ipl-logo

Uniformitarianism In Paleoanthropology And Middle-Range Research

885 Words4 Pages

In attempts to reconstruct human behavior that of meat-eating and its related behaviors paleoanthropologists and archaeologist’s works within the perspective of uniformitarianism, actualism, analogy and middle range theory (Atici, 2005). The Principle of Uniformitarianism was first proposed by a geologist, Dr. Charles Lyell, in his publication of 1871 (Holmes, 1965). The principle states that, “the present geological phenomena that are observed today are key to past geological phenomena” (Holmes, 1965). Application of Uniformitarianism in archaeology and/or paleoanthropology establishes the relationships between present processes and traces, which are used to infer the context of processes that created the same traces in the past such as the …show more content…

Merton in 1957 (Johnson, 2010). Lewis .R. Binford was among the first archaeologists to employ middle range theory in archaeology (Atici, 2005). Middle-range research attempts to link the low-range static traces of past behavior with their high-range, dynamic causal processes including biological, ecological and behavioral factors, through a series of relational analogies that comprise the middle-range (Binford, 1981). Middle Range Theory was used in this study because it helps deducing aspects concerning early hominid behavior such as that of meat eating, early hominid subsistence patterns and the like (Binford, 1981; Saanane, 2004; Shipman, 1986; Gifford-Gonzalez, 1991). For example Nilssen (2000) argued that Middle range investigations are widely used in practice by Plio-Pleistocene zooarchaelogist, largely focusing on the hunting versus scavenging debate of carcass access (Binford, 1981; Nilssen, 2000). In Paleoanthropolgical investigations for example based on Middle Range Theory, the discovery of close spatial association of fossil fauna with stone artifacts in archaeological assemblages suggest processing of animal products (see also, Bunn and Kroll, 1986; Shipman, 1986; Saanane, 2004). Such reasoning is based on Middle range theory and relational analogy (Binford, 1981; Gifford-Gonzalez, …show more content…

al., 1988; Binford, 1978). For example Binford (1978) made comprehensive observations of butchery activities by the Nunamiut Eskimos and then studied the bones for resulting butchery damage. Results from Binford’s (1978) study provided information for an account of butchery activities and their associated cut marks. Such marks may be used as models of early hominids butchering patterns and hence, provide evidence for meat eating by early hominids (Binford, 1978; Binford, 1981; Nilssen, 2000). Therefore, in studying the aspect of meat eating and attempts to reconstruct subsistence behaviors of early hominids at Makuyuni site 4, this study tried to incorporate principles of uniformitarianism, actualism, ethnographic observation, analogy and Middle Range

Show More
Related
1592 Words | 7 Pages

The fossil finding process is long and hard, it can take years before something life changing is discovered. Neil Shubin knows all about this as it took him and his team years of searching to find one of the most important fossils that tell about evolution, the Tiktaalik. Early on in the book Neil asks us “How can we visualize events that happened millions

Read More
1232 Words | 5 Pages

“Rifles, Blankets, and Beads” delivers an entertaining perspective on the Northern Athapaskan village of Tanacross. This book is an outstanding resource for anthropologists, students, and educators. In reviewing this book, the author brings a descriptive writing style when analyzing the Northern Athapaskan village of Tanacross culture and history with a focus on the potlatch giving us insight details how the potlatch celebrated among the Tanacross people. The author, William E. Simeone, is a great source for the Northern Athapaskan village of Tanacross because he lived there among the people. In addition to living there he also attended ceremonies in both Tanacross and surrounding villages, and participated in potlatches within the villages.

Read More
552 Words | 3 Pages

The book attempts to answer this question by comparing the historical developments of different continents over the last 13,000 years. During Jared Diamond’s study of bird evolution in New Guinea, he met a local politician named Yali. Yali was interested

Read More
236 Words | 1 Pages

The Balfour Declaration, issued on November 2, 1917, was a paragraph of the British Government supporting the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. However, Palestine was a region of the Ottoman empire at the time, making the intentions of moving the Jews into Palestine very difficult. Although, the chances of the Israelis moving to Palestine was low, the Ottoman Empire was falling apart. This created tension between the Israelis and the Muslims, since there was a possible chance of Palestine becoming a Jewish homeland.

Read More
457 Words | 2 Pages

That is because they are living. So they can observe and study their behaviors. What tolls they use, what do they eat and what is their everyday task? There is so much you can learn from them. However, for archeologist this is a bit difficult.

Read More
1510 Words | 7 Pages

Traditional practices in Anishnaabe culture include learning to hunt with family which helps to understand the land as their ancestors once did. Evan had just returned from hunting and he was thinking about what would happen if they ran out of meat for the winter and had to purchase more. “Evan ate southern meats when he had to, but he felt detached from that food”(6). Eating food you hunted and worked hard to put on the table has a different meaning and feeling attached to it. Whereas when you buy it from the store it does not take as long to collect and no work was put into gathering said meal.

Read More
1409 Words | 6 Pages

Home to a large Pleistocene fossil site, Saltville, Virginia has revolutionized modern archeology. The locality is especially significant because of unique interactions that took place between animals and humans 15,000 years ago. There has been recent evidence uncovered that Paleo-humans and the mammals in the surrounding Appalachian region interacted and the humans relied on the animals for survival. The deep history preserved in the land of Saltville reveals a past ecosystem that drew megafauna to its locality. The region, rich with life, is the second oldest known Pre-Clovis site in the Americas, marking its significance in history and archeology.

Read More
1260 Words | 6 Pages

The discovery of this mammal was proof that mammals had lived alongside the dinosaurs. It gave scientist a small glimpse into ancient mammal species. Chapter 6– Questions

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

If there’s something every country and the whole world has in common it’s that they were all home to native tribes, whether it was the Aztecs, Cherokees, Inuit, Nuer, Hadza or Incas and many more. Hugh Brody, a British anthropologist, writer, director and lecturer, writes about a tribe of hunters in the Arctic and Sub-Arctic of North America, who are known as Inuit. In his piece, “The other Side of Eden”, written in 2001, Brody argues that we still judge hunter-gatherers although we are the ones that dramatically and drastically changed their life because of our modern life styles. Ironically Brody named his piece, “The other Side of Eden”, alluding to The First Book of Moses, Genesis 2, or also known as “Genesis of the Garden of Eden”,

Read More
789 Words | 4 Pages

arguments, and directed the hunting and gathering. A new chief of a tribe would be the son of the original chief. This would go on for generations. Each village in a tribelet had a speaker that would be the sub-chief if the headman couldn’t be there. Sort of like a vice president.

Read More
536 Words | 3 Pages

An Edible History for Humanity was written by Tom Standage which emphasis the history of food and farming used by man throughout history. This book takes us through different parts of the world and gives us examples of how food has changed their way of life. The first civilizations had to go on very little for food. But in the early civilizations,Standage has thought me that food drew everything together. Food wasn’t there just to eat,but was the driving force for the life style of civilizations.

Read More
1040 Words | 5 Pages

Choi then quotes the Director of food studies at New York University, providing relevancy and authenticity to her work. The statement also establishes a link between what we eat and how it connects to particular memories and places in our minds. Moving on, the article is divided into six different subheadings. Each subheading explains the origin of indigenous food in different countries and what that denotes particular culture. Broadly speaking, food is necessary for survival, signifies status denotes pleasure, brings communities together and is essential for humanity.

Read More
507 Words | 3 Pages

This finding was further supported by the significant amount of spongy bone fragments that were found in both caves which indicated that bone marrow extraction had taken place. Furthermore, the findings from this study supported the researcher’s hypothesis that the Neanderthals struggled to intake more nutrients on a daily basis during the glacial periods since there was less prey in the environment which lead to their starvation and extinction. To further support this hypothesis, researchers suggested that other Neanderthal sites must be examined in order to determine whether nutrient extractions at those sites match the intensity of the nutrient extractions reported in this study. Overall, I found this article to be very interesting because of how the researchers were able to shed light on the mystery that surrounds the extinction of the Neanderthals by utilizing something simple as bone fragments. Lastly, I found this article to be fascinating because it led me to the ask the question of what will happen to human populations when the effects of climate change begin to devastate

Read More
643 Words | 3 Pages

Using a recent archealogical find as the basis for her argumenet, the author believes that the "so-called" Palean baskets were not uniquely Palean because a basket matching Palean characteristics was found in a nearby city called Lithos. However, a variety of understated assumptions belie this conclusion. A sample size of only one Palean basket found in Lithos may constitute a hasty generalization, and there may have been other modes of reasonable transportation between Palea and Lithos. The passsage indicates that only one Palean"basket was found in Lithos.

Read More
1421 Words | 6 Pages

Eating meat is beneficial to humanity, because they provide nourishment that cannot be obtained from other sources. Without the support of animals, humans lack a distinctive diet, that is essential to their well-being. However, since animals are so important to the diet, they deserve great care and respect as well. Humans were always hunters and gathers. They always knew that meat was a big source of protein that helped keep them going(Araki).

Read More

More about Uniformitarianism In Paleoanthropology And Middle-Range Research

Related Topics

Open Document