Pros And Cons Of Shays Rebellion
Last night on February 4, 1787, General Benjamin Lincoln attacked members of the Shays’ Rebellion, and successfully captured 150 of the rebels. As a result, Daniel Shays left Massachusetts and fled to Vermont. Shays Rebellion was an armed rebellion consisting of 1,200 angry farmers from Massachusetts. They caused major chaos in this state. On December 26, 1786 Daniel Shays and the rebels revolted in Springfield, Massachusetts insisting that the state legislature address their issues, such as lack of money.
They all had an immense amount of debt due to the government not paying the veterans, and the taxes being increased for farming. This led to Daniel Shays becoming one of the numerous leaders of the rebellions. At first they tried to change the laws peacefully by having a petition for them stating that the veterans and farmers were being treated unfairly because these new laws, guidelines, and new legislature rules (legislature was controlled by merchant interest). Therefore since the legislature was controlled by eastern merchant interest the petitions were declined which caused even more issues for the veterans and farmers. Protests began to increase tremendously, in August 1786 the legislature was going to have a court meeting considering the many petitions against the rebellions, but Shays had formed a protest that marched to the courthouse and prevented them from having the court sitting.
Hieu, I completely agree with your views on the two main struggles the Founding Fathers encountered while developing the foundation for this great nation. Your views on both taxation and the Shays ' Rebellion are very similar to mine. It 's crazy that a society in that time frame didn 't adopt the Europeans way of taxation, which evolved around the king and his government. Another good point you have is how it was up to the individual states to fend for themselves for protection. Where the thirteen colonies just finished working together to defeat Great Britain in the Revolutionary War.
This event was a test to show if the new country could take the violence current countries had to take. Shays Rebellion showed the American government was weak and needed a change soon. This event was so tragic that this led to the destruction of The Articles of Confederation. In current day America we are now governed by a stronger government under The Constitution that is why the event is so important in American history and that is why I chose this event.
Farmers in the Shay’s Rebellion were treated unfairly . Although the farmers in Shay’s Rebellion were considered reckless rebels, nevertheless they should be recognized as freedom fighters because they fought for things to be fair, they protested for people’s rights to be better, and they fought for what they thought was right. First of all, the farmers fought for things to be fair because many things were not fair to them and to others . According to class notes, “Farmers were losing land and going to jail,” this shows that they were treated unfairly and they were getting punished for doing nothing.
One effect of the bad government was Shays rebellion. Daniel Shay was a farmer, and at that time, the farmers couldn’t
Shayś Rebellious Ways Shay and his followers were a group of farmers out to no good. After the American revolution, the US was without money, so they raised taxes. Farmers who couldn 't pay were thrown in jail so a rebellion started. Shay and about 1,500 farmers stole weapons and fought. Some people say that the people in Shay 's Rebellion were freedom fighters, nevertheless Shay and his followers were rebels because they protested violently, caused chaos in the country, and were criminals.
At some point our National Government was so weak that we were unable to prevent violence and stop protest. The Shay's Rebellion proved that as well. What used to be our national government was the Article of Confederation. Though after the disaster of the Shay's Rebellion, they decided that they needed a change. They decided to revise the Articles of Confederation and they came up with a whole new document called the Constitution.
This is because Shays rebellion took place because the poor farmers were fighting against the outrageous taxes which were leaving them without land and in prison with no means of supplying food for their families. In many states at the time if someone didn't have land they weren't able to vote because in the governments eyes they had no power. These taxes were taking away the farmers land which then also took away their right to vote which left them powerless and made their options pointless. Poor farmers ended up in jail which left their families out on the streets begging for money and a means to survive. Just like the whiskey rebellion farmers were left without a way to supply for their family because the demand of whiskey was way down after the government increase the tax by 25%.
The farmers of Western Massachusetts were particularly upset about this, and began protesting against the failure of the colonies support. The popular Daniel Shays, a former captain in the Continental Army, led a rebellion. He demanded more paper money, tax relief for debtors and an end to imprisonment for debt. During 1786, Shays and his followers traveled around the colonies preventing the collection of
The next year, a problem occurred by the Massachusetts farmers that later became known as Shay’s Rebellion, broke out. The
The rebellion was a sign of justification for constitutional reform. As a result, the Articles of Confederation were revised not long after the end of the rebellion, thus the new consitution was signed on September 17th, 1787. In a way, Shay’s Rebellion also resulted in geographical change. With the new constitution, slavery was left out of the discussion, which paved the way for tensions to rise and cause the American Civil War.
Shay’s Rebellion Many farmers in the newly settled areas of central and eastern Massachusetts suffered from high debt as they tried to establish new farms. Unlike some of the other state legislatures, Massachusetts did not pass pro-debtor laws such as forgiving debt or printing more paper money. Instead, they had local sheriffs seize property and farms and place those farmers that could not afford to pay their debts into prison. This led to the first armed rebellion in the post-Revolutionary United States. The protestors believed that they were protecting the “good of the commonwealth” and opposing the “tyrannical government in the Massachusetts state” (Keene 2013).
Shay’s Rebellions follow the Revolutionary war and how the US fell into a economic crisis, There were a lot of tension due to farmers losing their property to to debt collectors. In January 1787, him and his force were sent to a federal armory at Springfield but it failed due the artillery fire and how it lead to 4 people being killed and 20 people being wounded. Rebellion doesn’t always end up peaceful and it can also show no improvement at.
Due to the fact that Massachusetts was newly settled, yeoman farmers were attempting to build new farms resulting in debt that the farmers could not pay. The yeoman farmers were also in debt because of a post-war recession, lack of payment of their army stipends, and failure to receive payment for their bonds. These debts lead to farmers being arrested which caused the anger that lead to the creation of Shays’ Rebellion. Other states with this problem were passing laws to protect their farmers during this economic crisis, but Massachusetts did not which further angered the lower class. The already poor farmers were forced to give up their land as payment because the farmers could not pay their debts in specie.
More about Pros And Cons Of Shays Rebellion
Shays Rebellion Research Paper
270 Words | 2 PagesDaniel Shays: Heroic Military Service In The Continental Army
961 Words | 4 PagesSimilarities Between Taxation And Shays Rebellion
143 Words | 1 PagesWhy Was Shays Rebellion So Important In American History
84 Words | 1 PagesFarmers In Shay's Rebellion
316 Words | 2 PagesConfederation Strengths And Weaknesses
294 Words | 2 PagesCauses Of Shay's Rebellion After The American Revolution Dbq
569 Words | 3 PagesShay's Rebellion: Shared Powers Between State And Federal Government
566 Words | 3 PagesCompare And Contrast Shays Rebellion And Whiskey Rebellion
1002 Words | 5 PagesExamples Of Ratifying The Articles Of Confederation
1081 Words | 5 PagesJohn Hancock's Life And Accomplishments
767 Words | 4 PagesGeographical And Social Changes As A Result Of The Back Country Rebellions
802 Words | 4 PagesWhat Are The Causes Of Shay's Rebellion
470 Words | 2 PagesOscar Wilde's Essay: The Role Of Disobedience In Society
1034 Words | 5 PagesWhiskey Rebellion Essay
849 Words | 4 Pages