ipl-logo

Processualism Grew Out Of New Archaeology

1518 Words7 Pages

A SYNCRETIC FUTURE: PROCESSUALISM AND POSTPROCESSUALISM

Sara Hutchinson
Archaeology 4100: Archaeological Theory and Method
March 6, 2023

Processualism and postprocessualism are two dominant theoretical movements in recent archaeological work. Though it is said that postprocessualists are a minority within the archaeological community, both theoretical approaches have had a wide impact on the development of the discipline. This paper aims to explore the advantages and disadvantages of either approach as well as examine examples of both theoretical frameworks in use. To conclude, this paper will make a hypothesis of the direction the discipline may take and will ultimately suggest a synthesis of processualist …show more content…

Though there is great diversity in how processual archaeology is practiced, there are some fundamentals that are widely present in processual scholarship. Central to processual archaeology is upholding a positivist epistemology. This means that they uphold that scientific knowledge is the sole source of valid truth, which is a fact that never needs to be proven within positivism. Due to this positivist epistemology, processualists often take an ahistorical approach and focus solely on scientific reasoning for their explanations. As a result, processualists' work tends to be deductive in nature, meaning they establish a hypothesis and seek to test it, with the establishment of general laws being a paramount goal. To the processual archaeologist, it is most important to study cultural change and evolution. Furthermore, processualists seek to explain what occurred in the physical world and presuppose that generally, individuals in the past have acted rationally when engaging with their physical world. These are the essential beliefs that processualists …show more content…

In this book, Spector explores how archaeologists can connect deeper with the material they study as well as encourage anti-hegemonic thought in unique ways. Spector decided to write creatively about a specific awl that she excavated at the Little Rapids site. Though Spector admits that this story is not completely factual, she highlights that despite this her story helps communicate personal connection with the site, explanations about the site, and explores how the present affects our interpretation of the past. This is a brilliant example of how postprocessualists break down expectations and hegemonic standards in archaeology to explore the inner lives and thoughts of past

Show More
Related
1598 Words | 7 Pages

The Field Research Procedure this paper focuses on covers excavations between 1983 and 1993 by Martin Carver. The Field Research Procedure assumes that archaeological data cannot be discovered but are defined and collected as a result of archaeologically informed choice. Data are variables which are chosen

Read More
1271 Words | 6 Pages

In the book Cave Rock: Climbers, Courts, and A Washoe Indian Sacred Place, the authors Matthew S. Makley and Michael J. Makley describe the history of legal dispute between a small Nevada Native American tribe, called Washoe, and non-Native climbers, over the use of Cave Rock. For a countless generation of Washoes, Cave Rock was the center of a great spiritual significance. The site use was strictly restricted to the Shamans, the most powerful traditional Indian doctors. The doctors do not explain what they do in the rock, but the Washoes claim that what the Shamans do up in the rock has “something to do with power involving extremely secretive and sacred rites” (10). While the rest of Washoe tribes have avoided trespassing the site, the Native doctors used the Cave to connect with powerful forces (11).

Read More
457 Words | 2 Pages

Since they don’t have the living people from the past here in the future. They have to piece together what they know about the past societies by their findings. They have to piece together what they find to know what they did on an everyday basis, what they ate and much more. When excavating a site

Read More
1452 Words | 6 Pages

Effective Criticism, Ineffective Execution Janet Spector ’s book What The Awl Means is a break-way writing that reflects on many relevant issues within archeology during the twentieth century. She addresses the academic issues within archeology specifically when learning about Native Americans. Through in-depth reports on archeological sites and artifacts Spector, introduces a new form of archeological review.

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

Graham and Anna Ritchie disagree with Euan. A Neolithic “low-road” connects Skara Brae with the tomb of Maeshowe, and passes near both of the sites. Low roads connect Neolithic ceremonial sites throughout

Read More
1865 Words | 8 Pages

The physical domain of the country had its counterpart in me. The trails I made led outward into the hills and swamps, but they led inward also. And from the study of things underfoot, and from reading and thinking, came a kind of exploration, myself and the land. In time the two became one in my mind. With the gathering force of an essential thing realizing itself out of early ground, I faced in myself a passionate and tenacious longing— to put away thought forever, and all the trouble it brings, all but the nearest desire, direct and searching.

Read More
1909 Words | 8 Pages

At 52 years of age, the Professor is not only discontent with his family and his professional career, but he questions the value of his accomplishments in light of Tom Outland’s great exploits. As the first person to explore the Blue Mesa and catalog its many ancient treasures, Tom epitomizes an American identity being created in the myths and legends of the Southwest following World War I. Tom’s very identity is enmeshed in the Southwest, his exciting adventures as a cowboy, and his time spent in the winter cabin with its view of the Blue Mesa. Even the Professor’s son-in-law Louie – who never knew Tom personally – heralds him as a “brilliant young American scientist and inventor, who was killed in Flanders, fighting with the Foreign Legion, the second year of the war, when he was barely thirty years of age” (Cather 30). With all of Tom’s accolades, Professor St. Peter feels that his roles as a husband, father of two grown daughters, and a Chair of Renaissance History at Hamilton pale in

Read More
597 Words | 3 Pages

Summary and Three Key Messages In Blackfoot Physics And European Minds, Francis David Peat (1997) examines the establishment of the “European consciousness” and compares this perspective with that of Indigenous science, calling specific attention to the animate world of the Blackfoot. Peat highlights the benefits of weaving these perspectives and expands on the idea of a marriage between the impersonal subjectivity of Indigenous science and Western sciences’ objectivity. In his work, Peat focuses on Blackfoot physics, examining its principles and application.

Read More
347 Words | 2 Pages

“The Importance of the Neolithic Revolution” is an article written by William Howells that focuses in on what the Neolithic Revolution was like all over the world. Also the definition of single site theory zeros in on what the Neolithic Revolution was like in one place. These two theories contradict and oppose each other. One theory of the Neolithic Revolution was single site theory.

Read More
1026 Words | 5 Pages

A well-excavated archaeological site can contribute greatly to our understanding of the ancient past. The good archaeological practice utilised by Sir Arthur Evans during the excavation of Knossos revealed a new understating of the ancient civilisation, commonly known as the Minoan civilisation. Despite the thorough excavation, his reconstruction of the city is considered inaccurate, creating a false narrative of the civilisation and skewing our understanding of the ancient past. British archaeologist Sir Arthur Evans, who led the excavations of Knossos between 1900 and 1931 has been recognised as a leading contributor to our knowledge of the civilisation on Crete. During the excavations, his team utilised a range of archaeological methods

Read More
856 Words | 4 Pages

The article written by Miner was one in which seemingly forced the student to keep reading. The varying ways in which the author described traditions created and passed down through generations of the Nacirema people evoked interest and question in the students mind. The student had never read this article, nor had he read an article written in such a way to make him feel emotions quite like the ones he felt while scrolling though the pages of this article. Fortunately, the student was able to find that he was not the sole student amongst his peers who had many questions and concerns that came to fruition while reading the Nacirema article. Questions fluttered around the readers head as he finished the first few paragraphs of the article.

Read More
1419 Words | 6 Pages

The Emic method gives a clear and accurate understanding of a culture due to the in-depth interview conducted by the anthropologist. But because there was a lack of information, confusion and strange descriptions of a non-exotic culture there is no way that this “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema” used the Emic method. Because of this it supports the fact that this essay was a Etic inspired

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

Lively’s diction give readers the understanding that Claudia and Gordon are not just looking for fossils, they are looking to win at “finding fossils.” Lively also emphasizes her theme of violence by

Read More
1231 Words | 5 Pages

The archaeologists, who have worked with the Native Americans for years through all government building on their land throughout the years, still do not see and understand the real problem with the

Read More
1214 Words | 5 Pages

Freedom and Oppression Throughout both the age of Enlightenment, we see the Artist of the time searching for perfection, coupled with the quest for logic such as Jean Jacques Rousseau and Denis Diderot. With the advances in society, these philosophers were at once able to substantiate their claims. The eighteenth century was the age of the enlightenment because it was both a pinnacle peak and a new beginning. New currents of thought were wearing down institutionalized traditions.

Read More

More about Processualism Grew Out Of New Archaeology

Related Topics

Open Document