ipl-logo

Second Degree Murder Case Summary

1087 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Murder case summarry

The scene starts on a 50 degree spring day, March 31, before 6:00 P.M. It involves Mr Muldoon (the police chief), Mr Ernie Miller, (the suspect), Mrs Miller, (the victim and the suspect’s wife), and me, the detective to the scene. The incident happened at the Miller residence. Mrs Miller is dead, and we need to find the reason why. There is substantial evidence that proves that the defendant needs to be convicted of second degree murder. According to Findlaw, second degree murder is defined as being in the heat of the moment. (criminal.findlaw.com) There are many blatant holes in Mr Miller’s argument. Let’s start at the beginning. We greeted Mr Miller at his back porch, where we heard him unlocking his back door to come out. He stated that …show more content…

These injuries are paired with signs of a fight. An organic substance was found under the decedent's fingernails, while the defendant had on bandaids during the questioning. I feel as though a DNA test on the organic substance versus Mr Miller’s DNA would be a crucial piece of evidence for this case. Mr Miller additionally stated that his wife was a heavy drinker. The defendant said this was why his wife had fallen, yet when Mrs Miller was examined, the coroner’s report stated that the victim had a 0 Blood Alcohol Content, or …show more content…

Both of her wrists had been ripped out of the sockets. There were miniscule cuts and scrapes along her calves. When investigating the substance,there was limestone in these scrapes, (which is coincidentally what the gravel in the Miller’s driveway is made of.) The decedent had bruises on the back of her head, and on her back and chest. How could the back of Mrs Miller’s head been bruised if she had fallen face first off the porch, as Mr Miller had originally stated. A final note that the medical examiner made was that the victim’s body was showing obvious signs of livor mortis. According to author Stephen Thompson, livor mortis is skin discoloration where the skin changes color after a body is moved. (98) This indicates clearly that Mrs Miller had been moved from the time of her death, and the only person who could have been there to move her was her husband.
When we were looking for any possible clues, we noticed that Mrs Miller had on a coat that would be fitting for the spring weather had she been planning on going somewhere, but would be overdoing it from “going outside for a drink” as the defendant had stated. When we looked in her coat, we found that there was a letter addressed to Ernie “Lubby Dubby” Miller with a return address from a female. We can assume with reasonable suspicion that Mr Miller was having an affair with the female on the envelope, a Mary “Sweetums” Eckhart. In the envelope was a letter

Show More
Related
570 Words | 3 Pages

He stated that he tried to perform CPR on the victim but it was too late and he was unable to revive her. However, the findings of blood spatter expert Samantha Warna they amount of blood and the consistency that was on Hill’s clothing was conducive to him being close to the victim as she was being bludgeoned. The prosecution argued that Hill was very calculated and even called Wright’s phone from his car to let the voicemail record the radio station that he was listening to so that he could prove that he wasn’t there.

Read More
398 Words | 2 Pages

The prosecution is charging the defendant Alex palmer with first degree murder of Jes Markson. Critical aspects of four witness testimonies will be analyzed and discussed. Furthermore, the prosecution will explain the importance of each testimony and how the testimony helps link the Defendant Alex Palmer to the crime. The first witness Detective Dana Brown should state that she has been working for the Hollywood police department for eighteen years, seven of which have been as a detective. Disclosure of this information to the jury will help establish her credibility.

Read More
1779 Words | 8 Pages

Case Briefs: Case: State v. Marshall, 179 S.E. 427 (N.C. 1935). Opinion by: Stacy C.J. Facts: A homicide occurred at the defendant’s filling station. At the filling station the deceased was previously drinking and was sweet talking the defendant’s wife in a whispering conversation. The deceased was asked to leave the building, yet the defendant order him more than once.

Read More
464 Words | 2 Pages

The arrestee claimed that she was in fear, so she threw water at the victim and the jar slipped from her hand. The arrestee stated that the victim caught the jar and threw it back at the arrestee, striking her back and then broke.” When the officer checked out Jenelle’s version of the story, he could not find any evidence of a broken Mason jar or pieces of glass, to confirm her statements. He also could not see any evidence of harm done to Jenelle by being hit by a glass. “This would have made the broken glass somewhere farther in the driveway, I looked and did not observe any redness or any other injury to the arrestee’s back.”

Read More
1063 Words | 5 Pages

The pathologist identified bruises on Rust’s knuckles that were consistent with having hit Lavallee. Miller had the doctor “confirm that Battered Woman Syndrome is not a psychiatric term”(Sheehy, 2014, 22). One of Miller’s strategies was to get Lavallee to testify on grounds that if she did not, the defense would be “introducing medical and psychiatric evidence without an evidentiary foundation”(Sheehy, 2014, 33). Nonetheless, the judge decided Lavallee was not required to testify so Miller went on to persistently try to get Dr.Dirks to state that one emergency visit a year is normal. Miller continuously tried to suggest that Lavallee’s injuries could have been caused by anyone, not just Rust because her injuries were quite often ‘singular’.

Read More
690 Words | 3 Pages

She said she invited some friends over afterwards for one last drink before they called it a night. She left a little bit earlier so she could meet her friends at the door. When she got home she found Author dead, met her friends at the door claiming that something terrible had happened. Author slipped coming down the stairs for another drink. The glass was still in his hand and she believed that he was dead.

Read More
661 Words | 3 Pages

First, Hatchett was convicted from the testimony of a witness. Gerard Williams testified and identified Hatchett as the man he saw swinging at the victim. From this single testimony, Hatchett was found guilty of second degree murder and sentenced to 25-years-to-life. The second reason the trial led to the conviction was because of something Mr. Hatchett’s lawyers did not do. Neither of Hatchett’s crutches and wearing a leg cast and was physically unable to commit the crime.

Read More
954 Words | 4 Pages

On Sunday, November 13, 1842 a double murder occurred at Smith Farm in Old Fields, Long Island. The victims, Alexander Smith and and Rebecca Smith, were a wealthy, well- respected married couple who ran Smith farm. George Weeks, the Smiths farmhand, was reporting for work the monday after the murder and heard the dog barking from the work-shed by the Smiths house. George Weeks then became suspicious since the dog was usually inside with Mr. Smith. George then looked in the house and saw that the east room window was broken and Mr. and Mrs. Smith were lying on the floor covered in blood.

Read More
1794 Words | 8 Pages

Accordingly, I questioned Pondexter “so-called” innocence in this horrific criminal act because he knowingly entered Lennox’s home with three other men with a gun to rob, inflict fear and possibly cause harm. In my view, the crime was premeditated, including the murder. According to Pondexter’s attorney David Dow, since the first gunshot fired by James Lee Henderson pierced Lennox’s brain the defense claimed that this was the wound that resulted in her death.

Read More
681 Words | 3 Pages

Elizabeth Short’s murder is one of the most notable cold case in the history of the U.S. . The failure to catch her murderer was blamed on the sensationalization of the murder by the media. The 2nd and 3rd cases were either once or still are cold cases, probably because of the time when the murders were committed. The first murder was more obvious who the killer was, unlike the last two who have twist and

Read More
960 Words | 4 Pages

First-Degree Murder is the most serious crime that can be committed, punishable by the death penalty. Once someone commits this crime, they are forever known as a dangerous and terrible person. The decision to murder someone is usually conscious, but in some occasions the suspect can plead innocent for reasons of temporary insanity. In the short story “The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe, a man decided to murder his neighbor because he was scared of the neighbor’s eye. When the police came to interrogate him, the man heard a heartbeat in his head.

Read More
1159 Words | 5 Pages

Stereotypes are preconceived notions about a specific group of people that justify various treatments of those people. The movie Crash, written and co-directed by Paul Haggis shows an in depth look at the deep racial divide that is flowing through the United States. The name of the movie gives in interesting general theme for the entire movie. With so many depicted interactions between various ethnic groups, races, and people of different social statuses, all these moving parts come together over a thirty-six-hour time period as plot lines intertwine (or crash together). Following the story of one couple in the movie, Rick Cabot, a district attorney for the city of Los Angeles, and his wife Jean, there is clear role of how both stereotyping and physical geography intensify the disconnect between different classes and ethnic groups.

Read More
689 Words | 3 Pages

Earlier that day before the accident, the judge had just lost his wife, made Mark Blackwell surrender his vehicle to his ex-wife as payment for missed child support. The judge and Mark Blackwell have also had a history together due to the fact the judge has sentenced him twice earlier in his life once for a violent act against his girlfriend which he received a light sentence of 30 days in jail and then again when Blackwell killed his girlfriend shortly after he was released from jail and received a twenty-year sentence. The evidence was strong against Joseph Palmer which would include blood of the victim on the front end of the Mr. Palmers’ 71 Cadillac DeVille, the conversation the two had during an encounter at a local convenience store w, and the security camera showing the changing of his path home to follow the victim (Mark Blackwell). Although there is sufficient evidence against the accused there are also issues with the story of the night when the victim was hit while riding his bike home.

Read More
1143 Words | 5 Pages

In the case of Mary Barnett, I agree with the courts decision to find her guilty of second degree murder and manslaughter. This is largely based on my analysis of the witnesses presented during the trial and the demeanor and actions of the defendant. Having an associates degree in psychology helped me formulate decisions about the role of each character and what part they were to play during the course of the trial. I utilized the teaching from the text book as well as the concepts from my social psychology class which required me to people watch and analyze the surroundings, body language, and actions of others.

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

The judge declares the “Murder in the first degree—premeditated homicide—is the most serious charge tried in our criminal courts. One man is dead. The life of another is at stake. If there is a reasonable doubt in your minds as to the guilt of the accused … then you must declare him not guilty. If, however, there is no reasonable doubt, then he must be found guilty.

Read More

More about Second Degree Murder Case Summary

Related Topics

Open Document