ipl-logo

Summary Of Amy Chua's Article Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior

842 Words4 Pages

Amy Chua a renowned author and professor of Law at Yale, produces an article that a majority will no doubt find controversial, others exciting and others yet down right offensive. The article, “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior,” published on 8th January 2011 in The Wall Street Journal, engages in an exposition of what she considers the Chinese, and essentially ideal model to parenting is, while at the same time launches a scathing attack on the Westerner’s approach to parenting. Although the article is quite controversial, and some of the narratives provided quite shocking, I do agree with some of Amy Chua’s assertions and proposals regarding parenting.
Amy Chua begins by stating the fact that Chinese parents are so good at raising stereotypically successful children is not a coincidence, but …show more content…

The basis of success is, therefore, defining specific areas that the parent wants the child to excel in, such as academics and very specific extra-curricular activities (violin and the piano), having very lofty expectations and making the child aware that nothing less than excellence will be accepted, and forcing the child to engage in rote repetition of the tasks or skills required to master the selected area. With the exception of her recommendations regarding how to go about motivating the child to engage in rote repetition, I agree with the other techniques adopted by the Chinese parents to ensure success. Personally, I do not feel that it is necessary to insult, or even castigate children, even those as young as 7 years of age into doing something, as I believe that it is possible to effectively motivate a 7 year old, or any child without castigation. An even simpler approach to ensuring rote repetition, could be the use of reinforcement and the instillation of a predictable

Show More
Related

China's One Child Policy Dbq Analysis

802 Words | 4 Pages

As seen in Greenhalgh’s and Winckler’s book, the one-child policy resulted in many single daughters, who received all the attention from their parents and while it may have been a blessing to some, many of the “hottest and best paying jobs… are open exclusively to young women with good looks and sex appeal,” (Doc D). This statement portrays that women are thought of as objects, with prospective employers only looking at their physical appearance, not caring for their education of inner self. However, this also portrays the gender inequality exhibited by China, and shows that women in China only receive jobs because of how they look. This compares to Fitzpatrick’s article, as the practice of female infanticide, killing female infants, also became common practice in some area’s after the one-child policy was put into use (Doc E). It had long been known in China, that boys were more valuable than girls, and this practice further goes to show the chasm, between boys and girls in Chinese society.

Read More

Kieu Tran's Comprehensive Diction Summary

242 Words | 1 Pages

Kieu Tran’s comprehensive diction produces a clear distinction between American and Asian culture with examples of “physical punishment in Asian traditions is not considered child abuse” and “in America, there is no way that Asian parents can physically punish their children, if their children perform badly.” Kieu Tran touches on the ideas that America relies heavily on the thought of equality between any person, whether it is a minor or an adult, and the effects it has on Asian immigrant families, especially from Vietnam. In America, beating a child for whatever reason is automatically classified as child abuse, and it can lead to days in jail, like what happened to Mr. Ma and his daughter. Mr. Ma struck his daughter twice, which led to him

Read More

Flight The Glass Castle Character Analysis

1095 Words | 5 Pages

There daughters were always ashamed of and resented their mothers, especially while they were young. The daughters felt this way because of the way their mothers raised them. The mothers were very hard on their daughters, and pushed them towards successful, sometimes causing their daughter to feel overwhelmed. The mothers wanted their daughters to keep their Chinese heritage and culture, but also take advantage of the opportunities they have in America. The daughters were often ashamed of their Chinese heritage, and the way that their mothers acted.

Read More

Summary Of American Born Chinese By Gene Luen Yang

817 Words | 4 Pages

Someone once said, “You’re always one decision away from a totally different life.” American Born Chinese by Gene Luen Yang follows three different characters as they experience hate and growth. Firstly, the Monkey King, a monkey who tries to be more than a monkey; Jin, a boy who tries to be more American; and lastly, Danny, an American boy who tries to forget his culture. In this book, readers see how all these stories connect and the growth each character goes through. After both Jin and the Monkey King meet someone like them or understand them, they realize their wrongdoings and start changing.

Read More

Model Minority Essay

386 Words | 2 Pages

Often Asian Americans are called the “model minority” because they seem to be successful economically, socially, and educationally without significant confrontations with the white majority (Johnson & Rhodes, 2015). Kim-Ly’s parents immigrated to the United States 27 years ago from Vietnam. Over time the family has progressed socioeconomically and now owns a small grocery store but still experiences stress over paying bills. Many cultural values of Vietnamese are derived from Confucianism, promoting filial piety and other strong family-centered values (Johnson & Rhodes, 2015). It is a central tenant in Asian culture to bring honor to the family and not shame it.

Read More

Invisible Strength: Rules Of The Game By Amy Tan

527 Words | 3 Pages

In Rules of the Game by Amy Tan, Waverly Jong’s mother expresses this to her in hopes that she would learn the “art of invisible strength,” which was a strategy for winning arguments and respect from others (Tan 497). Tan successfully illustrates the way of Chinese parenting and the frustration a Chinese child often experiences. As the interaction between mother and daughter becomes tense, Tan seems to convey the mother’s message-- “the art of invisible strength” a very understandable Chinese way of

Read More

Accepting Themes In The Book 'American Born Chinese' By Gene Yang

921 Words | 4 Pages

What were the important themes in the book American Born Chinese? This essay will explain the importance of expressing your feelings and accepting others. These two themes were very evident throughout the story. In American Born Chinese, the author Gene Yang wrote a story about a high schooler trying to find out how he can get better in school and deal with his cousin. There was also the story of an immigrant family from China who moved to San Francisco.

Read More

Mexican American Women In The Harsh Time

887 Words | 4 Pages

Even though there was an advantage of Chinese immigrant that most of them live in Chinatown, “which provided them with essential foods and services as well as jobs that relied primarily on trade with China” (chapter 4,4). A family without income could not survive. The statics shows that the unemployment rate of men was outnumbered women; therefore, the women in the family became the backbone of the family, “they often kept the family alive” (,15). The hard work of Chinese American women made their family survive. During the day, they worked hard, and during the night, they needed to take care of their family.

Read More

Dichotomy In The Woman Warrior

863 Words | 4 Pages

The Woman Warrior is a “memoir of a girlhood among ghosts” in which Maxine Hong Kingston recounts her experiences as a second generation immigrant. She tells the story of her childhood by intertwining Chinese talk-story and personal experience, filling in the gaps in her memory with assumptions. The Woman Warrior dismantles the archetype of the typical mother-daughter relationship by suggesting that diaspora redefines archetypes by combining conflicting societal norms. A mother’s typical role in a mother-daughter relationship is one of guidance and leadership. Parents are responsible for teaching a child right from wrong and good from evil.

Read More

Cholly's Parenting Style In The Joy Luck Club By Amy Tan

275 Words | 2 Pages

This passage explains the origin of Cholly’s parenting style, or rather, his lack thereof. It was interesting to consider the similarities between this passage and those from The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan. That book focuses on how several mothers raised their daughters. Frequently, the mothers’ childhoods had large impacts on how they raised their children. In particular, many mothers who had grown up in China wanted their daughters to maintain Chinese traditions.

Read More

What Is Good For You Persuasive Essay

990 Words | 4 Pages

Instead, it can cause them to underachieve” (Merryman 1). If children get recognition every second of every day of their lives, they will become complacent and satisfied with the work they put out now. They will not continue to improve, but stay at the same level for they do not have anything to push them for improvement. What should actually happen is parents giving their children credit where it is due, but do not give them too much, to where as they still want to improve and get better every single day of their

Read More

Amy Chua's Essay 'Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior'

208 Words | 1 Pages

In the essay "Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior." , Amy Chua compares and contrast the differences between the parenting styles of Chinese and Western parents. In the beginning of the essay Chua briefly describes her rules and regulations of what her children were and were not allowed to do. Following up after reading her rules and regulations it was fair to say that she had a very strict parenting policy. She herself even comes to say " All the same, even when Western parents thing they're being strict, they usually don't come close to being Chinese mothers" (Chua 409).

Read More

Personal Narrative: My Hispanic Heritage

234 Words | 1 Pages

Culturally, family is the base of my Hispanic heritage. As a child my mother taught me that family is the most important aspect of life. I remember my abuelita and uncle visiting every Thanksgiving and telling stories about their youth, from my uncle getting lost in Yosemite National Park to my abuelita regularly being dragged by the ear to Mother Superior’s office. When she came to visit, my abuelita would always share the family albums that she had stuffed in her suitcase. With every picture there was both a story and a lesson.

Read More

Essay On Second Generation Chinese Immigrants

384 Words | 2 Pages

The second-generation Chinese American refers to American-born Chinese. It was also known as "coconut" from cultural identity (outer yellow, white flesh within). From the cultural characteristics of the second-generation Chinese immigrants have the following characteristics. First of all, the second generations use bilingual. The second Chinese American immigrants often speak English in school or the workplace and using Chinese at home.

Read More

Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior Amy Chua Summary

1197 Words | 5 Pages

Some people might argue that a child’s upbringing forms the child’s foundation of life. It forms the child’s identity and its view of life. The upbringing of children is a wide concept because it is never the same. The question is if there is an edge between upbringing and torture. The intention of upbringing is indisputable – you want your children to have a great life and a great future, but perchance certain ways of educating children can cause more damage than good.

Read More

More about Summary Of Amy Chua's Article Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior

Related Topics

Open Document