ipl-logo

Review Of Examining Slavery In The Americas Through The Lens Of The Archives

2703 Words11 Pages

Examining Slavery in the Americas through the Lens of the Archives By June Meehan Scholars examine archives to understand the impact that each record or account had on slavery in the Americas. Ideas about gender, labor, and race were majorly influenced by the records documented that focus on African and indigenous women and the experiences of slavery. Reports on these topics tended to socially reproduce the ideas of the racial and gender inferiority of enslaved people, specifically women of color. Through assessing the variety of perspectives the record and archive offers regarding slavery and analyzing the archives deficiency on the topic itself, scholars attempt to address the issues brought about before and during slavery that led to a shift in societal archetypes. To write on a topic, scholars need many …show more content…

Considering how little the archives have on the topic of slavery, Fuentes, Finley and other scholars have to examine every possible source to even discover what the narrative of slavery was. Metcalf utilizes sources in her writing and focuses on how these reports lay a foundation for the rhetoric of slavery. Metcalf notes that there are many accounts of men justifying slavery. She introduces Aristotle’s argument of the slave being a “natural state” and how Prince Henry the Navigator paralleled servitude to stories like the Curse of Ham that led many to believe that blackness equaled impurity and enslavement. The reason Metcalf introduces the beliefs of these men is because through their records she has found their rhetoric that justified slavery. The archives surrounding the topic of slavery contain rhetoric that almost always was used by elites to justify the system of slavery. This reasoning for justification was especially noticeable when records containing the success of plantations were given to elite slave

Show More
Related
1160 Words | 5 Pages

Justin Brookshire HIST 4001 01/24/2023 The first scholarly historical work of significance considering the topic of slavery as an institution is American Negro Slavery by Ulrich Bonnell Phillips. As a southerner publishing in 1918, this book was racist in nature against African Americans. Phillips’ argues in his book that slavery was a necessary paternalistic practice between master and slave that established an interdependent agricultural society for the betterment of the country.

Read More
697 Words | 3 Pages

Slavery has sadly been in America from the start. Many have different opinions about slavery whether it should stay or be abandoned and forgotten. Although one person has written to Thomas Jefferson about one of history’s most important subject. Banneker starts it off by writing his strong views on how wrong slavery is not just listing all the problems, but in a letter that he uses strategies to make his view convincing. Benjamin Banneker uses rhetorical strategies such as ethos, logos, and various style elements to argue against slavery.

Read More
303 Words | 2 Pages

A majority of the sources Kolchin used in the book, American Slavery: 1619-1877 were secondary. The purpose of the book was to bring together research, ideas, and opinions from historians from over the years on American Slavery. Kolchin used a multitude of secondary resources that had primary sources listed and verified by the original authors. This allowed his secondary sources to be legitimate and trustworthy for the most part. Just one of his many secondary sources included: Hyman, ed.,

Read More
1606 Words | 7 Pages

When it comes to slavery, there is a tendency for the historians to have contradicting ideas. This is partly due to the fact that much of slave and early African American history in our country was passed down orally rather than being written down on paper. Three historians who show different ways of thinking towards this issue are Kenneth M. Stampp, Eugene D. Genovese, and Robert William Fogel and Stanley L. Engerman. Their articles cover different subtopics, but with the same focus; slavery and its effects on our history. “A Troublesome Property” by Kenneth M. Stampp is an article that touches on whether slaves liked being slaves or not.

Read More
616 Words | 3 Pages

Sally Hemings was a slave on the Monticello plantation in the late 18th century, and her experience helps us to understand that her gender aided the way she was treated versus if they went by the color of her skin (Dilkes Mullins). {Woman during this era were thought of as property, they were objectified, they were treated poorly and had no choice. Their husbands were liable for anything that they did} [Being a female during this era outweighed what one 's social status was. It did not matter what race you were, but if you were a woman, you were treated as such] (Dilkes Mullins). Ms. Hemings was a beautiful sixteen-year-old enslaved girl (Gordon-Reed, 102) who was more than just a slave on the Monticello plantation.

Read More
1545 Words | 7 Pages

Devin Plascencia HST 2201 Enslavement may have functioned as the single-greatest contributing factor to the economic prosperity of the United States. Even so, enslaved Americans’ experiences were far from singular. Not only did enslaved experiences differ based on the demands of each cash crop – namely tobacco, rice, sugar, and cotton – but also based on the size of slaveholding residencies, urban or rural conditions, and the temperaments of individual enslavers. Historical eras also informed differing slave experiences. Making use of evidence from historians Peter Kolchin and Chandra Manning, I argue that the experiences of enslaved Americans differed between the antebellum period and the Civil War.

Read More
298 Words | 2 Pages

Douglass's evaluation of the reasons this was the case engaged me while presenting information I never took into consideration. Having heard the argument of Slavery being tolerated by the Constitution, Douglass expands on

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

“The historical debate over slavery began where the propaganda war between abolitionists and apologists for slavery had ended. Condemnation of slavery as a moral evil and a system of ruthless exploitation was pitted against respect for slavery as an effective system for the adjustment of relations between a superior and an inferior race. ”2 This disillusion can be stopped by proper education of the history of slavery, the true history of slavery, not the pretty and happy version that some tend to

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

Life Under Slavery The enslaved African-Americans faced several hardships and danger because, in the 1800s, they did not protect enslaved families, but they were able to create family lives, religious beliefs, and a distant culture. At any time, a husband or wife could be sold to a different owner, or a slaveholder’s death could lead to the breakup of an enslaved family. So, if the slaves were sold to a different owner they aren 't responsible anymore for what happens to them. For example, if the slave gains a sickness something like that and the slave ends up dying they aren 't responsible for that.

Read More
419 Words | 2 Pages

On July 4th, 1952, Frederick Douglass delivered a powerful speech in Rochester, New York. He carefully crafted an argument aimed at persuading his audience that the United States must abolish slavery. Douglass strategically focused on highlighting the faults of American slavery, and in doing so, he uses important features such as vivid imagery, emotional appeals, and historical references to build a powerful case for the urgent need to end slavery. One of the most relevant features of Douglas's argument is the use of the imagery. Throughout the speech, he explains a well-focused picture of the brutality faced by enslaved individuals.

Read More
1110 Words | 5 Pages

One of the strategies Douglass uses to convince his audience slavery should be abolished is by “calling out American hypocrisy in his Fourth of July oration” (Mercieca 1). He shames them with no remorse. He speaks on the opposite treatments that enable whites to live in a state of freedom and liberty, while the blacks are living in a state of bondage. As the audience listens, he reminds them, there are men, women and children still held hostages to the chains of

Read More
1246 Words | 5 Pages

Providing readers with a different outlook on what slaves

Read More
428 Words | 2 Pages

Finally, Douglass ends with addressing concessions and providing well reasoned rebuttals that progressively support his central claim that the conscience of the country should be roused to protect the rights of slaves as men. Facing inquiries like the abolitionists should “argue more and denounce less,” Douglass analyzes why his claim is not arguable layer upon layer. First, salves are men who are entitled to liberty and should not be seen or treated as brutes. Furthermore, slaves do the same jobs, live in the same way and believe the same religion as all other American citizens do. Finally, slavery is inhuman and therefore should not be divine.

Read More
1642 Words | 7 Pages

From this, derives a bond with the reader that pushes their understanding of the evil nature of slavery that society deemed appropriate therefore enhancing their understanding of history. While only glossed over in most classroom settings of the twenty-first century, students often neglect the sad but true reality that the backbone of slavery, was the dehumanization of an entire race of people. To create a group of individuals known for their extreme oppression derived from slavery, required plantation owner’s of the South to constantly embedded certain values into the lives of their slaves. To talk back means to be whipped.

Read More
868 Words | 4 Pages

Author’s Purpose, Documentation and Research, Bias The purpose of writing “12 Years a Slave” was to educate the public on the realities of slavery and remind readers that no black person was free during that time period. This memoir is both the study of a narrow subject and of a large time period. While most of the book is the telling of the grim life of a slave, the institution of slavery itself is touched upon. By

Read More

More about Review Of Examining Slavery In The Americas Through The Lens Of The Archives

Open Document