ipl-logo

Similarities Between Winston And O Brien

1343 Words6 Pages

Isabelle Byrd Ms. Winder English III 5 April 2023 Two Sides of the Same Brain Yin and Yang, protagonists and antagonists, Winston and O’Brien These two men are different sides of the same coin. In the novel, the two individuals are portrayed as very similar. Their most common factor is their intelligence. The story follows our protagonist, Winston, as he rejects and rebels against the Party, a system that mind-controls individuals and whose primary goal is total tyranny and dominance. O’Brien, Winston's friend and ultimate betrayer, is the head of the thought police at the party. Though seemingly different, especially considering the social status in the book and where they are at, Winston and O’Brien in the novel 1984 think the same way. …show more content…

Since the beginning, Winston has felt a connection between O’Brien and him. Despite having visions of him, she says that they will meet in a place without darkness. Because of this, Winston automatically has hope that O’Brien is on his side. Winston trusts O’Brien enough to go to his apartment, which could've ended in exposure for Winston. Although in the novel, Winston usually trusts no one. Even he did not trust Julia at first. However, they have had a bond since the beginning like no one else in the novel. "One is reminded of this in the relationship between O'Brien and Winston, which is the only human relationship in 1984—the Winston-Julia relationship being hollow and merely physical by comparison." Ralph A. Ranald Ralph is explaining that Winston and O’Brien’s connection is deeper than Winston and Julia's ever could’ve been. Julia and he are purely physical, while Obrien and he connect on a deeper level. Fast forward: after being captured, it is shown that O’Brien has stalked Winston for seven years. He can predict Winston; he understands him. It's because he sees a version of himself in him. That is why he took so long with Winston during the process. "There was a link of understanding between them more than affection or partisanship" (Orwell, 25). O'Brien, when interrogating Winston, seemed to know what Winston was going to say before he even said it and even spoke Winston's private thoughts out loud. He is not a physicist, but he knows Winston well enough to guess what he is thinking. This just proves that Winston and O’Brien have this connection like no other couple in the

Show More
Related

Examples Of Stockholm Syndrome In 1984 By George Orwell

510 Words | 3 Pages

Further, Winston, “ had the feeling that O’Brien was his protector, that the pain was something that came from outside, from some other source, and that it was O’Brien who would

Read More

1984 Winston's Dialectical Journal

1692 Words | 7 Pages

In this section, Winston’s entire out look and thought process changes extremely quickly and determinedly. Once he starts to interact with this girl who he seems to keep bumping into to, the whole course of Winston’s outwardly obedient but internally disobedient behavior becomes much more actively counter regime than it ever had before. This drastic change begins even in his first interaction with the mysterious girl who falls in front of him in the hallway at their office, “A curious emotion stirred in Winston’s heart. In front of him was an enemy who was trying to kill him; in front of him, also, was a human creature, in pain and perhaps with a broken bone. Already he had instinctively started forward to help her” (107-108).

Read More

How Does O Brien Show Winston's Brotherhood In 1984

467 Words | 2 Pages

it might interest you to look at it, perhaps?”. O’Brien gets Winston’s attention by acting like the person Winston wants him to be. He is able to get Winston interested, and he goes to his

Read More

How Does Winston Present The Individual In 1984

739 Words | 3 Pages

The author george orwell in 1984, Winston's character portrays individuality through his thoughts on the party's views on creating a inhuman society vs his self leadership. This contributed to the leads of his tragic downfall. The theme of society versus individual can can be see in the beginnings of the book when Winston explain his life as a member in the party in London and how there is a figure watching everything he do called big brother. Winston explains how the party controls everything and strive to make rebellion disappear which show the society that Winston is up against. Wilson finally show that he an individual when he choose to break a rule of self thoughts and start a journal which he knows will lead

Read More

Similarities Between 1984 And Fahrenheit 451

1130 Words | 5 Pages

O’Brien and Beatty are both trying to mold Winston and Montag into the ideal citizens of their societies. O’Brien first tries talking to Winston and tries to get Winston to understand reality. O’Brien said, “But I tell you, Winston, that reality is not external. Reality exists in the human mind, and nowhere else… Whatever the Party holds to be the truth, is truth.

Read More

1984 Rhetorical Analysis

912 Words | 4 Pages

Award winning writer, George Orwell, in his dystopian novel, 1984, Winston and O’Brien debate the nature of reality. Winston and O’Brien’s purpose is to persuade each other to believe their own beliefs of truth and reality. They adopt an aggressive tone in order to convey their beliefs about what is real is true. In George Orwell’s 1984, Winston and O’Brien use a variety of different rhetorical strategies and appeals such as parallel structure, pathos, and logos in order to persuade each other about the validity of memories and doublethink; however, each character’s argument contains flaw in logic. Winston debates with O’Brien that truth and reality are individual and connected to our memories.

Read More

Examples Of Figurative Language In 1984 By George Orwell

922 Words | 4 Pages

Winston is forced to undergo tortuous procedures and brainwashing. While incarcerated, Winston has terrible nightmares about rats, in which O’Brien uses to his advantage. Winston is forced to have a cage of rats strapped to his head and eventually these rats eat Winston’s face. After receiving such tremendous amounts of torture, Winston pleads with O’Brien to torture Julia instead of himself. This utter lack of hope and feeling of helplessness is what O’Brien desired from Winston the entire time.

Read More

Similarities Between 1984 And Harrison Bergeron

1034 Words | 5 Pages

O’Brien uses fear, scaring Winston into loving his government, Big Brother, and pushes him to break. In Orwell’s book, he states, “‘Room 101’ he said”... “‘Comrade! Officer!’ he cried.

Read More

Examples Of Thoughtcrime In 1984

458 Words | 2 Pages

Winston was never a devoted follower, constantly questioning the world around him. Even when in custody, Winston continued questioning motives and denouncing the Party and Big Brother, despite the futility. He knew no societal changes would result from his actions, but desperately wanted to share his ideas with someone, and since he was already being tortured, he was capable of speaking freely in the jail area. The purpose was to rid him of his rebellious mindset, and to do so, O’Brien needed to know everything Winston honestly thought in order to ‘correct’ it fully. For example, O’Brien forced Winston to recognize that whatever the Party said was true by holding up four fingers and saying there were five, “But there had been a moment- of luminous certainty, where each new suggestion of O’Brien’s had filled up a patch of emptiness and had become absolute truth, and when two and two could have been three as easily five, if that were what was needed (Orwell 258).

Read More

Examples Of Dialogue For Winston's Dystopian

212 Words | 1 Pages

Winston thinks O'Brien as a good man. So, he decided to talk with O'Brien. Winston: Hey Winston (shook hands) Obrien:

Read More

1984 Betrayal Essay

1551 Words | 7 Pages

Julia, who he thought was someone he would never be able to betray. He says to her “‘ Only feelings matter. If they could make me stop loving you – that would be the real betrayal ”’(166). O’Brien represented the rebelliousness and friendship that Winston had been seeking. He let his guard down around O’Brien and O'Brien ultimately betrays

Read More

1984 Surveillance Essay

528 Words | 3 Pages

Charrington, a store owner, and O’Brien are friends with Winston, but they are not the friendly people Winston thinks they are. At first, Winston is clueless about who Mr. Charrington is because he seems to be just a standard citizen. Winston finally realized who Mr. Charrington was when he “was looking, with knowledge, at a member of the Thought Police,” and that member turned out to be Mr. Charrington. Furthermore, O’Brien is disguised as someone who questions the government, just like Winston. It is not until O’Brien allows the guard to hurt Winston that he realizes that O’Brien is one of “them [Thought Police].”

Read More

1984 Who Controls The Past Essay

885 Words | 4 Pages

but o’brien thinks he’s out of luck. At the end of the conversation o’brien makes winston take of his clothes. After winston took of his clothes he immediately started crying he saw how bad he was abused and was so distraught of the fact he looked the way he did. He was even more upset that way he suckerd into those aligations that o’brien was accusing him of. Winston had a moment of weakness and allowed o’brien to treat him like trash.

Read More

Examples Of Tyranny In 1984 By George Orwell

453 Words | 2 Pages

In addition, Winston told Julia he wished to “walk into O’Brien’s presence” and tell him he was an enemy of

Read More

Conflict And Internal Conflict In 1984 By George Orwell

1391 Words | 6 Pages

By:Aman Parmar Internal conflict and strife affects people throughout their lives and the way an individual handles it may speak to who the character is, and how they view the people around them. In the book 1984 George Orwell created a world in which Winston, and many others lives are controlled by the party, resulting in fear, which may lead straight into conflict with themselves. Conflict between the characters and the party, and strife between O’Brien and Winston. The internal conflict and strife that is developed by the characters can lead to a certain thought or representation of an individual or group that can lead to two different outcomes, one in which makes the character understand, or the complete opposite, as they face challenges that they aren’t used to. Conflict between a person and themselves, can lead to both positive and negative thoughts of a person or a party, leading to realization, and the truth, and may also lead to believing what’s not the truth, regrets and overthinking.

Read More

More about Similarities Between Winston And O Brien

Related Topics

Open Document