytic Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) is reflected as the forefathers of psychology and founder of psychoanalysis. Based on Freud’s theories, psychoanalytic therapy is a type of treatment that tends to observe at the background from early childhood to perceive if these situations have affected the individual’s life, or to current issues. (Counselling Directory, 2014) This therapy discovers how the unconscious mind empowers thoughts and behaviors, with the purpose of offering insight and resolution to the person seeking therapy. This form of therapy is a long-term treatment whereby it can take duration up to weeks, months or even years depending on the complexity of the patient being explored.

Read More

Psychoanalytic Theory In Counseling

1045 Words | 5 Pages

These are coping ways adopted by the EGO when it cannot deal realistically with the development of personality which occurs in different phases of a person’s development period. These stages are called the psychosexual stages of development. Techniques Used In Psychoanalytic Theory Psychoanalytic therapy contains several therapeutic techniques. These techniques are aimed at assisting create an awareness and bring an insight into the client's behavior.

Read More

More about Person-Centered Therapy Versus Psychoanalytical Therapy

Related Topics

Open Document