ipl-logo

Risk And Culture What Is The Difference Between Douglass And Wildavsky

1038 Words5 Pages

The second parameter of risk society this essay will consider is the change in the understanding of risk. In contrast to the arguments of Mary Douglas and Aarond Wildavsky (Risk and Culture 1982) that ‘there are no real or significant differences between the kind of differences between the kind of hazards that we are facing today, and the kind of hazards people used to face in earlier times’, Beck argues that the transition in modernity has led to a change in our understandings of the origins of risk (A. Christiansen & P. Sorensen, 2012, pg. 18). Pre-modern society or ‘pre-industrial’ society was characterised by the existence of external risk. These risks, for example; drought, famine and plague were attributed to external forces, such as …show more content…

In addition, with the presence of globalisation and the ability of ‘money, technologies, commodities, information and toxins to cross frontiers as if they did not exist’, risk is able to cross national boundaries and force global change (U. Beck, 2006, pg. 336). Demonstrating this ability to cross national boundaries and force change on a global scale is the concept of climate change. Multiple elements of the risk of climate change depict a risk society. The first is that the scientific causes of climate change lie deep within second modernity. The ‘innocuous and invisible gasses, such as methane and carbon dioxide, released as by-products of development change the composition of the atmosphere with untold consequences’ (H. Bulkeley, 2001, pg. 431). This complies with Beck’s previously mentioned argument that in risk society, risks arise as side-effects of successful second modernity and industrialisation. Secondly, ‘the sources and experiences of climate change are indeterminately distanciated over space and time, stretching social and natural relations of cause, effect and responsibility, transcending the spatial, social and temporal limits of risks in the past’ (H. Bulkeley, 2001, pg. 432). This complies with the argument that risks are inescapable and unpredictable in a risk society. Even …show more content…

In his 2002 piece Risk, Environment and Society Piet Strydom states ‘risk society is not only characterised by uncertainty about the intensity and reality of risk but also by uncertainty about the elusive concept of risk itself (P. Strydom, 2002). Due to the change in understanding the origins of risk, there has been an increase in contested, competing and conflicting risk definitions. Theorists of risk society compare and contrast many definitions of risk, including ‘local and global, individual and collective, natural and technological, real and constructed, calculable and incalculable, visible and invisible, voluntary and involuntary and actual and perceived risks’ to ensure effective risk communication (M. Ekberg, 2007, pg. 353). The proliferation of risk definitions is demonstrated by the academic literature surrounding the risk society. In World Risk Society (1999) Beck defines risk by distinguishing the difference between risk in danger, claiming ‘the point of this formulation is to distinguish decision-dependent risks that can be in principle brought under control, and dangers that have escaped or neutralised the control requirements of industrial society’ (U. Beck, 1999, pg. 31). In Ecological Politics in an Age of Risk (1995), he further attempts to establish the different between risk and threat by stating that if a private insurance company offers indemnity,

Show More
Related
1873 Words | 8 Pages

In document 2 the author states “seems to me to be leading us fast to a condition where the Government must expand it’s relief activities, and will lead in the end to disaster for all”. This evidence conveys a fear felt by the author that the government's intervention in the economy would lead to an increase of its relief activities and this would result in disaster for everyone. In

Read More
1533 Words | 7 Pages

Kevin Williamson writes in his essay “Apocalypse Soonish: The End Times Roll On” regarding the controversial discussion of climate change and humanity's’ love for apocalyptic drama. Williamson is an excellent writer who knows how to engage the reader with humor and wry comparisons as well as point out some obvious trends that show how dramatic some people can be regarding apocalyptic scenarios. However, his frequent disregard for the consequences of the warming's effects, inability to keep a concise argument and tone, and the recurrent misinterpretation of scientific findings, makes his paper difficult to take seriously. In “Apocalypse Soonish” Williamson compares previous hypotheses and estimations of the earth’s future to current studies

Read More
549 Words | 3 Pages

In the article ‘Why Bother?’ Michael Pollan, a Professor of Journalism at the University of California, examines the dangers of climate change and how ordinary citizens can reduce its effects on the environment. Although most scientists are concerned and have warned nations of its disastrous effects some still deny the existence of climate change. As if melting ice caps and the ever-increasing blue waters were not enough proof, some citizens believe that climate change is an “unproven theory or a negligible contribution to natural climate variability” (Hall 3). Nevertheless, citizens who believe in global warning can change how they live for the better.

Read More
722 Words | 3 Pages

Almost anyone who will read this essay has undoubtedly heard of the climate phenomenon Global warming. Global warming is a topic that gets discussed very often nowadays, most notably during political debate and discussion. Politicians use certain stances on global warming to appeal to voter’s emotions and logic in order to gain votes and support for their campaign, however climate change is nothing new, during the past several hundred thousand years the Earth has heated up and cooled down and even experienced so called “ice ages”, which is a period where glacial deposits located at the northern and southern hemispheres have grown due to dramatic global cool downs. Don’t be confused by climate terminology though, the global warming so widely

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

A harsh cold reality on climate change is exposed to an unbelieving world in Mike Pearl’s “Phoenix will be almost unlivable by 2050, thanks to climate change” article. Mike pearl is a journalist for Vice Magazine in 2017, a rocky year after the election of presidential candidate Donald J. Trump, in a less than stable political climate. As well as a less than stable living climate. According to Mike Pearl, temperatures in Phoenix, Arizona, may be unlivable by 2050 due to climate change. His article is more than effective, as it’s extremely terrifying as he stresses the importance of what this will mean with pathos, logos and ethos.

Read More
585 Words | 3 Pages

Is risk taking worth the effort? By: Gwen May Have you ever taken a risk? Risks are things that may have a positive or negative outcome. Whether it is something small like trying something new.

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

Risks are a possibility of loss or injury; all humans at least once in their lifetime have to do something risky. If life has no risks, you’re not really living it, since we humans do not grow as a species (or society) if there is no challenge in life. People in this world must have challenge and struggle to overcome an obstacle in their life to discover the real world. This way a person will grow physically and most importantly, mentally, to never do something adventurous or take the easy way out is on them. Krakauer, Emerson and Thoreau all have their own ideas on risk, but they all have in common is that risk can change a person for the good or bad.

Read More
1165 Words | 5 Pages

While the humanities lens emphasizes the present and the future impacts of climate change on human values, the historical lens emphasizes the past and how human activity has contributed to climate change. The humanities are concerned with the human response to climate change and how it affects human well-being, while history is concerned with the evolution of human impacts on the environment. By examining my topic through these two lenses, I have gained a more comprehensive and holistic understanding of climate change and its impact on humanity. I have learned that climate change is not just a scientific issue but also a human issue that affects every aspect of our lives. Regarding the similarities and differences in how the lenses relate to my topic, the similarity is that both lenses provide a perspective beyond the scientific aspects of the topic.

Read More
1315 Words | 6 Pages

The use of risk assessment tools has also come under scrutiny, McFerran stressing the importance of risk assessment mechanisms being conducted “with great sensitivity and skill”. Whilst these mechanisms have been regarded as “an empowering way of working that values the woman as expert in her own life” (Kearney, 2004), they must similarly be cautious of “[sending] women the

Read More
1588 Words | 7 Pages

Self-Reflection, Why I chose WMU College, and the decisions I had to make in regards to going, was not easy for me. Growing up in a house and a family where I am the first one to go to college, made everything about going to college a challenge. From a young age, going away is something I always wanted. Of course, my dream as a ten-year-old was to go to Michigan to be a Pediatric Neurosurgeon. And then, I took my first biology course my freshman year of high school, and that changed my plans drastically.

Read More
973 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction The risk society thesis by Ulrich Beck has been one of the most extensively discussed frameworks in environmental management (Matten, 2004). Ulrich Beck who is a German sociologist is the up-to-date theorist of modernity. Beck maintains that the risk which is intrinsic in modern society characterized by technological industrialization produces new forms of global risk society. Beck’s theory is based on the premise that the post-modernist world that we live considers safety and collective decision making on risk as more crucial than amassing wealth.

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

2. Brief analysis/warrant (How/Why this is important?)This shows how if we continue to pollute our atmosphere by emitting greenhouse gases such as carbon into our atmosphere, it will cause more natural disasters which will be more severe due to the rising temperatures which will allow for more severe storms, which is all a result from emissions. II. Conclusion A. Restate Thesis to remind the audience of your position: It can be said from the previous examples that global warming and climate change are both caused by human emission of greenhouse gases which result in consequences such as warmer temperatures and severe natural disasters.

Read More
1661 Words | 7 Pages

Climate Change This quote said by Washington State Governor, Jay Inslee shows the severity of climate change “We are the first generation to feel the sting of climate change, and we are the last generation that can do something about it.” “On Earth human activities are changing the natural greenhouse of the Earth.” (A blanket around the Earth). Burning fossil fuels is causing carbon dioxide to be released into the air.

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

Climate Change is one of the most unsettling problems mankind faces today. It leaves an impact on every single living thing, on every continent, no matter the privilege. Long term investment must be used to change the world. People must do more than just change out their light bulbs for eco-friendly ones, or drive fuel efficient cars. A choice as simple as changing our diets could reduce a human’s carbon footprint by fifty percent.

Read More
1719 Words | 7 Pages

One of the greatest issues that we face towards the environment has been an increasingly difficult problem over the last few years. Earths climate is changing at rapid paces and solutions are needed as quickly as possible to replenish natural ecosystems and cultures that depend on the environment. Climate change not only affects the animals in our ecosystem, but us humans as well. With the human population increasing every year, climate change is only getting worse. Many argue that the effects of climate change towards the environment are due to other extraneous factors, however, I myself am a strong believer that the problems such as rising sea levels, warmer temperatures and natural disasters are all due to both natural causes and human activity.

Read More

More about Risk And Culture What Is The Difference Between Douglass And Wildavsky

Related Topics

Open Document