ipl-logo

Rachel Carson Argument Essay

1183 Words5 Pages

Science is a controversial topic that has been debated as early as people started to question what humans know about the world. Even today many debate science, and the topic of climate change and this debate goes back to the 20th century where trailblazers tried to wake the public up to the world around them. Science is about evidence, so the fact that it became a political debate is an irrational development. Rachel Carson, a trailblazer of the 20th century, shook the world with her research awakening the American people, stood against all odds, and contributed to today’s society. Rachel Carson was a researcher and was infatuated with nature and very troubled by the damage done by man. In the 20th century America was ecstatic that they had a chemical, Dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane or DDT for short, that which supposedly and mistakenly had “no immediate damage to humans”(American Experience). The chemical would seep into the crops annihilating any pests that would …show more content…

In Silent Spring, “This pollution is the most part irrecoverable; the chain of evil it initiates not only in the world that must support life but in living tissues is for the most irreversible” (Obligation to Endure 3). Man has corrupted nature so that the very being of animals is a never-ending cycle of corruption. In “Silent Spring: Personal Synthesis of Two Cultures” Doris Fleischer states, “Since the book was so carefully researched and written, the attacks on Carson were personal rather than focused on the data or conclusions in the text” (Fleischer 20). Fleischer provides a plausible conclusion as to why Carson’s science wasn’t accepted, but Carson was a woman, and people of the time didn’t believe woman can do research. The work Carson completed was prolific for the time, and many didn’t accept it due to science being mistakenly assumed only for

Show More
Related

Charles Krauthammer The Myth Of Settled Science Summary

777 Words | 4 Pages

Whoever says science states facts isn’t saying the truth because science is always evolving and making new discoveries. Climate change is going to be a big concern, it’s going to cause a mass change in agriculture, the rising heat will affect farmers and how they grow crops. The burning toxic chemicals cannot lead to a positive outcome as well, it may rise health problems and create different types of dieses that’ll affect mankind. Science has its predictions, but how solid can these predictions be? “The Myth of ‘Settled Science.’” is an article written by Charles Krauthammer that addresses a different point of view on global warming.

Read More

Analysis Of To Understand Anti-Vaxxers, Consider Aristotle, By Gary Simon

1110 Words | 5 Pages

“Our advances in science over the past two centuries have truly been extraordinary, but our society still suffers from the forces that reject reason and prevent our ability to take full advantage of discoveries

Read More

Elizabeth Kolbert's Field Notes From A Catastrophe

1455 Words | 6 Pages

The human race has taken the planet under our control, but now we must keep the peace with the environment on which we so heavily depend--this is a crucial part of Elizabeth Kolbert’s main argument in her book Field Notes from a Catastrophe. However, while scientific evidence, climate models, and visible effects of global warming all work together in presenting a sound case for political action to be taken against further warming, there is a noticeable lack of actual policy-making. Kolbert points out that both the Clinton Administration and the Bush Administration failed to treat global warming as a political issue of top priority. Similarly, Fred Powledge highlights in his article “Scientists, Policymakers, and a Climate of Uncertainty” that current government officials continue to publicly question the validity of scientific evidence that proves human activity has directly affected the progression of climate change and actively cease to support legislation that works to mitigate further warming. While the majority of scientists agree that global warming is escalating at an unprecedented rate due to human activity, both Kolbert and Powledge agree that many politicians have yet to treat climate change as a serious issue that demands immediate action, and point out that some refuse to admit that it is even an

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of After Silent Spring By Rachel Carson

1563 Words | 7 Pages

Here was the source of the bitter, right/left divide that has animated the environment debate ever since. On one side are the voices of science and those concerned with the balance of nature; on the other side stand economic incentives and the powers that are the massed might of the establishment. Manufactured attacked Carson. Carson was also slandered by former secretary of agriculture, Ezra Taft Benson, as a communist because of her personal life, including her married status. Debates which were begun by Silent Spring were the beginning of some of the environmental legislation and the government agencies, we have today in order to regulate the use of the

Read More

AP Environmental Science: Silent Spring By Rachel Carson

1155 Words | 5 Pages

The problems she targeted in the past have only expanded into modern times as they have accurately influenced more and more ecosystems worldwide. Pesticides and other man-made chemical compounds are the main source of these environmental issues, and Carson would have continued to campaign for the halt of the use of chemicals. Although pesticides and chemicals are continuing to harm the environment, Rachel's book was a monumental wake up call to humans, as it revealed how much damage we are causing every day to ourselves and our surroundings. Arguably thanks to Rachel Carson’s hard work and dedication to advocating against man-made chemicals, DDT was finally banned in the United States in 1972. Rachel’s legacy still carries on today, and her work, specifically within “Silent Spring,” continues to bring awareness to the present major environmental issues— marking it as one of the most influential books of the twentieth

Read More

Labels In The Climate Debate By Justin Gillis

447 Words | 2 Pages

The text's meanings and purpose are climate change labels, the climate change debate, and the ‘science’ surround climate change. Moreover, in comprehending implicit-purpose, the text leans in favoring climate change. The text provides cynical adjectives in associating the term “deniers.” Words like “manipulating data,” “phony skeptics,” “ludicrous claims,” “cherry-picking,” and “Holocaust” are used relating to

Read More

Are The Pseudoscientific Ideas Of Race In Nazi Germany During 1935-1945?

3633 Words | 15 Pages

While some scientists were complicit in the regime's policies, others worked to expose the flaws and limitations of these ideas and promote evidence-based research and critical thinking. The use of pseudoscientific ideas about race during the period from 1935 to 1946 was met with a mixed response from the scientific community. Some scientists actively promoted these ideas, while others opposed them and worked to expose their flaws and

Read More

The Similarities And Differences Between The Political Party And The Republican Party

414 Words | 2 Pages

This upcoming election will pose an especially interesting aspect with respect to environmental science and sustainability. The two main political parties have their party platform statements that include their own viewpoints on some of these issues we face. The scientific fact behind global warming has been supported over time, and we see as a basis, the Democratic Party tends to accept the science behind climate change and embedded these ideas into their Party’s platform. While the Republican Party might not as a whole, reject climate change; however, the Republican Party tends to question or just reject the science behind climate change.

Read More

Pros Of Ww2

629 Words | 3 Pages

According to times; The U.S. farmer spends over $11 billion on all pesticides, and 58 percent of that money goes to herbicides, 28 percent to insecticides, eight percent to fungicides and the rest to other chemicals. By now, it was more important to the American farmer to kill weeds than insects. (Ganzel) Hundreds of different types of pesticides surfaced in the post war period, marking a new chemical age and lightening the load on american’s backs during the war and for generations after. And soon after the market was established, it paved the way for others as well.

Read More

Why Is Rachel Carson Misleading

100 Words | 1 Pages

They accused her of being unscientific, disloyal, hysterical and radical. The attacks toward Rachel Carson were misleading because although Carson wasn’t educated with the scientific composition of the pesticide themselves, she still went out on her own to inform the public personally, about the dangers of the chemical that was going on towards human and

Read More

Frankenstein: The Ethics Of Modern Day Science

933 Words | 4 Pages

Everyday scientist try to do the impossible I find this very hypocritical, because human nature is to try to reach out of the box and try new ideas. She was a women trying to write a book in early 1800s she was trying to do the

Read More

Analysis Of Under The Sea-Wind By Rachel Carson

916 Words | 4 Pages

“Carson showed how experts trusted their own creations too greatly and how they themselves were implicated in a vast complex of private and public interests designed to produce profits for chemical manufacturers and the growing agribusiness sector” (Stoll). Carson revealed how the industries were more about making a profit than protecting the environment. In a way, Carson woke the industry up and showed them just how much harm they were doing. “Much of the data and case studies that Carson drew from weren’t new; the scientific community had known of these findings for some time, but Carson was the first to put them all together for the general public and to draw stark and far reaching conclusions”

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Silent Spring By Rachel Carson

119 Words | 1 Pages

Rachel Carson was always interested in the ocean. When she was in college she was torn in picking which path she would take, her passion for writing ,or her love for nature. I think Rachel Carson should have her own National Holiday because her book “Silent Spring” was creating worldwide awareness of the dangers of environmental pollution. I say this because in the book Rachel Carson by Kathleen K. Kudlinski on page 61 it says, “He was horrified by the things he had learned from Silent Spring.” That means what DDT (pesticide) was doing to our environment.

Read More

Rachel Carson Silent Spring Summary

1077 Words | 5 Pages

As a result of the gender expectations in my culture, my childhood consisted of me being home playing with dolls while my brothers played outside in the yard and interacted with nature. Relatable to Rachel Carson, she grew up in an era where women were viewed as subjects rather than an intellectual contribution to society. Carson incorporated a biologist, George Wald, who argues that “only when we bring our focus to bear, first on the individual cells of the body, then on the minute structures within the cells, and finally on the ultimate reactions of molecules within these structures… we can comprehend the most serious and far reaching effects” of these synthetic chemicals ,” (Carson 200). I can relate to the author’s argument as a woman because my gender role as a Latina kept me from expanding my perception of nature. As a child my upbringing caused me to undermine the pollution in the air.

Read More

Effective Use Of Chemical Pesticides In Silent Spring, By Rachel Carson

665 Words | 3 Pages

Then one spring there were no birds, no visitors, no fisherman in the streams, and families were getting sick. (Carson, 1962, p.3) As the book moves forward chemical pesticides are discussed and the impact that they have on the environment.

Read More

More about Rachel Carson Argument Essay

Related Topics

Open Document