ipl-logo

Summary Of A Compensatory Response To The Problem Of Evil Beaty

921 Words4 Pages

Beaty, Michael Douglas. “A Compensatory Response to the Problem of Evil: Revisited.”
Religions, vol. 14, no. 1, Jan. 2023, p. 35. EBSCOhost, https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14010035

Beaty argues that the problem of evil can be solved by appealing to the concept of compensatory providence. He argues that God compensates for the evil that people suffer in this life by giving them rewards in the afterlife. Beaty's argument is based on the idea that God is just and merciful, and that he would not allow his creatures to suffer without compensating them in some way. Beaty's argument is creative and thought-provoking. He provides a new way of thinking about the problem of evil, and he offers a possible solution that is both plausible and consistent with traditional Christian beliefs. However, Beaty's argument is also controversial. Some people may argue that it is not fair for God to compensate for evil in the afterlife, when the people who suffer have already experienced the evil in this life.
Effingham, Nikk. “Using Wormholes to Solve the Problem of Evil.” TheoLogica, vol. 5, no. 1,
Jan. 2021, pp. …show more content…

He argues that if God is perfectly moral, then he must always act in accordance with the moral law, even if this means causing suffering. However, if God is perfectly loving, then he must always act in the best interests of his creation, even if this means breaking the moral law. Rutledge concludes that we must choose between a God who is perfectly moral and a God who is perfectly loving. Rutledge's argument is thought-provoking and challenging. He raises important questions about the nature of God and the relationship between morality and love. However, his argument is also controversial. Some people may argue that it is possible for God to be both perfectly moral and perfectly loving, even if this means that he sometimes has to act in ways that seem

Show More
Related

Peter Berger's The Sacred Canopy

849 Words | 4 Pages

It is a convenient and comforting respond to unfortunate and even devastating ‘fate’. The pain becomes bearable to those who suffer because the idea of all being a part of a bigger plan, it is more than you. However, this concept is built upon an irrational fundamental attitude, “the surrender of self to the ordering power of society,” (54) a problem that Berger expressed his concerns with. Another problem would be that the use of God as a shield works on believers, but not on nonbelievers. The question “why bad things happening to good people” still cannot be answered for the nonbelievers, a common critique of religion itself.

Read More

Mackie's Evil And Omnipotence

933 Words | 4 Pages

In Mackie’s Fallacious Situation, there are four main points that are discussed. One of the points is “Good must exist with evil”. Another is that “Evil is necessary as a means to good”. Another one is that “The universe is better with some evil in it that it could be if there were no evil”, and lastly is “Evil is due to human freewill”. These ideas try to explore the co-existence of evil and good in the same

Read More

Evaluating Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

1495 Words | 6 Pages

He describes the objection as, “all men desire the apparent good, but have no control over the appearance, but the end appears to each man in a form answering to his character” (1114b).   This view argues that all people pursue that which seems good, but some people cannot see the true good, which is out of their control.   The immediate implication of this objection, if it is indeed true, suggests that “no one is responsible for his own evildoing” (1114b).

Read More

Summary Of Peter Berger's The Sacred Canopy

717 Words | 3 Pages

The use of God as a shield works on believers, but not on nonbelievers. The question “why bad things happening to good people” still cannot be answered for the nonbelievers, a common critique of religion itself. Regardless of the problem of theodicy, however, religion has worked really well to create and maintain the reality. Berger explains that it is because religion legitimates effectively. “Religion has been the historically most widespread and effective instrumentality of legitimation….

Read More

Adams Objections To The Problem Of Horrendous Evil

1496 Words | 6 Pages

In this essay, I will explain and explore the problem of horrendous evil, which is an existential problem meaning, human existence/life is questioned. First, I will explain what the problem of horrendous evil is. Alternatively, I will then consider arguments for why the horrendous evils are understandable for religious people. On the former side, I will take into account, objections to the problem of horrendous evil and why it is flawed. Finally, I will demonstrate how Adams may respond to the objections made against her explanation for the horrendous evil.

Read More

John Hick Problem Of Evil Essay

1397 Words | 6 Pages

For years, many have questioned G-d’s role when it comes to addressing the problem of evil. Why is it that bad things always happen to the best of people? Oftentimes, we find ourselves wondering how an all-powerful, all-knowing, and all-good divinity could allow for such atrocities to occur, such as the Holocaust and the enslavement of millions. G-d’s role and existence surrounding the problem of evil is most often debated by philosophers and theologians alike such as English philosopher, John Hick. Hick introduces a consoling outlook to why such atrocities exist, framing G-d’s role and reasoning for evil's existence as a way for us to learn, grow, and better our souls.

Read More

David Weirob's Theodicy

579 Words | 3 Pages

The term theodicy in general relates to an effort in expounding why the Supreme Being has created several instances of evil and hurt yet He is good. This mode of occurrence is founded on the basis of offering a free will to the human beings. The theodicy model rotates around the knowing that the whole world has lots of free beings, however it is as well laced with major occurrences of annihilation, violence, besides anguish that massively contradicts the very reason of humanity and life. As Perry (30) observes, Weirob has an observation that the Supreme Being has a knowledge status that is likened to a special occurrence.

Read More

Summary Of Response To Atheists By Blaise Pascal

494 Words | 2 Pages

If we designate the God who punishes His followers as “anti-God,” the rewards to be earned by believing in God in offset by the possibility that the God we believe in is the “anti-God.” Similarly, the losses to be suffered by not believing in God is balanced by the possibility that the God we did not believe in is the “anti-God.” In this way, all possible attributes of God and their opposites essentially cancel the net benefit of each choice to zero. While some may argue that some of these attributes of God are “absurd,” without any prior knowledge of who God is, all attributes of God must be considered as equally

Read More

Walter Sinnott-Armstrong's Argument Analysis

2349 Words | 10 Pages

The problem of evil takes into account three defining features of God: all-good, all-knowing, and all-powerful and questions whether such a God would permit evil and not interfere. Sinnott-Armstrong discusses his stance by countering responses he coins as the Glorious Response, the Modest Response, and the Overriding Response. Whereas, Craig counters the arguments made by Sinnott-Armstrong. The Glorious Response Thus response suggests evil is

Read More

Why Does God Allow Suffering

967 Words | 4 Pages

God’s creation of the world proves He is all-powerful and the restoration that He will ultimately bring when He returns will only display His glory and power even more. God saves people from the effects of sin; He does not cause suffering and evil in the world. If anyone deserved an answer to the question of why God allows individual suffering, it was Job. Job never received an answer to why, but he did encounter God. Why God continues to allow suffering may not be known in this lifetime.

Read More

Old Testament Theology Of Hesed

2543 Words | 11 Pages

(Dyrness 60/ Hummel 297). b. God’s unfailing and steadfast love for believers is not based upon their actions

Read More

Problem Of Evil Research Paper

2016 Words | 9 Pages

The problem of evil is a very debated discussion in philosophy and the philosophy of faith. All of us have struggled with why evil has happened either to ourselves, people who are close to us, our nation, and even our world. Our mother gets cancer, the Holocaust, the 9/11 terrorist attacks, violence, and murders all bring us back to the question and problem of evil. This paper will explore the concept of evil and the problems that it creates in philosophy. It will also discuss many of the scholars and philosophers who took on this question to form their opinion and debate it.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Problem Of Evil

877 Words | 4 Pages

On the other hand, theists like Swinburne, believe that evil is necessary for important reasons such as that it helps us grow and improve. In this paper I will argue that the theist is right, because the good of the evil in this specific case on problems beyond one’s control, outweighs the bad that comes from it. I will begin by stating the objection the anti-theodicist gives for why it is wrong that there is a problem of evil. (<--fix) Regarding passive evil not caused by human action, the anti-theodicist claims that there is an issue with a creator, God, allowing a world to exist where evil things happen, which are not caused by human beings (180-181).

Read More

Patriarchy In Paradise Lost

1581 Words | 7 Pages

A New Outlook on Theodicy (A critique of John Milton’s response to the theodicy question in the epic poem, Paradise Lost) “Attempting to justify God and to assert his supreme power and beneficence, Milton makes numerous pronouncements about the existence of free will, both as narrator and in the speeches of God and the angels. In his arguments in favor of free will, Milton makes a determined attempt to remove God from all blame, keeping him, therefore, unassociated with evil and not responsible for its existence” (Morbey). The theodicy question has been a long term debate and continues even through today. It is inevitable that humans have wondered why they are here and so the creation of a higher being is a simple solution to that debate.

Read More

Religious Faith In Jean Meslier's Testament

1139 Words | 5 Pages

And yet, it escapes him that perhaps religious doctrines exist to serve subtle moral purposes, and that scientific fact is not their major concern. His opinions about religion epitomize all the myopia common to materialism and atheism. He forgets the profoundly inspirational qualities of faith; he ignores religion’s storehouse of literature, myth, and consoling rituals; and he entirely forgets the critical importance of religion in passing on a culture’s moral values. Had he understood the nature of man more deeply, he would have understood that only philosophers and saints can be induced to do good by appeals to reason alone; for the average man, only the fears of eternal damnation will keep his baser instincts in check.

Read More

More about Summary Of A Compensatory Response To The Problem Of Evil Beaty

Related Topics

Open Document