ipl-logo

Summary Of Defiance By Alvin Townley

1030 Words5 Pages

One of the two books being compared in this essay is titled “Defiance” by Alvin Townley and was written in 2014. The other novel that was chosen for this essay was written in 1971 and is titled “Five Years to Freedom” it was written by James N. Rowe. These two books were focused on the capture and the treatment of American Prisoners of War during the Vietnam War. The Vietnam War started in 1954 and ended on April 30, 1975 totaling over twenty years. Each book has its idea of the incidents that happened and in “Defiance” there are several stories of a gang eleven American soldiers that was known famously as the Alcatraz Eleven. This essay will talk about the different accounts the American men endured and how each author sees the events …show more content…

In the book written by Alvin Townley, Bob Shumaker who was an American Aviator was shot down and captured by the Vietcong and held in Hỏa Lò prison. Each American who walked through the door of the prison was given a Vietnamese name. In the other novel discussed, they are held by their captors at many different jungle camps that he repeatedly tried to escape from. The treatment of the prisoners was much more severe in “Defiant”, they were constantly quizzed for answers and if they did not answer they would be bound with rope with their hands behind their back and hung from the ceiling. The American prisoners had a Code of Conduct which never allowed them to spill the secrets of the U.S. government. In the book “Five Years to Freedom” the torture methods mentioned are quite different. Rowe is only held in his prison by bamboo cages and is in the jungle whereas the other book is an actual prison with many rooms. James Rowe is not pried for answers and is just simply a prisoner. He was only allowed to venture out forty yards during the day and he has the ability to set small traps to catch small game to supplement his daily rations of rice and. In the prison, they are not able to see the outdoors and definitely not fed. They are not handed water until they comply with what the Vietcong is asking of them. There is a quote in the book written by Townley that …show more content…

Although the Alcatraz Eleven held out on the Vietcong’s’ questioning, they all inevitably gave in to the torture they were being submitted to. Rowe was submitted to many hardships along the way as well but was offered a surplus of freedoms compared to the gang in “Alcatraz”. In Alcatraz they are bound by their ankles every night in a three foot by nine foot cells with no windows. They found themselves in there based on their fierce efforts to escape the other camps they were imprisoned in. Rowe is bound only by a bamboo cage is allowed to roam during the day, fish and make money, and he even is given the privilege to own two

Show More
Related
506 Words | 3 Pages

Cry Liberty: The Great Stono-River Slave Rebellion of 1739 was written by Professor Peter C. Hoffer, who taught as a historian at the University of Georgia. This novel is a brief, yet very informative piece of work that provides a re-examination of a series of incidents that occurred during the Stono Rebellion (which transpired on September 9, 1739). This rebellion manifested once a group of about 20 slaves had broken into a store alongside the Stono River, nearby Charles Town, which is now known as Charleston, South Carolina. The author did an excellent job recreating events in this book and developing the question of whether or not it was actually a rebellion.

Read More
408 Words | 2 Pages

Stephen Ambrose, author of “Undaunted Courage,” uses several key points to describe his purpose in the fourth chapter of his book titled “Thomas Jefferson’s America.” He His uses 3 main points to get his purpose of persuading the reader across. The three main points he uses are: Language, people, and events. of language, people, and events is used to give the reader a sense of persuasion. But how exactly does Ambrose give these points across?

Read More
229 Words | 1 Pages

Coping With War By: Branson In the books Camp Harmony and Unbroken during World War II, some people lost their freedom. After Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, the Japanese Americans in Camp Harmony lost their freedom. Because of the possibility of them being spies, the government wanted them to be monitored so America didn 't get spied on. In Unbroken, Louis Zamporelli washed ashore from being lost at sea and landed in Japan.

Read More
388 Words | 2 Pages

Walt Whitman’s “The Artilleryman’s Vision” and the letter to his mother are two pieces of work by the same author. The two pieces of work share some key differences. Other than being two different types of works, there differences go deeper than that. The characters and settings are both very different and yet, they still manage to to seem similar. They also have completely different writing styles and choice of words due to the different writing styles.

Read More
298 Words | 2 Pages

Captivity stories have become a popular genre throughout the American culture. The idea has gained popularity because America’s history with captivity has left unforgettable memories for all Americans. Stories like A Narrative of the Captivity of Mary Rowlandson and The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano have become very popular because of this. Although there are many differences between these stories, they both are similar in one way or another.

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

President Lyndon Johnson declared a campaign to win the “hearts and minds” of the Vietnamese, and the United States decisively lost that battle. At the beginning of Truong’s book he shares what ideas are going through his heart and mind, “I would have been willing to accept almost amy regime that could achieve real independence and that had the welfare of the people at heart. I was quite prepared to give Ho’s Northern government the benefit of the doubt on this score”(36). This quote illustrates the minds of a Vietnamese population desperate for independence in any form. They had been subjected to outside imperial forces for hundreds of years prior and were poised to accept any leader willing to help them to independence.

Read More
488 Words | 2 Pages

There was a special camp for those considered to be a severe threat located in Tule Lake, California. The buildings of the camps constructed substandardly of wood and tar paper. There were schools, hospitals, post offices and even libraries for the internees. But there was also barbed wire surrounding the camps and constant surveillance by armed

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

On March 16, 1968, American soldiers invaded Vietnam resulting in roughly 350 unarmed Vietnamese deaths (Yanak, Ted, and Pam Cornelison). They demolished the village of My Lai killing and destroying anything in sight. At first, this horrific event was kept a secret, but when information was leaked, America’s character was at risk. This horrific procedure

Read More
1009 Words | 5 Pages

Frank Morris and brothers John and Clarence Anglin were most likely the only people to escape from Alcatraz. It took months of preparations and hard work to pull this escape off, but they made it happen. There were many escapes attempted, but the only one that may have been successful took place in 1962 and was known as “The Great Escape.” Alcatraz was a federal prison located in San Francisco Bay, California. The prison was in operation from 1934-1963, and it held some of America’s most dangerous felons.

Read More
991 Words | 4 Pages

John Page Dr. Clemmer HP 4303 Birth of Modern America 5 November 2015 Voices of Protest: Alan Brinkley Alan Brinkley specializes in the history of the twentieth-century America at the University of Columbia. Brinkley earned his undergraduate degree from Princeton University in 1971, and then continued to earn his Ph.D. from Harvard University in 1979. He has studied in the field of history and has been a professor for the past thirty years. Alan Brinkley has been awarded various prizes and honors throughout his successful career. He like John Milton Cooper Jr. was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for his work of The Publisher.

Read More
603 Words | 3 Pages

The movie “The Matrix” and the “Book of Exodus,” have some noteworthy parallels. One of these parallels is that both stories are about humankind being led toward a path of freedom by one man (the hero). In “The Matrix” humans are a slave to Artificial Intelligence, the energy source needed for Artificial Intelligence to thrive. In the “Book of Exodus” the Hebrew are a slave to Egypt, and are used as the energy source to build a great city for the Pharaoh. There are parallels between the two hero’s

Read More
702 Words | 3 Pages

The Vietnam War was a long battle of seventeen long years. There were many causes leading up to this traumatic event. The U.S. got involved because of the spread of communism throughout Asia. The novel, The Things They Carried is about how morality can change both how a soldier thinks and feels. In Tim O’Brien’s historical fiction novel, The Things They Carried, both the physical and geographical surroundings shape the psychological traits of the characters during the following events: Mary Anne’s disappearance, the death of Curt Lemon and Mitchell Sander’s unbelievable story.

Read More
554 Words | 3 Pages

In Vince Brewton's article "'Bold defiance took its place': 'Respect' and Self-Making in Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave," it argues Douglass status as a slave. Brewton feels that the whipping of Hester made Douglass open his eyes about his slave status and wanting to change it. The article in some type of way is really about superiority, many of the slave owners wanted the slaves to know that they didn’t have any power and that the owners were superior. The worthiness of a slave and respect was crucial. This article spoke highly on culture, respect and opinions from the scenes in the narrative.

Read More
1261 Words | 6 Pages

The Things They Carried, written by Tim O’Brien and Slaughterhouse Five, written by Kurt Vonnegut, and both books that are an example of anti-war in literature. Both O’Brien and Vonnegut were both war veterans and put themselves in their own books. The books both portray the horrors of war. In both these novels they spoke on the destructiveness of war and how it also destroys the way a person thinks.

Read More
458 Words | 2 Pages

The books that are being compared and contrasted are both about The Civil War and what these soldiers went through. Each book has a few differences that separate them. The books are based on the same time period so they are going to have a lot in common. The books describe what both characters had to go through during the war. The differences in the book will show you how each soldier went through the war differently and the similarity’s will show you how it was for most of the soldiers in the Civil War.

Read More

More about Summary Of Defiance By Alvin Townley

Related Topics

Open Document