ipl-logo

Pyrrhic Defeat Model

663 Words3 Pages

In The Rich Get Richer and the Poor Get Prison, Jeffery Reiman argues that the best way to understand our policies toward crime is through the Pyrrhic Defeat model. Basically, it explains the failure of policies within the criminal justice system to reduce crime. According to Reiman, the criminal justice system does not eliminate all crime. It deals with a smaller portion in order to keep it from completely getting out of control. Crime is not drastically reduced, and it is never eliminated, therefore it is always present in society. Moreover, the whole system develops a stigma against the poor, who are trapped by it, while the rich go on living their lives unaffected. Reiman supports the Pyrrhic Defeat Theory by arguing that by not eliminating the poverty that causes people to commit crimes, society is actually failing to protect people from crime. This is most likely valid given the fact that most of prison population is poor. If society wants to eliminate …show more content…

The first is that criminal law does not define crime properly because it does not include the most dangerous antisocial behavior that takes place (Reiman, p. 67). The second is that police and prosecutors do not make charge and arrest decisions based on criteria that will help them get the most dangerous criminals (Reiman, p. 67). The third is that criminal convictions are also not necessarily the ones that are most dangerous (Reiman, p. 67). The fourth is that the decisions that sentencing judges make are not made with the intentions of protecting society from the most dangerous criminals, nor do they reflect proper punishment according to the crime and the harm done by it (Reiman, p. 67). The fifth is that the first four hypotheses validate that criminal acts are indirectly identified with the poor (Reiman, p.

Show More
Related

Reiman's Arguments Against Common Sense

248 Words | 1 Pages

Reiman begins his essay be explaining and describing the reasons in which he is against the common sense idea. The basis behind this theory is that common sense would tell someone that if something cost higher than something else, then fewer people will choose the item that cost more. Reiman offers three arguments in which he disagrees that the common sense idea will deter crime. The first one being that just because a person fears one penalty more than another, does not mean that this will deter the criminal behavior. It was stated that there is an equal likelihood of crime being deterred for the death penalty than there is for life behind bars.

Read More

Summary Of The Rich Get Richer And The Poor Get Prison

1586 Words | 7 Pages

One of the theories it speaks of is the Pyrrhic defeat theory. This theory states that the criminal justice system is created to function in a particular fashion in order to create an image of crime where crime is actually seen as the “threat from the poor”.(Reiman, 2010, p.5) “Reimans’s theory suggests that those who have power to change the system benefit from the way it operates: they can go on committing harms and accumulating wealth without punishment, while the country remains focused on street crime and poor minority criminals. ”(Leighton 2010) In order to accomplish this “The system must actually fight crime-or at least some crime-but only enough to keep it from getting out of hand and to keep the struggle to substantially reduce or eliminate crime.

Read More

Political Ideas Underpinning Criminological Theory

1997 Words | 8 Pages

The right, over the past 30 years, have significantly impacted on these debates by providing a new way of thinking that focuses on the individual and their responsibility, thus breaking away from liberal ideas that focused on the welfare state. Central to the criminal justice system was deterrence which characterised the use of prisons and toughening of laws and extension of powers of the police, by appealing to the fear of crime. This has resorted in conflict with those on the left who argue that the right fail to address social conditions in which crime arises, and by extending the powers of the police, it marginalises disadvantaged individuals further. The impact of political ideas on criminological theories and crime control stem from public opinion, which inform political tactics that determine who has influence in the political

Read More

Mass Incarceration Literature Review

1728 Words | 7 Pages

This issue led to what is now resulting in mass incarceration. Mass incarceration has been shown to affect mostly poor and minorities. Individuals living in poverty are not afforded the same royalties as those who are not in poverty. They are more willing to commit crimes because of their lack of fortune. The crime rate is more prone to be in urban communities, which hold a significant number of minorities.

Read More

The Similarities Between Feminism And Radical Criminology

699 Words | 3 Pages

Radical Criminology beliefs are founded in that crime is a result of social conditions that empower the wealthy and rewarded those that are in control of the political system while punishing and oppressing those who are not wealthy or in control of the political system. (Schmalleger, pg. 152) Radical Criminology holds the same belief as Marxist Criminology, that there are at least two social classes, the bourgeoisie class or the haves and the proletariat class or the have-nots. (Schmalleger, pg. 153) With that belief, Radical

Read More

Social Disorganization Theory Vs Conflict Theory Analysis

1132 Words | 5 Pages

Conflict theory assumes that the power struggle between competing social groups is natural or inherent. It assumes that the law favors the powerful and that the system is biased. Little empirical evidence supports this, because it is hard to test this theory. Alan Lizotee studied cases and found that race and socioeconomic status did influence sentencing decisions, while some studies have shown the opposite. (Adler et al.,

Read More

Theories Of Conflict Criminology

174 Words | 1 Pages

Five conflict theories are presented by Schmallenger in chapter 9 in an effort to explain crime and criminality: radical criminology, left-realist criminology, feminist criminology, peacemaking criminology, and conflict criminology. Radical criminology considers social conditions that disadvantage the lower classes and empower the more powerful as the cause of crime. Capitalism is pointed to in radical criminology as a cause of criminality. Left-realist criminology holds that crime is a problem of the lower social class, seeing “street criminals as…acting out of…deprivation,” while the ruling class are the “real criminals” (Schmallenger, p. 227). Feminist criminology seeks to explain crime from a gender perspective, noting that the causes

Read More

Herbert Packer Two Models Of The Criminal Process Summary

624 Words | 3 Pages

In “Two Models of the Criminal Process” Herbert Packer highlights two competing systems of value found in the criminal justice system, the Crime Control Model and the Due Process Model. Through the models, Packer does not make an attempt to establish what should or shouldn’t be done or what is “good” or “bad,” but rather aims to classify how different players in the criminal justice system value certain ideals and how that affects the outcomes or actions taken within the justice system. Although these values represent polar opposites values within the system, there is a grey area or spectrum of people who hold different values from both of the models. Though people hold a plethora of different values to heart, Packer’s “Two Models of the Criminal

Read More

Rational Choice Theory: Cesare Beccaria And Jeremy Bentham

537 Words | 3 Pages

Another criticism of the classical theory is that deterrence and rational choice theory both overlook social factors of crime (Bazelon, 2015). If criminal offending arises out of a temporary irrationality, classical theory fails to explain why the distribution of crime (according to official data) is not spread evenly among the social structure (White, Haines and Asquith, 2012). Cornish and Clarke (1986) argue that for some individuals, offending may only be considered rational in a way which is not responsive to the deterrence resulting from punishment. In a society where social inequalities are predominant, universal equality cannot be achieved by viewing everyone equally before the law (White, Haines and Asquith, 2012). Rational choice may cause some individuals to offend exactly as a result of social inequalities (White, Haines and Asquith,

Read More

Just Deserts Theory

1782 Words | 8 Pages

Through the decades, crime and crime control have been analyzed in an attempt to find the causes of crime and decide how to combat them. The United States showed an increase in their prison population in the 1970s when the country turned towards a more punitive justice system. Referred to as just deserts theory of crime, the aim is to inflict as much pain on the offender through harsh prison sentences, in hopes to cause as much pain as the crime they committed. The worse the crime is, the worse the punishment the criminal will endure. The issue surrounding just deserts theory is the vast amount of offenders who return to prison after being released, also known as the recidivism rate.

Read More

Criminal Justice Policies

958 Words | 4 Pages

While many criminal justice policies are loosely based on criminological theories if at all. The lack of consideration for criminological theories could come from the reluctance of scholars to test out the implications of theories on policy. In addition policymakers may simply be unfamiliar with crime theories and therefore have no theoretical knowledge to inform polices. Programs that lack theoretical support are more likely to fail, proving that many criminal justice policies are unlikely to be effective due to poor conceptualization. Even polices that are grounded in theory often are not well supported or are difficult to implement.

Read More

Criminological Theory

1506 Words | 7 Pages

Although, other researchers have suggested that punishment might not be answer to reduce crime rates, it is evident that the United States will continue with this procedure. Another key point important to realize is that the classical criminologists’ main intention was to reform the “judicial and legal system to make it more rational and fair”, which will also continue to be part the criminal and legal procedures as stated in the United States Constitution (Akers, 2013, p. 15). Moreover, Beccaria and Bentham argued that it would be prudent to increase citizens’ participation in political matters to obtain more control of the government’s decisions, which is currently known as a form of democracy. Therefore, it must remembered that thanks to the authors of the Classical theory, the United States presently has a reasonable legal system in which the punishment is proportional to the

Read More

Karl Marx Research Paper

961 Words | 4 Pages

Radical criminology, also related to this direction and popular in the West in the 1960s, views criminality as a class and ethnic inequality. Many theorists of conflict consider the capitalist system in the economy to be the main prerequisite for the formation of deviant behavior, that is why the solution of the current situation is possible due to the complete reorganization of the existing system, as well as the formation of a new system in which the distribution of resources among the haves and indigent members of society will be more just. Signs of deviant behavior can be found at every level of society, but the definition of the concept of such behavior is often associated with the socio-class position of a person. It is obvious that people from high society who have wealth, power, power and influence play a key role in shaping what is considered deviant behavior and what is not.

Read More

The Four Crimes Of Crime

927 Words | 4 Pages

It said to sad that crime is a big part of society .There are numerous of reason why a person commit a crime, here a couple of them it could be the person lifestyle , how they was raise, another reason crime is committed because the person could be envy and jealous of a person so they result in crime and also people commit crime because they are pure evil and have no morals and do not care about right and wrong. The four crimes I am going to introduce and speak about is four major crime that take place in society. The four crimes I choose was violent crimes, property crime, larceny/ theft, and aggravated assault. The first crime I will introduce is violent crime, it is one of the crime that cause bodily harm. The next crime that will be mention

Read More

Essay On Poverty And Crime

832 Words | 4 Pages

Crime offers a way in which poor people can obtain material goods they cannot attain through legal means. Often, threat or force helps them acquire even more goods, encouraging them to commit more violent acts such as robbery and rape. Thus, poverty increases crime

Read More

More about Pyrrhic Defeat Model

Open Document