ipl-logo

Should Child Soldiers Be Responsible For War Crimes

652 Words3 Pages

I am an eighth grade student at Sherwood Middle School, in Sherwood, Oregon. My language arts class is trying to decide whether or not child soldiers should receive amnesty. I believe that child soldiers who have committed war crimes should not be given amnesty by the United Nations. For one thing, not punishing these adolescents can have negative effects. It can influence the use of more child soldiers and not give justice to their victims. Although it may be true that some minors are forcefully drafted. Many children volunteer to become soldiers in wartime. In general, if a child can be convicted of crime, such as murder, then they should also be held responsible for crimes committed in war. The crimes they committed during war are just …show more content…

For instance, “ allowing child soldiers immunity from prosecution denies victims justice” (Child Soldiers, Prosecution, 12). Victims of crimes that have been committed want justice for what has happened. In addition, commanders can be influenced to use juveniles for war crimes because there would be no punishment (Child Soldiers, Prosecution, 18). If child soldiers aren't prosecuted then their commanders will continue to use minors because there would be no consequences for their actions. Not having consequences for war crimes committed by child soldiers will have bad outcomes.
It could be said that they are forcefully drafted. Most of the child soldiers are purchased, kidnapped or terrorized into joining a country’s army (Gettleman, 7). Many children are forced into fighting. On the other hand, “many children volunteer to become soldiers in wartime out of patriotism or a desire to avenge the death of their families (Child Soldiers, Prosecution, 11). If they have volunteered to be a soldier, or even if they hadn't, they still chose to kill and should be held responsible for their wrong actions. Though some children are forced to enrol to fight, the chose to commit the

Show More
Related
1458 Words | 6 Pages

Thousands and thousands, of children in the Middle East and Africa, are being used as soldiers where it is needed. These children kill others and do things that no other child should have to do. People wonder if child soldiers should be given amnesty or not. The issue of child soldiers came to worldwide attention when Ishmael Beah published his book A Long Way Gone, which was based on what happened while he was a child soldier. A child soldier is someone under the age of eighteen and who is used in wars.

Read More
569 Words | 3 Pages

As long as former child soldiers show that they will not recommit their acts of violence, they should be granted amnesty. Child soldiers are often forced into being violent. They shouldn’t be held responsible for things that they were essentially forced to do. Although there is plenty of evidence showing that child soldiers should be given amnesty, some may argue the opposite. People may say that they could sacrifice their own lives instead of killing others, but that is too much to expect of kids.

Read More
110 Words | 1 Pages

The decisions and actions Odysseus makes throughout his Odyssey, not only call upon the person he is but shape the person he becomes, with many of the challenges honing his character. Homer uncovers the traits that most befittingly define Odysseus as honor, courage and guile. The traits that are glorified in The Odyssey, connect to recent times because they are comparable to those we think of when defining a hero or an impeccable human being. Odysseus’ use of his honor, courage and guile showcase how these traits allowed him to excel in his time and also are key traits all should have for the challenges we must face in

Read More
939 Words | 4 Pages

There are thousands of child soldiers in the world today. These children are stripped from their homes and sent to fight with people twice their age. Many haven’t even had their 11th birthday yet. Although some people say that child soldiers should not be granted amnesty, evidence shows that these children do deserve amnesty, except in cases when the former soldiers show violent behavior after war because children are forced to commit acts of violence and are force addicted to illegal substances so they won’t want to leave.

Read More
639 Words | 3 Pages

“ Many children volunteer to become soldiers in wartime out of patriotism or a desire to avenge the death of their families.” This tells me that they do it for protection or like payback for what they had done before to everyone. “ At the time they might believe that recruiting would lead to a safer life as necessities as food, water and shelter would be available.” This tells me that some child soldiers join and everything because they need food and somewhere to live because they don't have it and they need it. This is another reason why I think child soldiers should be

Read More
1603 Words | 7 Pages

In the article, “CHILD SOLDIERS AND THE GLOBAL AGENDA” it says, “Children need be the victims of war only if there is no will to prevent it.” This helps show how children should not be involved in war in the first place. They aren’t the ones who have started the war. It isn’t their fault in the first place so why are people punishing the children for their involvement when it wasn’t their fault. They expect the kids to serve time or to get a death sentence when it was adults like them who brought them into this mess.

Read More
658 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine your childhood, sweet, cute and simple. This isn 't the case for everyone. Right now there are child soldiers who are making memories, but they aren 't good. They 're violent and damaging, but there is nothing they can do about it. These children are being forced by commanders to fight in war, they are seeing things that children should never have to see, and they 're being put under drugs and can 't think clearly.

Read More
868 Words | 4 Pages

Many young children under aged have been taken in by the government. They are being held captive tell they are drugged enough and brainwashed to go out and kill or to be killed. They are forced to train to kill under the influence of drugs and they are hardly aware of what they or doing. Child soldiers should be given amnesty because of the absents of their minds and them not being able to process what they are doing. These children are often seen as targets because they are under aged and not able to take responsibility for their actions so they are targeted to be able to kill without punishment.

Read More
1812 Words | 8 Pages

To begin, some will say that child soldiers should be prosecuted because they have caused harm to others, but rehabilitation should be the aim because of the horrors they have seen. Children have seen blood, bruises, bones, and dead bodies, haphazardly strewn freely among the battlefield--dead. They have seen men trying to murder each other right before their very eyes, and are aghast after what they have seen. What does this do to the minds of these innocent children who haven’t yet learned to be civil? The children are now scarred, and need to learn to cope with the violence they have been influenced by.

Read More
1802 Words | 8 Pages

Child Soldiers should be given amnesty because they are pressured to take drugs, forced into fighting, and don’t know what is going on after their new lives begin. Child Soldiers should be given amnesty

Read More
586 Words | 3 Pages

According to Human Rights Watch’s article, “Child Soldiers,” people as young as eight years old are put into the army. They are also being manipulated and forced into homicidal situations. More or less, this is violating the human right to freedom of thought, in

Read More
1646 Words | 7 Pages

When these children use their weapons, others are killed, and these children can get prosecuted. Child soldiers should be given amnesty because they are not fully responsible for their actions, they join without fully knowing what they are doing and for reasons other than wanting to fight, and they should be rehabilitated instead of being prosecuted. Child soldiers should be given amnesty because they are not fully responsible for their actions. Often, child soldiers are doing what they do because of drugs or because they are being forced to. Most times child soldiers are not doing what they want.

Read More
678 Words | 3 Pages

They also volunteer themselves or their parents sold them into it. Child soldiers should receive amnesty because they were forced into it and used as fighters.

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

Assignment page Video Where many children all over the world merrily and freely live under the protection of the law, for others, this is a distant reality, they live in a world where they’re battling poverty, stripped of their childhood and basic human rights are expunged, they’re the innocent victims of conflict, and war is made to seem their one and only duty, not to mention that these are children no more than 10 years of age. They are put into a situation where it’s to kill or be killed. The United Nations defines a child soldier as, “Any person under 18 years of age who is part of any kind of regular or irregular armed force or armed group in any capacity.” Since the past 15 years, child soldiers are being used in almost every region of the world. Unlike most children, who go to school, they’re abducted from their families and forced into becoming a child soldier, where living conditions are beyond imaginable.

Read More
857 Words | 4 Pages

In the world today, there is more than 25 countries who still actively use children in warfare. Child soldiers are human beings under the age of 18 who participate in military actions. They are evidently cheaper to maintain and to train than adult soldiers. They are also more loyal and obedient because the young respect their elders. It has been noted that estimately, 300 thousand children were recruited to fight and perform in war (Child Soldiers.)

Read More

More about Should Child Soldiers Be Responsible For War Crimes

Related Topics

Open Document