ipl-logo

Review Of What They Fought For By James M. Mcpherson

461 Words2 Pages

In “What They Fought For 1861-1865,” prize winning author James M. McPherson writes a conflicting non-subjected book that explores the major motivations of the men who enlisted and fought the Civil War. McPherson examines in a non-biased tone the reason why the men in gray and blue fought in the bloodiest war in American history. James M. McPherson discusses the significant characteristics of the theme and ideas of the book that explores ideology. Within the conflicting book, McPherson analyzes the major theme and idea of ideology or “what Civil War soldiers believed they were fighting for” (McPherson pg. 1).

McPherson encounters the quarrel that many historians disagree upon: whether or not the soldiers during this war knew their intentions of fighting the war. However, within McPherson’s book, he supports the idea that soldiers motives within the Civil War may have been influenced by social pressure, companionship, “masculinity; concepts of duty, honor, and courage” (McPherson pg. 1). Men who did not fight for this reason fought for their country as many believed that if “Our Fathers made this country, we, their children are to save it” …show more content…

By reading McPherson’s book, it is also believed that many soldiers were well aware that they were fighting to create a country that our Founding Fathers believed should be constructed: as one nation where everyone is guaranteed to be created equal with freedom among every man. However, from acquaintance and investigation, those can come to the consummation that some soldiers were also blinded by incomprehension. For example, the Confederates believed that they were fighting for their rights and freedom from the North. However, they fail to see that the North was fighting for the rights and freedom for the slaves from the

Show More
Related

Chapter 14 Of Foner Analysis

185 Words | 1 Pages

In chapter 14 of Foner on page 512 they talk about the Union and Confederate army. It mentions how, many of the recruits didn 't have military experience. They all had different ideas about it, they imagined it how it

Read More

Michael Shaara's The Killer Angels

1439 Words | 6 Pages

History 1001 - American History to 1877 Professor Phillips Paper Assignment The Killer Angels In 1975, Michael Shaara wrote one of the most classic Civil War books ever, The Killer Angels. In The Killer Angels, Shaara portrays the perspectives of many soldiers who fought in the Civil War including those from both sides, the North and the South.

Read More

What They Fought For Chapter Summaries

156 Words | 1 Pages

In chapter one of What They Fought For, I learned about the letters and diaries of the Confederate soldiers. The themes of the letters were home-sickness, lack of peace, and the defense of home against their invading enemy. The thought of soldiers fighting for their homes and being threatened by invaders, made them stronger when facing adversity. Many men expressed that they would rather die fighting for a cause, than dying without trying and this commitment showed patriotism. Throughout the letters, soldiers claimed their reason for fighting, was for the principles of Constitutional liberty and self-government.

Read More

Review Of For Cause And Comrades: Why Men Fought In The Civil War

997 Words | 4 Pages

Even though McPherson’s discoveries are different from most historians, he proves his thesis with strong arguments, supportive evidence, various sources, and clear information prior to and after the Civil War. By investigating events in chronological order, McPherson allows readers to learn exactly how and why men became motivated to become soldiers in the Civil War. Once McPherson set the scene with information prior to the Civil War, he began to examine the different categories of motivation for men from both sides who enlisted in the Civil War. Traditionally, historians say duty, honor, and strong beliefs are what caused men to become soldiers

Read More

James M. Mcpherson's What They Fought For: 1861-1865

1091 Words | 5 Pages

McPherson discusses how he found countless of confederate soldier’s letters filled with phrases like “the holy cause of southern freedom, duty to one’s country and death before Yankee

Read More

Summary Of For Cause & Comrades

1118 Words | 5 Pages

James M. McPherson’s For Cause & Comrades analyzes and discusses the different reasons why men fought and died in the Civil War. McPherson uses the journals and letters of 1076 soldiers, 647 from the Union army and 429 from the Confederacy. Using these first-hand accounts of the war, McPherson aims to answer the question of how and why soldiers participated in the war. McPherson’s thesis contends that “Duty and honor were indeed powerful motivating forces.

Read More

Courage In Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

730 Words | 3 Pages

The draft pulled them into it. They did not want to dishonor their fathers, their country and society who told them fighting is honorable. In “The Things They Carried,” it was this ‘dishonor’ that had lead them to enter the war, it was “nothing

Read More

Why Did Texas Fight In The Civil War Essay

587 Words | 3 Pages

You’ve probably heard of the Civil War, but do you really know the motivation behind the fighting? Just imagine, the year is 1861 and a war starts to break out. However, it is not just any war, it is the Civil War. This war dragged on over 4 years, taking down nearly 15,000 young men with it. These men were in their twenties and thirties, as young as thirteen, and were turned into soldiers.

Read More

Mcpherson And The Civil War

228 Words | 1 Pages

McPherson addresses an issue/problem people have had when we talk/write about the Civil War. That problem is what was both sides truly fighting for. This war broke up the Union into two parts, North and South. Without the war happening, America would not be same America as today. We as Americans need to know the real reason why in 1861, the North and South went against each other and that was because of slavery.

Read More

To Kill A Men Rhetorical Analysis

294 Words | 2 Pages

Unlike Adam and Eve’s battle of the sexes, Twain highlights how a group of men in a militia are a slave to their pride and naiveté. They have a preconceived idea that with war comes glory, but they do not consider the truths of it. Instead of understanding war as bloodshed and deadly, the narrator is a “naïve young man whose alliance is less with the Confederacy than with the romance of soldiering itself” (Ladd 45). As young men, they see fighting and war as a masculine act to be part of. Their guns are a phallic imagery that symbolizes their masculinity, but it is the very same object that makes them realize what war truly is when they accidentally kill a man.

Read More

What Is The Creation Myth Of Free State Of Jones

965 Words | 4 Pages

In the book Free State of Jones, Victoria Bynum bases her writings on historical facts of a small community in Jones County, Mississippi. Bynum describes how it was an “inner civil war” which a renegade farmer named Newton Knight led an “yeoman uprising”. Knight led this uprising because Confederates were being unruly and treated them as if they were underrated. Confederates and others felt they were above everyone and whoever did not meet their standards were pushed around and taken control of.

Read More

Confederates In The Attic Analysis

1063 Words | 5 Pages

The living legacy of the United States Civil War is a complicated time in American history one finds difficult to describe. The ramification of the war prior, during and after still haunt the current citizens who call The States their home. Tony Horwitz’s book Confederates in the Attic: Dispatches from the Unfinished Civil War looks at the wide gap of discontent that still looms in the late 1990s. For some southerners, the Confederacy still lives on through reenactments, stories and beliefs. For others in the South, reminders the land was dedicated to the Confederacy spark hatred and spite.

Read More

Summary Of The Best War Ever Sparknotes

756 Words | 4 Pages

While the effort of America was important in winning the war, there was a lot of discrimination and prejudice against blacks, Native Americans, women, and homosexuals within the military. The men who fought in the war saw terrible conditions and many had mental breakdowns. This chapter in the book explains the deaths that many soldiers witnessed and how many men became separated from humanity. This caused many soldiers to become insane. The final two chapters in the book talk about changes in the American society throughout the war and the results from the war.

Read More

How Lincoln Won The War With Metaphors Essay

148 Words | 1 Pages

American Civil War historian, James M. McPherson, in his essay How Lincoln Won the War with Metaphors, argues that if the Union and the Confederacy had exchanged presidents the Confederacy might have won the war. He supports his claim by comparing and contrasting Jefferson Davis’s lack of ability to communicate in an uplifting fashion to Abraham Lincoln’s use of figurative language, especially his metaphors that have the persuasive power of concreteness and clarity which everyone understands and by providing numerous examples of Lincolns metaphors. McPherson’s purpose is to demonstrate how Lincoln was a powerful leader due to his ability to communicate in an inspiring way and appeal to the peoples’ emotions through his use of figurative language

Read More

Themes In The Red Badge Of Courage

961 Words | 4 Pages

In the nineteenth-century war novel The Red Badge of Courage, author Stephen Crane portrays a unique perspective on war uncommon for his time through the experiences of a young Union private, Henry. Crane boldly exposes the horrors of war rather than the commonly proclaimed glory and honor of war, as well as the idea that war allows everyday men “to take measure of themselves.” In the Civil War setting of The Red Badge of Courage, “taking measure of oneself” involves pushing oneself to the limit physically and mentally on the battlefield to determine how courageous or worthy an individual truly is, as demonstrated in the hardships Henry faced throughout the war. However, the idea of war being the true measure of a man holds little truth, as the concept only acknowledges courage in the face of physical danger, ignoring courage in other circumstances. Today’s society, embodied by individualism and diversity, would most likely reject Crane’s limited viewpoint on measuring an individual’s courage and worth.

Read More

More about Review Of What They Fought For By James M. Mcpherson

Related Topics

Open Document