ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Elizabeth Barnes

769 Words4 Pages

Elizabeth Barnes argues against L.A. Paul’s claim that the decision of whether or not to have a child is not a rational decision no matter the choice. Paul’s claim is as a result of the transformative nature of such an experience as having a child. Barnes problem is with Paul’s conclusion which is along the lines of, “If you choose to undergo a transformative experience and its outcomes, you choose the experience for the sake of discovery itself. (p. 120)” Barnes disagrees, because such a statement would mean that the choice she and her husband made is not rational because they are rejecting the chance to discover a new experience. Instead, Barnes argues that avoiding having children can be a rational choice based on projected outcomes. Her reason is to avoid a violation of her current desires, preferences, and self. This would be reasonable if the arguments she used to reach this conclusion matched such a reasoning. The claim of violation …show more content…

Even when a pregnancy is found too late, there is no way for someone to have a child they don’t want to be having without external force. Moreover, it is possible to stop being a parent, even if you’ve had a child for a number of years. All you have to do is give them up, or prove to be a terrible parent. There is no possible way to to have you mauled limb returned or to be removed from a pillaging hivemind. Conversely, it would be within reason to argue that having a child results in a loss of autonomy. There are a recent psychological studies that claim parenthood creates a loss of autonomy. Statistics also show that childfree people are often happier than parents. However in these studies, loss of autonomy is defined as “losing the right to decide what we want to do” (Brogaard). This is something that occurs between equal human beings. Having a child, especially a young one, also requires you to sacrifice many things, but there are two problems with

Show More
Related

Pros And Cons Of Elizabeth Van Lew

367 Words | 2 Pages

Elizabeth Van Lew, a wealthy abolitionist, a woman who shows compassion towards the union despite her upbringing in a confederate state. A woman who actively bought slaves to free them, and later continued to her honorable deeds to benefit the union. This paper will argue that, Elizabeth Van Lew selflessly put the Union needs above her own, knowing that it was a dangerous act. Her motivations were pure and unselfish. The altruistic acts that she committed to resulted in her being one of the most successful and heroic union spies.

Read More

Charlotte Geaghan-Breiner's Argument

333 Words | 2 Pages

What makes Charlotte Geaghan- Breiner’s essay an academic argument is the evidence proven from research to back up her argument. She uses this argument to put sense into an audience of anyone who has children and give them information on how nature can be the solution to many problems. The type of argument Geaghan-

Read More

Existing Argument: Response Cohen's Harm To Children

246 Words | 1 Pages

Interest in Existing Argument is the response Cohen gives to proponents of her Harm to Children Argument, to whom which uses these new reproductive technologies. Cohen’s critique of these proponents of new reproductive technologies is, she believes that it is better to be alive than not to be, even if there is health risks to children conceived through IVF. Cohen believes that serious illness and defects are not necessarily a deterring cause (with the exception of serous cases) because, its better to be alive than to not exist at all. " …in almost all cases, better to be alive than not, and these children would not be alive but for the employment of these techniques, using them to bring these children into the world is justified." (textbook

Read More

Ethos And Pathos In Margaret Sanger's Speech

1351 Words | 6 Pages

In her pilgrimage to fight for women’s rights, activist Margaret Sanger created a speech on a severely controversial topic not only during her time period, but during our present time period as well. While many firmly disagreed with her and still do, she did bring to light a major disparity between sexes and social classes. By vocalizing her qualms with the rights of women, mainly in the middle and lower classes, to decide for themselves if they wish to have children or not. By voicing her opinions in an extremely misogynistic era she made herself a totem in women’s history. Women do have a right to decide for themselves if they wish to have children or not.

Read More

Margaret Sanger The Children's Era Speech Analysis

520 Words | 3 Pages

The argument over a woman’s right to choose over the life of an unborn baby has been a prevalent issue in America for many years. As a birth control activist, Margaret Sanger is recognized for her devotion to the pro-choice side of the debate as she has worked to provide sex education and legalize birth control. As part of her pro-choice movement, Sanger delivered a speech at the Sixth International Neo-Malthusian and Birth Control Conference in March of 1925. This speech is called “The Children’s Era,” in which she explains how she wants the twentieth century to become the “century of the child.” Margaret Sanger uses pathos throughout her speech as she brings up many of the negative possibilities that unplanned parenthood can bring for both children and parents.

Read More

Comparing Rosalind Hursthouse's Virtue Theory And Abortion

1529 Words | 7 Pages

Such considerations fundamentally shape human life and family relationships. A women needs to be aware of the various psychological and social factors that contribute to the decision such as “that human parents, both male and female, tend to care passionately about their offspring, and that family relationships are among the deepest and strongest in our lives—and, significantly, among the longest lasting.” These key intrinsic goods- in this case factors such as human life, parenthood, and family relationships- are ultimately worthwhile are not to be taken without due

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Abigail Williams

466 Words | 2 Pages

Today, God shined a light of savior upon myself and the prisoners of Salem. Despite this relief, the horrific tragedies visualized by the community can never be erased from the past; it’s a nightmare stuck on replay. Obvious to a portion of the community, there’s only one to blame for the destruction: Abigail Williams. The lying whore remains responsible for the deaths of many innocent lives including my dearest husband’s.

Read More

Margaret Sanger Speech Analysis

1446 Words | 6 Pages

These people do not control the size of their families, and they just have children even if they don’t plan on having them, and that is why Margaret Sanger want her audience to have knowledge of birth control, so they can control the size of their families, and so they won’t just have children whenever they don’t take care of themselves. Where they might end up giving these children up, or where these children might end up suffering, or where women just end up having abortions, and these are some reasons why Margaret Sanger opened up a clinic to help people to plan

Read More

Summary Of A Defense Of Abortion Judith Thomson

1070 Words | 5 Pages

In “A Defense of Abortion,” Judith Thomson argues with a unique approach regarding the topic of abortion. For the purpose of the argument, Thomas agrees to go against her belief and constructs an argument based on the idea that the fetus is a person at conception. She then formulates her arguments concerning that the right to life is not an absolute right. There are certain situations where abortion is morally permissible. She believes that the fetus’s right to life does not outweigh the right for the woman to control what happens to her own body.

Read More

Sacrifice In Toni Morrison's In Beloved

1238 Words | 5 Pages

Parenting has been a long practice that desires and demands unconditional sacrifices. Sacrifice is something that makes motherhood worthwhile. The mother-child relationship can be a standout amongst the most convoluted, and fulfilling, of all connections. Women are fuel by self-sacrifice and guilt - but everyone is the better for it. Their youngsters, who feel adored; whatever is left of us, who are saved disagreeable experiences with adolescents raised without affection or warmth; and mothers most importantly.

Read More

The Social Imagination: A Sociological Analysis

632 Words | 3 Pages

When a woman chooses to keep her baby, it may not be her decision; it may be her moral duty to the society influenced by her family’s pressure and religious belief. However, if she considers the broad social factors that will shape and influence her views, and that will allow her to make individual choices such as whether to keep her baby or not, she is applying what C. Wright Mills’ called the Social Imagination. James Henslin (2013) stated that C. Wright Mills’s sociological imagination gives us the ability “to understand how our personal troubles (the problems we experience) are connected to the broader conditions of our society” (p. 2). It allows us to question the “norms” and gives us the ability to see things from different perspectives

Read More

Hispanic Women Roles

516 Words | 3 Pages

The girls in favor of pro-choice shared that sometimes these children are left without parents. They are either left in orphanages or in foster care. Not all children have the right support and may feel unwanted as they grow up. Furthermore, some families cannot afford to have a child because they are not financially stabled. Some people feel they are not prepared to be parents.

Read More

Effects Of War In Persepolis

651 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine what it would feel like to live in a constant war zone. In the graphic novel Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi (published in 2000), Satrapi writes about her life growing up in Iran during the Islamic revolution. Throughout the book, Marjane speaks of her childhood and the experiences she had. Towards the end of the novel, the revolution became more and more dangerous and young children's lives were lost. At this point, Marjane’s family had to make difficult decisions about their next step in life.

Read More

Rational Choice Theory On Abortion

726 Words | 3 Pages

Rational choice theory is a framework for understanding and modeling social behavior. Kane and Staiger’s model is predicated on the assumption that women make rational decisions about sexual activity, contraceptive usage, and pregnancy resolution based on a comparison of the respective costs and benefits of each alternative. One of the costs of risky sexual activity is an unintended pregnancy. Women choose the optimal alternative depending on their values and the information they have available to them (i.e., make an economically rational decision). The underlying premise of rational choice theory is that women make choices that are rewarding to them and avoid those that are not.

Read More

Opinion Essay About Not Having Kids

880 Words | 4 Pages

I think I am more aligned to the position I think I am more aligned to the position of people who decide not to have kids. I think the decisions someone makes of having or not having kids, should be based on the happiness it brings to you. All reasons have an explain on why they are doing it, some people feel more happy not having kids because it gives them more time to focus on themselves. I think I am more inclined to people who decide not to have children Even though I am already a parent and I wouldn’t picture my life without her I agree with the people who decide not to take that route. .

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Elizabeth Barnes

Related Topics

Open Document