ipl-logo

Rhetorical Analysis Of Organ Sales Will Save Lives By Joanna Mackay

740 Words3 Pages

An organ is so much more than a body part in fact it may even be a life line for some. Could you imagine selling your organs just to put food on the table? Joanna MacKay wrote "Organ Sales Will Save Lives,” which was published in 2016 in The Norton Field Guide to Writing with Readings by Richard Bullock. In this article MacKay argues that lives should be saved not wasted. MacKay helps build her credibility throughout this article with facts and statistics. Joanna MacKay right away states her position on the subject, she brings up points arguing how she believes the sale of human organs should not be illegal, they should be regulated. Throughout this article she successfully employs emotional appeals to audience. She employs her own facts while …show more content…

Organ Sales Will Save Lives, states that about 350,000 Americans suffer from end-stage renal disease which is a kidney disorder that can be life threatening. MacKay continues to let the readers know how expensive, harsh and time-consuming dialysis can be. Some people don’t have the money to help pay for dialysis leaving their kidneys to just shut down and fail. The low odds of selling organs turns over to the black market, people for years now have been purchasing kidneys on the black market for about 150,000 dollars. This is highly illegal and can lead to many problems, there is no paper work to sign or any signs coming back to this. An organ from a cadaver turns out old or damaged, they look for a living donor. MacKay states that an organ from a living donor can last up to twice as …show more content…

The money they get then goes toward food, clothing, and everything they need to support their family. MacKay shows emotional appeal in this regard; however, MacKay’s counterargument states that donating a kidney may be very risky. Although, not risky enough to be outlawed. A quote in The Lancet. states “If rich are free to engage in dangerous sports for pleasure, or dangerous jobs for high pay, it is difficult to see why the poor who take the lesser risk of kidney selling for greater rewards… should be thought so misguided as to need saving from themselves” (Radcliffe-Richards et al. 1951). MacKay put this in her article to make a point, if people can endanger themselves by doing everyday things then why should something that can help your well-being and health be outlawed?
Some readers may think Mackay’s article was very one sided, she didn’t state much of a counterargument and when she did, she stated a rebuttal to help the readers see how there is really no wrong in this. One of MacKay’s counterargument had to deal with John Paul the second who states the “selling of organs is morally wrong and violates the dignity of the human person.” (MacKay 158) MacKay states that we pay men for sperm, we pay woman for donating ova, yet we expect someone to give away an organ for free? If the sales of organs were allowed people would have

Show More
Related
851 Words | 4 Pages

Kidney Transplants - The Hottest Thing Since Botox “Organ Sales Will Save Lives,” by Joanna MacKay, is an informative persuasive article where the author enlightens you about the worldwide kidney crisis and actively sways her readers into personally believing in her argument. MacKay uses facts to appeal to the readers' logic while simultaneously playing on their emotions in a perfect balance, and she is successful through substantial use of data, refutations, and a toss between a serious and passionate tone. MacKay starts her argument off strong by using the appeal of data. This is an amazing strategy to begin her argument with, considering not many people know what end-stage renal disease is, what it does to the body,

Read More
1056 Words | 5 Pages

In the article “Opt-out organ donation without presumptions”, published by Dr. Ben Saunders, he is trying to promotes / defend “opt-out organ donation system”, where people who did not give their consents are automatically, considered as giving their consent to donate their organs when they passes away. This is rather completely opposite to the current organ donation system, Opt-in system, which we are more familiar with, where only people who have given their consents are the group of people who are donating their organ to the (needs). And people who did not give their consent, their organs will not be touched. As the article continues, it describes how much the current society is lacking in available organ donation versus the number of

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

The essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by MIT student Joanna MacKay was written for a class on ethic and politics in science. In the essay MacKay elaborates that kidney failure is a major problem that has a possibility, not so complex solution. MacKay believes that this issue could possibly be resolved if the legalization of organ sales were to be possible. In fact, her main argument throughout the essay is that government officials should not waste lives, but rather help save them by legalizing this process. Furthermore, she explains the dangers of the black market and how authorizing organ sales would benefit all parties involved.

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

She discusses the case of Carl, a man who died while awaiting a kidney transplant. She describes how his family was left to mourn his death (Satel, 2001). By sharing these stories, Satel instills in her readers a sense of sadness and urgency, compelling them to consider the human cost of the organ shortage. Satel appeals to the emotions of her audience and makes a compelling case for legalizing organ sales by humanizing the issue and presenting the real-life consequences of the organ shortage. In her article "Organs for Sale," Sally Satel appeals to readers' emotions to emphasize the human cost of the organ shortage and the urgent need for a solution.

Read More
2266 Words | 10 Pages

"In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money. In such extreme poverty these people barely have enough to eat, living in shacks and sleeping on dirt floors. (Page 4 Para 3). "A study in India discovered that in the long run, organ sellers suffer. In the illegal kidney trade, nobody has the sellers interests at heart.

Read More
628 Words | 3 Pages

The legalization of organ sales in the United States would mean disaster for the lives of thousands of people. In Joanna McKay's article, “Organ Sales Will Save Lives.” she proposes that organ sales will save the lives of the thousands of people that are suffering from end-stage renal disease. However, how she plans to obtain the organs (kidneys, specifically) would cause more harm than good.

Read More
593 Words | 3 Pages

But not everyone can become an organ donor, so the choice isn’t always available. The fact that one of your organs can save up to eight lives is amazing, which is a reason that most people become organ donors. Some people are good Samaritans and they want to help others. On the other hand, some people do not care about the well-being of

Read More
460 Words | 2 Pages

More people are likely to donate if they would be rewarded so that they are helped just like the recipitant. She states that there are several donors in third world countries that would gladly give away their kidney’s for only the cost of $1,000. They are in such a desperate time they would sell their body parts, just to help their family survive. Another reason why organ sales should be legal is because it would stop the illegal trade of kidney’s.

Read More
737 Words | 3 Pages

During the previous decades, society’s behavior with regard to organ donation remains reluctant. A survey showed that although people plainly accept to offer their organs for transplantation, when a person dies, his or her relatives often refuse donation. To be able

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

More than 120,000 people died last year while waiting for a donor, donation of organs costs nothing (“Why be an Organ Donor”). Becoming an organ donor opens up various options such as organ donation or body donation. Body donation is where the bodies will be given to universities or schools around America, where the students of medicine department will do research on the body to figure out why the organ failed (“Body Donor Program”). The body will not be presented to the public and after it is researched it will be cremated and returned to the family as ash 's (“Body Donor Program”). With that being said some of the organs will be perfect to donate, but some may not meet all the requirements for donation , such as correct blood types, free of sexually transmitted diseases, diabetes, and mental health issues ( "Saving Lives and Giving Hope by Reducing the Organ Waiting

Read More
1217 Words | 5 Pages

Organ donation is currently the only successful way of saving the lives of patients with organ failure and other diseases that require a new organ altogether. According to the U.S Department of Health and Human Services there is currently 122,566 patients both actively and passively on the transplant list. This number will continue to increase, in fact, every ten minutes another person is added to the list. Unfortunately, twenty-two of these people die while waiting for an organ on a daily basis. Each day, about eighty Americans receive a lifesaving organ transplant.

Read More
542 Words | 3 Pages

Since there is an opportunity to save thousands of lives by enabling more people to be organ donors, shouldn’t we take it? Thirty years ago, the United States enacted a law that has inadvertently condemned hundreds of thousands of Americans to death. As a result of the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984, more Americans have lost their lives waiting for an organ than died in both World Wars, Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq put together. The act clearly states that the procurement of organs is prohibited; therefore, any financial compensation to donors is also illegal. Reforms must be made to the Transplant Act that would allow compensation to living donors.

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

The act Donating Organs, either prior to death or after death, is considered by many to be one of the most generous, selfless and worthwhile decisions that one could make. The decision to donate an organ could mean the difference of life or death for a recipient waiting for a donor. Organ donations offer patients new chances at living more productive, healthy and normal lives and offers them back to families, friends and neighborhoods. Despite the increasing number of donor designations in the past few years, a shortage still exists in donors.

Read More
1311 Words | 6 Pages

Title: What If It Was You Audience: State Legislators Imagine if it was you, if it was you laying in a hospital bed, waiting for an organ donation and with each passing minute that you don’t receive one, you are getting closer to your final days. It could very much be you, or your loved one, or a friend, considering over 121,272 in 2013 alone were waiting on organ donations. (Learn the Facts) The problem is that organ donation, or the lack of, is becoming a major issue.

Read More
845 Words | 4 Pages

The selling of human organs is not only illegal but unethical, in many cases unsafe, and it is very biased against lower class. CBS news reported a story in July,2009 on a man name Levy Izhak Rosenblum from, Newark, N.J. Sales of human organs from Israel on the black market to American customers in exchange for payments of 120,000 or more (CBS,2011). Levy feels as that he had performed a lifesaving service for desperately ill people who had been on official transplant waiting lists (CBS,2011).

Read More

More about Rhetorical Analysis Of Organ Sales Will Save Lives By Joanna Mackay

Related Topics

Open Document