ipl-logo

Race, Class And Feminist Theorizing About Motherhood

2056 Words9 Pages

The master narrative of motherhood is one of sacrifice and of nurturing children. Douglas Kirk’s 1959 film Imitation of Life is a social critique of the climate of the 1950’s depicting the lives and consequent tribulations of four women in two intertwining mother-daughter relationships. White aspiring actress, Lora Meredith and her daughter, Susie, hire Annie Johnson; a middle-aged black woman, as their live-in housekeeper. Annie and her mulatto daughter, Sarah Jane are thrust into the center of white upper middle-class society. Patricia Hill Collins’ “Shifting the Center: Race, Class and Feminist Theorizing about Motherhood” discusses the importance of incorporating structures of race and class into the subjective experience of motherhood. In Imitation of …show more content…

Annie discovers Sarah Jane is staying in Los Angeles and tracks her down in a last desperate attempt to make a connection. Annie is disappointed and heart-broken to learn Sarah Jane is “passing” and working as a dancer at an all-white club. Collins asserts that: “Outsider within status is bound to generate tension, for people who become outsiders within are forever changed by their new status” (S29). When Annie goes to visit Sarah Jane, she shuns her mother, telling Annie that she should act as if she never had a child and if the two should cross paths that Annie should not acknowledge her. In “Shifting the Center”, Collins concludes that “Highlighting racial ethnic mothers’ struggles concerning their children’s right to exist focuses attention on the importance of survival” (72), Sarah Jane believes that her survival and success in the “white world” depends solely on her ability to make people believe she is white. Although Annie does not want to leave her daughter behind, she accepts Sarah Jane’s choice to “pass”. Heartbroken and weary from vying for her daughter’s acceptance Annie returns home to Lora and

Show More
Related

Summary Of In Union There Is Strength By Mary Church Terrell

720 Words | 3 Pages

White America was already painting the picture of what life for women: housewives. Terrell encourages African American women that they can be just a great of mother as the woman of the “dominant race” and more if they teach their children values and morals. She states, “If the women of the dominant race with all the centuries of education. refinement, and culture back of them, with all their wealth of opportunity ever present with them, if these women felt a responsibility to call a Mother's Congress that they might be ever enlightened as to the best methods of rearing children and conducting their homes, how much more do the women of our race from whom the shackles of slavery have just fallen need information on the same subjects? Let us have Mother Congresses in every community in which our women can be counseled.

Read More

The Role Of Deception In Nella Larsen's Passing

575 Words | 3 Pages

1920’s society offered a prominent way for blacks that look white to exploit its barrier and pass in society. Visible within Nella Larsen’s Passing, access to the regular world exists only for those who fit the criteria of white skin and white husband. Through internal conflict and characterization, the novella reveals deception slowly devours the deceitful. In Passing, Clare and Irene both deceive people. They both engage in deceit by having the ability to pass when they are not of the proper race to do so.

Read More

Bucket Of Blood Katherine Waugh Analysis

949 Words | 4 Pages

This theme is developed through the mother yet deciding to stand out and do life her own way. As a woman, the mother in this story is expected to act like everyone else. Women in

Read More

Summary Of Passing By Nella Larsen

1624 Words | 7 Pages

Nella Larsen’s Passing is a novella about the experiences of African American women ‘passing’ as whites for equal opportunities. Larsen presents the day to day issues they face during their ‘passing’ journey through her characters of Irene Redfield and Clare Kendry. During the reading process, we progressively realize ‘passing’ in Harlem, New York during the 1920s becomes difficult for both of these women physically and mentally as different kinds of challenges progress ahead. Although Larsen decides the novella to be told in a third person narrative, different thoughts and messages of Irene and Clare communicate broken ideas for the reader which causes the interpretation of the novella to vary from distinct perspectives. Jakobson’s model of

Read More

Theme Of Identity In Passing By Nella Larson

1148 Words | 5 Pages

Identity is an important aspect in the novel Passing by Nella Larson, and it is tied within race, socioeconomic class, and gender. However this novel challenges the very notion of self- perception and how circumstances regarding your race, gender, and overall identity can change as you encounter obstacles and adversities ; as seen with Irene Redfield who’s own self-identity especially with respect to her race, family, and general livelihood is morphed and challenged with the reemergence of Clare in her life. One of Irene’s early encounters with Clare, the one where Irene is introduced to Clare’s husband, reveals how even though identity is such a pivotal part of one’s character we must still adapt to and act accordingly to the

Read More

Motherhood In Nella Larsen's Passing

1484 Words | 6 Pages

It is often said that a new definition of a woman arose in the 1920s. But is that true? While most women experienced many newfound freedoms in the 1920s, black women could not explore these freedoms as easily as white women. In the novel Passing by Nella Larsen, Irene Redfield and Clare Kendry grew up in Chicago together and are now both two wives and mothers in New York City during the 1920s, but there is a big difference between them. The novel’s title refers to light-skinned black women masquerading as white women for social benefits.

Read More

Zora Neal Hurston's How It Feels To Be Colored Me

534 Words | 3 Pages

The author establishes her ethical appeal, by providing the reader with a vivid image of how her childhood was growing up colored. She let the readers see through her eyes by providing common grounds, with people of color. Growing up in an exclusively colored town, and only seen whites occasionally, gives the author no reason to see herself as colored,

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of 'Everyday Use' By Alice Walker

1052 Words | 5 Pages

The speaker is uneducated, so the writing in the first person is readable for beginners as well as educated adults. Walker addresses the audience specifically to to create deeper imagery, where the audience can add their own experiences to the story, such as “You’ve no doubt seen those TV shows” (46). The speaker directly addresses the audience, and so anyone reading the story, whether a minority, or the majority, will be connected to the story. Purpose: Walker describes the impact of oppression on the relationship between mother and daughter, and how the oppressed view themselves.

Read More

The Triumphs And Downfalls Of Passing By Nella Larsen

409 Words | 2 Pages

The novel begins a brief flashback that takes the readers into the lives of two light-skinned woman from Chicago who were born into different social classes, but still shared the experience of growing up as black females. Although, at first, Irene Westover seems to be born a silver spoon in her mouth, she appears to sacred of her position in her family. She is completely absorbed in maintaining the perfect image she has established for her family members. Classifying herself as “practical and determined” (LARSEN 63), Irene simply conceals her overprotectiveness she imposes on her sons. She reprimands her husband for making observation regarding the issues such as racism and lynching before her sons.

Read More

Nella Larsen Passing Analysis

1919 Words | 8 Pages

Nella Larsen’s Passing is a novella about the past experiences of African American women ‘passing’ as whites for equal opportunities. Larsen presents the day to day issues African American women face during their ‘passing’ journey through her characters of Irene Redfield and Clare Kendry. During the reading process, we progressively realize ‘passing’ in Harlem, New York during the 1920’s becomes difficult for both of these women physically and mentally as different kinds of challenges approach ahead. Although Larsen decides the novella to be told in a third person narrative, different thoughts and messages of Irene and Clare communicate broken ideas for the reader, causing the interpretation of the novella to vary from different perspectives.

Read More

Feminism In The Bean Trees

853 Words | 4 Pages

They argue that a major theme is that “[a]lthough it is a job that can never be done perfectly, motherhood is depicted as an empowering role” (Parini 200). Throughout the novel, we see Taylor and Lou Ann adjusting and learning how to parent a child by themselves. It is a struggle for them; however, they learn quickly and conquer their motherhood. While it is valid that some readers might think motherhood is a hard and empowering role, still my theme of men-less women being powerful remains central because the power of women has a lot to do with raising their children. For example, Taylor is talking to her mama via payphone and tells her some exciting news.

Read More

Stereotypes In The Film Imitation Of Life

418 Words | 2 Pages

As a child, she recognized that her imitation of ‘White” afforded opportunities of mobility, education, acceptance and privilege. Her mother’s appearance as “Black” afforded opportunities of poverty, inferiority, and inequality. So, she fails to mention her mother’s identity and occupation to classroom peers and teacher. Sarah Jane wants cultural assimilation and white privilege.

Read More

Social Stratification In The Movie The Help

610 Words | 3 Pages

Black women are treated less than because of their ascribed traits, their gender and race, and are often dehumanized and belittled throughout the movie. They are treated like slaves and are seen as easily disposable. There are several moments throughout the film that show the racial, gender, and class inequalities. These moments also show exploitation and opportunity hoarding. The Help also explains historical context of the inequality that occurred during that time period.

Read More

The Help Movie Analysis

3436 Words | 14 Pages

The movie clearly exposes the many ways that the human dignity of African- American maids was ignored. They had suffered daily embarrassment but were able to claim their own way dignity. The film described about empowerment of individuals as well as about social justice for a group. It is a moving story depicting dehumanization in a racist culture but also the ability to move beyond the unjust structures of society and to declare the value of every human being.

Read More

The Effects Of Motherhood In Toni Morrison's The Bluest Eye

3280 Words | 14 Pages

Afro-American women writers present how racism permeates the innermost recesses of the mind and heart of the blacks and affects even the most intimate human relationships. While depicting the corrosive impact of racism from social as well as psychological perspectives, they highlight the human cost black people have to pay in terms of their personal relationships, particularly the one between mother and daughter. Women novelists’ treatment of motherhood brings out black mothers’ pressures and challenges for survival and also reveals their different strategies and mechanisms to deal with these challenges. Along with this, the challenges black mothers have to face in dealing with their adolescent daughters, who suffer due to racism and are heavily influenced by the dominant value system, are also underlined by these writers. They portray how a black mother teaches her daughter to negotiate the hostile, wider world, and prepares her to face the problems and challenges boldly and confidently.

Read More

More about Race, Class And Feminist Theorizing About Motherhood

Related Topics

Open Document