ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Vehicle Checkpoints

1291 Words6 Pages

Are the critics’ argument meritorious?
There is a lot of opposition when considering the constitutionality of vehicle checkpoints. I can see both side of the fence per se. Several different types of checkpoints are utilized throughout the United States. For example, an impaired driver checkpoint can be extremely beneficial while detecting irresponsible drivers who make a conscious decision to operate a motor vehicle after consumptions of alcohol causing danger not only to themselves but to every other driver on the roadway. Driver License check points allow police to ensure that citizens are driving around within the laws of their state.
On the flip side, the fourth amendment protects citizens from unlawful searches and detainments. While its ok to check for sobriety at checkpoints it shouldn’t be ok to detain someone without reasonable suspicion. While we all enjoy the benefits that our constitution affords, can we honestly say that detaining someone for an unreasonable amount of time is ok? No, we shouldn’t. While checkpoints benefit the clear majority of law abiding citizens they shouldn’t be used in a fashion to deprive them of their liberties.
Discuss the state of law as it concerns victim input into plea bargaining.
While plea bargaining can be an effective tool for the prosecution victims have a right to …show more content…

The first right that a defendant’s rights to manifestation could be manifested is the right to appear to trial. Physical presence and mental competence can be assessed to make sure the defendant understands the outcomes of the trial. The second right is that the defendant has the right to live witness testimony. The defendant has the right to hear the testimony of involved parties and witnesses. Lastly the defendant has a right to challenge witness testimony in court. In layman terms the defendant can challenge what the witness is stating that implicates them during the

Show More
Related

State Police Vs. Sitz Case Study

76 Words | 1 Pages

In Michigan Dept. of State Police v. Sitz, 496 U.S. 444 (1990), the Court upheld a warrantless, suspicionless checkpoint designed to detect evidence of drunk driving. In that case, police checkpoints were set up, at which all drivers were stopped and briefly (approximately 25 seconds) observed for signs of intoxication. If such signs were found, the driver was detained for sobriety testing, and if the indication was that the driver was intoxicated, an arrest was

Read More

Maryland Vs Pringle Case Study

1331 Words | 6 Pages

Given the totality of circumstances, an officer has satisfied the probable cause standard to arrest an individual believing that a felony is or has occurred in the officer’s presents. This type of warrantless arrest does not violate an individual’s Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights. Decision: Chief Justice Rehnquist delivered the Court’s opinion on this case. The Fourth Amendment guarantees that citizens “are to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause” This right is pushed down to the state level by way of the Fourteenth Amendment. This ensures that warrantless arrests can be conducted by police officers when the standard of probable cause has been met.

Read More

Case Brief State Of Oregon Vs Harris

569 Words | 3 Pages

It is the defendants constitutional right in the state of Oregon, to have the victim at trial face to face with the defendant. The Oregon law says: "Article I, section 11, of the Oregon Constitution provides a criminal defendant the right "to meet the witnesses face to face." That right of confrontation is not absolute, though. If the state shows that a witness is "unavailable," it may offer reliable hearsay evidence without presenting a live witness at trial. The issue in this case is what is required to establish the witness is unavailable" (Oregon v. Harris 2017).

Read More

Terry V. Ohio Tests The Limitations Of The Fourth Amendment

841 Words | 4 Pages

The case of Terry v. Ohio tests the limitations of the fourth amendment. On October 31st, 1963, three men were acting suspicious on the streets of Ohio. A police officer noticed three men walking back and forth and peering into a store as if they were planning to rob it. They continued doing so and ended up meeting with another person. At that point, officer McFadden approached to stop and frisk for any weapons or drugs.

Read More

No Probable Cause To Arrest Hayes Essay

551 Words | 3 Pages

Where there was no probable cause to arrest Hayes, no consent to go to the police station, and no prior judicial authorization for detaining him, the investigative detention at the station for fingerprinting purposes violated Hayes rights under the Fourth Amendment, as made applicable to the States by the Fourteenth Amendment. Reasoning: The police without a warrant or probable cause removed a subject from his home and transported him to the police station, where he was not free to go, although he was there briefly for questioning, In addition fingerprinted him.

Read More

Riley Vs California Research Paper

833 Words | 4 Pages

“Riley v. California”) Bensur and Brokamp say in their article that in court, Riley claimed that his Fourth Amendment right was violated because the officers did not have probable cause also called reasonable suspicion to examine his phone. The case went to the Supreme Court and the judges agreed that the police had acted

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Stop And Frisk

780 Words | 4 Pages

The act of “Stop and Frisk” began in the early 1900’s when crime rates began to escalate in major cities such as New York, Chicago, and Philadelphia. Stop, question, and frisk, or SQF, is an urban policing measure that involves the large-scale deployment of officers in public spaces (e.g., sidewalks, alleys, the communal outdoor spaces of public housing) tasked with conducting frequent investigative stops (Huq, A. Z. (2017). In the articles provided, it is questioned whether New York’s stop and frisk policy is constitutional or not. I agree with the court's ruling, I believe Judge Scheindlin seemed too involved. “Judge Shira A. Scheindlin, the appeals court said, jeopardized "the appearance of partiality ... by a series of media interviews and public statements purporting to respond publicly to criticism of the District Court”

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Should The NSA Surveillance

169 Words | 1 Pages

The whole point of the Fourth Amendment is not to completely stop the police, because the amendment can be waived if an officer has a warrant, or a person’s consent. The Fourth Amendment states that generally a search or seizure is illegal unless there is a warrant, or special circumstances. Technically stating that a citizen is protected by the Fourth Amendment, until a government employee gets a warrant, and then they can invade a citizen’s privacy. Also people state that the FISA Court’s warrants are constitutional, but the NSA’s surveillance is unconstitutional. Even though people do not like the NSA’s surveillance, the NSA is legal because the FISA Court that the people did not mind makes it legal.

Read More

6th Amendment Importance

847 Words | 4 Pages

For them to know the defendant they would be biased in their decisions. The arraignment clause makes the charges clear and understandable. It used to be that people would be put in jail without the knowledge of what they were put there for. Confrontation clause deals with the witness in a trial. The defendant now has the right to have the witness directly involved be brought to the stand.

Read More

Sitcom Stereotypes

1405 Words | 6 Pages

The sitcom is a type of television series, consisting a number of programmes in which episodes share the same situations and characters, but are separate from the others in the series in term of their plot lines. Two characteristics of sitcoms are stereotype and circular narrative. Stereotypes are used in sitcoms to familiarise the audience with characters right from the beginning. This helps us know what to expect from them, eg the stereotype ditzy blonde is used in 'Friends' to play Phoebe a weird/dizzy hippy. The stereotype 'senior jock' is used in 'The Middle' to play Axl, a ladies' man who is 'dumb'.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On The Fourth Amendment

427 Words | 2 Pages

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures shall not be violated… We all know the fourth amendment. It's the amendment that guarantees our safety within our homes and our personal belongings. Yet, how much do you know about the fourth amendment? The fourth amendment is full of history, controversy, and discussion, even in modern day.

Read More

Importance Of The Fourth Amendment

1058 Words | 5 Pages

Even with it, the current protests in Chicago show concern about people's Fourth Amendment rights. Many police officers in Chicago pullover and search people’s cars due to “suspicious” signs of drugs. Most of the people pulled over are black and this not only creates racial tension between

Read More

Benefits Of The Fourth Amendment

752 Words | 4 Pages

In addition, the law enforcement only needs to be “supported by a probable cause” or an “arrest warrant,” to search a United States citizen. Although, the police officer could arrest a suspect to stop them from running away or to preserve evidence. Besides the Fourth Amendment is still beneficial for all United States

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Stop And Frisk

796 Words | 4 Pages

Talks about is the stop-and-frisk legal in the United States and they have the fourth amendment on this situation. Terry v Ohio case resulted in the stop-and-frisk issue. HISTORY: Stop-and-frisk also known as “stop-and-search, began in the 1950’s. It gave police the legal right to search someone warrantless, if it had something to do with the law.

Read More

Case: State Of California Vs. Scott Lee Peterson

716 Words | 3 Pages

This aspect is concerned with the powers that be placing the defendant on trial, and proving that a law had been violated by

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Vehicle Checkpoints

Related Topics

Open Document