ipl-logo

Psychoanalytical Lens In Willa Cather's My Antonia

748 Words3 Pages

Was Willa Cather’s widely recognized novel, My Antonia, titled after the wrong character? Jim concludes his memoir stating that Antonia “still had that something which fires the imagination.... All the strong things of her heart came out in her body.... She was a rich mine of life, like the founders of early races” which seemingly proves that Antonia is Jim’s soul inspiration, the heroine of the novel (Cather 211). However, if this is the case, why would Jim ostensibly forget her for a whole chapter to fixate on a different character? Antonia also never seems to meet Jim’s expectations, for it is Lena that makes an appearance in Jim's subconscious, not Antonia. Although Jim may be unaware, the Psychoanalytical Lens helps explain why in the …show more content…

In book two Jim describes a dream that he had of Lena coming to him “across the stubble barefoot, in a short skirt, with a curved reaping-hook in her hand, and she was flushed like the dawn, with a kind of luminous rosiness all about her” (135-136). He goes on to wish that he could have this dream about Antonia, but is unable to. As explained in an article about the psychoanalytic theory by Saul McLeod, a Psychology Tutor at The University of Manchester, dreams portray what feelings lay in the subconscious. Jim's inability to have this dream about Antonia shows that though Jim may be unaware, his true feelings are for Lena.
When taking a psychoanalytical approach to My Antonia, it becomes apparent that Lena Lingard is the central female character. Throughout Jim’s maturation, Lena becomes the focus and idealization for Jim and manifests into his subconscious. Ultimately, Antonia is not Jim’s sole inspiration. According to Kim Wells the author of the paper, Hired Girls and Country Doctors: Working Women in the Domestic Fiction of Sarah Orne Jewett and Willa Cather, Lena is “Jim’s Muse, allowing him deeper insight into the poetry of Virgil just by virtue of her appearance in his room for a short visit”

Show More
Related
146 Words | 1 Pages

Minerva is making a sacrifice by giving up her son to her sister; Patria isn 't ready to do so, but expresses her support for her sister 's movement. Her ominous words are foreshadowing. It lets the reader know that things are intense and that they are only going to require even more sacrifice from the characters. She is going to be traveling a lot on the road, and coming back weekly for her revolutionary activities. Patria, ever the mother, at first doesn 't understand how anyone could give up their child, because the time and sacrifice it takes to raise and take care of one is already enough.

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

The setting of a story not only includes the material, physical settings, but the context and the ‘mental’ settings of the character are important as well. Ann is still a young woman compared to John, “eager for excitement and distractions” (401) and finds her relationship with her husband monotonous; to the point where they don’t even talk to each other as she sees no point in “talk[ing] with a man who never talked” (399). In fact, Ann found most of her neighbours the same way; finding no reason to talk about crops, cattle and other neighbours with them. Ann was alone, with no one to bring any interest to her life with the exception of Steven. When Steven came over during the storm, she “felt eager” and “challenged” (403) for the first time in a while; she even changed into a dress and did her hair to impress him.

Read More
687 Words | 3 Pages

This visitation had intensified the already vivid memories of his childhood. Lena’s visit had brought along an aura of warm and friendship with her. Lena’s visit had brought along a surge of flashbacks as Jim had stated he could plainly hear the laughs of the Danish and Bohemian girls. However, Lena eventually has to leave and Jim’s best days fled with her. Though everyone goes through a cycle of some sort throughout their life the one I have witnessed while reading My Antonia is to an extent is very different.

Read More
537 Words | 3 Pages

Lena added that she was a girl and her heels, to help Milkman to understand that she shouldn’t have to be the one, to have helped him go to the bathroom. Lena doesn’t realize that just by saying that she is a “girl” as an excuse, is making herself seem that she is just useless and inferior to everyone. A lot of people just like Lena have done the same as her, that just by their own gender they are and always will be inferior to men, because of this small incident that has happened to her in the past, is the main reason why she loaths

Read More
565 Words | 3 Pages

Antonia was around the same age as Jim so she gravitated toward him. Jim was Antonia's first friend when they moved to Nebraska. Jim taught Antonia how to speak English

Read More
439 Words | 2 Pages

In the 1920s to 1930s the US had experienced some immeasurable and distressed times known as the Great depression. People had difficulty doing basic things like providing food for their families, getting jobs and having a stable income. The segregation between black and whites did not stop even in these terrible times. The food crisis was a significant problem during the Great Depression.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

“The Veldt” is a short story by Ray Bradbury. This story can be analyzed using a Marxist and psychoanalytical perspective. For both of these perspectives, the main evidence is found in the kids and their relationship with their parents. For Marxist, “The Veldt” shows how the family relationship reveals the oppression of the lower class and their battle to become the new upper class. The structure of power in this can be connected to the power struggle of today’s society.

Read More
321 Words | 2 Pages

Ann is isolated with no one to talk to, and has to resort to speaking to herself, slowly convincing herself in doubt, with no one to set her straight

Read More
841 Words | 4 Pages

My Antonia: Jim and Tony’s Unrequited Relationship “I’d like you to have you for a sweetheart, or a wife, or my mother or my sister, anything that a woman can be to a man (206).” Jim Burden, a young man, narrated his memories and friendship with a young immigrant named Antonia Shimerda. My Antonia was a novel that showed incapable relationship between two characters, but displayed the real beauty and love in life. Willa Cather’s book illustrated how the main characters created a strong friendship, but, were separated from a relationship by societal norms and expectations.

Read More
1375 Words | 6 Pages

Willa Cather’s short story, “Paul’s Case” is about a young man who is determined to make his aspirations a reality by all means necessary. That meant being deceitful as a start of gaining control and social status and telling lies to get to where he felt like he belonged, but where did he belong? This desire was the beginning of a journey that would eventually leave him with nothing. There is something unusual about Paul, something that can only be explained by his demeanor and actions throughout the story. With that said, I intend to construct a complete character analysis of Paul as he searches for satisfaction.

Read More
513 Words | 3 Pages

Town life wears at Antonia and Jim’s innocence—Antonia capers with young men at a local dancing tent, and Jim flirts with pretty Bohemian immigrant Lena Lingard. Later at college, Jim’s secret love for Lena and close friendship with her distract him from his studies. Escaping to Harvard for renewed

Read More
1881 Words | 8 Pages

As the guilt consumes Ann, she begins to remember John’s loyalty. John would always come back. Ann thinks that she is imagining John as one of the shadows because: “a gleam of light revealed his face”. She can not stop thinking about John and her decision to betray him. The sense of loneliness and the temptation she faced motivated her to become desperate for a connection; the result was not fulfilling, Ann had given up all she had for temporary

Read More
855 Words | 4 Pages

Challenges of Immigration: The Shimerda’s Struggle Willa Cather’s novel, My Ántonia sheds light on the topic of immigration. Immigrants have many different reasons for why they might migrate to the United States. Some were trying to escape something from their old country such as avoiding a war, trouble with the law, or shame as is the case of the Russians Pavel and Peter. Reasons for immigrating could also relate to chasing the American dream as is the case with the Shimerdas.

Read More
1503 Words | 7 Pages

Shakespeare, like any other man in the 16th and 17th century, saw ambitious and dominant women as evil and even disturbing or disturbed. From Macbeth, we can see Shakespeare feels women should be challenged and punished because they are trying to change society. Nowadays these ambitious and dominant women are regarded as brave and respected because of their ambition, such as Lady Macbeth’s ambition to become Queen. Shakespeare presents Lady Macbeth as mentally disturbed.

Read More
702 Words | 3 Pages

Lena is a caring woman who loves her family. She is understanding of the problems of others, and can look past their mistakes no matter the gravity of what they've done. Even though both of her children are grown adults, she still has the motherly drive to protect them as if they were still young children.

Read More

More about Psychoanalytical Lens In Willa Cather's My Antonia

Related Topics

Open Document