ipl-logo

Rand Paul's Anthem Analysis

986 Words4 Pages

In several ways the novella Anthem can be compared to the modern day communist dictatorship North Korea. Although they are similar in some places they are completely different in other ways. Ways they are able to be compared and contrasted are the forms of government, the state and mentality of the citizens, and development or progress as a civilization. Although it is often said that anywhere can be better than a certain place, such as people saying that school is the worst place that exists for a relatable example, there are various different factors that play into the overall condition of something that it can be extremely difficult to tell. To finish the previous thought, school can be hated because people are put up to endure hours upon …show more content…

Everyone is equal to each other, they all have the same thoughts, and they all work to provide for each other. These ideas are the same in North Korea, although they are actually able to know who their families are. In the books civilization the children are not allowed to know who they are actually related to, they just brothers and sisters to each other. The citizens of the fictional civilization are also assigned a time and place for mating whereas in North Korea they have at least the freedom of choice given to them when it comes to relationships and children. Rand Paul in his argument against the Energy Independence & Security Act of 2007, while using the book Anthem to solidify his argument, states “The collective has no place basically for individual choice” which is the overall mentality of the citizens within the book, they are all seen as equal and are lead to think that they should work as one, not individuals. In this section the conditions of North Korea are much better because although people are not able to achieve everything that they may want to, the fictional civilization is forced to work to achieve one overall goal and nothing …show more content…

In the way that the civilizations are run the two seem remarkably similar and can be compared to each other quite easily. The state and mentality of the citizens is better in North Korea due to them being given much more freedom in what they want to accomplish throughout their lives. Where the progress of the civilization is concerned one of them advances where the other lacks, meaning that the military power isn’t too great in the fictional civilization but it is quite great in North Korea. From these three points either side can be argued about which one is better, which is right because although something is below standards from one perspective, it can be view upon from a different point of view from which it seems great, which means that neither of these civilizations are better than the

Show More
Related
953 Words | 4 Pages

In the books Fahrenheit 451 and Anthem, by Ray Bradbury and Ayn Rand, the societies displayed are very different from modern day societies. In Anthem the main character, Equality 7-2521, is a young man who lives in a society where there is absolutely no individuality personality wise and it is basically considered a sin to be different than others. In Fahrenheit 451 the main character, Guy Montag, lives in a society where no one thinks independently, it is illegal to read, and no one really cares about anything. Both societies restrict free thinking, but both do it in ways different than the other. In both books the main characters meet someone who changes their lives for the better.

Read More
363 Words | 2 Pages

Lily Haghpassand English 9 September 20, 2017 In the book, “The Anthem”, the government has found a way to maintain peace and harmony in society by instilling fear into its constituents. The members of this society are taken from their parents at birth and thrown into a world where differences are frowned upon and sameness is put above all other things, brainwashing each child with the notion that everything the government says is true. When children are born, they are denied bonding time with their parents and placed in the “Home of Infants” with other children their age and the idea of sameness is stressed. By doing this, they take away the emotion of love, among other things, and in turn, create a society of seemingly identical individuals.

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

Bill of Rights, and Anthem The Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, and Anthem all fight for equality and stand up for what is right. Both the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights have preambles and were drafted by people with similar backgrounds. They were generally educated and white men with property. The whole idea of the documents were to have certain fundamental rights that governments are created to protect the idea for all people.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

Harrison Bergeron vs. Anthem To live in a world where collectivism is a part of society it must be strange to the way we live now. In both dystopian novels everyone has the same rights and is equal which makes them practice collectivism. Throughout both novels they show their separate in relationship and figure out what relationships truly are and overcome the fear of their government discovering them. In Vonnegut’s “ Harrison Bergeron” and Rand’s “Anthem” their societies are the similar in equality but different in their relationships. Both novels show the characteristics that they are exactly equal because collectivism is practiced upon society by the close minded government. .

Read More
861 Words | 4 Pages

Elie Wiesel once said that “The duty of the survivor is to bear testimony to what happened... You have to warn people that these things can happen, that evil can be unleashed. Race hatred, violence, idolatries-- they still flourish.” This quote summarizes how the North Korean citizens worked their hardest to get out of the North Korean territory to be able to tell the world what has been going on in North Korea. For over fifty years, one family has governed North Korea for the entity of its existence (Sarah Pruitt).

Read More
892 Words | 4 Pages

As the story progresses the closing chapters of the writing reveal his pivotal judgments against the leaders of his society, attacking their weak morals. The main character condemns the word in which the society revolves around,” We”, as “the word of serfdom, of plunder, of misery, of falsehood and shame” (Anthem 97). The character is vindicated in doing so, for the society was an evil prison that had restricted his personal freedoms for his entire existence. It was Equality 7-2521’s duty to point out the society’s ultimate flaws. Practicing moral-tolerance in this case and not attempting to combat the evil he had been subjected to would only result in him being a victim to conforming society’s views once again.

Read More
891 Words | 4 Pages

As I said before this book was written in the form of first person plural. Doing this really helps the reader understand the state of the city’s beliefs and ways of living. It would have been much more confusing if Ayn wrote the book in regular first person. It would also need more explaining throughout the book. Anthem was one of the best books I have read in a long time.

Read More
493 Words | 2 Pages

Barbara Demick has developed the idea that North Korea “has fallen out of the developed world” by providing several examples of life as analytical ways of thoughts and processes of North Koreans in comparison to other countries

Read More
559 Words | 3 Pages

Anthem is a book that makes oneself contemplate the future and what evils are bestowed upon it. In this novel, the reader is caught in the life of Equality. Equality’s life is placed in the future, where the feared reality of communism has conquered all but the souls of few weary men. Equality is one of those few men who have a light that is invulnerable to a ravaging wind. Equality’s time captive before his extraordinary escape has taken a toll on his body and mind and now at the end of his journey forces him to question whether the decisions he’s made are full of sin or teeming with righteousness.

Read More
552 Words | 3 Pages

In North Korea, being in the Mass Games is a huge accomplishment. You train for hours on end so you will look exactly the same, as if you are becoming one. Even the military is so disciplined that they look exactly the same. But, the people in North Korea are different from the citizens in 1984 because they still have individual personalities. The Party convinces these people to all believe the same ideas and have the same opinions.

Read More
959 Words | 4 Pages

(U) North Korea (NK), although isolated, have developed their own cultural aspects over the decades. The civilian considerations, such as PMESII/ASCOPE, in NK comes in many shapes and forms. The cultural aspects of NK are dependent on and significantly affected by these considerations. The culture of NK varies from the political to the information considerations in PMESII/ASCOPE. The government control these aspects in NK giving little to no civilian involvement.

Read More
1957 Words | 8 Pages

The author reasserts what was stated in the book about how North Korea is a failed Stalinist state and that they miraculously survived the Cold War. The author writes about how North Korea’s leader Kim Jong-un will never open up his country’s economy or normalize realize relations with the United States because that would expose the huge gap between North Korea’s poverty and South Korea’s prosperity, which as a result will make more North Koreans Flee to the South. He then says that the only way Pyongyang will stay afloat is by begging other countries for assistance. He adds that North Korea will have the same fate as the Soviets and will cease to exist by 2030. He ultimately suggests that Washington D.C. should work to make peace with North Korea to avoid another Korean

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

As an American, we cannot comprehend the types of laws that are enforced upon North Korean Citizens. A few bizarre controlment rules that I still struggle to comprehend myself are there are only twenty-eight ways North Korean men and women can cut their hair, North Korean Men and Women are not allowed to own a bible or any western literature, and also there are only three channels on tv and you must only watch those. Along with those laws in place, the North Korean government has control over education and news which leads to many growing up to hate other countries besides their own with no reasoning behind their hatred. Our lives along with many others are still being affected by the iron grip of societal norms.

Read More
1058 Words | 5 Pages

Juche, as Charles Armstrong puts it, is the “overarching philosophical principle guiding all areas of life in North Korea”. Meaning autonomy, independence, or self-reliance, the origins of this ideological concept has been a highly debated topic. There are three main schools of thought: the instrumental perspective, which focuses on domestic and international relations as the main drivers, the traditional perspective, which looks at the influence of traditional political culture in Korea, and the individualist perspective, which explores how Juche was the intellectual result of Kim Il Sung. Armstrong falls under the first category of historians, and in Tyranny of the Weak: North Korea and the World, 1950 - 1992, argues that not only was Juche

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

North Korea is an imaginable country. You can't think, say, wear, or do what you want. There aren't any sources to the outside world. There is only one channel of tv. There is only one web in the Internet.

Read More

More about Rand Paul's Anthem Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document