ipl-logo

Social Issues In A Tree Grows In Brooklyn

1116 Words5 Pages

Social issues in Betty Smiths A Tree Grows in Brooklyn A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, written by Betty Smith, is a novel that not only tells a compelling story of adolescence but goes further and delves into various social issues prevalent during the early 20th century. Smith expertly uses literary devices to navigate the overarching problems in the story. The story revolves around the Nolan family and their struggles living in poverty in Brooklyn. For example, the Nolan’s struggle with discrimination living in an Italian majority community. Also, the children face struggles with education and the socio economics of the area. Lastly the protagonist Francie takes on the harsh gender roles of early 1910’s culture whilst living in a Brooklyn slum. …show more content…

She takes many smaller locations and adds meaning to them ultimately connecting them into a map of the social environment of 1910’s Brooklyn. This map is navigated by the character and in different parts she experiences difference pieces of the overarching issues that plague the immigrant families. Most notably is the school she attends her teachers treat them as follows "I hate the foreign children in my class,' she said. 'I hate them because they're different from the rest. I hate them because they're stupid and dirty. - They take the bread out of our mouths” (Smith 5). The author is clearly displaying the social injustice and overall attitude of people towards the immigrants. As Francie goes through this torment at her school she learns and grows from the environment and ultimately prevails. Smith also uses the Nolan’s place of residence as a tool to display social issues. For example, in her home she faces challenges of food scarcity and safety from the outside world. This is overlayed on her conscious and the Author uses her shifts from school or the neighborhood to the more sentimental moments inside the family’s home to display the overarching themes of poverty and desperation. Many of the novels main scenes take place in the family apartment and it truly develops into a place of expression and a stage for the truth to unfold. Betty Smith’s detailed and masterfully crafted …show more content…

She does this through her many locations and through her vivid descriptions of scenes, characters, and ideas. This wholly contributes the overall feeling of the novel and allows the reader to subconsciously follow her destined parallels between the life of Francie at home and the life of Francie unsheltered and in the world. This idea of parallelism become particularly important when Francie begins school in a new world. For example, once she switched schools from a slum school to a nicer school, she starts to change her perspectives, and almost regains her faith in humanity. At this new school the students are treated with respect and immigrants are no discriminated against. However, at her old school the teachers would mock the students, tell them they are worthless, and favor the non-immigrant children more. This parallel is not just in the setting but also in the time span in which Francie grows. She starts at this school and eventually starts progressing through life as a young woman showing the parallel between the child Francie and the womanly Francie who is taking on the world and trying to persevere. Furthermore, the author parallels the mindset of her father Johnny to that of Francie’s mother Katie, whereas Katie is resilient and will never give up on her future, Johnny ultimately ends up dead from his lack of motivation and reflection. This is summarized perfectly by this

Show More
Related
236 Words | 1 Pages

In the book A Tree Grows In Brooklyn by Betty Smith uses many literary devices like imagery and characterisation. Betty also uses social stratification, ethos, pathos, and logos in the book to help create a well rounded book. She writes about a poor family that lives in brooklyn and their struggles to survive and climb the social ladder. Johnny and Katie go through hard times, losses and success to try to survive and to have a better life for their children Francie and Neeley. They give everything they have and sometimes sacrificing food so Francie and Neeley will graduate high school and have a better life.

Read More
592 Words | 3 Pages

Another main point of this book kind of dealt with race as well because the Mexicans were seen as inferior to the Whites as well as the other races that were there in Arizona. It seemed to be a problem that the Mexican families were trying to adopt White children and it turned into a big issue of why they can’t keep the children. I felt that the author proved her point in writing this book because she explained all of the things that the Nuns went through with these children and how they were nearly killed for what they thought might be a kind act in God’s eyes. The orphans from New York entered into a racial predicament, which eventually got worse by the Anglo women. They were the ones who did not agree with the nuns giving children to Mexican families, and these Anglo women told their husbands and they had a vigilante resolution.

Read More
1055 Words | 5 Pages

Brooklyn in the 1970s was plagued by severe economic and political troubles unlike any the city's inhabitants had experienced before. This is what Brooklyn was described as by a recent PBS article, for one to be living in these conditions their life must have been shaped pretty severely. On the contrary, living in Scarsdale has brought me many opportunities that someone living in that Brooklyn setting might not have been able to obtain. August, a character in Jaqueline Woodson, Another Brooklyn, lived in this harsh time period filled with a multitude of problems. This realistic fiction novel accurately depicts the story of a young woman attempting to thrive in a place like Brooklyn.

Read More
54 Words | 1 Pages

Immigrants to America face possible danger and death, yet they are shunned. This is shown in the work of Barbara Kingsolver. The injustices the characters faced in the novel, which was set in the 80’s, are still prevalent today. As Martin Luther King Jr. once said, “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice

Read More
940 Words | 4 Pages

She is reminded of the violence that torn not only communities apart but families as well. How the social norms of the day restricted people’s lives and held them in the balance of life and death. Her grandfathers past life, her grandmother cultural silence about the internment and husband’s affair, the police brutality that cause the death of 4 young black teenagers. Even her own inner conflicts with her sexuality and Japanese heritage. She starts to see the world around her with a different

Read More
740 Words | 3 Pages

The Poverty-stricken area is filled with death and sickness. He describes it as a horrible place to have to live and work with starving orphans and many sick and dying people living in morbid conditions. The waste filled streets and fire prone buildings were just a regular thing for the people living under the poverty line. 2.) The story takes place in the slums of New York City.

Read More
524 Words | 3 Pages

In the quarter towards midway of The Street, Ann Petry describes how African American’s lived in poverty as well as faced racism. Petry portrays Lutie not “[seeing] anything at all but 116th Street and a job that paid barely enough for food and rent and a handful of clothes” (Petry 147). Petry is showing her readers that Lutie is not getting paid a fair amount in order to pay for her living conditions as well as her son Bub. She as well creates a feeling of poverty that lives amongst 116th Street which creates a more sentimental feeling to her readers. Petry as well shows that in 117th Street, “Lutie looked at each store, closely reacting to it as violently as though she had never seen it before” (Petry 152).

Read More
1033 Words | 5 Pages

The move to New York was a crucial moment in her life. She was finally able to start over and follow her dream after years of living in chaos. For Jeannette, moving to New York was a challenging experience. Her family and the only house she had ever known had to be left behind. The move represents Jeannette’s capacity to take charge of her life and improve it herself.

Read More
942 Words | 4 Pages

Francie Nolan begins the novel A Tree Grows in Brooklyn as an innocent young girl living with her mother, father, and younger brother, Neeley, in a tenament neighborhood of Williamsburg. Her bright, observant nature allows her to be joyful despite her family’s poverty and her father’s drinking. While Francie grows older in the pages of A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith, she “comes of age” through her increasingly trying experiences as she loses her childlike innocence, but gains immense strength in character and wisdom. The heroine’s childhood is littered with hardship that prominently contributes to her maturation and transition into adulthood.

Read More
736 Words | 3 Pages

Tenement districts in Brooklyn throughout the early 1900s provided challenges that entire families were forced to handle. A Tree Grows In Brooklyn, by Betty Smith, depicts the Nolan family facing difficulties that even children had to overcome while they lived in one of these districts. Francie Nolan, the main character of the novel, is faced with the greatest difficulty of them all: growing up. Poverty was one aspect of Francie’s life that caused her to lack certain fundamental features of a regular child’s life. This is shown through Francie consistently being without food due to poverty, and having to discover for herself in a very difficult way that hunger was a painfully real issue.

Read More
285 Words | 2 Pages

She uses pathos by talking about how hard the children have in the working atmosphere. She uses child labor to her advantage saying that it could all be solved with the right of women's suffrage. By getting the reader

Read More
3315 Words | 14 Pages

In a conversation with her mother, she says that “‘It started when I was eight years old. I was playing in one of those Brooklyn streets one sunny afternoon and I saw a group of right-minded housewives throw stones at a mother who wasn’t married. I grew up wanting to protest in some way against intolerance. So you see, Mama, the beginning of this novel really started when, as a child, I began to notice the world of Brooklyn around me’” (Jasmine 2018).

Read More
921 Words | 4 Pages

The quintessential image of the American dream is that of a house with a white picket fence and Mama thinks the house she buys in Clybourne Park will allow the Younger family fulfill that dream. It’s a symbol for belonging in America; it can also represent an acceptance of American cultural values, such as capitalism. In addition, it’s an emphasis on the Youngers’ value on family and the home because the Youngers rely on each other during hard times, and they are not afraid of what may happen in the new neighborhood they know they are not welcomed in because they know they have each other. Moreover, Lindner and the other residents of Clybourne Park who offer to buy the house the Youngers bought represent the discrimination against African Americans at this time, and possibly a reason black Americans, like the Younger family, need to fight for a sense of belonging. “And we have decided to move into our house because my father- my father- earned it for us brick by brick” (Hansberry 148).

Read More
879 Words | 4 Pages

“I came to a clear conclusion, and it is a universal one: To live, to struggle, to be in love with life--in love with all life holds, joyful or sorrowful--is fulfillment. The fullness of life is open to all of us” (Betty Smith). Betty Smith, born as Elizabeth Lillian Wehner, grew up in Brooklyn, New York as the daughter of poor German immigrants. At the time, child labor was legal and Smith began work at the young age of fourteen to help support her family. Smith’s life in the slums and her experiences during the Great Depression greatly influenced her writing.

Read More
552 Words | 3 Pages

Ehrenreich uses imagery, diction, pathos and logos to strategize her story and make it more appealing to the readers who are higher income people wanting them to understand how difficult low income life can be. Ehrenreich thoroughly illustrates her experience at the Hearthside using a metaphor. “Picture a fat person's hell, and i don't mean a place with no food. Instead there is everything you might eat if eating had no bodily consequences….The kitchen is a cavern, a stomach leading to the lower intestine that is the garbage and dishwashing area.”

Read More

More about Social Issues In A Tree Grows In Brooklyn

Related Topics

Open Document