Reasons Why Lyddie Should Sign The Petition
Within the reading, I caught that, “She did not go to work the next day or for many days thereafter. Her fever raged, and she was out of her mind with it.” This shows that the fever affected her badly, and kept her from going to work for several days, as it rages on. Also, throughout Chapter 17, it stated, “It had been two weeks since she fell ill, and Dr. Morris still refused to let her return to work.” which also shows that Lyddie has been ill for a long time.
Others might argue that Lyddie should not sign the petition, to earn money enough to pay off her family's debt. But the book states, “uncle Judah’s bound to determined to sell”(Paterson 143). Uncle Judah is determined to sell the farm to be repaid for taking care of Mama and the babies. Therefore there is no debt to be repaid and no farm to return to. In addition, Lyddie got a letter that states, “we regret to inform you of the death of Maggie M. Worthen”(Paterson 159).
The fictional novel Lyddie, by Katherine Paterson explains the hard life of Lydia Worthen. Petitions have come up a few times since the beginning of the novel. Now, Lyddie has to make a big decision. Should she sign the petition or not?
The appeal to reason is one that Liebelson uses liberally by commenting on the workers’ sexual abuse, meager pay, and dangerous work conditions. The author talks about a 16-year-old that “was badly injured by a machine belt that snapped and hit her eye”, workers being subjected to “between 8 and 13 hours daily, plus overnight shifts”, and much more (Liebelson 49). By writing about these conditions extensively, Liebelson appeals to the reasonable reader who understands them. At no point does she outright denounce the mills or their connected companies, but she does give the necessary context for the reader to formulate their own opinions against them. Liebelson is more focused on the impact the factories had on the workers than the factories themselves and because of this, she makes it a secondary point to make an argument against the mills.
Sometimes, in life, you have to make hard decisions. The book ‘Lyddie’ by Katherine Paterson is about a girl named Lyddie that leaves her life in Vermont to go work in the mills in Lowell, to earn money to pay off the debt for her family’s farm. The working conditions at the factory are horrible and there is a petition going around by one of Lyddie’s friends, Diana Goss, demanding shorter work hours and better conditions. Lyddie is unsure whether or not to sign the petition. Although some people might say that Lyddie should not sign the petition, for she might get fired and take in no more money for the debt, but she should, because if she does sign the petition and get fired, she will have a better life and be healthier.
In Katherine Patterson's novel Lyddie, the main character is facing a difficult decision to sign a petition to decrease the number of working hours and decrease the dangerous working conditions. On on hand, she thinks she should sign because of how it is affecting her and her friends, but on the other hand, she could get blacklisted for doing so. Lyddie is working in a mill with harsh working conditions. The air is polluted, humid, and on top of all that, the hours they spend in the crowded room with the looms is over fourteen hours each day. She traveled from her home at the farm, then to a tavern where after being fired, realized the best place to go was to Lowell, Massachusetts.
On the other hand, Lyddie should sign the petition because then she would have more free time. Evidence that supports this is, “Time is more precious than money, Lyddie girl. If only I had two more free hours of an evening what I couldn't do.” This shows that the factory girls did not have a lot of free time and if they signed the petition they would have two or three more hours of free time and that Betsy (another factory girl and Lyddie’s roommate) believes that time is valuable. However, Lyddie does not need extra hours of freedom, but more money for her family and to pay off the
Lyddie by Katherine Paterson is about a girl that works in a mill. The working conditions at the mill are not very good. There is a petition going around for girls to sign that work at the mill for better working conditions. While some people think that Lyddie shouldn’t sign the petition because she could lose her job, Lyddie should sign the petition that Diana Goss Circulates because of the dangerous conditions and bad conditions at the boarding house. Lyddie should sign the petition because they need better working conditions.
She hasn 't seen her family in 2 years and is still working hard to collect money to get her cabin back, which is in debt. When Lyddie meets Diana Goss, who was a girl working with Lyddie in the factory, Diana introduces her to a petition, that could change her life for the better, or for the worse. Should Lyddie sign the petition for a happier, healthier life, but could get blacklisted, or should Lyddie suffer for a few more years to get the money she needs? Some people might state that she shouldn 't sign the petition because the job has decent pay and that Lyddie doesn 't mind and is only focusing on one goal- money. The right decision for Lyddie is to sign the petition, so that Lyddie doesn 't get into any dangerous situation, doesn 't get worn out from her job and has a decreased risk of getting sick.
Lyddie Argument Essay In the book Lyddie written by Katherine Paterson, Lyddie the 13 year old girl works hard for her family, around 13 hours, and is surrounded by disease, low pay and is being watched over all the time. But when she is sent a way to work she finds a mill, then she meets Diana, who started a petition and who wants something more than her factory life. Lyddie thinks about joining her and signing her petition. There may be consequences but i think it will have a good turn out for lyddie, This is why...
One reason Lyddie should sign the petition is for better hours and wages. One example was one day at the mill Lyddie was telling herself “She needed the money. She had to have the money” (89). In this part of the book Lyddie is working on four looms just to earn a little bit of money. For all the hard work she is doing she needs more money and signing the petition may help in doing so.
And what was she to do with Rachel?”(122) Lyddie worked hard for the money she needed to go back home. When she finds out she can’t even do that, she doesn’t know what to do. Even though she doesn’t know what to do now, she should not sign the petition! She instead should wait it out until she knows what to do.
A person may believe they are free, while others recognize they are not. In the novel Lyddie, by Katherine Paterson, the main character Lyddie Worthen is not free because of the long work hours. Lyddie is a 13-year-old girl who needs to pay her father's debt. She works at the mill where it is dangerous because the air is polluted and the machine can hear the workers. They work six days a week 12 hours each day, and get one day off that they have to go to church.
In life many people have to make tough decisions. In the novel Lyddie, by Katherine Paterson during the industrial revolution, Lyddie a young girl who has to work at a mill. In the mill there is a petition for better working circumstances . Lyddie is struggling to make a decision to sign the petition or not to sign the petition. While there are many reasons not to sign , there are more reasons to sign the petition.
She disagrees with Slaughters about telling her story to young work and tells her that it is a bad idea. Horrified her collogue believes that once Slaughter tells them that less woman will join the work force because of the hardship. By saying “you can’t write that” “You, of all people” to Slaughter.
More about Reasons Why Lyddie Should Sign The Petition
Bad Air In Lyddie Made By Katherine Paterson
596 Words | 3 PagesHow Did Lyddie Get The Air In The Factory
507 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of The Novel Lyddie By Katherine Paterson: Making Individual Decisions
430 Words | 2 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Made In Hell By Dana Liebelson
1296 Words | 6 PagesAnalysis Of Lyddie By Katherine Paterson
863 Words | 4 PagesWorking Conditions In Katherine Patterson's Lyddie
809 Words | 4 PagesWorking Conditions In Lyddie, By Katherine Paterson
713 Words | 3 PagesWho Should Lyddie Sign The Petition
612 Words | 3 PagesShould The Struggle In Katherine Paterson's Lyddie
633 Words | 3 PagesHow To Write A Lyddie Argumentative Essay
599 Words | 3 PagesLyddie Petition
744 Words | 3 PagesThe Need Of Life In Katherine Paterson's Lyddie
757 Words | 4 PagesWhy Is Lyddie Not Free
441 Words | 2 PagesBetter Working Conditions In Lyddie, By Katherine Paterson
482 Words | 2 PagesAn Analysis Of 'You, Of All People To Slaughter'
53 Words | 1 Pages