In the short story “participation trophies send a dangerous message” written by Betty Berden, Berden talks about how children shouldn’t be rewarded for participating only to winners. Also reading from “participating trophies send a powerful message” written by Parker Abate, Abate discusses how children should be rewarded with trophies because of their hard work and dedication. “In addition to acknowledging their effort, they also received trophies or certificates, reminding them that they were part of a team. Children should be rewarded with trophies for participating so that everyone is treated equally. While reading both passages, “participation trophies send a dangerous message” by Betty Berden and “participation trophies send a powerful
In the article “Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message” by Betty Berden, she talks about why children should not receive participation trophies. On the other hand, in the article “In Youth Sports, Participation Trophies Send a Power Message” by Parker Abate, states why should children receive participation trophies? Kids should not receive participation rewards or trophies. Why shouldn't children receive trophies? According to Berden, there are many reasons why kids should be rewarded for participation.
Participation Trophies In the debate between the authors Parker Abate and Betty Berden, the two speak about all kids getting participation trophies and how it affects each kid. Though they both make outstanding points, I am all on Betty Berden's side; no participation trophies. Participation trophies should strictly be given to the winners, not every kid who takes a step on the field. When playing sports, most kids are learning how to work with a team and how to communicate; simple life lessons.
title Walking off the field with a huge smile on your face from winning. The loser are over there getting trophies for participating and you think wait why I won. Recently there has been a large discussion about should all kids receive participation trophies or not. I think all kids should not receive participation trophies. There are many reasons why all kids should not get a trophy.
Participation trophies also show the children that if you work together, you can do a whole lot. In the text it says, “Let us give the winners a trophy and the participants a certificate or give them all small trophies”. These kids dedicate time, effort, and enthusiasm, and they deserve to have something tangible to make them feel that their participation was worthwhile.” This is beneficial because it helps the children establish some confidence and helps them feel a part of the team that they worked hard to be in. Finally, with the evidence provided, while participation trophies are pointless and send the wrong message, they are still beneficial to a young child's
Trophies should only be allowed to teams who win first place because having many trophies increases narcissism and selfishness,devaluation of the trophy, and kids should have to work for their trophy. Having many trophies increases narcissism and selfishness. For example,In the article, “Losing is good for you”, Carol Dweck, a psychology professor at Stanford University says, “But after such praise of their innate abilities, they collapse at the first experience of difficulty.” After kids get praised at doing something good and realizing that they are really
Regardless of that, I don’t think kids should get trophies just for participating. A sport should be fun but kids don’t need a trophy for everything you do in a game. If the kids don’t get trophies, it could encourage them to work even harder to get more than just a participation
In the world, kids have worked hard to get a trophy by playing sports. There is other kids also in the world that are not athletic and didn’t work for it get a trophy just by participating. Everyone should not get a trophy. Some people say that kids should get trophies so it gives them a confidence boost; however, in real life kids don’t get a trophy by doing a simple task. Everyone playing a sport should not get a trophy because losing makes them try harder and trophies lose their meaning when you always get them.
The celebration of the end of your sport season is so exciting you could probably burst with joy but you have to wait after the awards. People have been talking about how participation trophies are good for the kids or bad for them. I think that participation trophies should be given to the kids. There are different reasons why participation trophies are good.
value. When I asked Mrs. Norman, a coach at Deridder High School, why she personally felt that participation trophies affect children, she responded, “From experience, I’ve realized that handing out a trophy to children makes them think that they will get rewarded for doing nothing, and that is not how life works at all. You have to put the work in. ”If every young player receives a trophy for merely showing up to practice, and playing games, the exceptional players are slighted. The same applies to teams.
Should Children Receive Trophies Just For Participating? What are trophies? They are memorable tokens that symbolize hard work and excellence. They are symbols of winners who worked hard to try and reach their goal.
Why should we raise our children up to believe that just because they showed up to the event they deserve a trophy? We are teaching them that losing is so awful that we can’t let it happen, so everyone gets to be a winner. As a society, we should not give children participation trophies because it is teaching them to accept failure. Trophies
Sadly however, most participation trophies don't work this way. They just blatantly hand them out to the children without any explanation other than “you were a part of the team!” In the end, however, all of the lessons taught from getting a participation trophy could be taught stronger without them. Sports at a young age should be about learning about the basics of the sport anyways and not about the rewards you get from
Parents can use these trophies to say their kid did well and gave great effort, even if they did not succeed. However, as former Olympian Coby Jones points out, "In the real world you are rewarded for achievement not effort" (Dickinson). By constantly rewarding children for simply participating, we take away their opportunity to experience and learn how to deal with sadness and other emotions when they fail. As Jon Doss notes, "It's an achievement that leads to more achievement and self-esteem" (Doss), and learning from failure is essential to success (Miles). Giving participation trophies does not prepare children for the realities of life later on and does not help them develop "tough skin.
The thought going through most children 's minds is, "why try if I know I am going to get a trophy anyway." A trophy is always secured in their mind. Trophies today have a whole new meaning. They do not symbolize a victory or achievement; they are merely reminders of childhood. Betty Berdan, a junior in high school says, "When awards are handed out like candy to every child who participates, they diminish in value.