ipl-logo

Polygraph Research Paper

1675 Words7 Pages

Running head: Polygraph 1

THE POLYGRAPH MACHINE: Tried and True or Witch?s Brew
Sharon Robinson
Bailiff, Duval County Sheriff?s Office
Florida Gulf Coast University

Polygraph 2
First and foremost, I state my uncompromising objection to the use of the polygraph by the Florida Court System. The history of the polygraph initially referred to as a lie detector. In 1914 and 1915 Vittori Benussi and William Morston produced a device that was supposedly capable of detecting if a person was being deceptive when responding to a question. Later, in 1921, a device capable of linking blood pressure and breathing, pulse rate, and exhalation with deception was developed. In 1926 Leonard Keeler developed the first polygraph machine, …show more content…

is an allusion to Masonic rites and to the trials administered to those aspiring to the ?Third Degree? level.? ?The polygraph interrogation is considered the ?fourth degree- without incorporation of sweat boxes or bludgeoning supposedly incorporated to reduce more violent means used to coerce confessions. Every lie detector involves deception, or attempted deception, of the suspect. Interrogators want the suspect to believe that they know more than they do, and that if he simply confessed to the crime they could make things easier for him. A story in the New York Times printed the story of Matthew …show more content…

(See illustration 1). A groundbreaking decision regarding the admissibility of polygraphs in court cases can be found in Frye v. U.S. Mr. Frye was convicted of second-degree murder. Mr. Frye appealed his conviction. When Frye attempted to bring in an expert witness to testify that he had taken a deception test, and to relay to the court the results of the test, the court held the professional testimony inadmissible. The court reasoned that ?the evidence did not meet the requirement that the evidence be sufficiently established to have gained general acceptance in the particular field in which it belongs,? thus the test results were summarily excluded by the Court.? ?The court held that without an established place in science, the test was still in the blurred realm between experimental science and demonstrated science, and therefore inadmissible.? ?In the court?s words, as the deception test was not ?sufficiently established?,? the testimony related to it is inadmissible.?

Show More
Related

Summary Of Thomas Clayton's Court Case

403 Words | 2 Pages

Also told the judge, the defense 's argument is not newly discovered evidence and the defense knew of this expert during trial. "There 's nothing new for counsel at the time of trial. As far as presentation at trial, the fact that is may have surprised defense counsel, I think they had time prior to trial to get their expert around. I think they were more so upset because we had the better expert," said Rider-Ulacco. Judge Peter Bradstreet denied the defense request for a new trial.

Read More

Case Brief State Of Oregon Vs Harris

569 Words | 3 Pages

Issue Case name: State of Oregon vs Kenneth James Harris, October 19th, 2017 Facts of the case: In the case there were two parties, one party including the defendant, Kenneth James Harris, and the State of Oregon. The dispute is based on the state of Oregon issuing a subpoena for the witness to come to trial for the case of the defendant, however, the witness failed to do so and was unavailable. The defendant argued that the only way the witness is unavailable is if the state did everything in their power to try to get the witness to court. The only thing the state did was provide the victims recording of the 9-1-1 call from the incident. Issue: Could the State of Oregon done more to produce the witness at trial?

Read More

Summary Of Terrance Bogan's Being Mommy Behind Bars

1497 Words | 6 Pages

Testimony is the elements or opinion of experts in the field that is discussed. Testimony is a recurring element Bogans uses throughout his essay. He makes a bold move of offering testimony against his thesis or claim but also offers testimony supporting his claim. A notable place Bogans

Read More

What Caused 9/11 In Peter Bergen's Could It Happen Again?

1065 Words | 5 Pages

This testimony helps draw the reader in and give them the mindset of, “well if an expert believes this, I should as

Read More

How Does Capote Use Dramatic Irony In The In Cold Blood

961 Words | 4 Pages

It confirms the already assumed. During the court trial, Dr. Jones was asked “From your conversations and examination of Perry Edward Smith, do you have an opinion as to whether he knew right from wrong at the time of the offense involved in this action?” (296). The doctor replies with a simple no. I strongly disagree what the doctor decides to reply. He claims he has no opinion because of Perry having no opinion.

Read More

How Does Loftus Study False Memories

423 Words | 2 Pages

It is unlikely that social consequences of false memories can be avoided. Elizabeth Loftus was intrigued to study false memories, and is perhaps personally responsible for subsequent developments throughout the history of false memories. Some of this history addresses various theories aimed at isolating how or why false memories occur. These include Source Monitoring Framework, Activation Monitoring Theory, Fuzzy Trace Theory, and strategies for persuasion which can lead to the development of false memory. Such persuasion leads to the present discussion concerning how persuasion in the judicial system has created false confessions and wrongful eyewitness testimonies, due to the Misinformation Effect.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Daubert Standard

1404 Words | 6 Pages

Under the modified Daubert standard, relevant scientific evidence is only admissible if it is centered upon testable hypotheses, conforms with the standard rate of potential errors, has been peer reviewed, and if the method is generally accepted in the scientific community (Hoog, 2008). However, there are three problems with the application of the Daubert standard. Firstly, David E. Bernstein and Jeffrey D. Jackson (2004) proved that there was no uniformity in the application of the standard in the sense that it’s only abided with in a portion of the states, and not necessarily with full adherence. Secondly, since the judge is not a scientist, it is difficult for him/her to, without doubt, determine the full honesty of the experts’ testimonies. An example from the Willingham case would be the two medical experts asserting that he was a sociopath although one was an irrelevant family counselor and the other, known as “Dr. Death” and later expelled from the American Psychiatric Association for ethical violations, had not even spoken to Todd Willingham.

Read More

James Mackenzie's Polygraph Essay

532 Words | 3 Pages

The technology required a “rubber diaphragm” to be connected to a vein located on the neck and the pulse of the wrist; this instrument was highly ineffective, due to being the first of its kind and lack of technological advances. This being said, James Mackenzie’s polygraph paved the path for many years of scientific and forensic work to come, which is why I will be adding this information to my timeline. In 1921 the first modern and somewhat accurate polygraph machine was invented by John A. Larson, a psychologist at the Berkley Police department. This instrument was the first of its kind and was in substantial use in investigations of that time period. The 1921 polygraph machine was the first to have a constant measure of blood pressure and pulse to record change and variation in data, on a rotating drum of smoke paper.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Reid Technique

911 Words | 4 Pages

The police then determine if the suspect is guilty and continuously interrogate, accuse, and even threaten the suspect for hours until they confess, whether they are guilty or not. On many occasions the people who are coerced into false confessions are have severe mental impairments that prevent them from functioning as a normal person with out the impairments would.

Read More

Washington V. Harper Case Summary

1116 Words | 5 Pages

In addition, a motion to suppress was filed, noting inculpatory statements which Duhon had given to investigators. His attorney argued that Duhon lacked the mental capacity to provide voluntary statements and did not understand his Fifth Amendment right to remain silent. Therefore, the statements provided by Duhon, even though he voluntarily gave them, cannot be used in court. The more imperative evidence, including the testimony of court-appointed experts in forensic psychology and criminal law, concludes that Duhon will remain incompetent. If the defendant is deemed incompetent, he cannot communicate with his attorney, cross examine witnesses, decide how to plea, and etc.

Read More

When I Grew Up In Jail Analysis

555 Words | 3 Pages

The story opens up with the writers first encounter of someone fearing him in public. And although it is purely off of race, his vivid description of himself portrays why she sadly felt that way, as stated “To her, the youngish black man – a broad six feet wo inches with a beard and billowing hair, both hands shoved into the pockets of a bulky military jacket – seemed menacingly close.” (Staples 188). He then goes on to describe his manner which is nothing like the stereotypical young black male, “As a softy who is scarcely able to take a knife to a raw chicken – let alone hone to a person’s throat…” (Staples 189).

Read More

Forensic Testing Essay

1095 Words | 5 Pages

This can be used for legal purposes. This type of testing can be used to identify catastrophe victim (these are people who die in accidents or disasters that can not physically be identified), identify crime victims, rule out (find innocent) or implicate (find guilty) crime

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Confessions

724 Words | 3 Pages

Consequently, when interrogators go into interviews believing the suspect is guilty, it brings on intense amounts of stress, putting suspects at a higher risk to crack under pressure. E. This increased pressure brought on by misclassified interrogations cause innocent suspects to feel so much stress they confess to a crime they did not commit. F. Misclassified errors are just one way suspects feel their only option is to give a false confession in order escape the pressure in the interrogation room. II.

Read More

How Does Tom Robinson Show Innocence In To Kill A Mockingbird

732 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee the term mockingbird symbolizes innocence in a person. In the novel it focuses on the fact that innocence, represented by the mockingbird, can be wrongfully harmed. There are two characters: Tom Robinson and Arthur “Boo” Radley that are supposed to represent the mockingbird. In the novel, Tom Robinson is the best example of a mockingbird because he is prosecuted for a crime he did not commit. Also, he was judged unfairly based on the color of his skin in his trial.

Read More

Pamela Meyer How To Spot A Liar Summary

761 Words | 4 Pages

The presentation is memorized and well rehearsed with no clear improvisation. In her presentation Pamela Meyer claims that on any given day we're lied to from 10 to 200 times, and the clues to identify those lie can be inconspicuous and unreasonable. She demonstrates the conduct and "hotspots" used by those trained to recognize deception - and she argues honesty is a value worth saving.

Read More

More about Polygraph Research Paper

Related Topics

Open Document