ipl-logo

Persuasive Perspective

739 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Summary of the National Response Framework

Q1. Which of the three perspectives do you find most persuasive? Least persuasive? Support your answer. Most Persuasive perspective I mostly agree with the perspective of Stephen M. Griffin since the national government clearly needs to become more directive in numerous areas. In this case, the government assisted in funding the construction of the levees and communication technology. However, this technology needed up ailing New Orleans completely (Shane & Lipton, 2005). Griffin asserts that the problem with federalism is that there was little to no functionality and collaboration within the various government levels. This problem led to the unpreparedness of the hurricane disaster in New Orleans (Starling, 2010). The different government …show more content…

She stated that the governmental response of Hurricane Katrina was not a complete failure as it also had some significant successes. These successes occurred when a foundation had been laid for cooperation between intergovernmental organizations. Such organizations include the National Guard that performed large-scale mobilization of survivors (Starling, 2010). However, the failures included the inability of New Orleans to limit its growth, its lack of flood protection and safety strategies and also the negative influence of politics on flood protection policies. This perspective did not highlight the best way strategies that the federal government and related agencies can utilize to collaborate more effectively and develop frameworks that will handle such disasters adequately (Roberts, …show more content…

A centralized response framework has greater flexibility and also the capacity to mobilize mutual aid. If the federal government takes all responsibility and spearheads the coordination and rescue attempts, the Katrina disaster would also have easily been prevented (Roberts, 2013). However, a centralized response creates redundancy and complexity issues which federalism is commonly known for. Time is wasted especially due to these protocols which put people at risk in times of natural disasters. When the flow of communication and decision making is rapid, immediate action can be taken out without delays caused from finding out the severity of the problem. A federal agency such as The National Guard needs proper authorization, especially when dealing with tragedies and therefore, this may create slow response times due to such issues (Shane & Lipton, 2005). During Katrina, there was no control and command from FEMA in New Orleans. There was also no criticism of Tsunami victims that received large amounts of aid while no government organization was adequately able to help New Orleans during their time of need (Shane & Lipton,

Show More
Related

Stafford Act Essay

237 Words | 1 Pages

The Stafford Act was enacted in 1988 and determines how and when the federal government is allowed to intervene in a natural disaster. It also defines the type of assistance to be provided as well as the distribution of funds among the federal, state and local governments. FEMA is responsible for coordinating the assistance identified in the Stafford Act. However, FEMA has to answer to the Secretary of Homeland Security rather than making their own decisions. The authors describe how our current governmental system isn’t well equipped to deal with major devastation such as Hurricane Katrina.

Read More

Independent Subnational Government: Pros And Cons

298 Words | 2 Pages

The idea of a federalist government is great, however, it has some downsides as well. Some advantages of federalism include keeping the government closer to the people, where states have the freedom and authority to make government decisions to local preferences. Federalism also allows local differences to reflected in the state and local government policy and reduce conflicts, this reduces the friction between interests and lessens conflict. The independent subnational governments allow for flexibility and experimentation, where successful policy innovations in one state can be adopted by other states and also the federal government. The achievement of at least some national goals is made easier by the participation of independent subnational

Read More

History And Explanation Of The Posse Comitatus Act (PCA)

1031 Words | 5 Pages

There became an obvious need for immediate assistance from the National Guard and the Active Duty Army to stop looters, crime, and other chaos that ensued shortly after the flood. Gaining assistance from state controlled National Guard units was not overly difficult. Unfortunately, use of Federal soldiers comes with the stipulation that “the Governor of the affected state must request use of the resources of the DoD”. (Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance) The Governor of Louisiana, Kathleen Blanco and her staff were already failing to control and lead emergency efforts.

Read More

Emergency Management Assistance Compact (EMAC)

896 Words | 4 Pages

Personnel and equipment come into the devastated area from all over the country, as well as Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands” (Bell, 2006, p. 26). 2005 brought the largest national response to natural disasters. Hurricane’s Katrina and Rita affected numerous states. The states affected were unable to help themselves, as would be responders were now victims. In addition to the lack of responders, the local infrastructure was decimated and local and state officials were unable to respond.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The American Government Under The Articles Of Confederation

1689 Words | 7 Pages

Because some powers overlap, there is often conflict between state and national government (Morone, 110). Although most people trust their own state governments more than the national one, there is still a strong sense of nationalism (Morone,

Read More

National Crisis Dbq Analysis

639 Words | 3 Pages

The Federal Government should play a direct role in solving a national crisis as they are in charge of

Read More

Explain Why There Is No Need For The Bill Of Rights To Be Written By The Federalists

419 Words | 2 Pages

A strong central government solves that problem because the federal government wanted to unite the states as one nation. The Constitution also says that the Federal Government would have no right

Read More

Why Did The United States Come Up With The Federal System Of Government

586 Words | 3 Pages

It was very essential for the united states of America to come up with the federal system of government. There were a number of reasons for this effect, among which included fear for the power centralization in the American political system. Also, this kind of government was considered appropriate because of the size of the united states as a country. Alexander, & Alexander, (2005) argue that federal governments are usually proper in large countries like the united states because there are very many people and a diverse group of individuals. As such, these groups of people may also have needs that are diverse which could as well mean a common culture that put them together.

Read More

Federalism: Delicate Balance Between Central Authority And Regional Autonomy

538 Words | 3 Pages

Federalism, as a political concept, embodies the delicate balance between central authority and regional autonomy. To me, federalism represents a system of governance that promotes cooperation, diversity, and resilience. It is a framework that allows for the effective distribution of power, ensuring the efficient functioning of a nation while honoring the uniqueness and individuality of its constituent units. In this essay, I will delve into the significance of federalism and its implications in fostering unity, diversity, and stability.

Read More

Homeland Security Gaps

1322 Words | 6 Pages

More and more authorities continue to be taken away and have been spread across many agencies within DHS. “FEMA no longer manages a comprehensive emergency management program of mitigation, preparedness, response and recovery and the agency function that President Carter and the Governors envisioned in 1979 no longer exists” (FEMA, 2013). The sole focus has turned to terrorism disaster preparedness and FEMA has become somewhat dismantled and lost its ability to provide the command and control that it had prior to the move to DHS. This will prove to be a major flaw and will again, show the failure of FEMA in the next occurrence of natural disaster the United States faces. There are other agencies within the DHS that need to be scrutinized as

Read More

Persuasive Essay

788 Words | 4 Pages

The first attempt and success to climb Mt. Everest occured in 1953. Since then, almost 4,000 people have been able to scale the mountain, but over 230 people have not been able to climb it successfully. There is a chance of accident or death when climbing this mountain or any dangerous activity. All people should should have the right to rescue services even if they knowingly put themselves at risk because there is always a chance of an accident happening, rangers are there to save people in danger, and there are rescue vehicles being produced to be used in case of an emergency.

Read More

Evolution Of Emergency Management Essay

967 Words | 4 Pages

Emergency management describes the process of preparing for disasters, responding to their occurrence and putting in place both structural and nonstructural measures to mitigate against them. Emergency management has come a long way in terms of evolution in the United States of America. In terms of evolution, there have been a number of changes with evidence in shift from state to federal and local involvement in disaster management. This paper will thus discuss the evolution of emergency management as well as the lessons that have come as a result of this evolution. The evolution can be traced back to the biblical times, Moses himself tried to manage floods by splitting the Red Sea (George et al, p. 1).

Read More

Department Of Homeland Security Essay

520 Words | 3 Pages

FEMA’s mission and priorities were changed so that, “terrorism prevention, preparedness, response, and recovery became central to the emergency management mission” (Haddow 325). As a result of the terrorist attacks on 9/11 the country’s focus shifted completely from natural disasters to an outright major assault on all things terrorism with no second glance at the potential emergency’s natural disasters presented. There might be a possibility that because of the nation’s extreme obsession with terrorists and terrorism that Hurricane Katrina was not given full priority nor given as much thought as it should have been because the whole focus of the government was on terrorism. When an agency and governmental structure, such as the defense agencies, undergoes an extreme shift within the course of a few years brought on so suddenly, there are bound to be weaknesses. Hurricane Katrina was the most challenging threat that tested the DHS as well as FEMA’s preparation and mitigation of natural disasters since the shift of focus.

Read More

Case Study Meeker

350 Words | 2 Pages

1. In my opinion Randy has difficult decision to make, because he needs to go against his boss. His supervisor Cheryl asked him to make illegal action. I think he shouldn’t listen to his supervisor, but do it in accordance with his conscience and as he was trained.

Read More

Principles Of Civic Responsibility

1556 Words | 7 Pages

Communal effort acts as a principle for our community to appreciate the creative cooperation and joint effort. We strive to create, promote, and protect social networks, public spaces, works of art, and media that support such interactions (Midburn Ten Principles). Talking to people and making connections is easy at Midburn. The energies and vibes around are extremely uplifting which is exactly what the festival is about. I've really met some amazing people and have made such memorable experiences I will have with me for the rest of my life.

Read More

More about Persuasive Perspective

Related Topics

Open Document