ipl-logo

Summary Of Consider The Lobster By David Wallace

618 Words3 Pages

In David Wallace’s “Consider the Lobster”, the Maine Lobster Festival (MLF) is profiled. The festival takes place every year in the Western Penobscot Bay area from July 31 to August 3. The area is described as “the nerve stem of Maine’s lobster industry”. For almost the entirety of the piece Wallace takes a topical approach and assumes the reader has very little knowledge of the lobster. He goes into detail about all the different things that go on at the MLF using lengthy run on sentences. He even details the vast assortment of different lobster dishes that one could find at the festival. Wallace then goes into the origin of lobster and all that it entails. He explains how they are classified, how it has transformed from something that prisoners …show more content…

Wallace includes the methods of preparing lobster, a discussion of whether the lobsters can feel pain, and describes PETA protesters giving out pamphlets advising festival goers to not eat the food. Over the course of the article, it changes from being informational about the actual festival, to a rhetorical question about the treatment of the animals that we as humans consume. I didn’t quite know how I felt about this article when I finished reading. Although Wallace is clearly confused and uncertain about his position, with all the lengthy footnotes, he does go to great lengths to weigh both sides of the argument. (if you can even call it that) What I was left to consider was the reasoning and justification for the treatment of the animals that will become our food. The information and the questions that Wallace presents attempt to make the reader consider things they either haven’t thought about or try not to think about. I was left with the impression that he is still uncertain on the moral and ethical implications that boiling lobsters alive raises. On one hand he seems to think that it is wrong because the lobsters seem to

Show More
Related

Summary Of Consider The Lobster

489 Words | 2 Pages

Foster Wallace’s article “Consider the Lobster” was published in Gourmet magazine, and is about the cruelties involved in eating lobster that many people consider elegant. Wallace starts off in this article by discussing the 56th Annual Maine Lobster Festival where over 25,000 pounds of fresh-caught lobster were eaten, and cooking competition were also available. In this article, Wallace discusses everything from how the lobster is caught, stored, and the cruel method in which these lobsters are cooked and finally consumed and also defined what lobster is by saying it’s a giant sea-insect. Furthermore, Wallace goes on to explain the history behind lobsters.

Read More

Analysis Of David Foster Wallace's Essay 'Consider The Lobster'

239 Words | 1 Pages

In David Foster Wallace’s article “Consider the Lobster,” he describes the harsh reality of lobster eating. At the site of the World’s Largest Lobster Cooker at the Maine Lobster Festival, Wallace describes in detail the brutal treatment of lobsters in order for people to seek pleasure in their appetite. Wallace’s argument is that it is not right to “boil a sentient creature alive just for our gustatory pleasure” (700-701). He thoroughly describes the process in which lobsters are boiled alive in order to support his argument that because lobsters have feelings too, we should not boil sentient creatures alive for our pleasure. Wallace’s argument complicates Nijhuis’ view on nature because Nijhuis makes the point that people should essentially

Read More

Summary Of Consider The Lobster By David Foster Wallace

641 Words | 3 Pages

In the text, “Consider the Lobster,” by David Foster Wallace, he argues that “animals suffering is just not complex, but it is also uncomfortable” (466). Wallace is basically trying to get his point and opinion across to readers, but as we all know everyone may not agree with him. By lobsters not being humans, some people may think that

Read More

Summary Of Consider The Lobster By David Foster Wallace

303 Words | 2 Pages

David Foster Wallace in the article, “Consider the Lobster,” argues that the way people treat lobsters is horrible. Wallace supports his argument by questioning whether lobster can feel pain, listing and describing the different ways to cook a live lobster, and telling the origin of the lobster. The author’s purpose is to inform people that the way people treat lobster is horrific in order to report about the Maine Lobster Festival. The author writes in a sarcastic and casual tone for the readers of the Harper’s Magazine and to the public. If we look at Wallace’s question in black and white

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Consider The Lobster By David Foster Wallace

996 Words | 4 Pages

The beginning of the essay, the tone and diction are both lighthearted and inconsequential- full of basic observations and details. As the argument progresses, the tone shifts to be much more serious, even the footnotes hold a more serious perspective and address more insightful issues. Even in the moments of sincerity, Wallace builds a place of non-threatening engagement, reassuring the audience that he is not an expert either and any decisions about the consumption of meat is an individual one. Such is evident in Footnote 14; Wallace explores the linguistic trends in naming food, then immediately identifies himself as a non-expert by restating that is is just a theory and asking about “biblio-historic reasons” that could unravel his whole

Read More

Summary Of David Foster Wallace's Consider The Lobster

973 Words | 4 Pages

From personal experience, I sense acidic undercurrents, a bursting bubble, and a rusted infrastructure; a western world that is growing, yet sinking. All these forms of decay make me speculate on how things got to be this way, but also what I should do in an attempt to change the tide. In David Foster Wallace’s “Consider the Lobster,” I am consistently puzzled on his concept regarding animals’ ‘right to life’ deeming some sort of equality in animal lives compared to human lives. A selection from this text that that sticks out to me and could stand alone as the main point of this text is when Wallace talks about how people would never stand around at a food festival where cows are publicly slaughtered. He says, “Try to imagine a Nebraska Beef Festival at which part of the festivities is watching the trucks pull up and the live cattle get driven down the ramp and slaughtered right there on the World’s Largest Killing Floor or something - there’s no way” (Wallace 24?).

Read More

Jonathan Foer Let Them Eat Dog Rhetorical Analysis

1521 Words | 7 Pages

In Jonathan Foer’s argumentative essay “Let Them Eat Dog”, he makes a very convincing argument for the consumption of dog, a surprising topic to argue for. However, when one reads through his excerpt, it’s quite difficult to escape the sound logic he utilizes throughout the piece. Ranging from commentary on the taste of dog meat to points about the ecological impact it would have if the U.S. started eating dog, Foer is persuasive and reasonable. So reasonable, in fact, that it begs the reader to question exactly why he would put so much effort into arguing for eating dog, something that most people won’t change their minds on no matter how logical the argument is. Foer even admits at the end of his essay that despite his best efforts, people

Read More

An Analysis Of David Wallace's 'Consider The Lobster'

1736 Words | 7 Pages

Likewise, he demonstrates his discomfort about society’s acceptance of lobster’s pain and dismissal of their essence. However, in order to understand Wallace’s real intention in the essay, it is necessary to know his perspective towards modern society. By reading the Incarnation of Burned Children, it is possible to relate the society issues displayed, with considering the Lobster issues. The inability of lobsters, or the child, to communicate their pain of our careless acts is what disturbs Wallace. Therefore, he displays different examples to persuade the readers that society’s morality is corrupted and that the whole industry of boiling lobsters alive is accepted under a false premise that some animals are not deserving of protection, or are not ‘highly developed’ to feel pain.

Read More

Summary Of Consider The Lobster

688 Words | 3 Pages

Ethics can be based off of preference on this topic by acknowledging that lobsters are sentient beings and that humans should have “the willingness to exert personal agency and accept responsibility”(Wallace 6) if they partake in the practice of boiling lobsters. Another step towards a moral and ethical practice is trying to understand why humans disconnect and dissociate themselves from the similarities found in other species. It is acknowledged that the “clacking” of lobsters in a boiling pot are indications of pain, but there are prolong and complicated effort to reach this answer. This difficulty stems from the fact that lobsters are not place on the same level of importance. The author states, “I have not succeeded in working out any sort of personal ethical system in which the belief is truly defensible instead of selfishly convenient.”

Read More

Consider The Lobster Analysis

1527 Words | 7 Pages

“Consider the Lobster,” by David Foster Wallace, published in the August 2004 edition of Gourmet Magazine explores the morality of the consumption of lobsters through the analysis of the Maine Lobster Festival. Foster Wallace guides his readers through his exploration of the festival and general circumstances of lobster eating before evoking a sense of obligation to the creature’s well being. His gentle slide into the ‘big picture’ through his causal argument wades readers into the depths of his thoughts through the power of storytelling until they are left with no choice but to engage with their own perception of the act with skepticism. Ultimately, the passage commands readers to reexamine their own consumption of lobsters regardless of

Read More

Analysis of 'This Is Water' by David Foster Wallace

1763 Words | 8 Pages

David Foster Wallace’s commencement speech “This is Water” at Kenyon College is often thought of as one of the most influential speeches because it calls the graduates to observe the world around them through a different lens. However, he does not accomplish that by calling the graduates to action, but instead challenges them to use their education. He also appeals to the students’ emotions through his use of ethos, logos, and pathos. Although people mostly only remember the antidotes, it is the message associated with reoccurring emotions and literary devices throughout the speech that moves the reader into action. Wallace is able to captivate his audience and persuade them to view the world without themselves at the center through his tactful use of rhetoric.

Read More

David Foster Wallace's The Water Speech

156 Words | 1 Pages

Throughout the speech of David Foster Wallace, I understand that the main idea he is trying to say in his speech is to think beyond of what you’ve be taught to. If you can think beyond what is right in front of you, then you have a skill that is beneficial to oneself. He encourages students to be more open minded, which allows oneself to think more “deeply”. The evidence that supports my idea is when the author gives the example of the two young fish who swam by the elder fish and did not understand what the elder fish meant by “How’s the water?”. The younger fish in the story represents people who only knows what is that is in front of them and does not think beyond it.

Read More

Conscientious Meat Eater Analysis

796 Words | 4 Pages

In the article, “Is It Possible to be a Conscientious Meat Eater”, the authors argue that processed meat can greatly affect the many things in our everyday life. Sunaura and Alexander’s argument is significantly unreliable because of the certain professions both authors yield. As stated in the article “Sunaura is an artist, writer, and activist in Oakland.” “Alexander’s profession is studying philosophy, and ethics in Athens, Georgia.” This shows that neither of them are qualified to argue in the subject of conscientious meat eaters.

Read More

Symbolism In 'The Oyster' By Anton Chekhov

1205 Words | 5 Pages

The anonymous boy reveals his illiterate, ignorant, and underprivileged attributes as he struggles to realize the definition of oyster. He hollers, “A strange word! I had lived in the world eight years and three months, but had never come across that word.”, to indicate the unfortunate inability to purchase or be educated. ‘Eight years and three months’ describes a long period of time where the boy by now should realize the meaning of oyster already because oyster is a common food that people generally consume it. The boy then curiously asks his father what oysters mean, but his father lethargically answers, “It is an animal . . .

Read More

Essay On Marine Animal Captivity

495 Words | 2 Pages

In my opinion, I believe that marine mammals should not be held in captivity for many reasons. To start, they are taking away the animals from their natural habitat. Secondly, captivity causes both major and minor health problems. Another significant reason is that the poor marine creatures do not have enough space to swim resulting in severe boredom and causing them to do harm to themselves Captivity causes many health problems for the innocent marine mammals. There was an incident when Six of Marineland 's seals were blinded, or got serious eye problems because of the unclean water.

Read More

More about Summary Of Consider The Lobster By David Wallace

Related Topics

Open Document