ipl-logo

Salton Sea Ethical Analysis

1284 Words6 Pages

The Salton Sea is 110-year-old lake that covers 350 square miles but is becoming increasingly salty and smaller in area. Over 400 species of migrating birds are attracted to the marshes and the fish. This essay will focus on three primary ethical dilemmas presented by the Salton Sea issue:
Who/What matters more in this situation?
Since the sea was human made, is it legal and ethical for humankind to sell the water as a commodity?
Does an issue have to impact a larger/greater community for it to be prioritized?
The main ethical dilemma faced by the Salton Sea is determining if either of the following two populations have greater importance - “hundreds of humans who work the land” (Burringer) or “millions of birds that stop to rest and gorge …show more content…

The final ethical dilemma refers to the fact that the Salton Sea issue only directly impacts a small portion of the human population. To truly address all of the ethical dilemmas listed, the people managing this issue have to be guided by concepts and rationales that look beyond the needs of corporations and the wealthy and seek to fix issues so that they do not disproportionately impact non-human animals and oppressed groups. Within the article, the author talks about how the Salton Sea issue impacts the local birds as well as the human population. As the water continues to disappear, the pelicans and grebes have less fish to eat. If the fish disappear, the migrating birds would have almost nothing to eat. Additionally, the dust in the air causes the local children population to have high rates of asthma in the country. As more and more sand is exposed, the wind will create dust clouds that will make it impossible to abide by federal air quality standards. There are two concepts that people could use to determine how to manage the first ethical dilemma listed. The two sides of environmental ethics can be generalized into life-centered ethics and human-centered ethics. Life-centered ethics relies on the idea that humankind is morally bound to protect …show more content…

Moncrief identified the environmental crisis as having three major areas of improvement - an absence of personal moral direction concerning our treatment of our natural resources, inability to adjust to stress, and a faith in technology. The area of improvement that pertains the most to the Salton Sea crisis is moral disparity. As stated within the article, corporate executives are often praised for increasing profits by ignoring pollution abatement laws. As discussed by Bullard, the current law requires a person to sue a polluter to invasion of human rights which can be difficult for those who cannot economically afford the lawyers needed to sue these large companies. For this reason, pollution and other environmental issues disproportionately impact oppressed groups. When faced with this problem, the people managing the Salton Sea crisis should consider implementing the system suggested by Wenz. The system is intended to prevent rich people (and companies) from being able to avoid exposure to harmful environments as well as lessen their involvement in decisions regarding overall pollution. The system itself involves communities earning equal pollution points that cannot be bought and sold on the market. In theory, the system would solve problems involving hazardous waste and companies would no longer be able to export pollution to poor

Show More
Related
204 Words | 1 Pages

Thomas Morton’s article, Oh This Is Great, wants people to have a greater understanding on what’s going in our world. People need to understand that our ocean is a pile of trash. As Morton stated, “The ocean is downstream of everything.” Considering the fact, people are thoughtlessly tossing their trash onto the floor, are sadly ending up into the ocean- where our food chain is greatly affected by.

Read More
655 Words | 3 Pages

The title of the article is The Environmental Crisis: The Devil is in the Generalities, written by Ross McKitrick. It appears in the April 2008 edition of the Academic Matters journal. The author is an associate professor and director of graduate studies at the Department of Economics at the University of Guelph. In discussing the environment, the author argues that the topic is rather wide to use vague terms to define or understand it. The issue is further complicated by politicians who use it as a campaign scapegoat, in which they paint it as a crisis.

Read More
953 Words | 4 Pages

Blackfish (2013) is an American documentary film directed by Gabriela Cowperthwaite and produced by Manuel V. Oteyza. The documentary primarily concerns the controversy of captured Killer Whales at the theme park Sea World, primarily that of Tilikum, an Orca responsible for the deaths of 2010 SeaWorld trainer Dawn Brancheau and two other individuals. The documentary begins with this incident but goes as far back to the 1970 's show the audience how young Orcas are captured in the wild and taken from their families and natural environments. Since its release at the 2013 Sundance Film Festival Blackfish has achieved both critical acclaim and caused controversy regarding SeaWorld 's treatment of its animals as well as retaliation from SeaWorld as to the legitimacy of the film 's claims.

Read More
1094 Words | 5 Pages

McKibben suggests there is inefficient spending and mechanisms by individual consumers. For example, a lots carbon emissions and sewage caused by individual consumers is the result of their inability to use the latest technology. Also, consumers’ inability to respect the regulations of the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act contributes to environmental pollution. He supports this idea by saying “Our wasteful habits wouldn’t matter much if there were just few of us” (559). On the other hand Jensen argues by saying prejudicing powerless individuals instead of those who actually attain influential power in the system of government and policy making is one of the problems to mitigate environmental pollution.

Read More
949 Words | 4 Pages

Offshore Drilling Every year, in the United States alone, 565 million barrels or oil are extracted as a result of offshore drilling; totaling a startling amount of roughly 1.5 million barrels a day. Consequently, these threatening practices are negatively impacting marine mammals, sea birds, sea turtles, and fish. Although drilling offshore provides access to expensive resources such as oil, it heavily contributes to the extinction and endangerment of animals, and the disruption of marine ecosystems, thus these practices should be prohibited and viewed as unethical. To begin, new techniques of horizontal drilling allow for even greater amounts of oil to be extracted from a single well, producing problems in infrastructure on land.

Read More
108 Words | 1 Pages

Do you think this is necessary? Do you think nature advocates such as the International Whaling Commission should allow this? Why or why

Read More
927 Words | 4 Pages

A Case Study on Polluter’s Dilemma I. Background/Point of View On a small plastic manufacturing, Jonica Gunson works as an environmental compliance manager. The company where she is working with is now facing a serious situation that needs to have a fast and decisive decision, decision whether to invest or not to invest money on new technology that will help decrease or as possible eliminate the level of toxic in the water which is flowing from the back of the factory up to lake. Though the company is compliant with the levels of emissions set by the Environmental Management board, the manager sees that environmental procedures for this specific toxic are sheathing behind logical evidence, particularly that there is a protest from a certain scientist that is publish in the newspaper.

Read More
1549 Words | 7 Pages

It is a major issue that should not be ignored because fishermen are murdering dolphins behind the scenes in the cove of Taiji, and the SeaWorld Organization’s capture of the dolphins. To finish off, activist at risk from helping dolphins should be set free. This is why mass murder of dolphins and potentially a mass murder of people is relevant to society. “There was a time when the only time and place where you could really appreciate these magnificent beings was in some kind of water park. An argument was created and sustained that this justified their presence and that entertainment was justified.

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

Many might think that ethical beliefs in what is right or wrong, good or bad, necessary or unnecessary, shouldn 't play a role in life or death. But what about the moral obligations that we share as human beings to protect

Read More
705 Words | 3 Pages

The mine wastes were deposited along the 620 stretch of the river, leading to great loss of animal life and vegetation. The pollution is regarded as the most destructive environmental disaster. The main type of depletion at the mine is the loss of minerals and other natural resources such as vegetation. Compare and contrast the views of (a) an ecological ethic, (b) Blackstone's ethic of environmental rights, and (c) a utilitarian ethic of pollution control.

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

The inhabitants right to an “environment that is not harmful to their health and well-being” and the right to “ecologically sustainable development” is violated. Environmental ethics, on the other hand, is the area of applied ethics that discusses, reflects and reasons on normative measures (values, rules, norms, criteria) for dealing with non-human natural entities in a responsible way (Karafyllis 2013, p.292). In particular, it refers to the value that mankind places on protecting, conserving, and efficiently using resources that the earth provides. Simply put, environmental ethics poses the question - what, if any, moral obligation does man have to the preservation and care of the non-human

Read More
461 Words | 2 Pages

Everyone has a job and everyone does their job. Not every job is right but people only do their jobs thinking it is helping the greater good. A nonfiction excerpt, “Savior Siblings” demonstrates the value of an infant's life, the song, “Independence Day” leaves the daughter without parents, and the excerpt, “ Lather and Nothing Else” indicates that taking a life goes against humanity. Consequently, ethics means the principles that portray the value of

Read More
874 Words | 4 Pages

Environmental ethics refers to the relationship that humans share with the natural world (Buzzle, 2011), it involves people extending ethics to the natural environment through the exercise of self-discipline (Nash, 1989). Herein the essay will give examples of anthropocentrism and non-anthropocentrism as forms of environmental ethics, criticizing anthropocentrism in contrast with a defence of non- anthropocentrism precedents. Anthropocentrism also referred to as human-centeredness, is an individualistic approach, a concept stating that humans are more valuable, and the environment is only useful for sustaining the lives of human beings (MacKinnon, 2007). The practise of human-centeredness is associated with egocentrism (Goodpaster, 1979), by contrast non-anthropocentrism is a holistic approach

Read More
1023 Words | 5 Pages

The reading assignments for this week has been very educative about the environment and making it a better place for living. In this written assignment, I will examine some of the ethical issues related to population growth and their effect to the environment. Also, I will propose solutions to these problems base on the reading material available for this Unit. But before I continue, I wish to introduce us to environmental ethics and its definition which I think it is very important for us to understand so as to know our role to play in this beautiful planet. Environmental ethics is the discipline in philosophy that studies the moral relationship of human beings to, and also the value and moral status of, the environment and its non-human contents

Read More
924 Words | 4 Pages

And one of the old solutions for this concern is to increase number of cultivation lands and exploit new fish stocks. But the competition for land from other human activities makes this an increasingly unlikely and costly solution .for example food producers are experiencing grater rivalry for land, water energy and the need to curb the many negative effects of food production on the environment becoming increasingly clear (Tilman et al. ,2001;

Read More

More about Salton Sea Ethical Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document