ipl-logo

Smoke Signals: Movie Analysis

542 Words3 Pages

This happened to Arnold in the book The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian and this also happened to Victor in the movie Smoke Signals, both were written by Sherman Alexie. In the movie, Victor ended up becoming better friends with a boy named Thomas, who at first didn’t want to be his friend. What matters most to both the of the main characters, Arnold and Victor, are their families. There are many similarities between the book and the movie, like alcoholism and money, but there are also some major differences, like friendships. First, in both the book and the movie Victor and Arnold’s parents are alcoholics. Victor's dad struggles with alcohol throughout all of Victor's childhood up until he leaves Victor and his wife. Eventually he gives up drinking but he dies soon after. Arnold's dad is also an alcoholic so is his dad's best friend Eugene. One day Eugene got very wasted and ended up getting in a fight with another man. He then was shot and killed by the man who he had gotten into a quarrel with. Eugene and his friend Bobby were so drunk that Eugene was killed over who got the last drink of wine, “The police think Eugene and Bobby fought over the last drink in a bottle of wine”(168). These two cases show how alcoholism …show more content…

Victor was always good at basketball, while Thomas isn’t good at any physical activity and wants to be Victor's friend. Victor ends up letting Thomas go on the Trip with him and slowly but surely becomes closer friends with Thomas. Now in Diary it is a different story, at the beginning Arnold is best friends with Rowdy, but once he switches schools he and Rowdy stop speaking. (quote). Although it doesn’t look good for their friendship, but in the end Rowdy and Arnold end up becoming friend again despite what both of them have been through. The differences in both the friendships prove how different the book and the movie

Show More
Related
314 Words | 2 Pages

There are many simularities and differences in the book and movie " The

Read More
243 Words | 1 Pages

The film called Smoke Signals, deals with the lifestyle of Native Americans living on an Indian reservation in Idaho. The main characters Victor and his best friend Thomas grew up together on this reservation. Thomas is a nerd who enjoys telling stories that have no interest to anyone. His parents died in an accidental fire in 1976, he was saved from the fire by Victors father Arnold Joseph. On the other hand Victor is a tough kid that never got over the fact that his father left his family when he was young.

Read More
1198 Words | 5 Pages

After reading John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men and Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451, some similarities found in both books relate to the theme of friendship. These two books are very different in showing their types of characters and storylines with Of Mice and Men being a type of realistic fiction novel which takes place during the Great Depression, while Fahrenheit 451 is an all-around fictional novel which takes place in a dystopian society. The protagonists, and most of the characters as well, have and form friendships with many different characters throughout the books’ storylines. These friendships are formed from losses or from a character’s personality traits. These formations of friendships are what make these two books very similar to each other.

Read More
476 Words | 2 Pages

Friendship is a wonderful yet confusing thing. This concept is brilliantly displayed in Chaim Potok’s The Chosen. In the book, the main character, Reuven, and Danny Saunders become friends through an interesting turn of events during a baseball game, the short version being that Danny ended up putting Reuven in the hospital with a baseball in the eye. After Reuven gets over some feelings of bitterness towards Danny, the two grow to be great friends. There are many difficulties when it comes to friendship, but the beauty of a good friendship is that good friends can power through them.

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

Some of the major differences, such as the changes in Jonas, Fiona, and Asher’s characters in the movie as well as Jonas’s escape, really separate the movie from the book. However, that is not to say that there are not plenty of similarities. The descriptions and portrayals of Jonas’s feelings about the Community, The Giver, and the structure of the Community are very similar between the two stories. While the similarities greatly outnumber the differences, some of the differences are very major and can change the story a

Read More
189 Words | 1 Pages

Shelby I agree that Suzy is a major representation of a smoke signal; she conveys Arnold’s death and the type of life he lived to his son, to free him of his rage and hatred toward his father. However the title can also been seen as a stereotype within itself; natives gathered in tents or around a fire using smoke signals to communicate is a common stereotypical depiction of Native American culture among films and books. Whether smoke signals are an accurate portrayal of Native American customs or not, it was a form of communicating in times of danger or distress. It’s no accident that throughout the movie Victor and Thomas both struggle to communicate with each other and their community. Their ‘smoke signals’ were muddled and neither understood

Read More
352 Words | 2 Pages

Another difference is the pacing of the story. The book allows the reader to

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Friendship can be a key element or theme to a work of literature. Friendships can be expressed in different ways throughout their story. Most stories express friendships as a high and low in one’s life. A friendship can be strained or broken because of outside forces, such as political views that are occurring in the story’s plot. “Recitatif” by Toni Morrison shows that one’s race can put a strain on one’s friendship.

Read More
402 Words | 2 Pages

Another difference is that in the movie they go into town, but in the book it 's never mentioned. Something else that was different was that in the book the mood was happy most of the time, while in the movie the mood was sad. A difference between the book and the movie is that in the book momma was going to burn Byron, but in the movie she does not burn him. A big difference is that in the

Read More
255 Words | 2 Pages

The movie has a different story structure. Unlike the book the movie has some flashbacks. Some differences are that she walks in oh the man in the beginning. The tells his wife in the movie that he is having an affair with another woman. The story clerk does not offer the woman cheesecake in the book.

Read More
1558 Words | 7 Pages

Another difference would be the way the short stories were ordered. In the book, the stories were told in no perceptible order, making it hard to remember who is whose daughter/mother etc. The movie begins with a party which all the characters attend, and the stories are disclosed as the character is thinking about it. The mother and daughter’s stories are staged after one another. The movie allows for a more natural way of telling the story, and makes it easier to remember the characters and associate mothers with daughters.

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

A book and a movie can be both the same and different. In The Outsiders there are many similarities and differences with the book and movie. They were the same because Johnny kills a man, they cut their, there was the movie scene, and Johnny and Ponyboy went to the church. Some of the differences is when Darry slaps Ponyboy but in the movie he pushes him, Johnny doesn't bring a lot of food in the book but does in the movie he does, when Johnny killed the man it was more described but it wasn't in the movie, and Johnny says he wants to kill himself in the movie. In The Outsiders one of the themes is “friendship”

Read More
309 Words | 2 Pages

It had more narration so the reader could understand what is happening. Secondly, the movie. The movie was different than the book. It had some parts that were in the book, but it lacked some details.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

In my opinion there are a lot of comparisons between the film and the book, but there are also differences between them too, but also they have impacted the audience in both the film and the

Read More
1815 Words | 8 Pages

In the short story, they interact negatively and the reader draws the conclusion that they aren’t friends or do not like each

Read More

More about Smoke Signals: Movie Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document