ipl-logo

Scarlet O Hara And Judy Jones Comparison

1041 Words5 Pages

One of the greatest parts of storytelling is getting to create characters with their own unique personalities and getting to build a dynamic with them. Gone with the Wind and “Winter Dreams” are two great examples of that with Scarlet O’Hara and Judy Jones, respectively. The time periods for both of the women are very different (50 years apart, to be exact), and that showed in some aspects of their personalities. However, a comparison of O’Hara and Jones divulges more similarities than differences in them as we try to explore who they will spend life with while also determining that Judy is a little bit worse of a person than O’Hara. Scarlet O’Hara’s story takes place during the American Civil War. She only has eyes for one man, Ashley, …show more content…

Scarlet is at least decent to the guys who want her affection and doesn’t go around with many other men behind their backs unlike Judy. Also, Scarlet is more rebellious as she rejects the standards of looking like a woman at all times and sneaks out to see Ashley to convince him to rethink his decision and marry her. Finally, she is much more impulsive as she murders the northern deserter when he comes into their home in order to protect her friends and family and then simply states that she will think about what she has done tomorrow. Meanwhile, Judy is much more arrogant than the prior as fully expects Dexter to caddie and drive the boat for her, personally states that she’s more beautiful than anyone else, and expects Dexter to drop everything for her when she returned, even though he was with Irene then. Judy’s looks change with her personality traits unlike Scarlet, like when she was unhappy with Simms at the end and seen as unattractive rather than beyond beautiful like she was to the golfers and Dexter before. The worst part about her, in my opinion, is when she hits Mr. Hedrick while golfing and is only concerned with how her ball could have been closer to the hole if it hadn’t hit him instead of apologizing, which is completely the opposite of O’Hara considering she showed she cared for others and even went as far as donating her wedding ring to the war efforts. Therefore, there is definitely a lot of contrast in these two

Show More
Related
1050 Words | 5 Pages

In Flannery O’Connor’s short stories, “A good man is hard to find” and “Good country people”, O’Connor utilizes multiple stylistic elements in her writing to create a complex and compelling plot line. These elements, such as moments of growing tension and resolve or relying on faith when a character experiences extreme fear, are key components that add direction and meaning to both of her short stories. Other examples such as headstrong females, like the grandmother from “A good man is hard to find” and Joy/Hulga from “Good country people”, shows how two different types of women can still have dignity despite their own faults. In short, Flannery O’Connor utilizes multiple stylistic elements in her short stories to create a meaningful and compelling tale of people from the south.

Read More
1388 Words | 6 Pages

The novel goes through many recurring themes such as child abuse, social and economic differences, and legitimacy. These themes not only impact the main character but all the characters as a whole. It is the harrowing story of how Ruth Anne “Bone” Boatwright, a child must learn to cope and deal with the many terrible atrocities that are inflicted upon her by her stepfather, “Daddy Glen.” Before Bone could even coherently make a judgment upon herself she was labeled as an outcast. She was a sin and mistake that should be labeled as such for the world to know about it.

Read More
268 Words | 2 Pages

The protagonists of both Erik Larson’s the Devil in the White City and Denis Johnson’s novella Train Dreams share similar experiences despite being located in different parts of the country. “That he'd taken on an acre and a home in the first place he owed to Gladys. He'd felt able to tackle the responsibilities that came with a team and wagon because Gladys had stayed in his heart and in his thoughts.” (Johnson, 82). At a time where women are beginning to venture out and become increasingly present in society, Grainier acknowledges the strength and support he received from his late-wife Gladys.

Read More
493 Words | 2 Pages

If Jane Addams were to do speed dating, she would most likely have chosen, Florence Kelley as a suitor for her work and involvement as a social activist. Florence Kelley was outspoken about racial equality and an activist for child's rights. She helped to create the NAACP, and was the vice president of NAWSA. Jane Addams supported and spoke out for equal treatment for all people, therefore her social and moral beliefs were compatible with Florence Kelley’s. While Kelley started the National Association for the Advancement of Colored people, Addams started the Hull House.

Read More
1530 Words | 7 Pages

This quote explains the first time Sarah has truly felt relief and free from any burden or judgment she endures from her abolitionist opinions. Sarah’s time away from her mother and prejudice town gives her the time and space to grow and truly become individualized. Sarah’s actions of rebelment shows that she is independent and true to herself by being able to go against her Truong 4 mother and live for herself, going against her family’s ways of living. To add on, Nina Grimke follows in Sarah’s footsteps, rebelling against their family’s lifestyle but more boldly. Nina refusing to be accepted into the church that the Grimkes attend and causes implications between Nina, Missus, and the Minister.

Read More
535 Words | 3 Pages

As the story progressed, I became irritated because Dexter only noticed Judy’s beauty. For this reason, he destroyed his engagement with Irene when he crossed path with Judy once again. Similarly, I was irritated

Read More
622 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout the entire story, Judy only cares for money, is cruel to Dexter, and proves to be selfish. These three characteristics can be proven through her words and actions in Winter Dreams. Judy Jones was born into wealth through her family.

Read More
1967 Words | 8 Pages

Without her looks Dexter did not want her, and realized he wasted a lot of his life obsessing over her. Dexter was more in love with Judy’s looks than the actual person she was. Once she lost her looks Dexter realized that she was not who he wanted

Read More
1051 Words | 5 Pages

She has many lovers who are wealthy and those who are not are left in the dust behind her. When Dexter is to be married she ruins his marriage to be by having an affair. Little does Dexter know that many years later he hear the news of Judy Jones not being beautiful, where now his winter dream is lost jst like Judy’s beauty. Looking at Dexters life and how he carries on about who he wants to be, one can see he lets others dictate his life and his decisions on who he was as a person.

Read More
675 Words | 3 Pages

Women have had it rough throughout history but some adapted and became stronger because of the hardship, like O-land from the Good Earth and the “Virtuous woman.” What makes them so similar is they are both hardworking people. Though there are many similarities, there are also a few differences. Both can be described simply because they have similar personalities as well. To survive in this world you need to be strong like O-lan and the Woman, while different they still did what needed to be done

Read More
232 Words | 1 Pages

Rash’s novel Serena is known as his 2009 PEN/Faulkner finalist and New York Times best-selling novel. It is a gothic tale of greed, corruption, jealousy, obsession, desperation, mental illness and murder; narrating the story of the newlyweds George and Serena Pemberton who arrive in North Carolina in 1929 to create a timber empire. Living further in the mountains, Serena shows herself to be the equal of any worker in the timber camp. Knowing previously that George has an illegitimate child from Rachel Harmon (a sixteen-year-old girl who used to work in the camp) does not affect Serena’s self-confidence or her trust towards her husband.

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

This causes the events in the story to unfold. Whether or not Judy is a true Femme Fatale can be argued as she is only going along with Gavin Elster’s, a man looking to kill his wife, plan. But nevertheless her actions influence the movie and she chooses to carry them out leading Scotties to

Read More
1029 Words | 5 Pages

The male characters in the novel do not understand the hardships women faced during wartime. While the men were fighting in the Civil War, women were forced to provide for themselves, which changed the roles of southern women. In turn southern women became as “ghosts” through the eyes of their male counterparts. Next, Gradisek focuses primarily on the life and domestication of Miss Rosa.

Read More
867 Words | 4 Pages

One of the most enjoyable facets of analyzing literature is comparing characters of similar or contrasting novels from the same time period and discussing how they are similar or dissimilar. In some cases, a reader can analyze more than one character from each book, in order to see if one is more or less like another. In this instance the two novels are not really novels, they are plays, in which characters drive the story’s development. With the action propelled by spoken dialogue, plays require their characters to be condensed so that the listener can understand the plot without copious amounts of exposition. With the information about the characters from the plays “The Glass Menagerie” by Tennessee Williams and “The Little Foxes” by Lillian

Read More
1211 Words | 5 Pages

“She simply made men conscious of the highest degree of her physical loveliness. Dexter had no desire to change her. Her deficiencies were knit up with a passionate energy that transcended and justified them.” (P. 5). Even though Judy had these attributes, Dexter didn’t want her any other

Read More

More about Scarlet O Hara And Judy Jones Comparison

Related Topics

Open Document