ipl-logo

Similarities Between A Streetcar Named Desire And A Respectable Woman

523 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How society treats a woman in streetcar named desire

Today we are comparing the play A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams and the short story A Respectable Woman by Kate Chopin.Throughout history you can find similarities and differences in different pieces of literature. They could be about a similar topic or something a little different, either way if you look hard enough you will find similarities and differences in the literature. The similarity in both stories is a family has one of there friends live in the same building as them. The difference in both stories is one does not mind the friend being in the same building while the other wants the friend out of their house. The different time periods may impact the similarities and differences because of the way people were brought up with different ideas and life experiences for example A Streetcar Named Desire takes place shortly after world war 2.
A similarity in both stories is a family has one of there friends live in the same building as them. Both of these pieces of literature have a family living in a building with one of their friends living in the same building as them. In the short story A Respectable Woman by Kate Chopin this is shown when Gouvernail came to live with his friend Mr.Baroda and his wife. Also in the play A Streetcar Named …show more content…

In the short story the husband does not abuse his wife while in the play the husband does abuse his wife. In the short story A Respectable Woman by Kate Chopin it is said that they were a pretty happy family just that the wife was not a fan of the friend coming over and staying a few days. In the play A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee William this is shown when Stanley abused his wife Stella but she would not leave him because she was a fan of his third leg. The difference in time period impacted the 2 pieces of literature because women were treated differently in 1894 than in 1945 after

Show More
Related
277 Words | 2 Pages

Some similarities one of them is that Krystina Chiger and Pavle Fredman are both Jewish. Another one is Krystina Chiger and Pavle Fredman were in the ghetto and Holocaust. I know Krystina Chiger and Pavle Fredman were in the Holocaust and ghetto because Krystina had to escape and Pavle was forced to live in the ghetto and he died. Next, they both wanted freedom from the

Read More
430 Words | 2 Pages

Last, is that one is very long and the other is very short. They are similar because there both in the same time and setting. Therefore, Drummer Boy Shiloh and Drumbeats and Bullets are similar and different. The two stories are different because there written by different authors.

Read More
784 Words | 4 Pages

For example, there are antagonists in both of the stories. But there are many more similarities than that. Similarities In the story “Three Billy Goats Gruff” there are two different countries telling the story. One is Norway, and the other country is Poland/Germany.

Read More
1805 Words | 8 Pages

Although some stories are written by completely different authors, countless stories can and have shared similar themes and ideals. One example of two stories that share similar concepts is the example of the stories: Sticks and Salt and Growing up Hmong in Laos and America. In the story, Sticks and Salt, Phuoc Nguyen talks about his life growing up as a Vietnamese refugee in America. On the other hand, in the story, Growing up Hmong in Laos and America, Pa Xiong Gonzalo talks about his life growing up as a Hmong refugee and his life growing up in America. Even though some stories may share similarities, there will always be differences in the stories and in the writing of the stories.

Read More
545 Words | 3 Pages

For example, in the story “A Sound of Thunder” the character stepped off the path, that the people on the trip were not supposed to step off and in the other story “Being Prey”, Plumwood went too far out in the swamp to where all of the crocodiles were. Another difference between the two stories were, Eckles in the story “Sound of Thunder” he got shot and killed. Unlike in the other story where Plumwood just got attacked by the crocodile, she didn’t die. One last similarity between the two are that both of the main characters did not listen to the warnings that they were both given in the beginning of both stories. Therefore in both of the stories “A Sound of Thunder” and “Being Prey” they both have similarities and differences in the

Read More
708 Words | 3 Pages

Many stories you read are similar in many ways if you just look. However they are difference in the way they act as different situation effect different things. In the story High Noon it’s about a marshal that stayed to fight the Antagonist, Frank miller, he is scared and desperate for people to help him fight. In the short story “The Most Dangerous Game” it’s about a world class hunter that is stuck on a island and must fight against a hunter than thinks hunting humans is right, and he must survive for 3 days from this very skilled hunter. The stories High Noon and “The Most Dangerous Game” are different in many ways, one is the similarities between the protagonist, there is also many different between the setting and conflict.

Read More
159 Words | 1 Pages

One major similarity between Blanche and Stanley is that they both like to manipulate or control other people, to make themselves feel better. Even though there are different ways Stanley and Blanche take control of other people they still do it in a familiar matter. For example, Blanche takes power and influence over people by lying to others and herself, to make them believe in something that actually never happened, with fantacy, therefore makes Blanche feel greater, than she actually may be. To go deeper in depth, to prove that Blanche is manipulative she also says. ¨I don 't tell the truth.

Read More
802 Words | 4 Pages

Everything in life has similarities and differences as long as you're looking for them, but some have more than others. Comparing similarities and difference between two things in life is making a compare and contrast (book) . When comparing and contrasting two pieces of literature you have to observe not only the themes of them but also the plot. Fences by August Wilson and My Papa's Waltz by Theodore Roethke have many similarities and differences throughout the literature due to themes and the plot.

Read More
830 Words | 4 Pages

One of the most important similarity is that both stories are well enjoyed over generations and teach great life lessons that serve the sole purpose of the

Read More
1886 Words | 8 Pages

Gender and power are quite distinctive from one another in both these texts. From one point of view it could be argued the men are the autocrats and considered as oppressors of females in the male dominated society. In the male dominated society men are the decision makers and have the instrumental role. Despite benefitting from the patriarchy they are still victims (Synnot n. p.).This is because to secure his place in the family, a man has to dominate over his children and wife, therefore faced with a choice between the two sexual dispositions, and a boy has to choose between his mother and father.

Read More
966 Words | 4 Pages

In A streetcar named Desire, Stella is associated to this stereotypic role, she is an innocent woman and housewife who takes care of her husband by loving him in an outrageous way. Even if Stanley is hitting her, she still loves him. Whereas Blanche acts like a seductress, at first sight she seems to be pure by wearing a “daintily dressed in a white suit with a fluffy bodice” (Williams 3). In reality the authors gives a false impression of her in order to affirm that stereotypes or first impression are not always true. Indeed, after several scenes Blanche uses her power of seduction in order to manipulate men and reach her objectives.

Read More
1245 Words | 5 Pages

Stereotypical gender roles have existed as long as human culture has, becoming a natural part of all of our lives. Within each gender lies a variety of stereotypes and expectations. Most notably for men they are often depicted as tough and the family provider. Whereas women are often shown to be soft and vulnerable. Throughout the play A Streetcar Named Desire the author; Tennessee Williams illustrates the main characters, Stanley, Stella, Mitch and Blanche with these stereotypes.

Read More
698 Words | 3 Pages

The Fight for Dominance In today’s society, gender norms convince men that unless they are able to control women, they are weak. Considered the inferior gender, women must find new ways to prove their own strength, whether it be through manipulation or their sexuality. The battle between the two continues as men strive to remain dominant, often by immoral means, and women attempt to gain the upper hand. In the screenplay, “A Streetcar Named Desire” by Tennessee Williams, the sexual tension and struggle for dominion between Blanche and Stanley is evident, and as the play continues, Blanche's promiscuity and Stanley's predatory nature foreshadow an inevitable confrontation.

Read More
1311 Words | 6 Pages

The works A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams and The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka depict characters struggling against expectations and societal norms, with Blanche and Gregor as symbols of isolation and social oppression. Through a comparative analysis of their gender roles, literary techniques, and themes, it becomes clear that both works use their respective literary lenses of Feminist, Psychoanalytic, and Marxist theories to expose the damaging effects of norms and societal pressures on individuals, ultimately emphasizing the need for freedom and self-realization from oppressive systems. One of the most notable differences between the original text of A Streetcar Named Desire and the 1951 film adaptation is how the setting

Read More
847 Words | 4 Pages

In the 1940’s men were thought of as the heirs to women. Tennessee Williams uses Stanley Kowalski as a model for how cruel and unusual men treated women at the time. Throughout the film Stanley is seen as a very abusive man with absolutely no right judgement. In today’s society the way he treats women would be morally unacceptable. However, during the 1940’s this sadistic man was seen as a true man.

Read More

More about Similarities Between A Streetcar Named Desire And A Respectable Woman

Related Topics

Open Document