ipl-logo

Sedgwick's Futility Argument And Doctrine Of Double Effect

477 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Utilitarianism and the rules of war

The care of civilians during a time of conflict has two arguments Sedgwick’s utility argument and Doctrine of Double Effect or Doctrine of Double Effect prime. I will argue for the Doctrine of Double Effect on the grounds it provide a clear view on what is considering the right actions. While Sidgwicks view allows for all actions to be consider just if framed correctly. Secondly, I will argue that Doctrine of Double Effect prime provides a greater respect to civilians by narrowing its aim. This is due to the update of the Doctrine of Double Effect by Walzer. Civilians require due care during a time of war and through the use Doctrine of Double effect along with Doctrine of Double Effect prime provides the most care. War presents this dilemma …show more content…

Sedgwick answer to this problem would be “Any act of force that contributes in significant way to winning the war is likely to be permissible”(walzer). The mission is to search the town thus military necessity; in this instance kicking the door down is allowed. If necessity allows anything than one must weigh the use of force thus the second rule is proportionality. The second rule of Sedgwick’s utility addresses the use of force to obtain the required outcome. The proportionality of force relies on the solider in charge if a good moral leader. Then one may assume kicking the door is the right amount of force required to obtain victory, in this sense would be opening the door, this is the end one hopes to achieve. If the solider in charge takes action against the door and a window the use of force would be out of proportion. This could be compared weighing each option on a scale of good and bad. The attempt would be made to balance each scale so not to be out of balance. The door would be placed on one side of the scale while the action of breaching the door on the other. Thus the action and the required out come is balanced or proportionate. The window when placed on this scale is not required to enter the house the scale is out of proportion. Sedgwicks answer to this

Show More
Related

Assess The Significance Of Allied Strategic Bombing On Germany During World War II

2007 Words | 9 Pages

An American airman wrote after the war that the introduction of strategic bombing created “total war”, where the opportunities to eliminate other nation’s strength did not just destroy the military armed forces, but also the civilians of the country itself, essentially making the home front a front line. In 1940, the British Red Cross Society changed its statutory role from helping sick and wounded soldiers on the front line, to also helping “wounded, injured and even mentally-distressed civilian victims, as a consequence of modern warfare”. This shows that World War II’s new war strategies meant that medical assistance needed to be provided to normal civilians, as well as soldiers in the field. World War II was the first time in history that civilians had been targeted to great effect. During World War I, there was an attempt by the warring countries to strategically bomb towns and cities.

Read More

X-47b Dbq

214 Words | 1 Pages

Based on the principle proportionality it is prohibited to intentionally launch an attack which is expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, and damage to civilian objects which would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military

Read More

Just War Ethics Summary

484 Words | 2 Pages

But is it enough? I also appreciate that through the years the just war theory has been expanded to include new parameters for methods and reasoning among other points (p. 143-4). But is it enough? 2) A major dilemma in war is the

Read More

Questions Two-What Did The Army Learn From The Meuse-Argonne

1161 Words | 5 Pages

currently down which is something that can be used very effectively in the art of war. In World War One we used this tactic again by entering the war when the enemy was already being threatened and attacked. By applying the lessons used in past wars, it allowed us to successfully navigate through future conflicts and battles. Question Two-

Read More

Moral Equivalent Of War Essay

901 Words | 4 Pages

Since the beginning of time, war has been practiced for numerous reasons ultimately to benefit a group of people or nations. But, when war divides the world into two different sides with the capability to destroy faster than we can create, it makes us question, is war really worth it? With the aftermath of World War One, people we’re still divided, but for a different reason, after a war with a catastrophic amount of deaths we had militarists advocating to fight and pacifists demanding peace. The two sources I have used from this essay comes from a European militarist, Friedrich Von Bernhardi with his book “War a Biological Necessity” and United States pacifists, William James, in his book “Moral Equivalent of War”. Therefore this essay will review the

Read More

My Brother Sam Is Dead By Mr Collier

707 Words | 3 Pages

The point is further established when Colonel Read states, “War is never fair. Who chooses which men get killed and which ones don’t?” (Collier and Collier 200). Warfare comes at a cost, and one never knows who will pay it. By the same token, the authors stress that as long as the fighting goes on only unfair consequences will

Read More

Thomas Findley Psychological Effects Of War

940 Words | 4 Pages

Moreover, the author decided to portray this concept throughout the whole novel to remind the reader that physical destruction is not the only disadvantage of war. Many individuals believe that surviving on the battlefield without experiencing dreadful injuries, grant the young soldiers a life full of peace and freedom. In fact, the youth who are affected by the psychological disorders need as much guidance and support as the soldiers who are brutally injured during the battles. Moreover, the psychological wars that bombard their minds have the power to trample upon their life. To conclude, the soldiers did not dare to aim for a successful future since the warfare annihilated their mental

Read More

War Is Kind And Mankind Rhetorical Analysis

443 Words | 2 Pages

In a desperate attempt for peace, as ironic as it may be, we create chaos, resulting in the death of millions at a time. Firearms burn bright in the dim sun, exposing the vibrancy of blood-stained suits. As the bullets penetrate skin, the life of another innocent individual has already been lost. Families never to hear a last, “I love you” before their loved one tragically passes in a loud, chaotic mess. They run towards the danger, knowing exactly what result the soldiers might have gotten in the gamble of life or death.

Read More

Ghetto Dbq

659 Words | 3 Pages

The Ghettos In the fall of 1941, many Jews in Germany occupied countries of Austria and Czechoslovakia were deported to Poland.(book) They were forced to live in the ghettos , which were set up in a major towns there.(book) These were enclosed by walls and guarded at night. The jews were only permitted to take a few personal items with them to the ghetto, in the process being stripped of the homes and property that they had left behind.(Daily Life in Ghettos) Jewish councils, made up of elders, who were community leaders, were responsible for organizing the day-to day affairs of the ghettos.(book) The people working for the Jewish council forced a very difficult task.(book)

Read More

The Perils Of Difference By Elie Wiesel

1068 Words | 5 Pages

When adults wage war, children perish. We see their faces, their eyes. Do we hear their pleas? Do we feel their pain, their agony? Every minute one of them dies of disease, violence, famine.”

Read More

The Theories Of Carl Von Clausewitz: The Principles Of War

1441 Words | 6 Pages

According to Clausewitz, military commanders must first be aware of the three most important strategic objectives of war: (1) to conquer and destroy the armed power of the enemy; (2) to take possession of his material and other sources of strength, and (3) to gain public opinion.1 To attain the strategic objectives, Clausewitz requires the application of three decisive military principles: military commanders must apply unrelenting pressure and energy to defeat the enemy; military commanders must mass combat power against the enemy’s vulnerability, creating or revealing additional weaknesses that the attacking force can exploit; and commanders must capitalize on speed, surprise, and shock to destroy the enemy. Clausewitz insists that

Read More

Critical Analysis Of In Defense Of Mercenarism By Cecile Fabre

1150 Words | 5 Pages

In the first section of this article, Fabre categorically stipulates “my claim is that, under strict conditions (which current practices do not meet), the marketization of war is not morally wrong.” She argues that although one should not kill for gain, circumstances might be so dire as to provide the employer and employee with a justification for such an act. She tables an argument based on the right of individuals to

Read More

Examples Of Utilitarianism In The Movie The Island

1524 Words | 7 Pages

The military officer then directs one of the working agents to “open the door “for the people. In this situation, an act utilitarian would view the situation based on bad consequences which encounters and then considers the situation as self-defence for others or moral obligatory in

Read More

Just War Tradition Essay

1716 Words | 7 Pages

There are three parts of Just War theory, named different in English but common in Latin. “Just ad Bellum” part describes the conditions under which the use of military force is justified, “Jus in Bello” gives guidance how to conduct a war in an ethical manner and “Jus post Bellum” directs how to act in a transition to

Read More

Alexiyevich's Unwomanly Face: An Analysis

1073 Words | 5 Pages

As a result we, as a society, come to reject the harsh details of war and further disillusion our own selves to believe that everything is fine by creating a false persona. With war comes a loss of identity, which further signifies disorder and a lack of control. The most important theme about war that we have studied is the loss of identity

Read More

More about Sedgwick's Futility Argument And Doctrine Of Double Effect

Related Topics

Open Document